Category: City Council

  • 2024-07-18 · City Council · Transcript · Planning Commission

    2024-07-18 · City Council · Transcript · source: 10yr-transcripts · sha256 7880ea56 · pages – · method: official

    Full text — searchable
    --- title: Planning Commission date: 2024-07-18 source: 2024-07-18_Planning_Commission.wav --- [0:00:55, 0:01:05]: Good evening. It is now six thirty. Loving God, as we gather here tonight in this Hallow Chamber, we invite your Holy Spirit into this place. [0:01:05, 0:01:15]: And we pray God that each of us would allow your spirit to rule our hearts, to guide our thoughts, and to control our lives. [0:01:17, 0:01:19]: And that our behavior would be assurance. [0:01:20, 0:01:20]: Amen. [0:01:21, 0:01:22]: Amen. [0:01:23, 0:01:25]: Gotta stand for the Pledge of Allegiance. [0:01:28, 0:01:40]: Play to registers flag of the United States of America and to the Republic we're just one nation individual invisible. [0:01:44, 0:01:45]: [109.6, 111.7]: Mix Jackson, may I have a roll call, please? [0:01:53, 0:01:58]: I'm Linda Logan, senior planner. The um roll call is as follows, Stanley Dumas. [0:01:58, 0:01:59]: President. [0:01:59, 0:02:01]: Anthony Mitten. Present. [0:02:01, 0:02:02]: Rel tip bro. [0:02:05, 0:02:07]: Okay. David Planchon. Present. [0:02:08, 0:02:14]: Dayden Williams. Present. Matthew Thomas. Present. Mr. Chairman, we have a quorum. Thank you. Thank you, Ms. Logan. [0:02:30, 0:02:50]: I'd like to welcome you to the City of Stockbridge Planning Commission meeting. I'm Stanley Dumas, Chairman. To my left, Mr. Anthony Mitten, the Vice Chair. To my far left, it's Mr. David Planchon. To my immediate right, Mr. Matthew Thomas, and to my [0:02:50, 0:02:53]: Far right, this is Mr. Jaden Williams. [0:02:55, 0:03:01]: Before the meeting began, there are some things I need to clarify regarding protocol. [0:03:02, 0:03:06]: Please play pay close attention to how the meeting will be conducted. [0:03:07, 0:03:09]: This will be a public hearing. [0:03:10, 0:03:17]: So I would ask that you keep your comments and presentations on a professional level, dealing with the facts that are important. [0:03:18, 0:03:20]: For this Commission to make its decision. [0:03:21, 0:03:29]: We will not accept comments considered by the chair to be personal, attacked on any individual or groups of individuals. [0:03:30, 0:03:35]: You will receive a warning of the chair from the chair if you d deviate from this requirement. [0:03:36, 0:03:43]: A second deviation will result in a request for you to leave the meeting and the premises for the evening. [0:03:45, 0:03:50]: Ask that you re refrain from any applauses or comments from the audience. [0:03:51, 0:04:02]: There will be only be one speaker at a time, and all remarks are made at the podium following the Chairpers Chairperson's introduction of the speaker. [0:04:04, 0:04:10]: Please direct any feedback to the commission and the chair and not to the staff or audience. [0:04:14, 0:04:25]: Please do not applaud or react to speakers, speak from the audience, cheer, execute a conversation with others in the audience. [0:04:26, 0:04:28]: or disrupt the order of this meeting in any way. [0:04:31, 0:04:40]: Be aware that these hearings are down to debate or an opportunity to ask questions which must be answered by individ any individual tonight. [0:04:42, 0:04:46]: But are merely an opportunity to present information. [0:04:46, 0:04:47]: To the commission. [0:04:50, 0:04:52]: Other than the appleton. [0:04:53, 0:04:55]: No person may speak more than once. [0:04:58, 0:05:10]: The applicant may reserve part of his speaking time as rebuttal and may speak next and last and may use the entire ten minutes allotted for the pro side of the application. [0:05:11, 0:05:16]: Other than the applicant, no person may speak longer than five minutes. [0:05:19, 0:05:23]: If you have a cell phone or other electronic device. [0:05:24, 0:05:29]: I ask that you either power them off or put them in the silent mode. [0:05:31, 0:05:41]: If anyone wishes to speak tonight, please fill out a form available on the table up front and hand it to staff before approaching the podium. [0:05:43, 0:05:55]: After each case is called, we will hear next from the city staff, and then we will hear from the applicant or their representative about what their plans are for the property. [0:05:57, 0:06:00]: Along with any relevant information they wish to present. [0:06:02, 0:06:08]: The convention members will be free to ask questions at any time before a vote on the project. [0:06:09, 0:06:20]: Following the applicant, anyone who wish to speak for or against the project or just ask questions will have the opportunity to do so. [0:06:23, 0:06:26]: Each side is restricted to a maximum of ten minutes. [0:06:27, 0:06:31]: Or time may be waived at the discretion of the presiding officer. [0:06:33, 0:06:37]: If questions are raised, we may ask the applicant to speak again. [0:06:38, 0:06:48]: Afterwards we will call for a motion and a second and have any necessary discussion and if the matter is not tabled. [0:06:48, 0:06:54]: We will vote to recommend approval or denial of the application. [0:06:56, 0:06:58]: The commission is only a recommending body. [0:06:59, 0:07:17]: The mayor and council will hear the items whether we recommend approval or denial. Unless tabled, these items are listened to by the mayor and the council at their meeting on Monday, August twelfth, and voted up voted upon by them at their meeting. [0:07:30, 0:07:34]: I need a motion, please, from the commission for the adoption of the agenda. [0:07:39, 0:07:40]: Mr. Chairman, I'll make the motion to adopt. [0:07:43, 0:07:56]: It's been motion by Mr. Mitten and seconded by Mr. Thomas that we adopt the agenda as presented. All in favor? Let it be known by the sound of aye. Aye. Any opposed? The ayes have it. The agenda is adopted. [0:07:59, 0:08:03]: You have before you approve um minutes from the [0:08:05, 0:08:12]: June twentieth meeting. If you haven't already done so, I ask you to peruse those. [0:08:14, 0:08:17]: And make any necessary corrections if there be any. [0:08:18, 0:08:25]: Chairman. Yes, sir. I make a motion to approve the June twentieth Planning Commission summary minutes. [0:08:31, 0:08:32]: Is there a second? [0:08:34, 0:08:35]: I'll say. [0:08:35, 0:08:50]: It's been moved by Mr. Williams, second by Mr. Thomas, that we approve the minutes of June 20, 2024. All in favor, let it be known by the sound of a. Any opposed? Ayes have it. The minutes are approved. [0:08:55, 0:08:57]: We have two cases tonight. [0:08:59, 0:09:07]: We have a comprehensive plan case and a rezoning case, and they are both related to the same property. [0:09:09, 0:09:12]: Located at four twenty five Country Club Drive. [0:09:13, 0:09:15]: I will read into the record. [0:09:17, 0:09:21]: Comprehensive Plan Amendment KCP twenty twenty-four-o five. [0:09:22, 0:09:24]: It's located in Council District Five. [0:09:26, 0:09:30]: The City of Stockbridge Planning Commission will hold a public meeting [0:09:30, 0:09:33]: Thursday, July t eighteenth, which is today. [0:09:34, 0:09:36]: In the city of Startbridge. [0:09:37, 0:09:41]: Mayor and council will hold a public hearing on Monday, August twelfth. [0:09:42, 0:09:45]: At six PM in the Stockbridge State Hall. [0:09:47, 0:09:51]: Located at forty six forty North Henry Boulevard, Stockbridge, Georgia. [0:09:51, 0:09:53]: To consider a request. [0:09:54, 0:10:00]: For a comprehensive land use change of property at four hundred twenty five Country Club Drive. [0:10:01, 0:10:03]: To resolve the property. [0:10:03, 0:10:05]: From high density [0:10:05, 0:10:08]: To low density mixed use. [0:10:09, 0:10:13]: To allow for the conversion of an an assisted living facility. [0:10:14, 0:10:16]: To a boutique hotel. [0:10:18, 0:10:20]: The applicant is Stuart Hope. [0:10:21, 0:10:23]: On this on behalf of Stockbridge. [0:10:24, 0:10:26]: Propco L C [0:10:27, 0:10:29]: The parcel number is [0:10:30, 0:10:35]: Zero fifty one dash zero one zero one six zero two one. [0:10:37, 0:10:49]: The property is on land lot fourteen district seven with six point nine two nine I'm sorry, six point nine two acres more or less within the city limits of Stockbridge. [0:10:50, 0:10:55]: The rezoning case is RZ twenty twenty four-zero five. [0:10:56, 0:11:03]: The City of Stockbridge Planning Commission will hold a public meeting on Thursday, july twenty eighth of july eighteenth, twenty twenty four. [0:11:04, 0:11:06]: At six thirty PM [0:11:06, 0:11:14]: And the City of Stockbridge Mayor and Council will hold a public hearing on august twelfth, twenty twenty four. [0:11:15, 0:11:16]: A six PM [0:11:17, 0:11:24]: In the Stockbridge City Hall located at forty six forty North Henry Boulevard in Stockbridge, Georgia. [0:11:25, 0:11:34]: To consider a request for the rezoning of property located at forty at four twenty-five Council Club Drive. [0:11:35, 0:11:40]: to rezone the property from OI, which is office institutional. [0:11:42, 0:11:46]: We're gonna r they wanna rezone it to C two, which is general commercial. [0:11:47, 0:11:50]: to allow for a boutique hotel. [0:11:51, 0:11:53]: The applicant again stood hope. [0:11:53, 0:11:56]: On behalf of Stockbridge Prop Core L C [0:11:57, 0:12:03]: The parcel is zero five one dash zero one zero one six zero two one. [0:12:05, 0:12:15]: The property is in landlock 14 of District 7 with 6.92 acres more or less within the Stockbridge city limits. Mr. Linton, please. [0:12:17, 0:12:30]: Thank you, Mr. Dumas. Uh my name is Gordon Linton, Planner One for the City of Stockbridge, and I'm here to present the cases for RZ 2024-05 and CP24-05 for 425 Country Club Drive. [0:12:34, 0:12:54]: Uh these are the case facts. As mentioned, the applicant is Stewart Hope on behalf of Stockbridge Pro Praccal LLC, and the owner is Stockbridge Proco LLC, and the agent is Stewart Hope. The address of the property is 425 Country Club Drive, and the number of acres is 6.92. As far as the characteristics, the current the building [0:12:54, 0:13:09]: Building is being used as a senior assisted living facility with the current land use designation of high density residential and with the current zoning of OI, which is office institutional. And in addition, the sign was posted on june eighteenth, twenty twenty four. [0:13:12, 0:13:32]: This is the the vicinity map. Um you have the public shopping center to the left, along with Chase Bank, uh PNC Bank and Georgia Credit, Georgia United Credit of the Union. To below you have the Eagles Landing Country Club, along with the Egypt Eagles Landing Country Club, which is the golf course, and to the right. [0:13:32, 0:13:34]: Right, you have the subdivision known as the village estates. [0:13:37, 0:13:42]: And this is the sign that was posted on June uh June eighteenth, twenty twenty four. [0:13:46, 0:13:57]: And this is a site visit that we did on June eighteenth, twenty twenty four. As you can see, it's adjacent from the entrance to the public shopping center and across is Georgia United Credit Union. [0:14:01, 0:14:04]: And this is the presentation for CP twenty twenty four-zero five. [0:14:06, 0:14:19]: As mentioned, the applicant's request is to change the current future land use designation from high density residential to low density mixed use to allow to allow for the conversion of assisted living facility to a boutique hotel. [0:14:20, 0:14:27]: And this is the City of Stockbridge Comprehensive Plan twenty twenty four with the definition of the high density residential. [0:14:30, 0:14:45]: And this is the future land use map and the property is surrounded by high density mixed use to the left, low density mixed use to the south, and you have a low density residential, high density residential, and low density mixed use. [0:14:49, 0:14:51]: And this is the project information [0:14:52, 0:15:00]: The exterior scope that will occur during the conversion from the existed living facility to the boutique hotel will include landscaping, uh the [0:15:02, 0:15:22]: Replacement of the existing terrace guardrails with ornamental railings, exterior painting, and installation of security features that includes cameras, and the remainder of the conversion will focus on the interior renovations that will include full room and bathroom updates. There are no proposed changes to the current side plan nor floor plan of the existing building. [0:15:22, 0:15:22]: [927.7, 937.0]: So the key points to highlight from the staff analysis that we did is that it is consistent with the comprehensive plan, particularly the economic development goal. [0:15:38, 0:15:46]: Along with the econom economic development policy and both the future land use goals, which is shown here, and the future land use policy. [0:15:51, 0:16:01]: And it is also suitable to the subject property since it will bring growth to the vicinity, provide additional jobs, and will attract tourists who will not only visit the boutique hotel [0:16:03, 0:16:05]: But would spend money at the nearby shopping center. [0:16:10, 0:16:20]: And staff staff recommends that the based on the staff analysis that we did, staff recommends that the current future land use just remains as high density residential. [0:16:25, 0:16:30]: And this is the presentation for the rezoning RZ twenty twenty four dash zero five. [0:16:31, 0:16:39]: As mentioned, the the applicant wants to rezone the property from OI, which is Office Institutional, to C2, General Commercial. [0:16:43, 0:16:54]: And this is the zoning map and the subject property is surrounded by C2, MFR, which is the village estates, and the PUD, which is the Eagles Landing Country uh Golf Course. [0:16:56, 0:17:04]: And in addition, the subject property is also part of the Parkway Mixed Use Overlay District, which is shown here in purple. And this is the site with the star. [0:17:07, 0:17:20]: And the zoning history of the property. The subject property was previously a hotel called the Inn and Eagles Landing, which is shown here. The construction on the hotel started in 1994 and was finished in 1995. [0:17:20, 0:17:28]: And then the subject property was rezoned from R M, which is multiple family residential, to OI, upon the request of Clearnt properties on November eighth. [0:17:29, 0:17:32]: two thousand four with their tending use as an assisted living facility. [0:17:36, 0:17:38]: And this is a survey of the property. [0:17:48, 0:18:07]: And this is the project information. Uh currently the system limit facility has sixty-eight parking spaces and it does meet the parking requirements found in section four point eight five of the UDC code, which is one parking space per room. And they will also have ten employees with six being full-time and four being part-time. [0:18:10, 0:18:27]: And the key points from the staff analysis that we did is that it is consistent with the goals of the policies found found in the comp plan. It's also consistent with the UDC, the intent of the C two district and the Parkway mixed use overlay district standards. [0:18:29, 0:18:49]: And some of the positive effects that will include additional growth with the three hotels, which is shown here in the vicinity. You have Holiday Inn Express, you have Micro Hotel Inn and Suites, and you also have True Hilton Hotel. So with that, it will bring additional growth to the city. It'll provide job opportunities within not only within the hotel. [0:18:49, 0:19:03]: such as staff services and for management, but also bring additional job opportunities for residents as well as in the city. It will also attract tourists, and it will increase the popularity and growth of the nearby golf course at the Eagles Landing Country Club. [0:19:07, 0:19:18]: And lastly, the proposed boutique hotel won't have any negative impact on the surrounding properties owners since it is surrounded by residential and commercial. And staff recommends approval. [0:19:25, 0:19:26]: Nice. [0:19:26, 0:19:29]: Thank you very much. Is the applicant present? [0:19:31, 0:19:33]: No, but I and his colleagues. [0:19:34, 0:19:36]: Would you approach the podium, please? [0:19:38, 0:19:39]: You have a presentation to make? [0:19:41, 0:19:41]: What was that again, sir? [0:19:42, 0:19:58]: Do you have a presentation to make? I do not other than just to reintroduce what Gordon said. Uh speaking the mic, please. The the goal of the property is to turn it into a boutique hotel as it once was, and that's pretty much it. [0:19:59, 0:19:59]: We can't hear you. [0:20:00, 0:20:20]: The goal is to turn the property back into its original state as a boutique hotel. It was as as it was originally constructed. Um there will be no major changes to the exteriors other than the uh the things that Gordon mentioned and most of the uh renovations will happen t on the interior of the [0:20:20, 0:20:20]: [1222.0, 1222.6]: Thank you. [0:20:23, 0:20:25]: Any questions from the commission, please? [0:20:27, 0:20:47]: Yeah, Chair, I have a few. Um thank you. Um is this you guys's first hotel or do you all have different hotels that you've I'm actually with the ownership of the current group. Um the property is under contract with a hotel group, but they are not undertaking the rezoning we are. Um this would be one of the [0:20:47, 0:20:55]: Their this would be their fifth hotel that they have in the Atlanta area. Um, I don't know what ones they are, but I know they own five in the area. [0:20:56, 0:20:57]: Oh yeah. [0:20:57, 0:20:58]: Mm. [0:21:02, 0:21:03]: Canagis for the record, please. [0:21:04, 0:21:05]: Grant Milton? [0:21:06, 0:21:06]: Uh [0:21:09, 0:21:11]: Melton, [0:21:12, 0:21:13]: Was that? [0:21:15, 0:21:31]: We'll get we'll get it at the end. Um, so you said they have five different hotels and one of the things that we try to push here on the board, especially in mayor and council, is quality in the actual community. Do you know by chance what are the ratings for those other hotels that they have? Is it a three star, five star, two star? [0:21:31, 0:21:47]: I'm not aware but I know this hotel um will be boutique and it will be probably a four or five star hotel. So define a boutique hotel for me'cause I'm trying to analyze it in my head and and I so w will it be shops in it? Like what it define that for me. [0:21:47, 0:21:53]: mainly defines the size of the hotel and the quality of the hotel. It's more upscale. [0:21:55, 0:21:58]: Gotcha. Okay. Uh that's all I have for you. Thank you. [0:22:00, 0:22:16]: Any more questions, please. Yes, sir. I have a question. So the facility is currently occupied, correct? Correct. So have the families and the residents been met with, made understood what the uh timelines are, uh what the intention is? [0:22:17, 0:22:37]: I am unaware of that because that is not my role in the company. I handle real estate. Um I was told that I think uh upper level management had spoken with the staff and they were directed to speak with the residents family probably two or three weeks ago about what the timeline and the process. [0:22:37, 0:22:40]: [1360.7, 1377.1]: Okay. Thank you. Chair. If I may, um I'd I would like to thank the gentleman, but I d I know the buyer said she was here and she would probably be able to answer um Commissioner Minton's question a little bit further. Just a type form answer. We'll get to that. Thank you very much, sir. Thank you. Mm-hmm. [0:23:00, 0:23:03]: Ma'am, did you say you were the applicant? [0:23:11, 0:23:12]: Tell us your name. [0:23:13, 0:23:21]: Uh good evening. My name is Venus Gervin. Uh I participated in putting the application together, but the formal applicant is the broker. [0:23:23, 0:23:24]: So you are not the Africa. [0:23:25, 0:23:30]: I'm the purchaser who will be converting it into the hotel. Okay. Go running. [0:23:30, 0:23:30]: Okay. [0:23:31, 0:23:35]: Um so to answer your first question, uh Ubutique Hotel is [0:23:35, 0:23:55]: Um it will be a soft branded hotel. Um we're looking in the upper upscale uh segmentation class. Um so um let's see what I'm not sure the best way to describe that, but it it will be um not your Hampton or you know Holiday Inn, but it will be [0:23:55, 0:24:05]: a more uh upper upscale um class than that. So uh different types of amenities, um food and beverage, um bar surfaces also. [0:24:09, 0:24:10]: Any other questions? [0:24:12, 0:24:14]: I have one for you. Mm-hmm. [0:24:15, 0:24:19]: Do you intend to develop the hotel, but do you intend to manage it as well? [0:24:19, 0:24:20]: Yes. [0:24:21, 0:24:23]: So the other hotels that [0:24:25, 0:24:34]: I think you said five, you were told five. Yes. That you own already. Mm-hmm. You manage and you you develop and you manage them yourself. [0:24:34, 0:24:41]: Uh yes, we have a um management, a third party management company uh that will manage the properties. So it's a different company, but yes. [0:24:43, 0:24:44]: So it's like a chain. [0:24:45, 0:24:52]: Uh no, it's not a chain. It's just uh I mean, we're just a a small um, you know, development group. Okay. Yeah. Thank you. [0:24:53, 0:25:08]: And I believe you had a question about um the existing occupants. Um, from my understanding, the um the current owners have another property not far from there and they were gonna relocate those occupants to that facility. [0:25:10, 0:25:15]: And that property is likely to be latest I was told. [0:25:16, 0:25:18]: Oh, are you are you okay. [0:25:18, 0:25:19]: Are you the [0:25:22, 0:25:23]: Oh okay, okay, I'm sorry. [0:25:24, 0:25:42]: The concern is obviously that we want to make sure that the the residents are given ample notice, the families, to make wise and informed decisions whether or not they want to go to a new facility. Yes. Yes. Or another facility in the case that you've just stated. Mm-hmm. It would be made available. Okay. Okay. Thank you. I don't have anything else. [0:25:45, 0:25:56]: If there are no further questions, thank you very much. Okay, thank you so much. Mr Chairman, I'd I'd like to ask a question. And and I may have missed the answer if this was asked already, but what exactly is the function of a boutique hotel? [0:25:57, 0:26:16]: Um the function um almost similar to the first gentleman's um question, it's uh it will be a soft branded hotel, so it's not a a holiday inn or a Hampton. It will be um an independent hotel, but you use the um the reservation services of a Hilton or a Marriott. [0:26:18, 0:26:28]: So for example, if you have if you're a Hilton Rewards member and you stay at this hotel and it's a soft branded Hilton, you can still get your rewards points. [0:26:28, 0:26:35]: That would be probably the best example. And the existing structure has how many rooms available to house people? [0:26:35, 0:26:38]: Um it has um fifty eight rooms right now. [0:26:38, 0:26:39]: Okay. [0:26:39, 0:26:39]: Mm-hmm. [0:26:42, 0:26:50]: And we're not um you know, we're not adding any um we're not adding onto the building or anything. We'll just work with whatever's there. [0:26:53, 0:26:53]: Yeah. [0:26:54, 0:26:55]: Any more questions? [0:26:56, 0:26:59]: I'm sorry, one last question, Chair. Uh [0:27:01, 0:27:08]: Our project description says it has sixty rooms and sixty eight room uh existing parking spaces. Are you changing or adjusting that at all? [0:27:09, 0:27:29]: Well it has um the space for 60 rooms. For example, they're using one room as a fitness center. So I haven't decided yet if I'm gonna keep that a fitness center or make it a room. Uh they're using another room as a suite onto another room. So I haven't decided yet if I'm gonna keep that a suite or make that its own room. So it can have a maximum. [0:27:29, 0:27:35]: maximum of sixty rooms, but right now it has fifty eight. So uh it'll either be fifty eight or sixty. [0:27:36, 0:27:37]: And [0:27:38, 0:27:43]: Were the opportunities for extended stay also granted in throughout this hotel or no? [0:27:43, 0:27:46]: Um no, that's not one of the brands that we're looking for. [0:27:47, 0:27:48]: Thank you. [0:27:48, 0:27:57]: Yeah, um I'm not sure that um I haven't really seen many extended stays that are in the the upper upscale category that I'm looking for. [0:28:01, 0:28:01]: Okay. [0:28:03, 0:28:04]: Good. [0:28:05, 0:28:06]: Thank you, Mel. Okay. All right. Thank you so much. Mm-hmm. [0:28:21, 0:28:24]: Since this is a public hearing [0:28:26, 0:28:27]: I'm gonna ask [0:28:29, 0:28:35]: If there is anyone in the building who would like to speak in favor of this project. [0:28:40, 0:28:47]: Seeing none, then I will ask if there are anyone present who wish to speak in opposition to this project. [0:28:49, 0:28:50]: Okay. [0:28:50, 0:29:05]: I will ask that you form a line to my right in this aisle. And if you hadn't already filled out a form, given it to the secretary, I would ask that you do so before you approach the podium. [0:29:07, 0:29:13]: If you've already done so, you may approach the podium third and give us your name and address. [0:29:19, 0:29:24]: Good evening, everyone. Speaking to the microphone, please. Make sure the green light is on. [0:29:25, 0:29:27]: Green light is on. Okay, sir. [0:29:28, 0:29:33]: My name is Bruce Meadows and I live at Thirty Indian Overlook Court in Stockbridge, Georgia. [0:29:34, 0:29:35]: Um [0:29:36, 0:29:56]: I ha I have prepared a thing to s to say, but I also do want to address some of the things that came up with the presentation of the former people that are presenting. The I'm a family member, my mother is a resident at Golden Crest, and the families have not been given an opportunity to know when or where the [0:29:56, 0:30:16]: The residence will be moved. Um they've not been given any date, any type of uh plan or of what would be done. Um I've specifically spoken to the um recently um the executive director to ask her for those details, and she told me that the owner had not informed everyone. [0:30:16, 0:30:35]: that yet. So if but information has been shared and I'd spoken with several of the staff members too and they also don't have any information as to what the plan currently would be. My mother is 83 years old. She was diagnosed approximately two years ago with dementia. [0:30:35, 0:30:55]: Um I know that's a uh an impactful diagnosis from many families, but for ours it was pretty significant in that my mother is very fun, she's very lively, she's very sassy, and for her to deteriorate to the point to where she needs this type of facility has been pretty debilitating for our entire family. Um [0:30:55, 0:31:15]: This facility became became highly recommended by Sherry Douglas with Southern Grace Hospice. She and my mother, she her mother and my mother were both in the emergency room one evening. They had both fallen and we got to talking as you do with fellow emergency room patients. And I found out what her uh type of work was and we got [0:31:15, 0:31:35]: Got to talking about it and that I was looking for a facility for my mom because we were nearing that point to consider that type of a change in our lives. She recommended Goldencrest without hesitation. She works in-house with a lot of the different facilities in the area, Henry County and beyond. And not that she had anything bad to say about. [0:31:35, 0:31:42]: about any of the other ones, but she recommended Goldencrest because of its size. It was smaller. There were more one on one care [0:31:42, 0:32:00]: available for the residents. I mean currently now there are only 24 residents in the home and there are only 24 staff members. So basically your ratio is one to one for care and concern for patients who greatly need that level of consistency in their lives. [0:32:03, 0:32:10]: I toured the facility myself and met with the executive director, and she walked me through the place and immediately it felt like home. [0:32:10, 0:32:19]: Uh yes, it's older. Yes, the decor is not new and boutique fashioned and whatnot. And and I do understand what a boutique hotel is. Um [0:32:21, 0:32:36]: But this place is is home, and I got so encouraged by that and by the attitude. I met several staff members on my very first men um visit. I met several residents on my very first visit. Some of them have been there for over eleven years. [0:32:36, 0:32:38]: And that is their home. This is their own. [0:32:39, 0:32:40]: Mm I'm sorry. [0:32:41, 0:32:42]: Well I'm sorry, I didn't hear. [0:32:43, 0:33:03]: Two minutes, okay, I'll speed it up, my bad. Um, this is more than a facility, this is a community. These people are there for each other, they learn to love each other, they learn and greet and meet everyone's families. And my mother, when she first walked into that place, prior to visiting there, she had said for months, I will not go anywhere. [0:33:03, 0:33:10]: I have a home. I'm not going anywhere. She walked into that place and immediately said, this is home. [0:33:11, 0:33:31]: Something about it struck her as this was where I'll be comfortable. And because we've moved in and she's acclimated to the system and to the activities, it is her home now. And she loves it there. The care is incredible. Couldn't ask for a better situation for my mother. And if this were to go through, I do know that it would be a huge loss, not only [0:33:31, 0:33:32]: [2013.1, 2032.5]: And the residents, but for the community, because Stockbridge and Eagles Landing is a community and it's built on that whole mindset of being there for and with each other. So I would definitely like to leave her there because it would definitely we're lucky she has a home to come back to. Thank you very much. [0:33:53, 0:33:56]: Appreciate it. Thank you, sir. Next, please. [0:34:01, 0:34:21]: Uh good evening. My name is Roselle Honorable and I am currently the property manager, maintenance man at the facility. And basically, back up uh Mr. Bruce piggyback when he says, uh it's more than just a building. It is a community. Uh from each from each residence uh to staff members. [0:34:21, 0:34:30]: Um I like to consider'em family. They're they're my moms, they're my dads. Um and like like you said. [0:34:30, 0:34:31]: When the sign went up. [0:34:32, 0:34:48]: No one knew. We still we're still in the dark for our staff and residents. Um and the the activity rooms, what they're saying, that's that's false. Um it's just it's just rooms. We got um [0:34:49, 0:34:52]: Uh uh activity, I mean a T V room and a dining room. [0:34:53, 0:35:13]: But um in in my three years there, um what I found if when residents are moved and relocated, it it doesn't it doesn't end well. Um is there some is there some things that need to be done to the building? Yes. But as far as us as staff, that's not our hand. All we do is we all we can do is our best. [0:35:13, 0:35:33]: the care and love and love on each every resident. And from for me to each staff member, I think they will echo that. So um if you're looking at the bottom line, sure the bottom line's gonna be good, but in the long run, I I think it would be a huge mistake for the families. We've uh we average like 30 residents and every since [0:35:32, 0:35:39]: The news is broke. We've been losing them left and right because they're trying to make preparations on what they have to do. Thank you. [0:35:39, 0:35:40]: Thank you, sir. [0:35:41, 0:35:42]: Next please. [0:35:45, 0:35:54]: Hi, I'm Sophia Oliver. I'm the nurse at Golden Crest. I've been there for seven years. Um, been nursing thirty one years. Um [0:35:55, 0:36:00]: The facility is more like a family oriented place. These residents look up to us. [0:36:01, 0:36:05]: Um they live there, we love on them, we treat them better than sometimes their family members. [0:36:05, 0:36:10]: I got people there who don't even have people come to visit them and they live there. They don't have nowhere to go. [0:36:10, 0:36:11]: And [0:36:11, 0:36:15]: When they talk about turning into a hotel, it was a hotel before why it didn't work then. [0:36:16, 0:36:18]: So now you want to turn it back into a hotel. [0:36:18, 0:36:23]: Which apparently didn't work. So now these people live there, been there years and years. [0:36:23, 0:36:27]: Y'all trying to take these people are trying to take it from them is not fair. [0:36:27, 0:36:30]: It's not fair to the staff, it's not fair to the residents. [0:36:30, 0:36:33]: We got a few residents here right now that's they don't have nowhere to go. [0:36:34, 0:36:37]: You know, some of'em don't even have family members and this is their home. [0:36:38, 0:36:57]: You know, and I just feel bad. You know, I'm here now. I worked all day. I work all day with them. And they look up to me. They treat me just like I'm their daughter. I treat them like m they're my parents. I love on them and they know that. If they go to another facility that they d that they don't know nobody at, guess what? They're gonna pass away. And I don't like it. [0:36:57, 0:37:01]: You know, and they'll tell you, each one of them will tell you how we treat them. [0:37:01, 0:37:21]: You know, our carpet is dirty, yeah. But the building is nice. We don't have no fitness center. We don't have all that. We got an activity room where we do bingo and throw balls and whatever we do. But they love it. You know, we might not have no van network. If y'all wanna help us get the b van fixed to take them on out of us, y'all can do that. But until then, we got a little bus, we go take and get ice cream. [0:37:21, 0:37:41]: Lights went out the other day. We took them come up there on our off day at night to come and sit with these people in the dark. I don't think nobody else gonna do that for them. We took them to get ice cream and stuff, you know, in the dark. They like that. You know what I'm saying? So my thing is don't take their home away from them. This lady sold her house to move there. [0:37:41, 0:37:43]: You know what I'm saying? She ain't got nowhere to go. [0:37:43, 0:37:56]: So, you know, when they they they talk I I understand about hotels or whatever, I get it. But that don't work for me right now. I don't public speak very well, but I think I'm doing all right right now, you know, because it it this this this gets to my heart. [0:37:56, 0:38:11]: You know, and when y'all talking about t putn turn it turn their home into a hotel, these people don't have nowhere to go. We got about thirty residents there. Five of'em leaving because they saw a sign got posted up. We don't know what's going on. I don't know what's going on. Nobody told us nothing. [0:38:12, 0:38:30]: On thing we was told was that we got a hearing that we gotta come to on July the 18th at 630. And best believe I'm gonna be here. And I'm gonna be at the one on August. So my thing is don't take these people home away from them for a hotel. You can put a hotel anywhere in the middle of the country club. Yeah, I get it. Y'all want the golf people to come somewhere live? Apparently that didn't work. [0:38:31, 0:38:36]: They tried that before. So next next thing you know, it's gonna fail again. These people ain't gonna have nowhere to live. [0:38:36, 0:38:43]: But anyway, I know my time is almost up. But anyway, I appreciate if y'all let these people live where they're supposed to be living at. Thank y'all. Thank you, man. [0:38:44, 0:38:45]: Next please. [0:38:50, 0:39:10]: Good afternoon. My name is Mar Glenn, and I'm a resident of the villages. I don't know what to say after her impassioned speech, except maybe to give her my time after I'm done. I just had two questions of the requester, and that is the villages of Eagle Land. [0:39:10, 0:39:30]: Is a private gated community which does not have a gate where they're planning to put in that hotel. And I want to see if they are going to allow us to remain a gated community and fence that area off. And the other question is, when will they speak with the residents? [0:39:30, 0:39:41]: I'd like to um have more information so we can have an informed decision as you said and if I can give the rest of my time to this young lady because I would love to hear her speak some more. [0:39:43, 0:39:43]: Thank you, sir. [0:39:47, 0:39:48]: May um [0:39:49, 0:39:53]: In the blue, you said you were the baya. [0:40:02, 0:40:05]: She hasn't even filled out a form yet. [0:40:07, 0:40:13]: Yes, I'm the purchaser. Can you answer uh the gentleman's question as far as the g the gated community? [0:40:15, 0:40:19]: Uh I'm sorry, w as far as the Did he leave? [0:40:19, 0:40:20]: Mm-hmm. [0:40:21, 0:40:22]: Okay. [0:40:23, 0:40:25]: Yeah, these things. Uh [0:40:30, 0:40:31]: Mm-hmm. [0:40:34, 0:40:35]: Yeah. [0:40:35, 0:40:36]: Game on that side. [0:40:37, 0:40:39]: Okay. Yeah, that's definitely something that we can look into. [0:40:42, 0:40:43]: Okay. [0:40:43, 0:41:00]: Did she answer the question? You good? Uh also when we want to speak with the presidents. Oh uh I'm not sure. This is the first kind of step in the um in the process for us. Um so I mean we we just need to kind of go from here and see where this takes us. [0:41:00, 0:41:18]: Yeah. But I but yes, I'm I'm planning on speaking with everyone uh in the surrounding area. Ma'am, would you speak in the microphone, please? Uh no, I was saying I'm planning on speaking with everyone in the surrounding area. Um, you know, as far as I mean, I'm I'm not in the assisted living business. Um I just saw the property listed for sale. [0:41:18, 0:41:34]: So I I I really can't speak to uh the you know, the other employment um issues. I have a question for you since you brought that up. Uh the gentleman that was sitting here indicated there you are. You are the seller and you are the buyer. Am I correct? [0:41:35, 0:41:37]: And you all have a contract. [0:41:37, 0:41:43]: Yes. Is it contingent on this being approved? Yes. [0:41:45, 0:41:51]: Okay. That's what I want to know. Thank you very much. Okay. Anybody else have any questions? [0:41:52, 0:41:53]: I I got it. Yeah. [0:41:54, 0:41:57]: Yeah, any more questions for the the lady before? [0:41:58, 0:42:00]: Yeah, okay, thank you, Mayor. [0:42:02, 0:42:04]: Ma'am, you may approach the podium, please. [0:42:05, 0:42:06]: Give us your name and address. [0:42:07, 0:42:11]: Hello, my name is Lisa Glenn, and my address is the one ninety nine equals club drive. [0:42:12, 0:42:15]: Um stock bridge and [0:42:17, 0:42:27]: I have a lot of concerns about that property becoming a hotel. Yes, it was a hotel before, but it was a hotel for the country club and it was when the golfers came in. [0:42:27, 0:42:30]: to do those tournaments back in the day. [0:42:31, 0:42:32]: That has ceased. [0:42:32, 0:42:36]: So if anyone is goes to that hotel. [0:42:36, 0:42:37]: As a visitor [0:42:37, 0:42:39]: They do not have access to the golf course. [0:42:40, 0:42:40]: Or the club. [0:42:41, 0:42:44]: А те доксать. [0:42:44, 0:42:46]: There is no gate. [0:42:46, 0:42:50]: м ор то стоп інівоз тру [0:42:51, 0:43:08]: to um go to all those expensive homes where the doctors and lawyers and entertainers and all those live on that side of the golf course. And our house is the first house at that gate. So as soon as they come in that gate, they have access to come straight to our house and [0:43:09, 0:43:19]: Yeah, crime rampant. It's there's nothing protecting us over there now with that hotel going there. None of the neighbors I walk [0:43:19, 0:43:28]: Quite frequently every morning, and every neighbor that I've seen, I've actually talked to about this change in the zoning. [0:43:28, 0:43:37]: Most of them have not even seen the sign. They didn't know what was going on over there at all. Nobody knows. We know because my husband got a letter. [0:43:37, 0:43:49]: That was it. Nobody else has gotten a letter. So it's like they they're doing it in secret and they're just throwing it in there and all of a sudden we're gonna be surprised and not know where, you know. [0:43:50, 0:43:50]: This [0:43:52, 0:43:59]: And we don't know what a boutique hotel is, what the price range of a boutique hotel is, you know, um [0:44:00, 0:44:07]: I've dealt with a lot of hotels when I helped house a couple of homeless people and they stay in the hotels. [0:44:08, 0:44:09]: That's not gonna be good for our area. [0:44:10, 0:44:15]: Our area, we have a very, very, very, very, very high hoe. [0:44:15, 0:44:17]: Like the highest in the state of Georgia. [0:44:18, 0:44:20]: And now our HOA is not going to even protect us. [0:44:21, 0:44:22]: From this hotel. [0:44:23, 0:44:27]: That's not good for us. A lot of people have already put up their houses for sale. [0:44:28, 0:44:32]: There's like eight houses for sale up in that area now, since I've told people. [0:44:33, 0:44:34]: So [0:44:35, 0:44:36]: Are property values gonna go down? [0:44:37, 0:44:47]: tremendously and our neighborhood is gonna go to pot. We do not want a hotel there. Everybody I've talked to said no, they do not want a hotel there at all. [0:44:48, 0:45:03]: And when I say expensive homes, I'm talking about like that's where um Hank Aaron lived, Chris Tucker's families live over there, T I and Tiny's families live over there. There's a lot of prominent people over there and they will have access to their homes because there's nothing blocking. [0:45:04, 0:45:11]: If they're gonna put a wall around that hotel and put walls down the side, and I mean high walls, so they can't climb over and jump and whatever. [0:45:12, 0:45:15]: then they might consider it, but right now no. [0:45:17, 0:45:19]: That's what I have to say so far. [0:45:19, 0:45:20]: Thank you, Mayor. You're welcome. [0:45:21, 0:45:23]: There's no one else that has not already spoken. [0:45:24, 0:45:26]: Wish to speak in opposition. [0:45:27, 0:45:33]: If you've already spoken then you will not get an opportunity to speak again. You may take your seat, sir. [0:45:35, 0:45:39]: I said you will not get a opportunity to speak to you. You may take your seats. [0:45:44, 0:45:50]: If there's no other speakers present, then we will close the public hearing. [0:45:56, 0:46:00]: I need a motion from the commission. [0:46:02, 0:46:11]: on the comprehensive case, comprehensive comprehensive plan case, CP twenty to twenty four dash zero five. [0:46:12, 0:46:15]: Chair. Yes, sir. Um [0:46:20, 0:46:40]: I w I'm gonna make this motion really solely because of one, we don't have, I believe, sufficient enough evidence for a hotel to go there. Um, or sufficient enough evidence as to why they want to move the residents, especially hearing from um some of the people in the area that work there as well, and they're saying [0:46:40, 0:46:45]: they have not heard from the owner currently as to where [0:46:45, 0:47:05]: The uh current senior senior citizens will actually go at the moment. That's kind of concerning to me, especially to place a hotel in an area where they're already comfortable, it's already secluded. It's a secluded area for our seniors, so you you know they're not making noise. It's not like they're having a big party or anything. Um so at this moment, I'm gonna make a motion. Uh [0:47:05, 0:47:22]: Uh due to some reasonable experience because I also have some family that have let me know when they when they get to a certain age they want to go to Golden Crest. Uh I'm gonna make a motion to deny comprehensive plan uh CP dash twenty twenty four dash oh five. Thank you, sir. Is there a second? [0:47:23, 0:47:26]: Mr. Chairman, this is Dave Planchon. I would like to second that motion. [0:47:27, 0:47:29]: It's been moved by Mr. Williams. [0:47:29, 0:47:36]: And seconded by Mr. Planchon that we denied comprehensive plan K C P twenty twenty-four-zero five. [0:47:37, 0:47:39]: All in favour that it'd be Namarasan of A. [0:47:39, 0:47:42]: In your pulse. [0:47:43, 0:47:49]: The eyes have it. The comprehensive plan case has been voted to den be denied. Thank you. [0:47:52, 0:47:57]: With respect to rezoning case R Z twenty twenty four dash zero five, I need a motion, please. [0:48:03, 0:48:15]: Chairman. Yes, sir. Uh once again, since there is not a current new development coming to that area, I'm going to make a motion to deny rezoning case RZ-2024-05. [0:48:15, 0:48:16]: Thank you. [0:48:17, 0:48:18]: Is there a second? [0:48:18, 0:48:19]: Mr. Chairman, I second. [0:48:20, 0:48:25]: It's been moved by Mr. Williams and seconded by Mr. Minton. The [0:48:25, 0:48:33]: Retoning case RZ twenty twenty four dash zero five be denied. All in favor, let it be known by the sign of I. [0:48:33, 0:48:34]: Oh yeah. [0:48:34, 0:48:42]: Any opposed? I have it. The rezoning case RZ 2024-05 has been voted to be denied. Thank you. [0:48:48, 0:48:52]: Next we will have a presentation. [0:48:53, 0:48:55]: By Jalen Hudson. [0:48:58, 0:48:59]: Mm mm mm. [0:49:22, 0:49:26]: Taylor, tell'em who you are. Tell'em who you are. [0:49:28, 0:49:34]: Well, good evening. Um, my name is Jalen Hudson. I'm a summer intern here at the city of Stockbridge. [0:49:35, 0:49:36]: Um just a little brief [0:49:37, 0:49:45]: description about myself. Um I'm a rising senior at Benedict College. Um in the business field. Um I'm a business major actually. [0:49:45, 0:49:48]: Um, just a little bit about my intern so far. [0:49:49, 0:50:05]: Um since I've been here, it's been very welcoming, very open arm. Um I've been taken under the wing of Ms. Jackson and Mr. Linton. They've been showing me the ways of learning how to, you know, plan and zone correctly. Um but without further ado, I'll get into my presentation. [0:50:09, 0:50:29]: So, first thing, what is planning? Planning and zoning are separate functions that work together as part of a long-range effort to plan quality communities. Planning provides a vision for communities while zoning is only one of several tools available to help achieve this vision. It involves the regulation of [0:50:28, 0:50:34]: of using space considering the physical form, economic functions, and social impacts. [0:50:35, 0:50:40]: Urban planning aims to improve existing urban areas and creating new urbanization. [0:50:43, 0:50:56]: As we see here we have a s a chart with zoning and planning. Zoning is pretty much guided by the zoning ordinance, determines what can happen on the property today, which includes zoning districts and a zoning map. [0:50:56, 0:51:07]: Planning, on the other hand, is guided by the comprehensive plan, determines what can happen on the property in our future. It includes character areas and a future land use map. [0:51:10, 0:51:25]: So here we have our current zoning districts. Uh I'll run through them right real quick. We have our rural residential district, suburban residential district, our city center residential district, multiple family residential, residential [0:51:25, 0:51:26]: Mobile home. [0:51:26, 0:51:31]: Office institution, downtown district, neighborhood commercial district. [0:51:31, 0:51:33]: Our general commercial di district. [0:51:33, 0:51:40]: Heavy Commercial District, Light Industrial District, Office Distribution District, and our Plant Unit Development. [0:51:43, 0:51:53]: Here we have a updated zoning map of this year. Um just you know, you can take a quick look for a couple of seconds and I'll move on to the next slide. [0:51:58, 0:52:06]: Here we have our overlay zoning districts, Parkway Mixed Use Overlay District, also in abbreviations of PMU. [0:52:06, 0:52:11]: And we have the downtown village overlay district in abbreviations of D T V. [0:52:14, 0:52:25]: Here we have our future land use map which falls under the planning as mentioned as mentioned before. So you all can take a quick look and I'll move on to the next slide. [0:52:31, 0:52:46]: Here we have our link to both zone the future land use map and our zoning map. Um, the City of Stockbridge Unified Development Code, the interactive map is under GIS. [0:52:50, 0:52:53]: Now here we talk about the process of zoning. [0:52:53, 0:53:13]: So it kind of s I guess starts out with, you know, the customer presents their ideas and then of course it runs down to the staff, which runs into the approval or denial. So here let's just say the staff says yes, then the customer will apply for permits with permits division. Now if we go to [0:53:13, 0:53:20]: the denial. The customer will have to apply for a rezoning, use permit, modification, and or a variance. [0:53:20, 0:53:25]: And also the staff will have to use comprehensive plans to analyze those requests. [0:53:26, 0:53:31]: Both mayor, council, or planning commission makes the final decision. [0:53:34, 0:53:36]: Now what is zoning? [0:53:36, 0:53:48]: Zoning is the act or process of parsoning a city, town, or borough into zones reserved for different purposes, such as residents or businesses. [0:53:48, 0:53:55]: It will control the way in which the land can be developed and what purposes the zones can serve. [0:53:56, 0:54:06]: It also regulates more specific details of construction such as maximum building height, minimum lot size, or how far a house needs to be set back from the road. [0:54:10, 0:54:30]: Now, this is this is what I'm interested in. What and who is a planner? Planners help decide what kind of building should go where, where new parks may be needed, and what areas in the community are in need of changes to make them better places to be. A planner serves as the zoning administrator of this board and enforces the city's. [0:54:30, 0:54:30]: [3272.5, 3274.1]: What exactly do they do? [0:54:34, 0:54:43]: Planners interpret a community's zoning code, determines what type of buildings are allowed in what places, and help a community create a vision for what it wants to become. [0:54:45, 0:55:05]: Now this slide is personally, you know, it means a lot to me because, you know, I grew up in the city of Stockbridge since I've been in ninth, tenth grade, but I've always been around the city and I always wanted it to become, you know, something better than what it can be today. So as far as, you know, bringing in new businesses, whether if it's [0:55:05, 0:55:12]: um hotels, restaurants, anything to kind of bring the the attraction to the city of Stockbridge and bring people here. [0:55:14, 0:55:34]: So we'll get into the possible recommendations by the planner. So once again, the approval, we approve the request as submitted by the applicant, or we can deny, which denies the applicant's request, block any further reapplications of the property for a year. And then let's say approval with some you know conditions. We'll approve. [0:55:34, 0:55:40]: Approve their request with extra conditions placed, but it may be recommended by the staff and or the board. [0:55:41, 0:55:50]: And then of course deferral. Defers the case to the next planning commission meeting in order to complete further action necessary prior to decision making. [0:55:54, 0:56:13]: And this one right here is the staff report, which will be sent in a week in advance. Uh it includes, you know, site history, public utility services, considerations, so on and so forth. Um, as you all can see uh on the slide, I won't, you know, get into all of them, but as you all can take a look, it's right there. [0:56:15, 0:56:22]: And then also in bold at the bottom, the staff will review the reports and answer questions thirty minutes in advance of regular meetings. [0:56:26, 0:56:29]: Next slide will be the chapter nine zoning amendments. [0:56:29, 0:56:49]: If you all can see, I've highlighted four parts that stuck out more to me. So number one was whether the proposal is consistent and/or compatible with the city's plans, goals, objectives that reflect in the city's comprehensive plan. Then I can jump around. Uh, how does the proposal impact traffic safety and [0:56:49, 0:57:02]: and congestion and then how will the proposal impact the value of adjacent properties? So we have fourteen amendments, but like I said, I stuck with four just for the you know for the sake of the presentation. [0:57:06, 0:57:26]: And then we start getting to the sectioning, which is you know requirements for special use permits. So as you can see, it goes as the proposed use shall not cause traffic congestions or conditions that will adversely affect nearby properties. The physical conditions of the site, including um to topography. [0:57:26, 0:57:46]: However, you pronounce it, uh, drainage and size and shape are suitable for the proposed development. Then you have the adequate public facilities that are available to serve the proposed use. Then the applicant has made a bidding agreement, a binding agreement, I'm sorry, for any specific limitations or conditions necessary to protect. [0:57:45, 0:57:56]: to protect the public interest, and also it assures the continued beneficial use and enjoyment of nearby properties or that no special limitations are necessary to protect the public. [0:57:58, 0:58:12]: Then you have the conditional use with specific limitations, design features may have been required that will further aim the comprehensive plan and will not only be a d unduly d detrimental to nearby properties. [0:58:15, 0:58:35]: And then of course your items that we or you know I as a future planner would like to consider site plan design, neighboring zoning districts, traffic flow, multimodal c capabilities, screening and or landscaping, the concept comprehensive plans of the future land use. [0:58:35, 0:58:42]: Anything else you deem relevant and recommend you to familiarize yourself with each site in advance of your meeting. [0:58:45, 0:58:50]: And this was my presentation. Um I'm open to take any questions. [0:58:51, 0:58:53]: Any questions from the Commission? [0:58:54, 0:58:57]: No questions, but very well presented. [0:58:57, 0:59:03]: Thank you. Seemed like a bright young man and look forward to seeing you work with the city in the future. [0:59:04, 0:59:06]: Thank you. And it will be a pleasure to be here soon. [0:59:08, 0:59:09]: Thank you, sir. [0:59:17, 0:59:29]: Mr. Anderson, do we have any project updates? Um no sir, Mr. Dumas. Um staff doesn't have any updates at this time. I want to like I'd like to thank Jalen for a great presentation though. [0:59:34, 0:59:35]: Thank you, sir. [0:59:36, 0:59:41]: You have any comments, any further comments? Uh no sir, Mr. Dumas, thank you. [0:59:42, 0:59:44]: Can they comment from the board? [0:59:45, 0:59:48]: Chairman, um I missed the last meeting. I see the insert for the text amendment. [0:59:49, 1:00:02]: Is this something that was not on the agenda for discussion? Okay. Yes, sir. We'll we'll we need to take that to city council first to get their blessing and bring it to the Planning Commission. Okay. It'll probably be on the um August meeting. [1:00:05, 1:00:05]: Right, thank you. [1:00:08, 1:00:09]: Anything else? [1:00:11, 1:00:12]: You all ready to go home? [1:00:14, 1:00:15]: I need a motion to adjourn. [1:00:17, 1:00:18]: So moved here. [1:00:18, 1:00:30]: Is there a second? I second. All in favor, let it be known by the sound of aye. Aye. I go ahead. Meeting is adjourned. Thank you. Thank you all. Thank you all for coming. Have a good evening. [1:01:06, 1:01:07]: Thank you, gentlemen.
  • 2024-07-15 · City Council · Transcript · Special Called Meeting Public Hearing 1 Millage Rate

    2024-07-15 · City Council · Transcript · source: 10yr-transcripts · sha256 77068842 · pages – · method: official

    Full text — searchable
    --- title: Special Called Meeting Public Hearing 1 Millage Rate date: 2024-07-15 source: 2024-07-15_Special_Called_Meeting_Public_Hearing_1_Millage_Rate.wav --- [0:00:00, 0:00:18]: Not the first time, you know. I think you disqualify. And we're gonna we'll try this again. Ladies and good. So I had to call a meeting to order. And the invocation simply stand will begin by American Berry. If you can stand. [0:00:20, 0:00:36]: Dear God, pray today that you would be with us and be with seedings that you will order our footsteps and lead them out of slow make the best decisions for citizens' storage. Lord God, you continue to guide us and give a loving grace and mercy in everything we do. In your son Jesus' name pray. Amen. Amen. All right. Pledge allegiance. Pledge allegiance to the [0:00:37, 0:00:39]: Yes, good evening everyone. [0:00:39, 0:00:59]: Mayor Ford? Present. Mayor Pro Timberry. Present. Councilman Alexander. Present. Councilmember Barber. Present. Councilmember Gantt. Present. Council Member Thomas. Present. Mayor Ford, you have a call. Thank you, Madam Clerk. Appreciate that. Council, I need a motion to uh adopt our agenda, please. So moved. For Mr. Alexander, is there a second? [0:00:59, 0:01:19]: Second. Mr. Berry, second that all in favor, please indicate. It's unanimous decision. Thank you very much. And what we're going to have tonight, ladies and gentlemen, is our first of three public hearings in reference to a miller's rate. Now that's going to be presented by Mr. Gardner, which is our city manager. But let me uh read our public hearing rules before he gives his presentation. And [0:01:19, 0:01:39]: And uh you citizens that are present, you'll get a chance obviously to uh have opportunity to uh give your opinion here uh during the meeting or later on. Please mute all cell phones and other electronic devices. If anyone wishes to speak tonight on public hearing item, please fill out a form available at the table and hand it in to the city clerk before approaching the podium. After he's case. [0:01:39, 0:01:59]: The council would hear from the city staff, followed by applicant or representative regarding the proposed plans for property along any other relevant information. The council will be free to ask questions at any time before the vote. Following the applicant, uh anyone who wishes to speak in favor or opposed to the case will have an opportunity to do so. East side would [0:01:59, 0:02:19]: be allotted 10 minutes total. Additional time may be extended or at the discretion of the council. Please keep comments and presentations professional, referring only to the facts that are pertinent to the case. We will not allow comments or personal attacks toward any individual or group. Please refrain from any applause or comments from the audience during the public hearing. After the presiding [0:02:19, 0:02:39]: Officer recognizes the speaker, he or she shall have direct all comments to the presiding officer, that is me, and never to the members of the council, staff, or audience. All comments will be made from the podium where you will be required to state your name and address for the record. Please note that these proceedings of these hearings are not a debate. [0:02:39, 0:02:59]: Will cause you to be removed from the chamber and the building by law enforcement if you deviate from these proceedings. Other than an applicant, no person may speak more than once. The applicant may reserve part of his or her speaking time as a rebuttal and may speak next and last, and you may use the entire ten minutes allowed for the process. [0:02:59, 0:03:19]: Side of the application. If questions are raised, the council may ask the applicant to address questions andor concerns. The presiding officer will call for a motion and second to the motion and will have any necessary discussion in a matter of it's not tabled. The presiding officer will call for a vote to recommend approval or denial for the request. This is our public [0:03:19, 0:03:26]: uh hearing rules. On that note, Mr. Gardner, our city manager, please come forward and uh and and give us your presentation, sir. [0:03:27, 0:03:47]: Mayor. Yes, sir. If I could just uh for for clarification, this is for the city of Stockbridge Millage. That's correct. You do not live in the city. This does not affect your tax rate. Is that correct? That is correct, sir. All right, thank you. Okay. But it is an open meeting regardless of the city. Yes, sir. Okay. All right. Good deal. [0:03:47, 0:03:55]: Yes, sir. Good evening again, Mayor, Council, uh residents. Um, tonight uh we have our first public hearing. [0:03:57, 0:04:05]: Our first public hearing regarding uh setting of the millers rate for uh twenty twenty four, twenty twenty five. [0:04:06, 0:04:13]: And so with that I'll get proceeded with um some information regarding the millage rate, regarding regarding the digest. [0:04:13, 0:04:33]: Um, talk about some of the growth that's happening in the city, the impacts, um, what we see from our proposed what we preliminary work on our budget, um, and then millish rate options and how that would affect um different homes of different prices within the city um based on different scenario different options. Uh and from that. [0:04:33, 0:04:40]: you'll be able to kinda glee exactly um where the mill is rate is headed based on on our preliminary budget. [0:04:43, 0:04:50]: So what precipitated the budget me the budget uh bubble public hearings is under Georgia law [0:04:51, 0:04:58]: Um a r uh increase in your m property digest, not your millage rate, precipitates uh [0:04:59, 0:05:05]: increase in property tax. So like the some state I worked in, like the state of Illinois. [0:05:05, 0:05:08]: It's not that way. What drives the [0:05:09, 0:05:13]: increase is the increase in millage. So your property could go up but your [0:05:14, 0:05:16]: Your military stays the same. [0:05:17, 0:05:18]: That's considered um [0:05:18, 0:05:23]: not a property tax increase. But in Georgia it's considered a property tax increase. So I digest [0:05:24, 0:05:34]: um for this year grew, unlike in previous years where we were having double digit growth. Um I think it was close to twelve, twelve or eleven percent last year. This year, uh [0:05:35, 0:05:45]: number is one point eight six billion is where we was last year compared to one point nine billion this year. So there was a slight four point four percent increase from twenty twenty three to twenty twenty four. [0:05:45, 0:05:53]: So under Georgia law, what that means is even if the city council votes to keep the millers rate at three point seven seven, which was adopted last year. [0:05:54, 0:05:57]: That still would precipitate the need for public hearings. [0:05:57, 0:06:00]: Because the digest went up even though the miller's rate did not. [0:06:01, 0:06:05]: Right. And so under that we're required to have three public hearings [0:06:05, 0:06:22]: And at that third public hearing, that's when the millage rate would be set at the Wisher Council. As we did last year, when we instituted a millage rate, we were advised by a financial advisor that it's best to advertise a number, even though you will come in under that number. [0:06:22, 0:06:28]: But you want to put a number that's not the number that you're currently at as advertising just because. And here's our scenario. [0:06:29, 0:06:34]: Unlike Henry County, whose budget begins June J July one and ends [0:06:34, 0:06:42]: January 30th of the previous year, the county had no idea what the digest would look like when they just adopted their budget, even though they might have numbers built in. [0:06:43, 0:06:45]: Um you they did not know. [0:06:45, 0:06:57]: Right. So for us our calendar our budget is calendar year, January one to December. So we have a very good idea of what our property tax and our loss revenues would be, unlike the county to some degree. [0:06:57, 0:06:58]: Right. So [0:06:59, 0:07:12]: We advertised a number just above what the number we have, but it wasn't what we did last year. So last year we presented six mills and the sun the city council adopted three point seven seven. So this year we advertised four point two five. [0:07:12, 0:07:19]: With the understanding that we know we could probably work our budget in under that number and would recommend a number smaller than that, lower than that. [0:07:20, 0:07:37]: Uh and so what does the military does? It it drives your general fund revenue, your general operations of government, police. In some cases if you had a fire department, fire department. Um, your parks, your recs, your public works, the folks that do your roads, your side that cleans your do your sidewalks. [0:07:37, 0:07:55]: That funds general government operations, right? Unlike your enterprise funds, or what we call our business type funds, which are water and silver that act and sanitation that act in a competitive business environment, they act differently. So that's what sets what funds your property tax and sales tax fund your general fund. [0:07:57, 0:08:00]: And I don't know how clear this is, I'm gonna try to see if I could blow it up. [0:08:01, 0:08:14]: It's the only way I could get it in here, but I'll I'll do another one and show you guys a different scenario. But in essence, what this slide shows is the increase in our digest um over the last five years, and that digest shows 1.862 billion. [0:08:15, 0:08:18]: The new digest is one point nine four billion. [0:08:18, 0:08:18]: Right. [0:08:19, 0:08:21]: Motor vehicles uh three point four [0:08:21, 0:08:22]: Million. [0:08:23, 0:08:29]: Uh we still have mobile homes in the city of Stockbridge and their values are right at two million dollars all combined. [0:08:30, 0:08:32]: Um we don't have timber in the city, so that doesn't count. [0:08:33, 0:08:37]: Um heavy equipment, we're right at about seven hundred se uh seventy five hundred. [0:08:38, 0:08:58]: And so our gross digest with all those things added adds up to one point nine five billion dollars. So because most of us as homeowners in the county, we could apply for relief from our county taxes, and that's called homestead exemption. So all of us have exemptions. Those exemptions are right at forty four point seven. [0:08:58, 0:08:59]: Seven million. [0:08:59, 0:09:17]: So that comes off of the one point five billion and it leaves you a net digest value of one point nine oh six billion dollars. When you apply, and for everybody to remember, the value of your home is not predicated on what your pr that your [0:09:18, 0:09:26]: Your 100% value is you're not taxed on one hundred percent, you're taxed on forty percent of the value of your house. So if your house is a hundred thousand dollars. [0:09:26, 0:09:31]: Forty percent of that is sixty and that forty and that's what you're tax on. [0:09:32, 0:09:40]: Um your tax on your the millage rate is applied to that. So when you apply the the three point seven seven millage rate that was adopted to that one point nine [0:09:40, 0:09:41]: It would genera. [0:09:41, 0:09:56]: generate a revenue of seven point one million dollars. Um, unlike last year when you applied that same millage rate to the one point eight billion, it gave you a six point eight billion. So that's just over three hundred thousand dollar difference between last year and this year. [0:09:58, 0:10:03]: So that was the four point four growth um increase in the digest. [0:10:05, 0:10:07]: So how does that look on a home? [0:10:08, 0:10:20]: That's not clear either. Um for so for a house that's valued at a hundred and fifty thousand dollars, um forty percent assessed value makes it sixty. [0:10:21, 0:10:30]: Um and because we had an increase also there's a rollback mechanism applied to it. That rollback mechanism we calculated out is right around three point six one. [0:10:31, 0:10:34]: Right. So they would pay two hundred and sixteen. [0:10:34, 0:10:39]: At the two at the present millage rate, they would pay two hundred and twenty six. [0:10:39, 0:10:47]: And if you adopted the advertised millist rate, which we would are not gonna recommend, they would pay two fifty six, two hundred and fifty six a year. [0:10:48, 0:10:50]: Is what they would pay for a house. [0:10:51, 0:10:54]: And the median houses in inside the city stubbridges right between [0:10:55, 0:11:02]: In the number between two hundred and seventy-five to three hundred. So that house assessed value would be at a hundred and ten. [0:11:03, 0:11:04]: All right. [0:11:04, 0:11:08]: Once you apply the millage rate to that, rollback would be [0:11:10, 0:11:17]: Uh three hundred and ninety-seven dollars a year in city property tax. At the three point seven, which is the current, it'll be four hundred and fourteen. [0:11:18, 0:11:22]: For house valued at four hundred thousand, cess value on that would be one hundred sixty. [0:11:23, 0:11:28]: Annual property tax rate of the rollback would be five seventy seven dollars a year. [0:11:28, 0:11:29]: At the current miller's rate. [0:11:31, 0:11:32]: First. [0:11:32, 0:11:52]: It would be six oh three um for a house of that that value a year. And so that and as we compare to some of our neighboring sisters, when we look at their tax rates, obviously everybody's looking at or has advertised an increase. Um so McDonough's at three point zero three three, Hampton is at four point five, uh Henry County I think it's at twelve. [0:11:52, 0:11:55]: twelve and they're talking about increasing theirs. [0:11:58, 0:12:02]: And this just gives you an example of typical house, those values. [0:12:02, 0:12:12]: And for the most part those values, when I look at them from last year to this year, roughly gone up about six thousand in some cases. In some cases it's gone up a little bit more. [0:12:12, 0:12:20]: Um but overall our digest is on up only four percent. So that house under the current and current rate, remember two hundred and twenty-six a year. [0:12:21, 0:12:22]: Eighteen dollars a month. [0:12:22, 0:12:27]: Um if you just apply one of the millis rate examples options we give, which is four point one five. [0:12:28, 0:12:37]: They would go to four hundred and two hundred and forty nine dollars versus two hundred and twenty-six dollars. A house valued at two hundred and thirty-four, and these are exact numbers for those houses. [0:12:38, 0:12:40]: Um their current would be three fifty seven a year. [0:12:41, 0:12:42]: Or twenty nine dollars a month. [0:12:42, 0:12:44]: At one of the options. [0:12:44, 0:12:48]: The middle option of four point one five, it would be three hundred and eighty eight. [0:12:48, 0:12:50]: per year or thirty two a month. [0:12:52, 0:12:55]: Another house valued at two hundred and eighty one six. [0:12:55, 0:13:00]: Would see uh Miller's rate at three point seven seven of two hundred nine dollars. [0:13:00, 0:13:03]: Um seventeen forty four a month. [0:13:03, 0:13:23]: And at the one point one five four point one five, four hundred and sixty-one. And the caveat, that's my old house. Um so the other house at three hundred and eighty one um would be five hundred and seventy-four seven fifty-five per year at three point seven seven or forty seven um [0:13:23, 0:13:25]: Yeah. [0:13:25, 0:13:26]: Um [0:13:26, 0:13:32]: And it the four point one five would be six hundred and thirty two a year or fifty two dollars a month. [0:13:32, 0:13:34]: Yes, sir. Mayor that that [0:13:35, 0:13:55]: Look at that figure for two eighty one. That seems uh dramatic difference between the two oh nine and four sixty seven. You only going up um to uh four fifteen. Looks like that might that figure might be incorrect. Yeah, hold on. I'll make sure. I might have done some [0:13:55, 0:13:56]: Crazy mass. [0:13:58, 0:14:02]: A higher price home you only went up three eighty one. [0:14:04, 0:14:18]: Time set by forty. Okay. Time set by point zero zero three seven. Yeah, that's five hundred and forty-seven and uh two hundred and eighty one. [0:14:19, 0:14:22]: Six, two eighty one, six. [0:14:23, 0:14:24]: Times forty percent. [0:14:26, 0:14:29]: Times point zero zero three seven seven. [0:14:30, 0:14:45]: Yep, oh I'm sorry, that number's incorrect. So that number would be four twenty four hundred and twenty four dollars. I'm sorry. So that'd be four hundred and twenty four dollars um for the house that I lead at two hundred and eighty one. What's what's the current rate at three point seven seven dollars? So one of those guys. [0:14:45, 0:15:02]: So that's what that's what the current rate is. So if you apply the miller's rate now at that at that house, that's what they will pay. It'd be four hundred and twenty four dollars and sixty five cents a year. Right. So the two oh nine was wrong. Okay. Yep. The the one for two for two eighty one is cor incorrect. The two oh nine is wrong. Yes. Okay. [0:15:02, 0:15:04]: My apologies. [0:15:06, 0:15:06]: Continue, please. [0:15:08, 0:15:22]: And this is not clear. Um so working with our staff over the last um month or so, including our last meeting today with the police department, we came up with our general fund um preliminary numbers at right around twenty nine point [0:15:23, 0:15:26]: five uh million to run the general fund. [0:15:27, 0:15:33]: Um, with our revenues, if you go to the rollback, that revenue would be two hundred and two twenty two million. [0:15:34, 0:15:46]: twenty two point one million, which is roughly about a three hundred excuse me, uh three hundred thousand dollar difference between where we would be, um at option number [0:15:46, 0:15:47]: Two [0:15:47, 0:16:07]: Um when you apply the millage rate at 3.77, that gives us roughly a break-even with a little bit overage, a little bit of break in break-even. Everything above that, obviously at the four four mils would give us an excess of four hundred thousand and a uh average uh [0:16:07, 0:16:27]: Miller's rate of 3.15 would be 724,000 above, and a millage rate at 4.25 would give us give us 915,000 above revenues to expenses. So with that, obviously the clear picture of breaking is break-even would be option number two, would be the remillage rate, which is key. [0:16:27, 0:16:44]: keeping the millage rate what it is right now. And that would be the staff recommendation based on what we've got to date. We don't anticipate anything going up. We do anticipate doing a little bit more of a cutting if we can. Um but for the most part, that's what it's gonna look like for us in running the budget. And so with that [0:16:44, 0:16:51]: We'll move forward, but that's gonna be our recommendation uh probably at our third meeting would be to keep the millers right while that what it is. [0:16:52, 0:16:53]: Okay. [0:16:53, 0:16:57]: So when you talk about who takes your dollar, so if you take a tax dollar [0:16:58, 0:17:03]: a dollar of your taxes and you had to divide it up against all the taxing entities that that are out there in the county. [0:17:04, 0:17:05]: Your school board. [0:17:05, 0:17:18]: Uh, their current twenty three point six mills, three of that being bonds that they float um for schools. So their millage rate is twenty plus the three for the bonds. They're right at fifty nine cents of your dollar goes to the school board. [0:17:19, 0:17:21]: Fifty nine cents out of every dollar you pay. [0:17:22, 0:17:22]: About [0:17:23, 0:17:28]: Twenty six cents out of every dollar you pay goes to Henry County. [0:17:29, 0:17:33]: Um at three point seven seven, you're looking at eleven cents. [0:17:33, 0:17:34]: On a dollar. [0:17:34, 0:17:38]: And right now most of us, whether we on city water. [0:17:38, 0:17:39]: Or on [0:17:40, 0:17:41]: Henry County Water Authority Water. [0:17:42, 0:17:45]: And less for those folks who live in certain parts of the county that's on Clayton County. [0:17:45, 0:17:49]: They won't see this, but I think this mill they do see it. This mill is raid. [0:17:50, 0:17:55]: is applied for Henry County Water Authority at two Mills, and it's been there for a number of years. [0:17:55, 0:18:04]: And my understanding that it's slated to go away in a few years, but it's still there. You pay that to the Water Authority, regardless of whether or not you live, utilize [0:18:04, 0:18:06]: If you utilize their water or not. [0:18:06, 0:18:10]: Every resident and if you're on Clayton County water and you live on [0:18:10, 0:18:14]: Valley Hill Road and you're in Cleeton County, you're still paying that two mils to Henry County. [0:18:15, 0:18:15]: Right. [0:18:16, 0:18:28]: Um, so that's pretty much who gets your money. Um when you talk about from a dollar standpoint in cents, who gets it? City around eleven cents, Water Authority about five cents off of that, Henry County about twenty six cents, and the school board fifty nine. [0:18:30, 0:18:32]: Uh moving forward. [0:18:32, 0:18:52]: Obviously, next step in the process is we will have two more millage rate meetings as required by law. Um council is expected to adopt the millage rate at our third meeting, regardless of what I mean what that millage rate may be. They're required to adopt it. Um and that could be anywhere from the rollback all the way up to 4.2, but the staff. [0:18:52, 0:19:00]: As obviously, as you can see from the slides. And we will make this slide available online after tonight's meeting, so you guys can go through it if you want to. [0:19:00, 0:19:03]: Um be available, so we're required to. [0:19:03, 0:19:16]: There's also um this will apply once adopted, the millage rate, the new millage rate, whether it stays the same or not, well you'll start to see that in your tax when you get your tax bill if you're on escrow. I mean b tax bill goes out in October or November. [0:19:17, 0:19:29]: August. So yeah. So some of us get ours in October, November, December. Some folks are who own their homes outright tend to pay a little payoff. Um but you'll see that process between October and December of this year. [0:19:29, 0:19:32]: There will be a b an initiative on the ballot. [0:19:32, 0:19:35]: Um for all Stockbridge residents. [0:19:35, 0:19:55]: And they will be whether or not you want to accept homestead exemption for your city taxes. As a homeowner, you already have exemptions. If you haven't applied, please do. Um, but you're allowed to exempt have exemptions from your um county taxes. It's a separate process um because we're accept a sep a separate taxing entity. [0:19:55, 0:20:05]: So you have to apply with us to get that exemption. So that exemption will be on the ballot. And as far as I know, in the state of Georgia, no homestead exemption ballot initiative has failed. [0:20:06, 0:20:26]: That's not to date. Um, and so that'll go and take into effect um starting 2025, you will get those that re exemption off your city property tax if you apply. And it's weighted for regular homeowners as well as for those homeowners that are 62 and above, as well as those homeowners who are on septic. [0:20:26, 0:20:27]: То [0:20:28, 0:20:29]: You will be able to get an exemption. [0:20:30, 0:20:31]: Um [0:20:31, 0:20:33]: So that application, um [0:20:35, 0:20:40]: Like I said, will be separate from when you apply for Henry County. You will have to apply for your homestead exemption here at City Hall. [0:20:41, 0:20:45]: Um we will be ready and available at the end of the year. [0:20:45, 0:20:54]: Once it's passed to go live with the application. So you can come to City Hall or staff will be able to email it. You can send it back to us and we will get those exemptions processed. [0:20:56, 0:21:16]: Okay, Ms. Garner, I appreciate the presentation. Um obviously uh last year was the first time uh that uh we had to set a millage like this to set a millage rate. So obviously this is a reoccurrent. Now that we're in this this is a reoccurrent effect that has ha has to happen every each and every year. We'll have to go through this whole process. It depends. Excuse me? It depends. [0:21:16, 0:21:25]: So if if if there is a significant increase in your digest, um, and kind of give you an example, so [0:21:25, 0:21:28]: We grew by four point four, Hampton grew by twelve. [0:21:29, 0:21:49]: Right, which is kind of crazy. Right. I don't know what's going on in Hampton, but that twelve percent increase in their digress. Um, if that meets if you know, as you work your budget, like I said, and you fac factor in those numbers, you might be able to go to the rollback. And if you go to the rollback, then there is no advertisement because you keep everything technically with [0:21:49, 0:21:54]: What you bring in is what you're gonna bring in the next year, it's considered even, so you don't have to go through this process at all. [0:21:55, 0:21:59]: All right. But for most communities if you have an increase in your digest or the miller's rate. [0:21:59, 0:22:04]: you're required to advertise for an increase if you're gonna hold on to the same elevator go above it. [0:22:04, 0:22:15]: Okay, you have we have a Henry County Task Commissioner represented here this evening. So I did not wanna know if you wanted to introduce her if she needed to come to the podium and make any comments at all, if it's necessary. [0:22:16, 0:22:28]: Mayor. Yeah, well stand by. If they have any questions, she's here to answer. All right, good deal. All right. Yes, yes, sir. If I may. Yes sir, go write it, please. Mrs. Alexander, you'll be next. [0:22:30, 0:22:34]: I want to read a statement into the record. [0:22:35, 0:22:38]: Based on a a notice. [0:22:39, 0:22:40]: To the Henry Harrell. [0:22:42, 0:22:45]: To the citizens of Stockbridge. [0:22:46, 0:22:49]: I councilman Alfonso Thomas [0:22:50, 0:23:00]: have not been involved in any meetings, discussions, or a city council consensus. [0:23:01, 0:23:07]: to tentatively adopt or approve a millage increase. [0:23:09, 0:23:17]: I only read this notice for the first time for an increase online at the Henry Hare a week or so ago. [0:23:19, 0:23:22]: I am not in favor of an increase. [0:23:23, 0:23:27]: I personally need a thorough review. [0:23:28, 0:23:29]: Of the city's budget. [0:23:30, 0:23:34]: complete with regards to every detail [0:23:34, 0:23:38]: and department concerns. Therefore, [0:23:39, 0:23:41]: I will not support [0:23:41, 0:23:51]: I'll vote for a millage increase until this budget review and process is completed. Thank you. [0:23:51, 0:24:02]: All right. Mrs. Alexander, go ahead, please. Yes, uh, thank you so much. Um, Mr. Gardner, you had indicated that the recommendation is going to be uh to leave the military unchanged. [0:24:04, 0:24:24]: Yes, sir. And that uh legally, um, so everybody understands last year uh the rate that we advertised was four point one two five, and we actually chose to set it at three point seven seven. And this uh in this year the rate advertised was four. [0:24:24, 0:24:32]: But again, we the recommendation is to opt for 3.77. Is that correct? [0:24:32, 0:24:33]: Yes, sir. [0:24:33, 0:24:53]: Now in the discussion and I think I made this in my motion when I made the motion for 3.77 was we knew at that time we were not gonna have uh any exemptions available during the first year or two. Is that correct? Yes, sir. So what I think I I did say during that time was [0:24:53, 0:25:13]: We're gonna set the rate at the lowest rate possible to finance the budget so that we could turn, in turn, basically give everybody the exemptions up front. Those that setting it at 3.77 instead of 4.125 finance the budget, but basically it it was the equivalent. [0:25:13, 0:25:33]: Of giving everybody the exemptions up front because we knew legally we were not going to be able to have those exemptions in the first two years. But as you indicated, we had legislation passed, and the homeowners that are here today will be able to vote yay or nay on a homestead exemption. [0:25:33, 0:25:45]: exemption going forward, is that correct? Yes, sir. Okay. Um and certainly uh we have a representative from the Henry County uh tax commissioner's office here, correct? [0:25:45, 0:25:47]: Yes, sir. Uh ma'am, would you come to the podium, please? [0:25:57, 0:26:17]: Thank you so much. Sure. And your name? Lynn Cardi, Deputy Tax Commissioner. Deputy Tax Commissioner, thank you for coming to here tonight. I think one of the things that's always very helpful to this total discussion is to go into an explanation of Henry County is one of the only counties, uh one of the [0:26:17, 0:26:37]: few counties in the state of Georgia that actually has a frozen exemption, which basically, if you bought your house in 2004 or 2007, whatever it is, your tax rate is based on if you have an exemption, will be at the year and frozen at that rate on a yearly basis. That has saved taxpayers [0:26:37, 0:26:57]: thousands of dollars here in Henry County, even though the rate has increased. Could you kind of explain that to uh the cons the the the public so they understand that there are some significant savings that have already been achieved through the fact that this frozen exemption, which I really didn't understand until previously, [0:26:57, 0:27:12]: that I'm paying the same rate as when I purchased my home in 2004 now. But a new homeowner that came in and they purchased my home would then be retro to the price that they purchased it at this year. [0:27:12, 0:27:26]: Correct. The frozen exemption uh went through legislation back in two thousand and four and it took place in two thousand and five. Um, if you at that point in time, if you owned your home at that point, you were frozen at the two thousand and four, like you had said. [0:27:26, 0:27:28]: Um anyone coming forward? [0:27:28, 0:27:34]: Um, it is frozen from the year prior. So if I was to purchase a new home in two thousand and twenty. [0:27:34, 0:27:38]: It's frozen at the r and pl applied for exemption for two thousand and twenty. [0:27:39, 0:27:42]: then the exemption is frozen based off the two thousand nineteen tax year. [0:27:44, 0:28:04]: Absolutely. That is something that some most folks don't know that the r millage rate hasn't been um has been at twelve point seven three three now for uh maybe seven or eight years I think on the county level and we just recently uh implemented the the city tax that we uh have here uh as the city. So there's been [0:28:04, 0:28:24]: Some significance in where we were. And as the city manager has indicated, some 60% of the overall tax digest goes to the school board. Is that correct? Or somewhere around there? And then Mr. Gardner indicated what 26% or so goes toward the county's tax. [0:28:23, 0:28:33]: Digest. It should be noted here today. I love seeing public participation. Thank you all for coming out. [0:28:33, 0:28:41]: But the school board represents 60% of your tax revenue. You know how many people showed up to their meeting last year? Three. I was one of them. [0:28:42, 0:28:45]: You know how many people showed up to the counties? [0:28:45, 0:28:46]: Very few. [0:28:46, 0:28:48]: This room is packed. [0:28:48, 0:28:49]: Right. [0:28:49, 0:29:09]: You should do the same thing for those meetings where 60% of your money is coming, and also where 26% of your money is coming, as opposed to where 11% is coming, and the recommendation is to leave the rate unchanged. But see what happens is through what we see on social media, through next door. [0:29:09, 0:29:20]: in these various channels, a lot of misinformation has been placed out there that this is where you ought to be when no one is talking about where 60% of your money is going. [0:29:22, 0:29:26]: Also, you should understand that the county budget was already passed. [0:29:28, 0:29:48]: The budget that was passed on their side is going to require a millage rate increase in order to pay for it. It's already been passed. So, in order to pay for the budget that they passed, requires a mileage rate increase. Now, what you should understand is that instead of you should be in this room, but you should also be in [0:29:48, 0:30:02]: those rooms where the majority of your money is coming to. And somebody needs to tell you that because we get the same result every year where everybody comes to this meeting and then the meeting where my school board text and I'm going to close this. [0:30:03, 0:30:04]: My total tax is [0:30:05, 0:30:07]: Fifty two hundred dollars this year. [0:30:07, 0:30:13]: I'm paying thirty four hundred dollars to the school board and I'm paying about six hundred to the city. [0:30:14, 0:30:34]: I went to that meeting where my thirty four hundred dollars was at and my twelve hundred dollars was at because I knew I was gonna be at this meeting and I voted for the lowest rate possible at 3.77 so that I could set this rate. Because I have to write a check too in order to pay this. But understand the facts. And when you're getting the facts, [0:30:34, 0:30:36]: I need this representation. [0:30:37, 0:30:45]: The county's having their meetings this month. Do you know when the county meetings are, ma'am, or d do you know? The county is having their meeting on the thirtieth at one o'clock. [0:30:45, 0:30:57]: Okay. So certainly we need to make sure that we have this type of representation and that room needs to be packed because there's literally and the school board is having theirs too right now, correct? This j in July? [0:30:58, 0:31:12]: Yes, sir. They they will actually vote for their millage rate on next Monday at four thirty. Next Monday at four thirty, where sixty percent of your money is going. You should be in that room also. So I'm gonna conclude my remarks. Thank you. [0:31:12, 0:31:14]: Anybody else in the council any comments at this point? [0:31:17, 0:31:18]: Anybody else to council? [0:31:18, 0:31:38]: All right. So this is a public uh public hearing. So ladies and gentlemen, you'll have an opportunity to to uh voice your opinion. And so uh right now the recommendation is three point seven seven to keep it as as it has been for the last year. Obviously we will not uh vote on that until the third uh hearing and that actually is set for the twenty [0:31:38, 0:31:41]: twenty second of July. But uh [0:31:41, 0:31:55]: It's a public hearing, so you get an opportunity to speak. So anybody that's that's that's say four, four to for us to keep the um let's l for to keep the three point seven seven, right? If your comments if you wanna make comments on that, you line up on this side. Anybody up from my far left? [0:31:55, 0:32:06]: If you want to make any comments for to keep it to keep it as is. If you it's on this far left side and leave free line up. Anybody in the middle, if you have any comments, I'm gonna we can line up on the left side of on my left side over here as well. [0:32:07, 0:32:08]: Anybody on the right? [0:32:09, 0:32:10]: In comments four. If you want [0:32:11, 0:32:26]: Yeah, yeah, for keeping the same. That's right. For keep it the same. I mean I just w just want to hear you out. I just uh first before you come, I just wanna make sure anybody wants to speak, they'll line up so we know how many people are coming and you speak. So you're right now I have only one gentleman who wants to speak for. [0:32:26, 0:32:26]: All right. [0:32:27, 0:32:38]: Uh do you want to speak come stand up please, ma'am. If you want uh don't come not just yet, sir. One second. I just wanna make sure'cause sometimes uh folks change their mind and halfway through this, uh I just wanna make sure I got folks up [0:32:38, 0:32:39]: That wanna speak. [0:32:39, 0:32:40]: All right. [0:32:40, 0:32:54]: So right now I have three folks. Okay. Now, what's gonna happen is you I want you to come to the podium, give your name and address, and you get your time. Well, we got a clock going, but um the ten minutes total, but we we'll see how long it takes and make your comments and we'll go from there. All right, sir, please. To the mic? [0:32:55, 0:32:57]: Ms. Four. Give your name and address, please. [0:32:58, 0:33:08]: Good evening everyone. Even my name is Juan Martin. Address is six two four Armitage Way. I'm in the North Bridge Crossing Subdivision. [0:33:08, 0:33:10]: Um as we know [0:33:11, 0:33:13]: Most of us if you look around the room [0:33:13, 0:33:15]: Many of us are [0:33:15, 0:33:19]: Сенірсин, мені в вас on fixed incomes. [0:33:20, 0:33:21]: Um [0:33:21, 0:33:24]: I do have a video that I wanted to play, but I won't [0:33:25, 0:33:36]: uh suffer you that unless you allow it. But it's just uh something about the tax increases are rampant over the country. There's one particular case of a guy in Chicago [0:33:37, 0:33:40]: Геда хом на фіфті сквар фіт. [0:33:42, 0:33:54]: His tax rate uh um um his evaluation of his home went from 180,000 to 1 million dollars. [0:33:55, 0:34:05]: I have the video right here. His tax rate would go from eighteen hundred dollars a year to over thirty thousand dollars a year. [0:34:05, 0:34:07]: Of course this was a mistake. [0:34:08, 0:34:08]: And [0:34:08, 0:34:11]: They are still aпіel, a pier, appeal. [0:34:11, 0:34:18]: But the appeal has gone on so long he's had to go and live with relatives. He can't make the payments. [0:34:19, 0:34:19]: Um [0:34:20, 0:34:33]: This is just ridiculous. Well appreciate appreciate the explanation, sir. But obviously you said this isn't Chicago and you had a test. But one thing I have noticed and one thing I do believe a lot of times when [0:34:34, 0:34:36]: uh governments see [0:34:37, 0:34:40]: Certain practices successful in one part of the country. [0:34:41, 0:34:44]: Somehow it gravitates to other parts of the country. [0:34:44, 0:34:48]: They could see, you know, that's just been my observation. [0:34:49, 0:34:52]: But I just want to say that uh it's just it [0:34:53, 0:34:55]: We people cannot afford it. [0:34:55, 0:34:59]: Okay, appreciate you. Appreciate your comments. Thank you. Next person please. [0:35:00, 0:35:06]: All right folks, calm please calm down. Name and address, please. [0:35:06, 0:35:11]: Uh good evening and thank you for this opportunity to speak. My name is Eugenia Brown. [0:35:11, 0:35:16]: One six eight Addy Lane, North Bridge Crossing Subdivision. Okay. [0:35:16, 0:35:36]: Um, I just wanted to share some of my thoughts and concerns regarding not just the millage rate, but also the appraisals of the properties. Um, as everyone knows, a lot of these um home values are um overinflated, and that's [0:35:36, 0:35:37]: Resulting from [0:35:37, 0:35:53]: post-pandemic where we had people moving, relocating because they could work remote, East Coast folks, West Coast Coast folks coming in and just buying up properties, offering up to 40 grand over asking. [0:35:54, 0:35:59]: So between that happening with everyone wanting to spread out as a result of covet. [0:36:00, 0:36:06]: Um then we have these hedge fund backed investment companies, which as everyone knows. [0:36:07, 0:36:08]: They've gotten [0:36:08, 0:36:10]: Твозенс о проперті з не метро. [0:36:11, 0:36:12]: Atlanta area. [0:36:13, 0:36:18]: They've purchased these properties from people wanting to get out, seeing an opportunity to make some good money. [0:36:19, 0:36:23]: Де пайда ладома нефорідовірні пропадіс анден ескалати. [0:36:23, 0:36:25]: the value and the price. [0:36:26, 0:36:32]: As a result, in my opinion, in my thoughts, is the appraisals appraisals. [0:36:33, 0:36:34]: Or [0:36:34, 0:36:37]: based on some very inflated home values. [0:36:38, 0:36:44]: Now I think that has to be taken into consideration as well with the millage rates. [0:36:44, 0:36:46]: As the gentleman stated [0:36:47, 0:36:51]: There's lots of retirees. I'm not there yet, hopefully in the next year and a half. [0:36:52, 0:36:53]: on fixed incomes. [0:36:54, 0:36:58]: Ви в ган летс фронтом а моргич холдers. [0:36:58, 0:37:01]: Your t twenty two hundred thousand dollars. [0:37:01, 0:37:05]: Тwеті2 шорни. [0:37:06, 0:37:07]: taxes and insurances. [0:37:08, 0:37:08]: Yeah. [0:37:09, 0:37:12]: Моргes are not going to be tenable at this rate. [0:37:12, 0:37:14]: Folks on fixed incomes, [0:37:14, 0:37:15]: You can't go to [0:37:16, 0:37:19]: Соціаль секерісай, а не мормані. Ми такси в гонку. [0:37:20, 0:37:26]: Those of us still working can't go to our employers say, Hey, hey, I got a big tax increase coming. I need some more money. [0:37:27, 0:37:30]: So we're gonna run into a potential [0:37:30, 0:37:30]: Bubble. [0:37:31, 0:37:31]: Where [0:37:32, 0:37:35]: Folks are just gonna have to sell because they can't afford to stay in their homes. [0:37:36, 0:37:37]: And then when that happens [0:37:38, 0:37:39]: We already know. [0:37:39, 0:37:41]: We have the investors will come in. [0:37:41, 0:37:42]: Snatch up the properties. [0:37:43, 0:37:44]: And turn them into [0:37:45, 0:37:48]: Very expensive rentals, which is happening. [0:37:49, 0:37:52]: And then those that they do sell again overpriced. [0:37:53, 0:37:56]: The benefit to the county in that respect is. [0:37:56, 0:38:04]: They can't file homestead exemption, and you get more tax dollars from the investors. So I would just like to say. [0:38:05, 0:38:18]: There's more to it than just the millage rate, there's actually the home values and the comps that have been used with these values that we're now having to pay the escalated taxes on. [0:38:18, 0:38:23]: Uh thank you for your comment. Thank you for your time. No, no problem. Thank you. Okay. [0:38:27, 0:38:47]: Uh all right folks. You're I read the I read the reading about the public hearing, but you're not supposed to be clapping in this nature, but go ahead. Please, your name and address, please. Uh good afternoon. My name is Laretha Martin. My husband just spoke, so he said some things that already that would that that uh that I feel and uh and and I'll and [0:38:47, 0:38:53]: Mm, the lady that just got up to speak, she says some of the things, but I'm speaking as a senior citizen. [0:38:54, 0:39:01]: I am a senior citizen and everything is going up. When I moved here [0:39:01, 0:39:11]: My water bill was lower. My double water bill has almost tripled since I moved since since 2019. [0:39:12, 0:39:32]: Everything is going up. And I noticed that the next meeting is at ten o'clock in the morning. Most people that working people they can't attend the meet this this meeting to oppose or agree. And social security, so she just spoke about social security. Social security [0:39:32, 0:39:48]: they raise your social security just to get some of the money back. So as senior citizens, we give and we have given as seem like it's taken back. And that's what I w all that's all I have to say. I just do not agree with the increase. [0:39:49, 0:40:06]: At all. Thank you. Thank you, ma'am. And uh just one let me make you note that we're recommendation is the three point seven seven, which is just the same. There's no increase thus far. Um and we haven't agreed to that, but uh uh we'll make a final decision on july twenty second. Yes ma'am, please. You next name and address, please. [0:40:09, 0:40:16]: My name is Karen Charmain. I live at 110 Creek Circle, Stockbridge, Georgia. [0:40:17, 0:40:23]: I am a citizen of Stockbridge, have lived in this community. You could throw a rock and hit my house from here. [0:40:24, 0:40:30]: I have lived here. I have voted probably for every one of you at one time or another. [0:40:31, 0:40:38]: I want to thank you, Mayor, Council members, and citizens of Stockbridge that are here tonight. [0:40:39, 0:40:47]: I disagree with the millage rate. You can say that it's not anything to do with taxes, but it definitely equates to a tax increase. [0:40:48, 0:40:49]: Now. [0:40:50, 0:40:55]: Further, I think you all should tighten your belt and sharpen your pencils. [0:40:57, 0:41:06]: Senior citizens are a big concern. I'm not gonna say I'm old, but I'm older. And at least two people on this council. [0:41:06, 0:41:08]: Or senior citizens. [0:41:08, 0:41:10]: And those of us that work [0:41:11, 0:41:12]: Or don't work. [0:41:12, 0:41:32]: Ten o'clock in the morning is not a great time for the meetings. And I just have understood from Miss Holliday that those are set by the county. And yes, ma'am, the county needs to change their time too. Because one o'clock in the afternoon. Excuse me, ma'am. She can hear you. Dress me. One one o'clock in the afternoon is two [0:41:32, 0:41:41]: Is is too is is too inconvenient for most people. So I'm asking to strongly consider changing those times. [0:41:43, 0:41:53]: This is not good. We have never had taxes in Stockbridge until last year, and there is frivolous spending in this city. [0:41:54, 0:42:06]: It needs to be checked and put in check. And I remind you respectfully right now, the City of Stockbridge organizational chart says that the city citizens [0:42:06, 0:42:13]: are at the top of that. We voted you in to represent our concerns. [0:42:14, 0:42:20]: We did. So what that really means is you work for us, not the other way around. [0:42:21, 0:42:22]: Thank you for your comments. [0:42:24, 0:42:28]: All right, folks. Next next individual, please. Name and address. [0:42:36, 0:42:38]: In an address, please. [0:42:40, 0:42:42]: Hello everybody. [0:42:42, 0:42:45]: How you doing? My name is Claire Kellum. [0:42:46, 0:42:50]: I live at two hundred forty two Hunting Court in Jonesboro. [0:42:50, 0:42:52]: Spiver Ridge Sub Division. [0:42:53, 0:42:54]: Aye. [0:42:55, 0:42:58]: Like the most of the people, I am a citizen. [0:42:59, 0:43:06]: Can we a senior citizen. Council we're gonna stand this time, is that correct? [0:43:07, 0:43:08]: Okay. All right. Please stand the time. [0:43:09, 0:43:12]: I don't work. I'm almost eighty years old. [0:43:13, 0:43:23]: I'm a single woman. My taxes went up last year, four hundred and some dollars. It went up. And now I'm talking about going up again this year. [0:43:25, 0:43:32]: I'm against that because where are we supposed to get money from when we only get a little money every month? [0:43:34, 0:43:37]: Where are we supposed to get money to pay all of this taxes that? [0:43:38, 0:43:38]: You know. [0:43:39, 0:43:45]: Keep the property tax from I mean the houses from going up. We're not selling, we just living there. [0:43:45, 0:43:47]: We're not getting anything out of it. [0:43:48, 0:43:49]: We just live there. [0:43:50, 0:43:53]: So stop raising the house values up. [0:43:54, 0:43:58]: Talk my house is worth this much and that much. It ain't worth nothing'cause we ain't getting nothing. [0:43:59, 0:44:04]: So I'm not for this hier increase because I'm a single woman. [0:44:04, 0:44:11]: And I have a fixed income and I'm almost eighty years old in case anybody [0:44:12, 0:44:13]: Won't and no. [0:44:15, 0:44:16]: By myself. [0:44:18, 0:44:20]: You understand with a fixed income. [0:44:22, 0:44:23]: And that's the truth. [0:44:24, 0:44:26]: Okay, thank you for your comments. [0:44:28, 0:44:48]: All right, all right, all right, ladies and gentlemen. Now let me let originally want to open this up, I said the four comments for. I didn't say comments against, I said comments for. That's what we're supposed to do. Comments for. But the real I will open it up for comments against if there's still someone that wants to uh have any uh negative comments against this uh of the recommendation three point seven seven, which is the current rate that [0:44:48, 0:45:03]: at this point. And once this if there's no one up for besides this lady here, then I'm gonna go through a list of things. I'm gonna get a couple folks up here and we'll see what we can do to answer some questions and then I'll open it up once again for comments that are that are actually uh against this, if there are any. Ma'am, please. [0:45:05, 0:45:06]: Name and address, please. [0:45:08, 0:45:11]: Yes, Sharon Nelson, one seven six, Spivey Ridge Circle. [0:45:13, 0:45:14]: Wait, please. [0:45:14, 0:45:27]: And uh I am skeptical of the tax increase uh because of how the hold annexation worked. When we were annexed into um Stockbridge, um [0:45:27, 0:45:42]: We received that city's tax, that extra city stockbridge tax, and there was no way to get an exemption for that tax. Um and I as it was explained for the t first two years, there's no way that you could um [0:45:43, 0:45:49]: apply for any kind of exemption, which was unfair and I don't think it was really explained in that manner. [0:45:50, 0:46:10]: Um I think that I know this was uh something that was passed, that annexation was passed, and uh but I don't think that these um intricate details and these nuances were explained because my understanding is that the city of Stockbridge already has a process for exemption. [0:46:09, 0:46:29]: Then immediately you would be able to apply for those exemptions. Okay, I'll go ahead and vote for this annexation, but like I applied for exemption through Henry County, at the same time I should be able to apply for exemption through Stockbridge County. But that was not the case. And as I understand [0:46:29, 0:46:45]: this evening that there is an initiative to whether you even want to accept exemption. Well, like most people say we're senior citizens, of course we want the exemption. So why should that be an initiative in a boat and something else that [0:46:46, 0:47:06]: People may not really fully understand, and it doesn't pass, and that small that portion for the city of Stockbridge that you may not even be able to apply for exemption. So these things that occurred as of this annexation and not being explained, senior citizens. [0:47:06, 0:47:15]: live on these exemptions. And when you get a tax bill that says City of Stockbridge and there's an extra charge there, you haven't put that in your budget. [0:47:15, 0:47:21]: for this extra charge. You didn't even really understand that you couldn't even file for exemption for that. [0:47:21, 0:47:30]: And that was an increase, and so to me that was that was misleading or not really explained in a way where everybody understood. [0:47:30, 0:47:50]: So that's why I'm a little skeptical of the tax increase of how this whole annexation worked and how it wasn't explained. And for two years people had to try to come up with money for this city of Stockbridge tax that was added on top of the county um tax. Thank you. Thank you. Okay. Uh Mr. Gardner. [0:47:50, 0:48:10]: I need you back to the podium and come back to the podium, Mr. Gardner. Okay, and so and uh I f I'm sorry, I forgot her name. Yep, yeah, I need you to come back to the podium, please. And f I will tell you folks for transparency sake, uh is already done at least the two of us are senior citizens. I'm one of those. I'm a senior citizen, I can get my social security now. [0:48:10, 0:48:30]: So I'm happy about that as well. And uh I put him on Front Street, but the senior individual council is Mr. Thomas. He's a little older than I am. So you're right. There's two of us that are senior citizens. So I understand that point in this aspect, but I also happen to have been blessed enough to have a retirement and from the military. So yeah, anyway. [0:48:30, 0:48:50]: took a couple notes of some things. I need for you some clarification on this part. Uh first of all, uh appraisals. I don't think we have much to do with appraisals all at the city level. Any type of appraisals are all. We don't control that. No sir. Can you expand on that at all? Yes, sir. So all properties in Henry County and most counties are conducted by the county appraiser. [0:48:50, 0:48:59]: Um that individual is charged with appraising all real property in the county, whether you're city or unincorporated county, and based on [0:49:00, 0:49:05]: Uh a number of factors to include sale prices and some other things that happen within the area. [0:49:05, 0:49:07]: They are able to determine [0:49:07, 0:49:14]: um property values based on that and b and then from that they create the digest that covers all properties. [0:49:14, 0:49:24]: and you apply the millage rate the forty percent rule and in the millage rate to that. But no the cities have no control over the tax appraiser. That is a separate individual of the county. [0:49:24, 0:49:30]: Um that does that job on behalf of all of the cities in Henry County as well as unincorporated Henry County government. [0:49:31, 0:49:51]: Okay. These uh hedge c companies that buy out these homes to rental, I mean we we like we're not f we don't we particularly care for them to to do that at all. But it's not a whole lot we can do with that. Let's do legislators through our our through our state reps or state senators maybe to get some legislation at the at the Capitol in reference to that and even dealing with mortgage rates. Uh we the city's [0:49:50, 0:50:08]: don't have much to do with the mortgage rates that I recall. No. Uh at all. I don't know if if you can expound on that at all. I just don't think we have any we have no says over that. Those are those are banks and uh banks are the controlling all that, I would imagine. So no. So companies, investment groups, whether it be [0:50:08, 0:50:13]: You know, Stockbridge City Council as an investment group decide to pool their money and buy property. [0:50:13, 0:50:17]: Obviously that's the American way and unfortunate some of it does have [0:50:17, 0:50:19]: negative consequences when companies [0:50:20, 0:50:40]: Major companies, major hedge funds with long dollars in the billions are able to buy real estate and then turn those real estate into an investment vehicle rather than a vehicle for folks like us to want to buy a home and become a homeowner. And in actual fact, they actually work to compete against homeowners. [0:50:40, 0:50:55]: is in the market when butchers and homes, which is a bad scenario because it does drive up prices. And if those prices in that area in a specific area continue to grow, that affects to some degree the values in that area, which precipitates the increase in the digest to some degree. [0:50:55, 0:50:56]: Um [0:50:56, 0:51:03]: Thank you so much. So far, you know, we haven't been hit greatly by that in the city of Stockbridge, however. [0:51:03, 0:51:07]: I will tell you that, you know, that ship has sailed it just hadn't reached it yet. [0:51:08, 0:51:14]: Um, in a major way. I mean, we do have one community that's just outside the city that's one hundred percent rental. [0:51:14, 0:51:16]: Um single family detached homes. [0:51:17, 0:51:19]: Uh that are all rental units. [0:51:19, 0:51:20]: Um [0:51:20, 0:51:24]: But it's it's hard for us to control that. That's something that obviously [0:51:24, 0:51:25]: Um [0:51:25, 0:51:45]: We have to work with our state legislators and recognize too that our state legislators did pass law. So under Georgia, we are a political subdivision of the state. So we derive all our powers to operate government from the state legislature. And some of you guys have lived in other states know this. [0:51:45, 0:51:46]: Some states have home rule. [0:51:47, 0:51:53]: Well, we could create our own laws to govern how we operate, but we're not we're not one of those states. Um [0:51:54, 0:52:14]: As it relates to the initiative, the only way to get relief in property tax is for the state to grant us the right to have a ballot initiative for the voters to vote on. Um, we are very much driven by those that type of procedure, but it is governed by state law. We have no control over that. The city just can't arbitrarily say we want own city. [0:52:14, 0:52:15]: And do it. [0:52:16, 0:52:17]: That would be in violation of the law. [0:52:18, 0:52:34]: Um, so we're required to follow those laws, which means we the the citiz the res the elected officials um sent a resolution to our state representatives. Those state representatives put a bill on the floor, that bill passes to allow for residents in the city [0:52:34, 0:52:36]: To have a homestead exemption. [0:52:36, 0:52:38]: If then you go and vote. [0:52:38, 0:52:42]: Um and vote yes, which I said it hasn't been one that's been denied. [0:52:43, 0:53:00]: So you vote yes and then that homestead exemption kicks in um in that following year. And so that's what we did. So we've had one year without and then from hopefully this year we'll have um well last year and this year, um two years, and then next year folks if approved, we'll be able to get homestead exemption relief. [0:53:01, 0:53:21]: Uh I think I answered all your questions. All right. Um so you explained the homestead exemption, so otherwise it's up to the vote. It's a powerful thing. And they must vote for that homestead exemption come uh November 5th. Uh Mayor Ford. Yes uh stem yes, sir. Um Mr. Garner is standing, uh in one of the statements [0:53:21, 0:53:27]: Um one of the citizens mentioned since the annexation [0:53:27, 0:53:30]: Ісса Дубок, а ми но. [0:53:30, 0:53:33]: The tax that you were paying to the county and then come to the city. [0:53:33, 0:53:53]: Can you can you dispel that notion that it's not a double tax? Yes, sir. So whether you were in at the time, twenty let's say it's twenty twenty-two flat number, whether you were in the city or the county, you paid um a property tax millage to Henry County for police service. [0:53:53, 0:53:56]: That was one point zero nine. [0:53:56, 0:54:04]: uh mills in the police district. So they have a police district, they have a fire district, there's a code enforcement millage. Um [0:54:04, 0:54:09]: when you came into the city, the city d pretty much took that millage that was going to the county. [0:54:10, 0:54:30]: into the city um and adjusted by another one point I think it's one point one point eight six six is what got us to one point to the three point seven seven so originally every resident was paying that one point one point nine oh four mils to Henry County for police that [0:54:29, 0:54:40]: That came into the city and so the only addition you paid was to one point eight six six that covered everything else. So it's not a little bit of a double taxation. [0:54:41, 0:55:01]: All right. Um and the w I think this clarification in reference to our next two uh hearings on this during the morning hours and these were uh obviously what I was understand is you were set by the county on these particular time frames, is is is I mean the task commissioner, obviously you all set those times, is that correct? Yes, I [0:55:01, 0:55:21]: Okay, because Mayor. Yes, yes, Mayor. It was a collaboration. What it is is the county has to be present at each one of these village rates for all of the cities in the county. And we had to coordinate schedules where they could be here and our council could be here. And um that's kind of how it was. They had already set [0:55:21, 0:55:29]: that means for the other cities and we had to fit fill in and get in basically where we could. [0:55:29, 0:55:49]: Okay. Thank you. Thank you for that. And of course once again the recommendation from the staff right now is three point seven seven, which is the same as it was last year. Not to change it, not to rise it or slower it. It stays stay steady. And that will be voted on on the m uh January excuse me, July twenty second. So it's not a it's not an increase. The recommendation is not an increase. [0:55:49, 0:56:09]: Increase is a stay hold stay hold, stay on that pace uh uh percentage. Uh-da-da-da-da. Let's see here. Obviously, uh senior citizens, yes. Uh a lot of us are seniors. I've already acknowledged myself along with Mr. Thomas, are seniors ourselves in this aspect. Uh so and home prices and [0:56:08, 0:56:23]: I guess the sense of the rise of home prices. I guess uh y you can consider that good or bad, I can depend on who you are, I suppose. But Yes, sir. It it is good and bad. So for all of us as homeowners, that's our typically that's our number one asset. [0:56:23, 0:56:32]: Right, that if push come to shove, even though it's not liquid, but it's our it's our number one asset, our most expensive asset. Um [0:56:32, 0:56:35]: So I will use myself as an example. [0:56:35, 0:56:37]: Uh I bought my house in two thousand. [0:56:38, 0:56:40]: I paid a hundred and thirty six thousand for it. [0:56:40, 0:56:43]: And in twenty ten it was worth thirty two thousand dollars. [0:56:44, 0:56:50]: I couldn't get a refinance on my house because my house I was upside down under water. [0:56:50, 0:56:56]: With the recession. So my number one asset was now my number one liability, and I couldn't get rid of it. [0:56:56, 0:57:04]: If I wanted to, I would still be held to that mortgage. Even though I would have sold my house to an investor for thirty-four thousand dollars, I still had to make up the difference. [0:57:05, 0:57:11]: Um, so your house is your number one asset and obviously any asset you have, you want to see it grow. [0:57:11, 0:57:15]: But the other side of that is as your value as that value grow, [0:57:15, 0:57:18]: Obviously you pay taxes in this country and [0:57:18, 0:57:22]: that has a negative impact because it increases that that um [0:57:23, 0:57:25]: That the amount that you pay on that asset. [0:57:25, 0:57:30]: But no, I think for most of us we want to be able hopefully to retire from our three bedroom house and [0:57:31, 0:57:32]: Walk out with [0:57:32, 0:57:34]: A million dollars from a house we paid. [0:57:34, 0:57:37]: A hundred thousand foil twenty, fifty years ago. [0:57:37, 0:57:40]: Right, and that's what you typically see from the folks who move here from New York. [0:57:41, 0:57:45]: They bought their homes in the seventy and now able to sell those homes that they purchased for under a hundred. [0:57:45, 0:57:48]: For over a million, and they move down here and buy a house outright. [0:57:49, 0:57:58]: Right? Because they sat in their homes for thirty years and allowed for their value to increase over that time, that asset paid off for them. And that's what most of us would hope that it would do. [0:57:59, 0:58:19]: Um but once again it has a negative impact because as that house value, obviously the taxes applied to it makes you have to pay more. So it's kind of a dumb. I took another note here. Water bills, water bills rising, I guess and uh some of us have Henry County water, others have so i if can you further explain? So yeah, so Henry County sent a notice I think to every [0:58:19, 0:58:23]: Everybody letting them know that they were going up on their rates late last week. Um [0:58:25, 0:58:33]: I'm sorry, ma'am. Please. So Henry Henry County and No Center noticed that they were increasing their water rates and obviously [0:58:34, 0:58:54]: I hate to speak for them and uh and I probably won't, but obviously to process water is not where you just grab the water from the from a lake or stream and just put it there. There's a process to treat it, that process costs to treat. And as I think the resident said, everything is going up. And so to buy chemicals to treat, the process [0:58:54, 0:59:14]: To treat, we are seeing it across the board. And I assume that's what's particular precipitating that increase on the water rate side. It's because the cost of chemicals and the cost of to keep that process going is also everyone's bearing that that cost, regardless. [0:59:14, 0:59:21]: I I paid 89 cents for a cotton of eggs. That same cotton of eggs is almost$3. [0:59:22, 0:59:25]: All right. What changed? Chicken's still the same. [0:59:26, 0:59:30]: But that ain't that's not where the cost came in. They're factoring in transportation. [0:59:30, 0:59:38]: Right. Um they're factoring in some other things and that's what they're basing that cost to go from the eighty nine cents to three dollars and ten cents for the same twelve eggs. [0:59:38, 0:59:58]: That's not a discussion I guess uh folks the citizens need to have with the water authority themselves. Is that uh is that right? Say again? To have have some discussion with the water authority or or or call and rep on the bill, uh just call and talk to them further about to get explanation about that. Yeah. You you can call and question your bill, um just to make sure and they know [0:59:58, 1:00:18]: So that Henry County, if you're on Henry County water, and for us, you're on what they call AMI meters. So they're able to read your meter from where they are on Highway 20. They don't have to come to your house to read your meter. Okay. And in some cases, they can see anomalies in your usage. And I don't know for everyone who set it up, but you can ask their [1:00:18, 1:00:32]: call you or they'll send you a note or notice letting you know that your water usage is above or above normal and that precipitates you to go and look. So I've had the same issue. Um my son toilet broke when he was here for Christmas. He left. [1:00:33, 1:00:34]: And all of a sudden [1:00:34, 1:00:41]: I got a notification from Henry County saying my water use had gone above normal. Walked around, went up there, and sure enough, it was just [1:00:42, 1:00:43]: Turnin'. [1:00:43, 1:00:49]: Um so I had to go fix it. They will give you relief if you do have a leak. Make sure that you keep your receipt. [1:00:50, 1:00:52]: Keep your receipt and give it back to them and they will [1:00:53, 1:01:13]: credit you back um what you paid what you paid to get that leak fixed. So that's something that they can do. And they could also come out and check your meter. If you think it might be off, they will check your meters for you as well. All right. Just want to make sure here I I opened it up for four. You all can have your seat for right now if you don't mind. I went for so I actually I want to open up for anybody that gets the recommendation. [1:01:13, 1:01:25]: 3.77. Anybody's against that? All right. Anybody on my left side? Anybody on my left side is against that. They will still want to speak against the 3.77, which is a recommendation. Anybody in the middle? [1:01:26, 1:01:27]: Anybody far right? [1:01:28, 1:01:30]: That's against it. Do you want to speak, ma'am? [1:01:31, 1:01:34]: Come on up, please. Anybody else? All right, please, your name and address please. [1:01:39, 1:01:59]: Uh my name is uh Jocelyn Williams, live at 190 Banks Drive, Strutbridge, Georgia. Wanted to uh thank the council. My um comment for against is just um to thank the council, understand this is the annexation for me, and I was always in Henry County as a senior citizen trying to gather every [1:01:59, 1:02:19]: Every year my November um payments for my home. I'll just need the name of representatives that can work with me and help me on um when now that I'm in Henry County and Stockbridge, there is a requirement that I have to have um trash sanitation. So [1:02:18, 1:02:38]: So I already had a person I was using, so I'll have to cut him off on the 31st because I have to put inside of my um property tax mixed with Henry County, and that's what's making everything grow up go up. So I'm so grateful that it's staying at 377. I just want it [1:02:38, 1:02:58]: To put an opposition on record that when things go up, I just once again for me, so that I can explain to my family and the people in my community that we have to know that things are going to increase, but there are ways that we can work together. There are services, there are programs. [1:02:58, 1:03:18]: Programs that we can use as a teacher. I can teach people how to do that. But once again, my opposition is to everything is now jumbled together. Henry County from the annexation. I now have to get ready for Stockbridge. The police get ready that things have changed. [1:03:18, 1:03:38]: Over. So I would just like to get the name. I'm going to write it down and someone can work with me with my property tax. Ms. Williams, this is what it'll be from Henry County. Now Stockbridge will add this and they will add that. [1:03:38, 1:03:48]: follow the law and I thank you so much. [1:03:49, 1:03:50]: Mr. Gardner? [1:03:50, 1:04:10]: Thank you. Thank you very much. Appreciate it. Okay. On that note then I see no other comments. So I will close the uh public hearing. All right. And we'll go through this process again with the council. You're more than welcome. This open meeting, uh, public hearing on the uh n twenty the nineteenth, which is this Friday and the twenty-second, both at ten o'clock [1:04:10, 1:04:15]: in the morning morning welcome come back if you like. On that note, I'll close the public hearing. [1:04:15, 1:04:19]: And also, um, on that note, I will ask for a motion to adjourn. [1:04:20, 1:04:21]: Is there a second? [1:04:22, 1:04:26]: Mr Mr. Berry second there. All uh all in favor, please indicate. [1:04:27, 1:04:27]: All right. [1:04:27, 1:04:29]: Okay, fantastic. We have now adjourned. [1:04:30, 1:04:31]: Thank you, ladies and God bless you all.
  • 2024-07-15 · City Council · Transcript · Special Called Meeting

    2024-07-15 · City Council · Transcript · source: 10yr-transcripts · sha256 43e0d9c1 · pages – · method: official

    Full text — searchable
    --- title: Special Called Meeting date: 2024-07-15 source: 2024-07-15_Special_Called_Meeting.wav --- [0:00:47, 0:01:00]: Alright ladies and gentlemen, I'd like to open up our special call meeting um dealing with SPLOS, SPLOSS 5 project list. It is uh Monday, July 15th, and I have [0:01:01, 0:01:02]: Five O seven. [0:01:06, 0:01:07]: On that note uh [0:01:08, 0:01:10]: Could we please stand for the invocation? [0:01:12, 0:01:32]: And I'll give this this evening. Lord, thank you for bringing us once again and continue to discuss the business of our city, continue to discuss the splot five, excuse me, splot six projects, things of our future, to help move our city forward. Be with us always that we make good logical decisions and with your spirit in your name, Lord. Help us always to do make the right decisions. Thank you. [0:01:32, 0:01:48]: Thank you and God bless us all. Amen. All right, uh say pledge allegiance. Pledge allegiance to flag the United States of America and to a new Republic for which it stands, one nation, under God, indivisible, liberty and justice for all. Okay. [0:01:49, 0:01:51]: Madam Clerk, roll call, please. [0:01:53, 0:01:55]: Yes, Mayor. Good evening, everyone. [0:01:56, 0:02:05]: Evening. Mayor Ford. Present. Mayor Pro Timberry. Present. Councilman Alexander. Present. Councilwoman Barber. Present. Councilwoman Gantt. [0:02:06, 0:02:10]: Let the record replay, Councilwoman Gantt is not in attendance. Councilman Thomas. [0:02:10, 0:02:25]: Mayor Ford, you have a quorum. Thank you, Madam Clerk. Uh Council, I need a uh motion to adopt the agenda, please. Mayor. Yes sir. Before we get started, uh we have this tragic incident that took place over the weekend when we had people [0:02:26, 0:02:46]: We we had the tra I'm sorry, we had this tragic incident that takes place over the weekend where people lost their life out exercising their right um uh during uh at in um it was it's just really sad situation. If we might be able to take a moment just to recognize them, that would be great. I I I'm sorry I have to admit, uh shame on me. [0:02:45, 0:02:57]: See the shooting that took place with the president and the person that lost the president. Okay, that's what you're referring to. All right. So would you want a moment of silence that you could please? Okay, we'd have a moment of silence at this point. Thank you. [0:03:05, 0:03:15]: All right, thank you, ladies and gentlemen. And uh there's no need to have violence like that in this country. No, sir. Okay, all right. So on that note uh need a motion to top the agenda, please. [0:03:16, 0:03:21]: Oh so m mister Mr. Mary, is there a second uh Miss Marby second that? [0:03:22, 0:03:25]: Ms. Barber, you second that? Thank you very much. All in favor, please indicate. [0:03:26, 0:03:33]: All right, synamic decision. All right. On that note, uh we got new business, PLOS six project list presented by Mr. Gardner. [0:03:34, 0:03:35]: Please, sir. [0:03:35, 0:03:42]: Good afternoon, Mayor and Council. Uh tonight we're here to discuss uh uh Is the mic on, sir? Yes it is. I'm sorry. [0:03:45, 0:04:05]: How's that? Yeah, that's to be better. Thank you. Excellent. All right. So tonight we're here to discuss the SPLUS and SPLUS SPLUS six specifically uh program. Um over the last few months the SPLUS committee has been meeting uh around Henry County. We had a meeting here back in May uh to go over projects that were a priority. [0:04:05, 0:04:17]: to the city as well as joint potential joint projects. Uh and about two weeks two weeks ago the city, the county had another meeting at which they laid out the options. [0:04:17, 0:04:20]: uh that was before us as it relates to [0:04:20, 0:04:40]: how the splus would be distributed and the options uh out there that they were presenting to the cities. Uh it is in obviously in everybody's best interest that we get a six-year spLUS. The current SPLU that we operate under will end. And that SPLOS obviously was a five year spLUS because we couldn't come to an agreement some years ago. [0:04:40, 0:05:00]: So tonight I really just want to talk a lot about the the options that are available to us, um, the use of the 2020 census versus the 2023 numbers. Um, and then see obviously there's gonna have to be another joint meeting between the cities to finalize which of these options did we all could agree on to present. [0:05:00, 0:05:03]: and to Henry County, uh when we have the next joint meeting. [0:05:04, 0:05:05]: So [0:05:05, 0:05:07]: The county pretty much laid out [0:05:07, 0:05:24]: Uh let me do this. Let's go back to our list. As recall we revised the list. Um that number has ever been changing until we finally got a numbered narrowed down and it's just a little bit below what we have. Um but we went with the sixty million that would go to the city over the six year period. [0:05:24, 0:05:44]: And we allotted um fundings for those. So it was about thirteen million. And the the areas in red are where we kinda made the adjustments for the additional back in February, I think we were looking at forty-four and we found out that the number was undisflated and we wanted to recognize the increase in how we would w put those increase. So the numbers in red [0:05:44, 0:05:50]: are the adjusted numbers or added numbers that we put in um to the program. [0:05:51, 0:06:11]: And some of those projects we hadn't discussed earlier, but we found out later, like the wayfinding, that we can you obviously pay for that and get that project done next year, depending on how we uh address the options. Um but our total being right around sixty point six million. And this current year's PLUS and T S Plus are actually outperforming the perf [0:06:11, 0:06:18]: what the original estimates was for those. So all things being equal, we hope to continue in that in that arena. [0:06:22, 0:06:42]: So one of the issues that that we first saw with the options that the county had laid out was not just the distribution, but the use of the twenty twenty versus twenty twenty-three census. As you know, we got a referendum that annexed about sixty seven hundred new residents into the city of Stockbridge, and that started January. [0:06:42, 0:06:43]: January of twenty twenty one. [0:06:44, 0:06:50]: So the numbers that were reflected in the twenty twenty census does not account for those folks. They're still technically in the county. [0:06:51, 0:06:54]: And so that's where some of the issues came in. [0:06:54, 0:07:05]: Um originally looking at this. Obviously, and the county is going by that that distribution of population and by their numbers it's sixty-eight thirty-two. [0:07:05, 0:07:23]: Which is a little different from the lost, as you know, because we had to literally have the state come in and address some of the issues with the new population that we have in. And so our level is uh right under fourteen percent for us. So use of the twenty twenty census obviously [0:07:24, 0:07:26]: diminishes the amount that we would get. [0:07:27, 0:07:31]: But what the county has done is they've given us a list of about six options. [0:07:31, 0:07:33]: Опціон Она, вичті сі бифою. [0:07:34, 0:07:50]: is literally a distribution based on the twenty twenty census, which at the time the city of McDonough was a little bit larger than us in population. So they would get twelve point three four, we would get twelve point three one. Um we know that that number is not the same and I'll show that in a d in another um presentation. [0:07:51, 0:07:58]: And so based on that, there will be no designation of level projects. And what we mean by level projects is the county won't [0:07:58, 0:08:09]: bundle projects or grab a specific project and make that project a level one or level two, which means they go and they will bond finance in advance those monies. [0:08:09, 0:08:11]: Um to get project started right away. [0:08:12, 0:08:16]: Rather than going through the paygo, they would bond finance in lieu of. [0:08:16, 0:08:16]: Right? [0:08:17, 0:08:18]: If that happens. [0:08:19, 0:08:22]: they have to repay that money back'cause remember they're taking a loan [0:08:22, 0:08:24]: To get those money, so that means [0:08:24, 0:08:27]: that any priority level projects [0:08:27, 0:08:30]: We the cities won't see any funding. [0:08:31, 0:08:32]: Won't see any funding. [0:08:32, 0:08:38]: For over a year. So even though the splots six would start if approved by the voters in November, would start [0:08:39, 0:08:41]: April of twenty twenty five. [0:08:41, 0:08:58]: the county would collect all of those funds and repay off whatever that money's this they borrowed. And you'll see it as I pull up the other slides, what their what their options are. So in that situation, we don't collect until somewhere around 2026, in the year 2026, even though the splot starts in 2025. [0:08:58, 0:09:04]: So that's one of the issues where you see where it's gonna talk about levels, level one or level two projects. [0:09:07, 0:09:09]: So right now the county is anticipating [0:09:10, 0:09:12]: Let me make this so everybody can see it. [0:09:25, 0:09:40]: So option one, the county overall the county's anticipating about four hundred and seventy million over a six year period of displus. That would be the hundred percent collection. And the distribution would be, like I said, twelve point three one percent of stock bridge for fifty seven point eight. [0:09:40, 0:09:44]: twelve point three four to McDonough at fifty seven point nine [0:09:44, 0:10:02]: Locust Grove at three point eight for seventeen point eight million and Hampton three point five for a collection of sixteen point seven million and Henry County at sixty eight percent would collect three hundred and nineteen million six hundred. [0:10:12, 0:10:25]: So under option two, the the the Hen Henry County, they changed the percentage in terms of how much each community gets. So they went down six one percent to sixty seven percent to the city's getting thirty three percent. [0:10:27, 0:10:28]: Under the scenario, obviously. [0:10:29, 0:10:30]: We're still under the city of McDonough. [0:10:31, 0:10:33]: But we would get twelve point six. [0:10:33, 0:10:35]: For fifty nine point six. [0:10:35, 0:10:39]: McDonald get twelve point seven percent at fifty nine point eight. [0:10:39, 0:10:42]: Um locust Grove three point nine. [0:10:42, 0:10:45]: at eighteen point four milyen [0:10:46, 0:10:50]: The city of Hampton would get three point six percent at seventeen. [0:10:51, 0:10:54]: And the county would get three hundred and fourteen million. [0:10:54, 0:10:58]: But this is the caveat under level two, which is public safety. [0:10:58, 0:11:16]: And they have listed under public safety for them police, fire, animal control, and a couple of other buildings that they want to get uh moving on. So they would bond ahead of time, they would borrow that fifty one million dollars and that fifty one million dollars will have to be repaid. [0:11:16, 0:11:23]: over the first th those all collections until that money's paid off will be put towards paying off that loan. [0:11:23, 0:11:25]: Nobody would get any monies within that time period. [0:11:26, 0:11:30]: Um just the county to pay off that money so that they can get started on those level two projects. [0:11:36, 0:11:36]: Is it? [0:11:37, 0:11:37]: Yes, sir. [0:11:39, 0:11:47]: Clarity. Let's just say right now they're c they're I think they're collecting around eleven or twelve million dollars a month. [0:11:48, 0:11:58]: Uh, in terms of total overall splice one T splice splice. So technically that would be maybe about twelve. I mean, we're looking at go back to the figure again. [0:11:59, 0:12:03]: Which one? The previous chart, number two. Option two I think he's talking about. [0:12:03, 0:12:23]: Right. So if they borrowed the fifty one million dollars up front and they were collecting ten million a month, basically that's about five months that they would take off the top to repay that money. Is that what you're saying? No. It's actually longer than that. It that that that would be the look at it from a logical standpoint, but no it's [0:12:23, 0:12:24]: Um [0:12:26, 0:12:31]: And I forget how they laid it out for me, but it w it doesn't actually work like that, sir. Um [0:12:31, 0:12:41]: The time period in which they would collect would go longer than just five months because you're collecting ten million. It doesn't work like that. It'll go a little longer than that. It'll go to about a year. [0:12:41, 0:13:01]: Okay, so it at any event we're looking at maybe about twelve months. But I mean I just as in layman's term and my common sense way of thinking, if they're gonna pay the money up front and they're collecting ten to twelve million a month, it might take that long to pay it off on sure that maybe some interest or whatever to go with that. That's correct. So [0:13:01, 0:13:11]: So it'll take longer than that time period. So you're looking at, like I said, it'll be close to a year before we start collecting any funds for the city to start its PLUS programs. [0:13:11, 0:13:18]: Um so under option two they stayed with the sixty seven thirty three split. Uh hold on I'm sorry, option three. [0:13:18, 0:13:22]: Um they went to a sixty six thirty four split. [0:13:22, 0:13:31]: But in this case they have a level one project and a level and level two projects. That level one project is the tag office in the city of Locust Grove. [0:13:32, 0:13:42]: Um, that they would bond finance ahead of time and I'll show you all that um breakout. So that total jumps from fifty one million to eighty five million that they would take off the top. [0:13:43, 0:13:49]: All funds collected would go to repaying that. Once that is paid off, then everybody will start getting their distributed funds. [0:13:49, 0:13:53]: But recognize those distributed funds would only be over a five year period. [0:13:53, 0:13:59]: In that case, obviously the number jumps a little different. Um so we'd be at thirteen percent. [0:13:59, 0:14:03]: Um right on at sixty one million, sixty one point four. [0:14:03, 0:14:16]: McDonough 61.6, um, Lucas Grove at 18.9, uh Hampton at 17.7, and then the county obviously at sixty-six percent, with Collec uh 310. [0:14:29, 0:14:33]: And option options option four. [0:14:34, 0:14:41]: has the county at sixty five uh and the cities at thirty five and I will tell you that they're not looking at this option at all. [0:14:41, 0:14:46]: Um from what I've been told. But there you'll see the distribution going to sixty three. [0:14:47, 0:15:05]: Um for the city of McDonough and the city of Stockbridge. Um and then the city of Locust Grove at nineteen point five, Hampton at eighteen, uh the county at three oh five, the last one was at three ten. Um but they will fund those those level four pr those level four projects, those level one and level two projects. [0:15:09, 0:15:14]: And then obviously we can't come to an agreement on the SPLOSS. [0:15:16, 0:15:22]: This one is a little different. Okay. So this is saying that the cities can't agree with the county on the distribution. [0:15:22, 0:15:26]: What'll happen is the same thing that happens currently happen on this plus five. [0:15:26, 0:15:27]: No IGA. [0:15:28, 0:15:48]: You can't have a six years plus, you go to a five years plus, and the difference between that is three hundred and eighty versus four hundred and seventy million. So that is a significant difference in the amount of funds that that would be allocated. The county will continue to do sixty-eight percent, we will do thirty-two percent, and those numbers will drop. [0:15:48, 0:15:56]: Us from the 60s into the 40s, kind of where we started out with the numbers we were looking at at 44 million. So we'll be at 46.7. [0:15:56, 0:15:58]: McDonald would be at forty six point eight. [0:15:59, 0:16:01]: Locust Grove at fourteen point four. [0:16:01, 0:16:20]: Uh Hampton at thirteen point five, and then the county will collect two hundred and fifty-eight million for their programs. So Mr. That is worst case scenario. So Mr. Gullian was saying m for a no IG, that means everybody across the board in the county and the four cities ultimately all lose across the board the amount of funds. I want to make it known to the council though is that uh [0:16:20, 0:16:24]: I I and I would hope that you would agree with this so we can work this out. [0:16:24, 0:16:44]: that uh the based on the twenty twenty census is out out. We should really go with the estimate of twenty twenty three. And I know that uh Tim from uh from local school here presented that information at our last meeting with the county a couple weeks or so ago. And uh that that I think that's more beneficial for us as a city because we are larger than Madonna and I believe that Madonna has [0:16:44, 0:17:04]: No problem with that. They realize that that's the case. And of course, as Mr. Gardner mentioned earlier on in the presentation, is that if they stay with the 2020 census, that means that the sixty seven hundred folks that we gained through legal legislation, they're still counting on those folks from that that that basis. That's one thing. The other thing is what I like to mention to the council is that we really [0:17:04, 0:17:24]: an issue for a six year spLOS. But really what we need is a six year spLOS here, not a five year. So I just want to lay that out for you all and for further discussion, an explanation maybe from Mr. Gardner answering questions you may have about this. But uh and of course there will be a time frame working through with uh Senator Vincent the mayor of [0:17:24, 0:17:44]: Madonna about having a a joint meeting with all the uh the mayor city managers and all the cities prior to the deadline of thirty July to make sure that we're in sync uh with the other cities as we we uh before we signed this IGA uh with the uh with the county. Uh but I obviously wanted to make sure we had a [0:17:44, 0:18:04]: meeting we with you all tonight to make sure that Mr. Gardner ha understands where we're going and we have and we understand how we want to handle this when we go with the final uh designation with the rest of cities as well as is uh as well as before I have to sign off on IGA. Want to make sure that you're well aware of of of the situation. We have a a consensus of what direction we [0:18:04, 0:18:09]: So you your point you look concerned, you have an idea. Okay, Mr go ahead, Mr. Alzheimer's. [0:18:09, 0:18:24]: I'm in total agreement with you in terms of we've been down this road before and I think in the last iteration of this we ended up we went there with a proposal and we ended up leaving with twenty five percent. [0:18:24, 0:18:38]: Remember that? Yes. We we thought we were gonna have some negotiation and there was no negotiation. Right. And it ended up being twenty five percent. And uh at this point, to me, you said they're not really entertaining option number four. [0:18:39, 0:18:39]: No. [0:18:40, 0:19:00]: No. Okay, so uh uh waiting uh to me, my own personal opinion, waiting doesn't bother me as long as I'm getting more money. Because in the time it gives us time in that year ramp up to prepare for the projects and honestly we uh you know we we got some other projects that we might be able to [0:19:00, 0:19:20]: work on that we need to get off the board in the meantime uh on the T splot and the SPLOS to show residents that we're trying to we're moving forward with a lot of these projects. So the waiting doesn't really bother me. I just like the larger percentage because we're going to I would have went for the 34 and still are waiting, but you say they're not waiting [0:19:20, 0:19:40]: They're not really working on that, but the 33% gives us a greater percentage because basically we went from 25% to 33% over the last negotiations that we had. It cost us a lot of money because we only went five years and we only got 25%, and they got all of the money off the top anyway. [0:19:40, 0:20:00]: By going five years, is that correct? They got all of the money off the off the top. So the winning position to me would be uh the third position, which is the thirty three percent. There is some a little bit of waiting involved, but it's a much higher percentage. It's a higher percentage, uh, and it gives us time. [0:20:00, 0:20:20]: To consult because I I honestly think that, you know, like you said, it might be a year to pay the money off, but it may not be there. That's on the outside, I would think. So I'm okay with waiting as long as we get a larger percentage of the money, because if you're waiting, uh you get a full [0:20:19, 0:20:39]: percent what is the difference between those two numbers i'm sorry it ain't between the 32 percent and then the 33 percent so at the 30 at option one which is the 68 split that's with no priority projects right so that's based on the 2020 population where Henry [0:20:39, 0:20:43]: County made up sixty eight percent, the city's made up thirty two percent. [0:20:43, 0:20:57]: So that split would be literally the city of Stockbridge at fifty-seven point eight, city of McDonough at fifty-seven point nine, um, Hampton and Locus Grove at 1716, the county at 319. [0:20:57, 0:20:57]: Total [0:20:58, 0:21:00]: In the pot is four hundred and seventy million. [0:21:01, 0:21:21]: Um option two, which I think the chair would entertain because they're able to get priority their level two projects project done ahead of time, would just put us right on the sixty I'm sorry, uh option two is right on the six smoke. Right on the sixty million. The county gets to do their priority projects and [0:21:21, 0:21:25]: And just to let you know what their priority projects are. [0:21:26, 0:21:30]: It would be they would do the fifty one million. [0:21:30, 0:21:50]: Rich is that I'm sorry, what I'm trying to do now is the difference between thirty two percent and then the um so at level at level two, at level two, they get to bond finance the animal new animal shelter, um, fire rescue facilities, fire rescue equipment, and e nine one one and ema facility. So public [0:21:50, 0:22:10]: safety. I mean all of those options f uh help us first spatially uh with homeowners insurance it puts we know that we need additional fire stations so those are plus pluses to the community. Now certainly I might argue about the locust grove tag office since we had to build our own. [0:22:10, 0:22:15]: Everybody agreed that that that the TIG office was not a really big [0:22:16, 0:22:36]: um pusher for for a level one project. I mean, because you re realize the majority of the residents here come to the TIG office here. Um so that's not even though it's a countywide project, obviously it's gonna serve the needs of the folks that live in the Hampton um [0:22:36, 0:22:40]: Locust Grove, Ola, El Walla um communities. [0:22:40, 0:22:48]: Okay, so we have fifty seven six basically for thirty three percent and then for um [0:22:49, 0:23:04]: Fifty nine at thirty three with with level two public safety getting the first bite. Well I'm looking at the amount that we're receiving. We're looking at fifty nine sixty nine six for option two. But then option one, we're looking at fifty seven [0:23:05, 0:23:25]: Fifty seven. So basically that's about a million eight, million seven difference in that percentage uh that would go in with option number two. I mean, there's gonna be a little bit of waiting. They're already leaning toward option number two. And I have a secondary question for you. Go to option two again. [0:23:25, 0:23:45]: Now let me add in there for real quick if you don't mind. You realize this is on 2020. I think we need to push for 2023. I I I'm getting ready to address that. Okay, okay. Okay, go ahead, sir. I'm sorry. Now listen, uh the reason I'm I'm gonna address this this way. If McDonough is already in agreement with where we are right now, right, why don't we just go to the city of McDonough? [0:23:45, 0:24:05]: And let's say let's split the difference and let's us meet in the middle. Let's get the same amount as the city of McDonough versus going back to the county and say, you know, we come up a little bit, you go down a little bit, we're there, we're negotiating amongst the cities. We don't really have to go to the counties in order in order to get that because I don't want to. [0:24:05, 0:24:25]: end up in that position where we are and we're grappling at the table. Is there really going to be true negotiations and where we're going to? But certainly if the amount, the mount, the the amount, the amount is not going, is the the amount total population amount is going to change for the cities, the total population [0:24:24, 0:24:36]: So if you use the twenty twenty three census, you will change because the remember [0:24:37, 0:24:41]: the city of Stockbridge unless you plan on taking from your sister cities. [0:24:41, 0:24:42]: [1483.1, 1503.1]: Um it has to come from the county. So the county would be a little bit lower than what what what's up here. So they will receive a little a less percentage. So the si basically the sixty-seven hundred residents came from unincorporated to us. So basically the difference in what we're looking for is that sixty seven hundred residents [0:25:03, 0:25:14]: is different from unincorporated to incorporated, that's what we will be requesting of the county. And that's what I and that's the conversation I had with the county manager and the county chair on finance was [0:25:15, 0:25:19]: You know, you have to look at that and and and here's the issue. So [0:25:20, 0:25:23]: Under this premise we're getting a little less funding. [0:25:24, 0:25:27]: But we're still obligated to take care of those areas that came in. [0:25:28, 0:25:32]: Even though they're actually the funds to include them are in the sixty eight percent. [0:25:33, 0:25:34]: It's not included in the thirty two. [0:25:35, 0:25:40]: So in essence, when we're addressing any of their issues under the Splos Roads infrastructure. [0:25:41, 0:26:01]: It's coming from our smaller port, even though their number is incorporated in that sixty eight, it's not in that s in that thirty two, it's not in that twelve point six percent. Okay, that that makes sense. So now now that I I I I understand I thought you were just talking about between us and McDonough. No, the difference is is not really McDonald will pretty much stay with [0:26:00, 0:26:13]: where they are, they they their amount would not change. We would be seeking those additional dollars from the county which would increase our allotment, which would take us over them as the largest city. [0:26:14, 0:26:34]: Correct. And and if you recall we had this type of discussion when we went through loss negotiations when we actually when it passed initially in November a couple of years ago, we had to go back and take to some additional percentage of loss because of the gain that we had. This is on the same similar lines. Okay. Okay. I I got it. Now I just wanted to make sh the I I was thinking [0:26:34, 0:26:45]: That the pot would change between us and McDonough. The pot's not gonna change. McDonough's number would stay the same, and we would be seeking basically a small, basically we're talking about [0:26:46, 0:27:06]: Maybe a couple of maybe a few maybe four or five hundred thousand dollars, not a a monumental amount for those sixty-seven uh sixty seven hundred residents or whatever that amount is going to be, but it wouldn't be an earth-shattering amount. It's still gonna be close to what McDonough is getting, just a little bit more based on what the [0:27:06, 0:27:07]: Percentages. Right. [0:27:07, 0:27:27]: And and and we have to realize too, that is predicated on whether or not the county wants to agree to that, which they've already said they're not, right? Um and if and just playing it out logically, if they say no, then we have gotta come to a decision as to [0:27:27, 0:27:30]: Во и вона узебуці? Ізет [0:27:31, 0:27:51]: Well one, the base of the of the s of of the split is gonna be on the twenty twenty census. If we don't come to an agreement there, then we run into the risk of not having an agreement at all. Okay. For clarification, they've already rejected the request. They they've they've rejected it in conversations. Okay. That they're not going to [0:27:51, 0:27:54]: They're they're not gonna go to the twenty twenty three number. [0:27:54, 0:28:06]: So in essence, I mean, really do but we could ask, basically. And and and that's what certainly we should ask. And that's what we did when we we pointed out to the county commit to the county um folks that [0:28:06, 0:28:10]: You you you still put us in the bind, just in the conversation I had before with you guys. [0:28:12, 0:28:14]: We're carrying a portion of [0:28:16, 0:28:17]: Unincorporated county [0:28:18, 0:28:20]: in the city since twenty twenty census [0:28:20, 0:28:25]: But you're factoring in their numbers in your revenue calculations. [0:28:26, 0:28:27]: Well they're in the city. [0:28:28, 0:28:28]: So [0:28:29, 0:28:39]: It obviously that should be a that's a sticking point and should be, not only just for us for McDonald, because that changes even their percentages b based on the growth since twenty twenty. [0:28:40, 0:28:42]: Right. And as I explained to the county officials, [0:28:43, 0:28:49]: You don't collect this money until 2025. You're four and a half years away from us from the next census. [0:28:51, 0:28:55]: And you're using pretty much. By the time we start collecting, you're los you're using [0:28:55, 0:28:57]: Five and a half year data. [0:28:58, 0:29:00]: To determine a split. [0:29:01, 0:29:01]: Right. [0:29:01, 0:29:03]: Doesn't it make sense? [0:29:03, 0:29:04]: But [0:29:04, 0:29:09]: Obviously it's in the best interest of them looking at it from their perspective because under that scenario [0:29:10, 0:29:13]: At twenty twenty, they were sixty eight percent. We were thirty two. [0:29:13, 0:29:16]: Our loss negotiations are a little bit different. [0:29:17, 0:29:21]: Рай, і цмор тоді сити сикс тридцять фору, веге омос фотин процент. [0:29:21, 0:29:22]: Mm-hmm. [0:29:22, 0:29:40]: So that's the difference. If I could continue real quick. Yeah, I certainly let me just say this. They watching this meeting just like we do. So some of this probably need to be discussed offline on what the strategy's gonna be, you know. You know, I I think you you you hit the head on the nail on the head, right? I mean [0:29:41, 0:29:55]: All things. If they say no, we're not using twenty twenty-three, okay, we all want a six years plus. If we take that off the table, then we come down to which one of these options we feel is in the best interest of the city, and that's the option that the city council wants to go with. [0:29:55, 0:29:57]: Right. Um [0:29:57, 0:30:06]: Like you say, there's nothing wrong with asking, as my grandmama used to say, ax not what not. Ask not what So if you if we don't ax [0:30:06, 0:30:11]: They won't know that this is what our position has been. Now are we gonna go concrete in that position? [0:30:13, 0:30:22]: And if that put going concrete in that position costs us a year, you're looking at three hundred and seventy versus three hundred and eighty versus four hundred and seventy million. [0:30:23, 0:30:35]: Do you happen to have I'm sorry, do you happen to have um of that briefing that uh uh Tim had shown with all the twenty twenty three numbers, so we can at least show the rest of the council that that presentation if you got that handy? [0:30:43, 0:30:50]: Just to give you some insight, council, on on um these twenty twenty three numbers and percentages so you at least have an idea of what it looks like. [0:30:53, 0:30:54]: Well for acid. [0:30:55, 0:30:58]: I'm sorry. [0:31:41, 0:31:46]: So in this chart what we what what Tim looked we looked at was we did the projections. [0:31:46, 0:31:48]: Pretty much from twenty twenty ten. [0:31:49, 0:31:51]: All the way through over to twenty twenty three. [0:31:51, 0:31:58]: Right, where our population went from twenty six to thirty six. That included the sixty seven hundred and something people that came in. [0:31:58, 0:31:59]: That jumped our number. [0:32:00, 0:32:08]: Um right around the thirteen percent percentile number. And so when you look at that, that's where the thirty-three [0:32:08, 0:32:15]: thirty three se sixty seven split comes into play to some degree. The issue is obviously um [0:32:16, 0:32:35]: Our number is a little different from from McDonough's number. So that's where the rub would come in. Obviously the county is looking at the option of going to a sixty-seven thirty-three. They're just using the twenty, they're just using the twenty twenty census. And so when we broke down the number, um [0:32:36, 0:32:44]: in here and Tim is you know, we have to make some adjustment based on what the county is seeing in there. So all things being equal, if we go [0:32:44, 0:32:46]: to a um [0:32:46, 0:33:01]: six year spLoss. You know, we're looking at a right around nine point something a year in revenues collected. Um that would get us right around fifty seven. But we know we've adjusted some numbers since this chart came out. The numbers have had to be adjusted. Um [0:33:03, 0:33:17]: So that that was that was how that actually broke down. And on the high, it was sixty one. And that's where my calculations, when you saw my projections on the number, I was using the sixty million uh excuse me. [0:33:20, 0:33:22]: The sixty milyen is a hard a hard total. [0:33:26, 0:33:33]: So splitting the difference between what what Tim was projecting as the high and what was being projected as as the low. [0:33:34, 0:33:37]: Um, right in between there. So on the high side [0:33:37, 0:33:47]: continuing kind of where we've been with our collections, that's where we would be based on the on the twenty twenty three census. So that's that's somewhat the difference. Um [0:33:48, 0:33:49]: You know. [0:33:49, 0:33:51]: That's about a seven million dollar dear force. [0:33:52, 0:34:02]: So so yeah, so you're talking about a w a one one point something million dollar if that difference in there, um, at the sixty eight point seven. [0:34:06, 0:34:16]: So we would get thirty-four, it's kinda b f pretty much falling on the loss. Well, this is here is older number, but the law where we negotiated a loss and remember we got an additional percentage. [0:34:16, 0:34:18]: Because of the population change. [0:34:18, 0:34:25]: So Tim number was not fairly exact'cause it our new numbers was actually at thirty six point something, but [0:34:26, 0:34:31]: And I sent that over to him, but that's kind of where the distribution would be. [0:34:31, 0:34:42]: So we're not that far off in the ballpark in terms of the distribution. It's not it's not some significant ten or nine million dollar difference. You're talking hundreds of thousands to a million, million one. [0:34:42, 0:34:43]: Right. [0:34:44, 0:35:04]: I'm all for asking, so that's my position. Council, any any other you all about this latest information? Any questions or thoughts, concerns on this side? Down here? Any any concerns, thoughts? Go right here, please. Um thank you, Mayor. Uh Mr. Gardner, uh quick question. The bonding that they would take off top for [0:35:04, 0:35:21]: Besh for projects such as the public safety, animal control and those other things. Is that by law that they get to take off top first? Is or they c they coming to us with an agreement saying these are the projects that we want to do? [0:35:21, 0:35:28]: And we're asking to bond this amount off top first. It's it's negotiated, but they actually are negotiating from the high we're on the low side. [0:35:29, 0:35:29]: I'm sorry. [0:35:30, 0:35:32]: They they've got the high ground, we've got the low ground. [0:35:32, 0:35:36]: For that particular as it relates to splots in general. Because remember [0:35:37, 0:35:40]: They don't have to include us in Splash. By law they don't. [0:35:40, 0:35:45]: Um they could just have a five years plus and and move forward with the population based on the last census. [0:35:46, 0:36:01]: Well, we we lost a lot of money doing that. We were aware of that. Correct. But we what I'm saying is uh so I just wanted to make sure I didn't know even though it's a negotiated end, I didn't know if it was me it was by law that they get to do that. [0:36:01, 0:36:21]: Uh unlike loss to some degree, the county actually gets to put they they get to lead the charge on on SPLS. Um LOS is a little different, um, but when it comes to SPLOS, we can't call a SPLOSS. They can. They can call a SPLOS for six years and say, Do you all want to negotiate? Here's our terms. [0:36:22, 0:36:24]: If we say no, they go to a five year sploss. [0:36:25, 0:36:27]: And in that five years plus scenario, you know what they could do? [0:36:28, 0:36:38]: They could go ahead and bond finance their projects off and still put us in the loop. So that's we've done that. Yes, that has happened. But I've m uh m [0:36:39, 0:36:41]: But I'll wait'cause I don't want to talk. [0:36:42, 0:36:47]: strategy of online. But I what I do want to do is um [0:36:48, 0:36:49]: Um [0:36:51, 0:37:01]: That difference, that's a big difference that twenty twenty three since is compared to twenty twenty is not just a hundred. So thousand dollars or two hundred thousand dollars. [0:37:01, 0:37:03]: So if you go back to huh. [0:37:09, 0:37:14]: So if you go back to scenario one at the sixty eight thirty-two or [0:37:15, 0:37:21]: Option two at the sixty seven thirty three, which is close to where we are. [0:37:21, 0:37:22]: Um [0:37:23, 0:37:34]: Uh option three does it a little bit, with sixty six thirty-four. But remember that eighty five million is what they're gonna move forward on with those level one and level two projects right away. [0:37:34, 0:37:42]: Right. And so you might be looking at a year, a year and a half or more around there before we see a dime c start hitting us. [0:37:42, 0:37:56]: Right. And so that's the key for us is, you know, do you think that the tag office is a hot button issue that that the the the folks here are gonna like as well as the folks in the county gonna like? Mm-hmm. [0:37:56, 0:37:57]: Um [0:37:58, 0:38:09]: You know, versus the public safety. And I think that's why you have the option two, which just address uh addresses the level two projects, which are the public safety projects, and I'll show you those again. [0:38:09, 0:38:11]: It's the fire station. [0:38:12, 0:38:26]: It's the new animal shelter, which you guys are watching the news, you've been hearing about it. Um, new fire rescue facilities, um, the new fire rescue equipment and the new the E one E nine nine one one and and EMA facility. [0:38:26, 0:38:35]: uh uh what's they're willing to make those projects and they would go forward and do the TIG office on a paygo situation rather than bond financing that. [0:38:36, 0:38:38]: Well, uh I would be interested in knowing [0:38:40, 0:38:57]: This current spots that we're in, how long it took them to collect fifty one million dollars? I I wanna know the time frame of that collection. I could I could get that. If they i i I could get that number from from from the county, how long they think it would take. Um if I remember correctly, they were saying at the meeting [0:38:58, 0:39:02]: Um f I don't know if Mayor and Mr Alexander you remember, I think they were saying [0:39:02, 0:39:12]: somewhere in the neighborhood, I think it was a year to a year and a half based on if they do the level one, level two versus level one only,'cause obviously that's only six million dollars. [0:39:13, 0:39:24]: If you go back, if they just did the level one, which they doesn't show that as as the number one option'cause it's not a sexy sell to anybody, the Tiger Office, look and see. It's either no priority projects [0:39:24, 0:39:30]: or the public safety, but you don't see the level one, the Tiger Office by itself. [0:39:30, 0:39:32]: That's just a level one project. It's [0:39:33, 0:39:39]: they don't put it out there by itself. So what it what they're saying is public safety is our priority. [0:39:40, 0:39:44]: that those facil fire facilities fire aparatus e nine one one [0:39:44, 0:39:45]: And an animal controlled [0:39:46, 0:40:06]: We're more geared towards that, uh and bond findings in those ahead of time versus doing the TIG office by itself with just one level one priority project. Um and obviously six million dollars is not a long wait if they did it. So they obviously that's not a win. Um so that's why I think they put the level two [0:40:06, 0:40:13]: And they give us the option of splitting it closer to where we are from a population distribution, 6733. [0:40:14, 0:40:18]: But doing the fifty one in advance, and then we all get [0:40:18, 0:40:19]: And remember [0:40:19, 0:40:20]: Um [0:40:20, 0:40:22]: If all things hold true. [0:40:22, 0:40:24]: Івен тру ковід. [0:40:24, 0:40:35]: We saw an increase in our sales tax. Our sales tax never dipped. That wasn't just Henry County, that was pretty much around Metroid Lana, Fulton County, everybody. Um [0:40:35, 0:40:38]: People might not have been gathering around but they were buying stuff. [0:40:39, 0:40:41]: Um and having it delivered. [0:40:41, 0:40:46]: Right. Um so that's so sales tax didn't go down. So all things being equal. [0:40:47, 0:40:50]: Should we surpass the four seventy? Yeah, probably will. [0:40:50, 0:40:51]: Um [0:40:51, 0:40:53]: And so that means it's just more in a hat. [0:40:54, 0:41:04]: But once said we I'll find out what that take if they bond finance, what that date is, and I will get that back to you guys. Um if I could get an answer tonight, I'll let you know tonight. If I can get an answer. [0:41:06, 0:41:08]: So I I guess [0:41:09, 0:41:15]: Moving forward, I mean is is council in agreement that we should look at l option w option two? [0:41:15, 0:41:18]: Option two and option three or just option two. [0:41:19, 0:41:20]: Oh on uh option one. [0:41:21, 0:41:36]: I mean, if you have a fallback and I know the strategy, but I mean it is what it is, they're gonna find out anyway. Um, it ain't like we could sue'em over anything, can't. I mean the DNS what what we all come to an agreement or don't come to an agreement on. [0:41:36, 0:41:56]: Um so I was gonna say I I'll tell you what, I uh I'm I'm I like option two with six years and twenty twenty-three data. Okay, that's that that's my wish list. Right. Now whether or not we can get that's another story, but that's my wish list because I think that's only fair to us. That's what I think. Anyway. Mr. Everton, go ahead, please. Uh I concur with what you just stated. [0:41:56, 0:42:04]: And certainly my position is the same as yours, which is we will ask. Right. We will put provide pr provide the data. [0:42:05, 0:42:25]: But they're they're you know, they we started at thir they started we started at thirty four, they started at thirty two. Negotiation requires compromise. They come to the thirty three percent which is hitting the middle on where we are in terms of negotiation. We make a request, as you have stated, based on the twenty three [0:42:25, 0:42:45]: Data and then indicate that that data is solid as a rock, but at the same time, when they got the stick, what do you do? Because that's just what it is, because they can say we don't want to do that, and that's kind of where we are. So, what I want to do is do what we did, present the data, and see what the response. [0:42:44, 0:42:51]: But rest of council, what kind of thoughts you the rest of the council have? [0:42:52, 0:43:06]: Same mayor for I'm in agreement with you as well. Th obviously twenty twenty three data would give us the best solution outcome that we would want to have, but again, like it's been stated it's ultimately not [0:43:07, 0:43:13]: in our final decision, but we will shoot for it. You you never know what you can get'til you shoot for it. So go for that and [0:43:13, 0:43:19]: We'll negotiate from there. All right, sir. Appreciate it. Mr. Option two. Option two as well, sir. Same thing. Um [0:43:20, 0:43:22]: Ms. Gantt, you you good up too? [0:43:22, 0:43:33]: Well, I'm I'm going for the same thing, your suggestion. Okay. I think it's within the best interest of the city. Mm-hmm. So that's what I will go for, starting off the century. Okay. Ms. Barber? [0:43:35, 0:43:55]: You have any comment? You don't have a comment. All right, so be it. All right. So option two, it's six years and twenty twenty three data, sirs is what we're looking at now. And then obviously um we'll have to have some additional conversation with the other three cities, primarily well the other three cities anyway, can we have to go collectively uh with them [0:43:55, 0:44:15]: them uh to the county for to sign off the IGA. And so we have the primary position. I guess uh there might be have to be a secondary position. I don't know if we want to go down that road right now, but you got a primary position and then and uh so sometime within the next uh week or so we'll have to meet with the rest of the cities and then before the end of the month sign off get to the [0:44:15, 0:44:35]: the county and sign off on an IGA and obviously council uh between myself and of course and Mr. Gardner we'll keep you abreast and keep you up what's going on so you at least know where we stand on this so because in this aspect and hopefully we can get all the things we need for our city properly that we think is right. So um anybody got any other questions, concerns? [0:44:35, 0:44:40]: Okay, me as well. Does that conclude the pro uh the uh your presentation? [0:44:40, 0:45:00]: Are you concluded with your presentation? No, certainly in a totally different category. The the there was a quite a disparity between the joint product projects where county money was being invested in McDonough and county money was being invested in the city. I think those conversations need to continue because uh [0:45:00, 0:45:20]: I I I stated it and I sent you all the email. I feel like there was obvious bias on the sploss committee toward the city. And Mayor, you indicated it during the joint meeting. It was a travesty that flippin' road was removed from the list. Right. And we certainly need to go back to see whether or not we could have some allocation. [0:45:20, 0:45:23]: uh for flipping road and such projects. [0:45:24, 0:45:35]: Yes, I was I was I was told that they would look at including flipping and I did put that down in our on our list with them, um, that flipping would be on there. Um [0:45:35, 0:45:43]: East Lake Parkway, Eagles Landing Parkway, Hudson Bridge, Um East Atlanta Road, um [0:45:44, 0:45:55]: were on that list and also if they locate a property in the inside the city limits, we w if they want to we could discuss um [0:45:56, 0:46:00]: The senior center as a discussion and I think that's what the position we said we go. [0:46:01, 0:46:03]: Um I did add one other thing in there. [0:46:03, 0:46:05]: And that was the [0:46:06, 0:46:17]: And some remember this and um Mr Alfonso you might remember this. Did the Rock Quarry Road used to be a splos project before a joint project from years and the money was reappropriated, correct? [0:46:18, 0:46:29]: So I did actually add that on there and more so for engineering and design, because obviously we won't get it done in this plus, so we'd have to wait till the T S Plus. Kind of the same thing we're doing with Patrick Henry. So I added that just [0:46:29, 0:46:49]: for them to know that realizing if if we put in one hundred percent, that roadway is going to be utilized by unincorporated Henry County residents coming from Flat Rock Road and all the other areas up there that traverse down old cornyars and then would come on that road to hit Rock Roy to get to there to get to the hospital and get to I seventy five. [0:46:49, 0:47:09]: So it's not just a single or city city project. It should be something to look at jointly. So I could I added that to the list as well. And second and and lastly, we he we were talking about a park parti particularly in district three and uh see whether or not they would be willing to partner with us on some since we've allocated a [0:47:09, 0:47:29]: If we get the six years flies about six million dollar the park improvement, maybe they could help us to assist with the park in District 3. Um And the only reason why I didn't put that is it you know obviously we're they're in the recreation business, which we're not, and that's where the joint boat lady expense come in for building a park. For us [0:47:29, 0:47:49]: it's gonna be more of a passive use park because that's what we're that's our that's our niche. Um and so looking at that property and also willing to leverage some of the the funds that we would get to go after a kaboom grant. Um been successful in the past past community with about three kaboom [0:47:49, 0:48:09]: grants for parks in East Point that literally stave off and that would just take a community effort, us bringing the match and they will bring the facilities, put them in the parks. So there's some options us to play with, but ultimately um you know getting community buy-in um and and putting the putting the project together. But if if you want me to add that I will. [0:48:09, 0:48:29]: I just realized that I didn't think it was the big that big of a lift, but I guess every every every little bit counts, so I'll resend that and put that on the list if if you're not sure. Let me say this too. Don't let the past be the hist be the deterrent for what we're doing in the future. Our kids do need some sports bills in the city. We've seen [0:48:29, 0:48:49]: where we were on the board where we were held over, dangled over the banner about our sports field down at Cochrane Park. Right. So it certainly would be a good thing if we had soccer fields or football fields or lacrosse fields, some sports fields in the city for for our own use, whether we [0:48:49, 0:49:09]: recr whether we shopped out the recreation to them or what we decided to do, but it certainly would be good to have some recreational sports fields in the city, whether that's lacrosse or soccer or football or some type of facility, even baseball. [0:49:09, 0:49:24]: You good? Anything else down this way? Pickleball. anybody else? Okay, so you said you'd be able to add that, try to work that in. Yes. [0:49:24, 0:49:25]: Okay. [0:49:25, 0:49:32]: All right. Any other questions, Council? Anything else, sir sir, you need to in reference to splot six that we need to discuss tonight? That's it. [0:49:33, 0:49:40]: That's it? Anything else? Alright, so no more else on that, then uh ask for um a motion to adjourn our meeting. [0:49:40, 0:49:41]: Is there a second? [0:49:42, 0:49:47]: I second. Okay, Ms Gar uh from uh Mr. Alexander and Ms. Gantt, all in favor please indicate. [0:49:47, 0:49:55]: Snapchat, thank you. God bless you all. We're in this particular meeting. We will get started with our next meeting here at 6 30. So we've got rough.
  • 2024-07-08 · City Council · Transcript · Regular Council Meetings

    2024-07-08 · City Council · Transcript · source: 10yr-transcripts · sha256 f24738f8 · pages – · method: official

    Full text — searchable
    --- title: Regular Council Meetings date: 2024-07-08 source: 2024-07-08_Regular_Council_Meetings.wav --- [0:09:46, 0:09:50]: Put it up to you. K more. [0:09:52, 0:10:03]: Also what's up? I'm Monica Jones and I'm super excited to be here. Um excited to serve the community as well as um help the city of Stockbridge grow. [0:10:04, 0:10:05]: Thank you. [0:10:09, 0:10:21]: Hello, my name is Ivy D. Sears of Ivy League Realty. I am super excited to be here, super excited to be appointed. I look forward to learning and assisting the community to grow. [0:10:26, 0:10:32]: Good evening, everyone. My name is Kim Mays. I'm the owner of Kim Mays State Farm Agency. [0:10:32, 0:10:35]: Which is in Stockbridge, so as a business owner. [0:10:36, 0:10:44]: I am really excited to be a part of this board and hoping to help to put Stockbridge in the [0:10:44, 0:10:45]: Growth direction. [0:10:46, 0:10:59]: And um excited to use my background. Okay, so I have a degree in architectural engineering and commercial construction and real estate, all the things. So super excited. Thank you for selecting me. [0:11:04, 0:11:24]: And then Vanessa Holley, I clerk, will also sign this and we'll get a copy of this as well. And I believe this is for them. Okay. Yes, they're saying their names on their manager. We've got the names on it, but we can get the right one for. Okay. That's just called okay for serious. Okay. Okay. [0:11:24, 0:11:44]: It's up to clear it up to you. Okay? Thank you very much. You all mean you need to take a picture, right? Okay. [0:11:44, 0:11:45]: Yeah. [0:11:49, 0:12:05]: All right. So how about uh the uh this pal? So yeah, you'll get it. Is there a miss pal? Thank you. I guess we're gonna show you. Oh really good? Okay, great, thank you. Is that the problem? Okay, how about uh [0:12:06, 0:12:07]: Okay, the group. [0:12:07, 0:12:09]: Yeah, massive. [0:12:16, 0:12:36]: Okay, come right here, sir. You got a you got an idea of what we're gonna go through? A little bit. A little bit, raise your right hand. Okay, I state your name. I can you cook? Board member? Board members affirm. You solemnly swear on the firm. That I will faithfully perform. That I will faithfully perform. The duties of the downtown development authority. The duties of the downtown development authority. Of the city of Stockbridge. [0:12:36, 0:12:56]: And that I will. And that I will. To the best of my ability. To the best of my ability. Support and defend. Support and defend. The charter thereof. The charter thereof. As well as the constitution. As well as the constitution. And the laws of the state of Georgia. And the laws of the state of Georgia. And the United States of America. And the United States of America. I further affirm that. I felt further affirm that. Upon assumption of this office. Upon assumption of this office. [0:12:56, 0:13:16]: Do not hold. I do not hold. Any unaccounted for public money? Any unaccounted for public money. Do or payable to the state? Do or payable to the state. Any political subdivision of the state. Or any political subdivision of the state. The city of Stock Bridge. The city of Stock Bridge. Any authority thereof. Or any authority thereof. Nor do I hold. Nor do I hold. Any other office of trust? Any other office of trust? Of the government. [0:13:16, 0:13:36]: Of the government of the United States. Of the United States. Of this state. Of this state. Or any foreign state. Or any foreign state. Prescribed. As prescribed. By the law of the state of Georgia. By the law of the state of Georgia. I solemnly affirm. I solemnly affirm. That I'm fully qualified. That I'm fully qualified. Under the Constitution. Under the Constitution. The laws of the state. And the laws of the state. To hold the office. To hold the office. Downtown Taverna Authority Board. [0:13:36, 0:13:56]: member of downtown development authority board member and i will and i will perform the duties perform the duties of my office of my office the best interest in the best interest of the city of stock rich city of stock rich best of my ability to the best of my ability without fear without fear favor favor affection affection reward reward or expectation thereof or expectation thereof on the eighth day of july twenty twenty four [0:13:56, 0:14:00]: On the eighth day of july twenty twenty four. Red listed sir. [0:14:04, 0:14:08]: Now sir the floor is you can we have anything you want to say just [0:14:08, 0:14:28]: How's everybody doing this evening? Well, I did want to take this moment just to say one thank God, and I want to say thank my family for being here today, and I'm grateful for this opportunity to serve in the city of Stockbridge. I came down here from New Jersey two years ago, not sure what I was going to do, but I found a spot here and I look forward to serving this great community and seeing it be the greatest. [0:14:28, 0:14:30]: Yeah. [0:14:37, 0:14:39]: Is there a a Toriqa pound? [0:14:41, 0:14:42]: Oh yeah. [0:14:44, 0:14:45]: Yes sir. [0:14:55, 0:14:57]: We take a second picture? Okay. [0:14:59, 0:15:13]: We'll do right hand. Come on outside. Come on up here. [0:15:16, 0:15:26]: Yeah, thanks. Thank you so much. Appreciate it. Work open for the trickers. Thank you so much. Once again, this palette is not here, right? Okay. Well [0:15:29, 0:15:34]: What I'm gonna read next is actually a proclamation here. This is um [0:15:35, 0:15:53]: This is really a uh, this is just really somewhat emotional, great, this aspect. This is actually a proclamation acknowledging one of our own. Miss Vanessa Holliday, come up please. [0:15:56, 0:16:05]: This holiday is has recently been um named the 2024 Clerk of the Year with the Georgia Municipal Association. [0:16:10, 0:16:23]: He um there are five hundred thirty-six cities in the state of Georgia. Now I don't know if every city's got a city clerk, but the whole bunch out there. What this means is she is number one in the state for this year. [0:16:27, 0:16:47]: Remind me she's always number one in our heart anyway. But the fact the fact that George Municipal Association acknowledged this publicly at our annual conference in Savannah uh last well about two weeks ago now in this aspect. So and uh the proclamation here in this he also got a great award. We'll show that to you in just a second in this aspect. So uh we're very proud of [0:16:47, 0:17:07]: Vanessa and the fact that uh he's one of our own right here that got acknowledged statewide and being number one. This is fantastic. So for you, Miss Holliday, okay. Recognition of Vanessa Holiday 2024 Georgia Municipal Clerk of the Year, whereas the Georgia Municipal Clerks Association has honored Vanessa Holliday, City Clerk of the City of Stockbridge. [0:17:07, 0:17:27]: With the highest honor as the 2024 Municipal Clerk of the Year, Vanessa Holiday will represent all 536 clerks across the state of Georgia. Whereas for the past 12 years, Vanessa has been a pillar of dedication and service as a city clerk in Stock Rates. She has shown a great deal of drive, professionalism, service during her time as a municipal clerk. [0:17:27, 0:17:47]: Ras Vanessa has served others with compassion and leadership as a clerk as well as a several community organizations throughout the city of Stockbridge and Henry County area. Ras Vanessa's commitment to professional development is evident in her qualification. She's uh in her qualification. She is a Georgia certified clerk and an International Institute Certified Municipal Clerk. She's also a [0:17:47, 0:18:07]: Complete a master's educational management development program for the University of Georgia's Carl Vincent Institute of Government, the Human Resources Administration certification, the Minnesota leader and the honorable cohort for diversity, equity, and inclusion with the Georgia Minnesota Association. And let me stop for a second. That particular one, that honor, she and I actually tag team on that. We did to this course. [0:18:07, 0:18:27]: Together. So and we had a great time for about eight months, wasn't it? Learned a lot, absolutely. So I just want to mention that we tag team rode together back and had a great time. Okay, we're all right. Okay, Vanessa is a proud member of the Georgia Municipal Clerks Association and the International Institute of Municipal Clerks and the Georgia Records Association, the Georgia Cemetery Association, and National National Association. [0:18:27, 0:18:47]: States and Government Archives and Records Administration. So now therefore I answer this floor by virtual authority blessing me as the mayor of City of Star Peter, Georgia. On behalf of City Council members, Zelda's Donna Barber, Kyle Berry, Lakeesia Gann, and Fons of Thomas to hereby dedicate this proclamation a day and the day of Vanessa Holiday, Georgia Municipal Association, two climate discrete. [0:18:47, 0:19:07]: 2024 of the year, we congratulate her elite accomplishments and recognize the hard work, dedication, and passion for the profession and community that she displays. She is an asset to our community and municipal government. A witness thereof, I have hereunto set my hand in Great Sea of the City, Stockbridge, Georgia, on the eighth day of July, year of our Lord, 2008. [0:19:07, 0:19:14]: 24. And I signed this. Normally probably she signed this. She can't sign on private. [0:19:18, 0:19:26]: And your staff, your staff is bringing you some other things. [0:19:27, 0:19:47]: Fantastic. You uh this ladies and gentlemen, I'm holding it now, but it's not mine. This is actually this is what she got at the that at the Georgia Municipal Association a couple years a couple of month weeks ago in our our Warsaw in in Savannah. And it's they see some nice, nice plaque here in this aspect. She's probably gonna bring show this in her office without doubt. So [0:19:47, 0:19:49]: Okay. [0:19:50, 0:20:01]: Now I'm I'm I'm actually holding this for you, but the problem is yours. All right, please. [0:20:04, 0:20:10]: Congrats, thank you. By the way, yeah like your point, I'm sorry. [0:20:10, 0:20:25]: Oh my goodness. Okay, thank you. Uh I love what I do and I really, really appreciate the Georgia Municipal Association uh for recognizing me. I appreciate appreciate everyone who submitted a nomination. [0:20:26, 0:20:28]: And then to be selected. [0:20:28, 0:20:34]: out of the five hundred and thirty six clerks that we currently have because we have some amazing clerks that I work with. [0:20:34, 0:20:37]: And so to be selected is an honor. [0:20:37, 0:20:40]: When I was first appointed [0:20:40, 0:20:45]: In two thousand and ten, I was told you have to have thick skin and a backbone. [0:20:45, 0:20:52]: And both are true. And anybody who knows me knows I stand firm on my yes and hard on my no. [0:20:52, 0:20:57]: And it has been a joy to work in a community that I live. [0:20:58, 0:21:10]: to help every day to make this place a better place. So I am so thankful and so honored to have been recognized. You just have no idea. My d dynamic duo staff. [0:21:11, 0:21:14]: Cassandra and Shahri, I could not do this without them. [0:21:14, 0:21:34]: The team here at the city of Stockbridge is so supportive and so amazing. My governing body for appointing me year after year after year to do what I do, I am so appreciative. So just thank you for everything. I really appreciate it. [0:21:34, 0:21:50]: Take this for us, please. Come on with your ladies, please. This right here should be good, I suppose. And I don't know if one of you want to hold the balloons as well. I mean come come on. Guess what? [0:21:51, 0:21:52]: Scary. [0:21:56, 0:22:08]: Okay, hold on one second. Oh, we need to have this in power. You can't hold it once you want to hold it. Alright, there you go. Alright, let's just do this. [0:22:10, 0:22:28]: Fantastic. There we go. All right. Thank you, ladies. Alright, that's all outstanding. Outstanding. Now the question is can we do this again? I don't know how soon we can do this again, but we'll we'll work at it and try to do it again sometime, okay? All right. Um is it cloud here? [0:22:28, 0:22:48]: Okay. All right. Well, ladies and gentlemen, that's it. If that's if we got here uh Rika Powell, if I'm here, that's the one I was supposed to swear next on the youth council advisory committee member, but uh we're gonna start our meeting roughly the ten minutes. So if she gets in for that, we'll do that. If not, we'll continue along with our meeting. You're more than welcome to stay as long as you like for the council. [0:22:48, 0:23:03]: is open to the public, always. Uh so uh thank you for being here and uh Scott Bridge is where for me to connect. Okay, you understand that's our little tag right on the bottom. But uh God bless you all and uh hang hang out if you want to hang out tonight. Okay, thank you. [0:23:20, 0:23:21]: Yeah, I want my content. [0:23:22, 0:23:25]: It's body, is it? [0:23:25, 0:23:30]: copying with some website and if it's a result. So it's in my [0:23:46, 0:23:48]: It's a lot of that. [0:23:50, 0:24:00]: Yeah. So it's uh second time is second time is not controlled. [0:24:10, 0:24:11]: Yeah, yeah. [0:24:12, 0:24:14]: Yeah, okay. [0:24:15, 0:24:15]: Right. [0:24:16, 0:24:25]: [1485.0, 1505.0]: Okay, it's all about talking for one button and we already did it on it, but yeah, we're all where we're after. [0:25:05, 0:25:11]: So quite. [0:25:11, 0:25:13]: But yeah, I'll be [0:25:25, 0:25:30]: I remember sitting here about it. Somehow. [0:25:32, 0:25:35]: So the the ladies come back in. [0:25:50, 0:25:54]: This is not good for the past. [0:25:57, 0:25:57]: You know what? [0:25:58, 0:26:00]: Are you doing it? [0:26:05, 0:26:07]: [1571.0, 1578.2]: Well congratulations. You start. Okay, yeah. Not all this local day or not. [0:26:18, 0:26:19]: No. [0:26:19, 0:26:20]: Yeah. [0:26:22, 0:26:28]: Yeah, uh, DJ was. [0:26:40, 0:26:42]: I never heard that. [0:35:15, 0:35:18]: All right, council, let's uh let's come to dial so we can get our meeting started, please. [0:35:42, 0:35:45]: But you see. [0:35:46, 0:35:47]: Yeah. [0:35:52, 0:35:54]: But I'll sit up. [0:35:56, 0:35:58]: Yeah. All right. [0:36:01, 0:36:02]: Okay. [0:36:04, 0:36:07]: All right, counselor, let's uh let's come to Dial so we can get our meeting started, please. [0:36:34, 0:36:42]: All right, ladies and gentlemen, I have uh six oh four and I'd like to call our city council meeting Monday, July eighth to order. [0:36:44, 0:36:50]: And the invocation, um, Doctor Gordine, could you please come to the mic? And if you're able to stand, please do so for the invocation. [0:36:56, 0:36:59]: Uh it ma is the mic make sure the mic's on? [0:37:04, 0:37:07]: Testing. Oh there you go. Thank you very much. [0:37:07, 0:37:11]: Heavenly Father, before we start this meeting today, [0:37:11, 0:37:13]: We want to begin with Thanksgiving. [0:37:13, 0:37:33]: During this meeting, we will discuss many things and make many decisions, but we never want to lose sight of our gratefulness to you. Thank you for your faithfulness and provision in our lives. Thank you for each person in this meeting and the unique talents and perspectives they bring. We thank you for the [0:37:33, 0:37:53]: the opportunity to gather together and work together towards a common a common goal. In your name we pray. Amen. Amen. Pledge allegiance, pledge allegiance to the flag, the United States of America, and to the Republic for withstand one nation, under God. [0:37:53, 0:37:55]: With liberty and justice for all. [0:37:56, 0:37:58]: Madam Clerk, roll call, please. [0:38:01, 0:38:05]: Mayor Ford. Present. Mayor Pro Tem Berry. [0:38:06, 0:38:23]: Let the record reflect. Mayor Pro Timberry is not an attendant. Councilmember Alexander. Present. Council Member Barber. Present. Council Member Gantt. Present. Council Member Thomas. Present. Mayor Ford, you have a quarter. Thank you, Madam Clerk. Council, I need a motion to adopt the agenda, please. [0:38:25, 0:38:28]: So move. Is there a second, Mr Alexander? Is there a second? [0:38:29, 0:38:31]: I'm Ms. Gantt second, all in favor please indicate. [0:38:32, 0:38:50]: Okay, thank you very much. Unanimous decision on that moment. And before you council, you have the adoption of the minutes, the amended uh joint uh Main Street Advisory Board, City of Stockbridge of course, and uh and our downtown development authority retreat minutes, uh which was back on thirteenth of uh April of twenty twenty four, and then our council meeting minutes of june tenth. [0:38:51, 0:38:56]: And also our work session minutes of June twenty sixth. If there no one changes out and need a motion to approve them, please. [0:38:56, 0:39:02]: So okay, okay. From Mr. Alexander to Miss Barber for a second, that as well. All in favor, please indicate. [0:39:03, 0:39:23]: Uh thank you very much. Madam Clerk, do we have any public comments at all? No public comments, Mayor. Okay, thank you very much. Okay, but before you uh just want to know for the ceremonial piece earlier today, uh we had several different swearing in ceremonies. Um we had Mr Kenyon Cook uh sworn in for the Downtown Development Authority. And then for Citywide Development Authority we had [0:39:23, 0:39:40]: uh Monica Jones, Kim Mays, and Ivory Sears to join that particular authority. So we welcome them, all of them on the particular committees there. And of course we had a special recognition of our own Vanessa Holliday as the Georgia Municipal Clerk Year of the Year, 2024. So congratulations to all the folks in the Vanessa as well. [0:39:43, 0:40:02]: So on that note, uh outstanding. I love doing those those ceremonial things and recognize individuals for the great help in this aspect. So uh what we have next is the presentation, council consideration approved the city of Stockbridge Citizens Police Advisory Council zone for replacement member application, presented by Chief Frank Tremor. Chief, please. [0:40:11, 0:40:13]: Good evening, Mayor and Council. Evening, sir. [0:40:14, 0:40:15]: Um [0:40:15, 0:40:25]: As you know, our Citizens Police Advisory Council, they've been doing a lot of great work. We had a successful car show uh this past uh well two weekends ago now. [0:40:25, 0:40:39]: We've got a number of other community events uh coming forward. And um our Citizen Police Advisory Council was actually nominated as a finalist uh for the Motorola Award of Excellence at the Georgia Chiefs conference this upcoming year. So they've been doing a lot of positive work in our community. [0:40:39, 0:40:45]: Uh as you know, there are twelve members that sit on that council. Uh one of our representatives that represents the [0:40:46, 0:40:51]: uh zone four area which is the Eagles landing community, uh Miss Diana Williams had to resign. [0:40:51, 0:40:54]: Which left us with a vacancy and uh Miss Judy Neal. [0:40:55, 0:41:02]: Has uh filed application to be considered for that vacancy for the uh zone four area. She currently serves as the [0:41:03, 0:41:06]: uh president of the village of eagles landing homeowners association. [0:41:06, 0:41:24]: And uh we would be asking the council to um uh appoint her to serve in that vacant board position this evening for zone four as a zone four representative. Thank you, Chief. Comments council representative um Okay, there's our motion to accept this uh nomination. So moved. Is there a second? [0:41:25, 0:41:26]: It's their second. [0:41:28, 0:41:30]: Miss Barber second then. All in favor, please indicate. [0:41:30, 0:41:31]: Yes. [0:41:31, 0:41:35]: Okay, sir approval. Okay, thank you sir. Appreciate it, Chief. [0:41:36, 0:41:56]: What we what we have next, ladies and gentlemen, we actually have a public hearing involving uh several uh one well, several issues here. And so what I'd like to do is read uh the public hearing rules at this time, and then I'll read through the each under the issues involving this particular uh variance code in this particular uh uh comprehensive plan amendment. [0:41:56, 0:42:02]: Amendment. Once again, for public hearing rules are please mute all cell phones and other electronic devices. [0:42:03, 0:42:08]: If anyone wishes to speak tonight on a public hearing item, please fill out the form available on the table. [0:42:08, 0:42:11]: and handed to the city clerk before approaching the podium. [0:42:11, 0:42:26]: After each case is called, the council will hear from the city staff, followed by the applicant or representative regarding the proposed plans for the property along with other other relevant information. The council will be free to s to ask questions at any time before the vote. [0:42:27, 0:42:39]: Following the applicant, anyone who wishes to speak in favor or opposed to the case will have the opportunity to do so. Each side will be allotted ten minutes total. Additional time may be extended at the discretion of the counsel. [0:42:39, 0:42:53]: Please keep comments and presentations professional referring to only to the facts that are pertinent to the case. We will not allow comments or personal attacks toward any individual or group. Please refrain from the applause or comments from the audience during the public hearing. [0:42:53, 0:43:05]: After the presiding officers recognize the speaker, he or she shall direct all comments to the presiding officer and never to the members of the council, staff, or the audience. All comments will be made from the podium where you [0:43:05, 0:43:08]: will be required to state your name and address for the record. [0:43:09, 0:43:11]: Please note that these hearings are not a debate. [0:43:12, 0:43:32]: Failure to comply will cause you to be removed from the chamber and the building by law enforcement if you deviate from those these proceedings. Other than the applicant, no person may speak more than once. The applicant may reserve part of his or her speaking time as rebuttal and may speak next and last and may use the entire ten minutes allowed [0:43:32, 0:43:34]: for the pro side of replication. [0:43:35, 0:43:39]: If questions are raised, the counsel may ask the applicant to address questions and or concerns. [0:43:39, 0:43:51]: The presiding officer will call for a motion and second to the motion and have any necessary discussion. If the matter is not tabled, the presiding officer will call for a vote to recommend approval or denial of the request. [0:43:53, 0:44:10]: Now we have several different items, well, several different things I'm gonna read, and then then Mr. Ryan Anderson will come forward to address uh all these issues. So this deals with a comprehensive plan amendment case, CP 2024-02, Council District number four. [0:44:10, 0:44:30]: The City of Stockbridge Planning Commission will hold any will hold a public meeting on Thursday, June 20th, 2024 at 630 p.m. And the city of Stockbridge Mayor and City Council will hold a public hearing on Monday, July 8th, 2024, at 6 p.m. in the Stockbridge City Hall, located at 4640 North Henry Boulevard. [0:44:30, 0:44:50]: Stockbridge, Georgia. To consider the request for the comprehensive plan amendment of property 111 Old Conyers Road to change the property's future land use designation to low of low density residential to special purpose to allow for the construction of a mixed-use development, including commercial and residential uses. The applicant is charged. [0:44:50, 0:45:10]: Charlie Hightower on behalf of the First National Land Trust LLC. The property is located in land lot 68 of District 12 with 6.71 plus and minus acres within the city limits, cyber city limits, and once again it'll be presented by Ryan Anderson. The rezoning case, RZ 2024-02, once again, council. [0:45:10, 0:45:30]: Of District 4. The City of Stockbridge Planning Commission will hold a public meeting on Thursday, June 20th, which happened on 2024 at 6:30 p.m. in the city uh the city of Starbury's mayor and city council will hold a public hearing on Monday, July 8th, 2024, 6 p.m. in the Starbury City Hall, located at 4640 North Anion Boulevard in Starbury. [0:45:30, 0:45:48]: Bridge, Georgia, to consider the request for the rezoning of the property at 111 O'Connors Road to rezone the property from SR Suburban Residential to PUD Plan Unit Development to allow for the construction of a mixed-use development including commercial and residential uses. The applicant is Charlie Hightower. [0:45:50, 0:46:10]: And on behalf of the First National Land Trust, LLC, the property is located in land lot 68 of District 12 with 6.71 acres within the Stopper City limits. The variance case RV 2024-01 Council District 4 variance is to reduce the parking requirements according to the number of bedrooms per [0:46:10, 0:46:27]: apartment unit, whereby whereby studio and one bedroom apartment units would have only one parking space instead of the required 1.2525 parking spaces per unit, and two bedroom units would have only have 1.25 parking spaces per unit instead of the 1.75 parking spaces per unit. [0:46:28, 0:46:45]: The City of Stockbridge Planning Commission will hold public meetings on once again on Thursday, June 2024 at 6 30 P.M. And the City of Stockbridge, Mayor and City Council will hold a public hearing on Monday, July 8th, 2024, at 6 PM in Stockbridge City Hall, located 4640 North Henry Boulevard in Stockbridge, Georgia. [0:46:46, 0:46:49]: You considered a request for three variances on property. [0:46:49, 0:47:09]: 111 Old Conyers Road to allow for the construction of mixed use development, including commercial and residential uses. The applicant once again is Charlie Hightower on behalf of First National Land Trust, LLC. The property is located on land lot sixty-eight of District twelve, six point seven one acres within the city limits uh stopbridge. Variance case RV twenty twenty four. [0:47:09, 0:47:29]: Council District 4 variants requests RV 2024-02 variants to modify the ground floor retail square footage requirement by changing the residential rental space ratio for the required ratio of 75% to 25% of the proposed ratio of 87.5 to 1. [0:47:29, 0:47:49]: Me, 12.5 percent. The City of Stockbridge Planning Commission will hold a public meeting on Thursday, June 20th, 2024. Uh at 6:30 p.m. The City of Stockbridge Mayor and City Council will hold a public hearing on Monday, July 8th, 2024, at 6 p.m. Stockbridge City Hall, located at 4640 North Annie Boulevard, Stockbridge, Georgia, to consider requests of [0:47:49, 0:48:09]: Three variances of the property 111 Old Conyers Road to allow for the construction of misuse development, including commercial and residential uses. The applicant is Charlie Hightower on behalf of the First National Land Trust LLC, a property located at the landlock 68 of a district 12 of 6.71 acres within the sea limits stop bridge. In a variance case, [0:48:09, 0:48:29]: ARV 2024-03, Council District 4, variance to increase the project destiny from 24 units per acre to 29 units per acre. The City of Stockbridge Planning Commission will hold a public meeting on Thursday, June 20th, 2024, 6:30 p.m. And the City of Stockbridge Mary City Council will hold a public hearing on Monday, July 8th, 2024. [0:48:29, 0:48:49]: It's 6 o'clock p.m. in the Stockbridge City Hall, located at 4640 North Antonio Boulevard in Stockbridge, Georgia, to consider a request for three variances of property at 111 Old Conyers Road to allow for the construction of mixed-use development, including commercial and residential usage. The applicant is Charlie Hightower on behalf of First National Land Trust LLC. The property is located. [0:48:48, 0:48:56]: Located landlot 68 of District 12, 6.71 acres within the city limits stop rate, presented by Mr. Ryan, please. [0:48:57, 0:49:17]: Mr. Ryan Anderson, I'm sorry, please. All right. Good evening. I'll present the cases in the in the order that the mayor read them into the record. The first um case we will address will be the um the comp plan. The applicant is proposing to go from low density residential to special purpose with a proposed density of 29.8 units. [0:49:17, 0:49:30]: units per acre on six point seven one acres of land. Here's a vicinity map. Um the site is highlighted in yellow and uh in the blocks uh are the [0:49:31, 0:49:47]: locations of businesses that are in the area. You got the Stock Bridge Public Works, Downtown Fool Mark, you got Cochrane Park Public Shopping Center, 55 Valley Hill Townhomes, and Diamante Townhomes are all in the vicinity. Here's an aerial photo of the site. [0:49:52, 0:49:59]: This is a um a photo of undeveloped land from a staff site visit on mark on May twenty-first, twenty twenty four. [0:50:00, 0:50:14]: Uh here's the location of the stream. Uh approximately three acres of the site contains floodplain. So here's um once sh uh a shot of one of the flood zone areas on the property. [0:50:16, 0:50:22]: This is the JSJ cleaners. This is the proposed access to the proposed mixed use development. [0:50:28, 0:50:44]: And uh also another lo a shot of the location of the stream and the Brush Creek Commons wetland that is associated with the property. Here's the layout of the proposed development um of the site plan. This is just conceptual and basis. It's subject to change. [0:50:51, 0:51:00]: Uh once again the applicant wanna change from low density resid residential to special purpose to allow for the construction of a mixed use development that would include both commercial and residential uses. [0:51:04, 0:51:24]: Here's the City of Stockbridge comprehensive plan map from 2023 to 2024. And you see that the special purpose district allows a density rate of 16.01 to 24 units per acre. It's a new concept that we recently included in our 2023 to 2028. [0:51:24, 0:51:28]: comprehensive plan that was voted on in October of last year. [0:51:31, 0:51:45]: Here's the future land use map of the uh area. Um you can see that we do do have one property in there in the area that was recently um had a company amendment to go to special purpose with a density rate of 16 units per acre. [0:51:45, 0:51:47]: And it's also on East Atlanta Road. [0:51:50, 0:52:04]: the surrounding um land use densities. You got the Spanish Village Subdivision, which contains 28 units and has a density rate of 1.5 units per acre. You got Duvall subdivision, which has 16 units [0:52:05, 0:52:07]: А то рейда он университет таунхом. [0:52:08, 0:52:09]: У шконтайс 100 units. [0:52:10, 0:52:30]: At a density rate of seven units per acre. D.R. Horton Town Homes, which is in the development phase, has 165 units at a density rate of 6.62 units per acre. 135 East Town Homes was the product I was referencing that was approved by council for a special purpose. [0:52:30, 0:52:38]: Purpose land use category. They have 27 units at a density rate of a little over 16 units per acre. Pine Grove. [0:52:40, 0:52:59]: has 270 units at a density rate of four units per acre. And Pine View has 77 units with 2.4 units per acre. The um the 135 East Atlanta Townhomes is the highest dense project in the city as a look at 16.36 acres per unit. [0:53:03, 0:53:11]: Um as it relates to the comp plans, staff recommend um approval of the change from um suburban residential to PUD. [0:53:14, 0:53:16]: Anyone have any questions before I go into the rezone? [0:53:17, 0:53:23]: Yeah, counselor. Any questions on the first piece there? Yeah, go ahead. Ms. Barber, go ahead. I do. [0:53:23, 0:53:28]: Yes now. Mr Ryan, yes. You said something was subject to change. [0:53:29, 0:53:40]: Uh the the site plan is conceptual. It it could pot it it could potentially change based on the outcome of this meeting tonight. Okay. Based on staff recommendations and whatever else that council may add. [0:53:41, 0:53:43]: Thank you, sir. Okay. [0:53:44, 0:53:51]: Any other questions on the on the first p piece of this? Okay. All right, R Ryan, keep going, sir. Yes, sir. [0:53:52, 0:54:04]: Mayor Ford, I do have a question. Each of these items are gonna be h heard separately? Yeah, well we'll vote on them separately, yes. We'll have to vote on separately. Okay. Thank you, sir. Uh-huh. [0:54:04, 0:54:15]: Uh the applicant is proposing to go from suburban residential to PUD to allow for the construction of a mixed use development that would include both commercial and residential uses. [0:54:17, 0:54:21]: Mr Aaron. Not Mr. Anderson. Mr. Anderson. I'm sorry. [0:54:21, 0:54:28]: You wanna vote you wanna vote on right as we I was gonna let him go all the way through. He and I discussed this earlier, but you prefer to vote e on each item as we go along? [0:54:29, 0:54:49]: All right, fine. We uh I mean I guess we could we can do that. Stand by. All right, so anyway, so what we have is well let me just uh say this comprehensive plan amendment, KCP twenty twenty-four-zero two, council district four, and let's say this is in reference to future land designation from low density residential to special purpose to allow for construction of misuse development, including [0:54:49, 0:55:09]: Commercial residential uses. Now, what I saw submitted to us certainly there need to be we we're gonna there's some revisions in the layout and that kind of thing that may be considered. So [0:55:08, 0:55:28]: Once we get to that point, then we would have all the information presented to us and have a full discussion before going back to vote. And you know what and I just thought about something too is a public hearing. I would before we do each I would have to open it up anyway. Right. I've just thought about that. But that's actually what that is actually what Mr. Anderson and I talked about originally, but I just realized something you you you [0:55:28, 0:55:45]: So let's let's stop for a second. All right, got two different types of concepts here. Anybody else got a thought process how you want to proceed on this? Mayor Ford. Considering I'm the district representative for this area. [0:55:46, 0:55:48]: Yeah, I'm not sure. [0:55:48, 0:55:53]: what I am requesting here. Well I considered that we just heard um the presentation. [0:55:54, 0:55:54]: From [0:55:54, 0:55:58]: Mr. Anderson regarding the comprehensive plan amendment. [0:55:58, 0:56:06]: Can we please ask the council if they have any questions? If they don't have any questions, move to the public hearing. [0:56:06, 0:56:08]: After we go through the public hearing. [0:56:08, 0:56:20]: Then the council, if they have any other questions, want to make comments, we do so and we vote on the item. Okay. [0:56:20, 0:56:21]: There is a public hearing. [0:56:22, 0:56:23]: For my district. [0:56:23, 0:56:25]: There's always controversy. [0:56:26, 0:56:27]: Always. [0:56:27, 0:56:28]: Be consistent. [0:56:29, 0:56:30]: That's all I'm asking for. [0:56:30, 0:56:39]: Stand by. All right, counsel. All right. We got two different types of opinions here. Understand? Anybody else got any comments initially before we move forward on anything else? Yes, ma'am. Go ahead, please. [0:56:40, 0:56:45]: Mayor, I don't object to anyone wanting the presentation to be heard. [0:56:46, 0:56:47]: Um [0:56:48, 0:56:49]: for their district [0:56:49, 0:56:54]: But the last couple of times, regardless of whose district it is, I thought we talked about [0:56:55, 0:57:06]: Letting Mr. Anderson go through the entire presentation. That's what I was doing. For all of that's what all of for for each for all of it. So that when we do a public hearing [0:57:06, 0:57:09]: the public can talk in regards to [0:57:09, 0:57:10]: All of it. [0:57:11, 0:57:23]: And then we can come back and d and vote on each single subject item. Right. That's where I was. Because we had done that in the past lately. I just thought that um [0:57:25, 0:57:29]: out of respect for time and constantly saying, okay, are you for this? Are you for this for this? [0:57:30, 0:57:32]: But they what happens is the public gets up. [0:57:33, 0:57:33]: And they're [0:57:34, 0:57:35]: Their discussion [0:57:35, 0:57:37]: Isn't about [0:57:38, 0:57:43]: one agenda line item that we're voting for, they're talking about the entire project. [0:57:43, 0:57:47]: And so m my concern is is that we've [0:57:48, 0:57:52]: We've now formed a pattern that we began working on where [0:57:52, 0:57:55]: Mr. Ryan would give his entire presentation. [0:57:56, 0:57:57]: And then [0:57:58, 0:58:00]: We would vote. No, and then the public [0:58:01, 0:58:15]: We have their comments, whether they're for or against. Right, right, right. And then we would go based off of the agenda item, we wouldn't vote on all of those, we vote one by one per the agenda item. That's correct. And we've been doing that consistently across the board. [0:58:16, 0:58:24]: For all, no matter what district it is. Okay. Stand by. So anybody on this side, you tell me have any comments one way or the other right now? Anybody have any comments on this side? [0:58:25, 0:58:26]: Yes, sir. Go ahead, please. [0:58:27, 0:58:29]: I I I think also um [0:58:30, 0:58:34]: For all of us to have a better understanding of the counts and the community. [0:58:34, 0:58:40]: With mister Anderson going through the full presentation, I'm I'm actually I'm agreeing [0:58:40, 0:58:55]: Uh so when we come in and even when um the citizen have their opportunity, they're looking at the full perspective as opposed to the individual. And I I think and I'm not [0:58:56, 0:59:01]: you know, the controversy whether, you know, we do it this way or that way at different times. [0:59:01, 0:59:07]: I I can't speak to that, but it just seemed logical that mister Anderson complete the full [0:59:07, 0:59:12]: uh presentation and then ask the question. All right. Back to you, Miss Barber. [0:59:13, 0:59:17]: Yes, Mayor Ford. Yes, sir. Yes, ma'am score. Go ahead. We all know. [0:59:18, 0:59:23]: If the council so chooses not to approve the comprehensive plan amendment. [0:59:24, 0:59:26]: Everything else is irrelevant. [0:59:27, 0:59:28]: That's the very first item. [0:59:29, 0:59:31]: That is the most important item. [0:59:32, 0:59:33]: So yes. [0:59:33, 0:59:36]: Mr. Anderson can c proceed with his [0:59:37, 0:59:40]: presentation full presentation. If you'd like. [0:59:40, 0:59:43]: But we all know this comprehensive plan amendment. [0:59:43, 0:59:45]: If it does not go through [0:59:45, 0:59:53]: We don't need to even hear about the rezoning case, the variance case, any of the variance cases. I don't want to prolong this meeting. [0:59:54, 0:59:55]: All right. [0:59:55, 1:00:15]: I thank you. Okay, for clarification. Clarification. Um, and I do understand the point uh councilwoman barber just made, but it is it my understanding that Mr. Anderson is going to present it all. Yes. But the vote will be individualized. Yeah, that's right. It'll be individual votes, yes sir. Right. Absolutely. Okay. Ms. Ryan, continue. [1:00:15, 1:00:19]: Continue on please. All right. All right. So the applicant is proposing um [1:00:21, 1:00:30]: To go from suburban rezoning to a PUD for um a mixed use development containing two hundred uh apartment units and commercial on the first floor. [1:00:33, 1:00:35]: Here's a look at the zoning map. [1:00:39, 1:00:46]: Here's another look at the layout, the proposed layout. Uh some of this stuff is repetitive from uh my previous presentation. [1:00:48, 1:00:54]: Uh also s something uh really important that this project would be in the tax allocation district for the city of Stockbridge. [1:01:03, 1:01:11]: Uh the distance the project will be point seven miles from the downtown center and point seven miles from the Stockbridge amphitheater. [1:01:14, 1:01:20]: Uh, this is a proposed breakdown in the number of units. Um, there will be a hundred and nineteen, well [1:01:22, 1:01:25]: There will be ninety five studio apartments. [1:01:26, 1:01:42]: 95 one bedrooms, six two bedrooms, and four three bedroom, two baths. That's what the applicant is proposing. Here's a rendering and elevation of the proposed development. You see a five-story um building with commercial down on the ground floor. [1:01:50, 1:02:00]: This is the uh first floor plan. You got retail three sections of retail and um parking on the first floor on the first level. [1:02:10, 1:02:11]: Uh staff basically um [1:02:12, 1:02:19]: recommended um approval with conditions for this proposed for the applicant proposal that the number of units will be reduced from [1:02:21, 1:02:41]: Staff recommend approval with conditions. The first condition is the number of proposed units will be reduced from 200 units to 160 units at a rate of 23.84 units per acre due to the maximum density allowed by the special purpose future land use designation, which is 24 units per acre. Flock cameras will be installed at the entrance of the [1:02:41, 1:02:50]: Mixed use development. On the eastern side of the subject property, a 25 land strip shall be extended past the pool area found in the conceptual site plan. [1:02:50, 1:02:57]: The front facade of the re residential building shall be compr comprised of not less than fifty percent of the combined materials such as brick, stone. [1:02:57, 1:03:00]: or stucco or a combination of brick and stone. [1:03:00, 1:03:04]: The remaining twenty percent may be comprised of stucco shake. [1:03:04, 1:03:06]: And or cementus fibro siding. [1:03:07, 1:03:08]: The side and rear. [1:03:08, 1:03:09]: Uh the side and rear. [1:03:10, 1:03:30]: Facade of the res residential building shall be comprised of any combination of primary materials, including brick, stone, and secondary materials, including stucco shape and/or cement fiberboard, but not to exceed 30% of the entire building. The color shell consists of a cohesive complementary palette, limited use of the [1:03:30, 1:03:37]: The accident color is permitted as long as they are not bright or fluorescent and complement the overall palette of the material. [1:03:37, 1:03:48]: The proposed mixed use development shall not exceed four stories. All parking spaces must be located in the rear of the building per section 2.52H1 of the Stockbridge Unified Development Code. [1:03:50, 1:03:56]: Okay, that's that's it for the uh rezoni. Staff recommended approval uh with conditions. [1:03:57, 1:04:17]: Okay. Any questions from thus far about this one? Customary ten foot multi-use path along the frontage. I don't see that you have that on there. Okay, we can add that as and certainly yeah, we start setting the precedence of decorative street lights. That's already in the code, that's why we didn't add it. The decorative street lights are [1:04:17, 1:04:37]: in the code? Uh uh what's sorry? So what was in the code? The sidewalks, the 10-foot sidewalks, that that's mandatory in a way by code. Yeah, but certainly we wanted along the entire frontage. It would be old Conyers Road and uh East Atlanta Road so that these residents and uh uh would be uh beholden to that and certainly [1:04:37, 1:04:57]: The thing that we introduced the last time was the decorative street lights as we attempt to move these standards because that's what's along here as well. So certainly those things had we had discussed in the previous zoning. And certain I and I look at this and I look at what we did over at [1:04:57, 1:05:17]: Jodeco certainly with when the final layout is done. I think Jodeco is really the template of where we really need to go in terms of how it's developed with the parking enclosed, around, not visible. You know, the old school is you drive. [1:05:16, 1:05:36]: up and you're looking at the back of cars and you're looking at this unattractive parking lot versus the new standard where Jodeco set out to do, which is to have the building front the street and then have the parking uh be wrapped and enclosed uh inside that so uh you know as well and then the stairwells would be hidden [1:05:36, 1:05:47]: uh inside the structure where it would look like the Jodico looks, which is the town home look, versus looking like a traditional apartment kind of setup. [1:05:53, 1:05:55]: Yes, sir. Go ahead, Mayor Prota. [1:05:55, 1:06:15]: Uh Mr. Anderson, can you go back to the slide regarding the uh ratio of the apartments? I sa I think I saw the uh a higher proportion of studio apartments as opposed to two and three. That may have been because they originally proposed two hundred and fifty-seven units. So we've uh um we've had them to cut it down. When they first submitted it was [1:06:15, 1:06:22]: I think like two hundred and fifty seven. Is that what you're looking for? Yes. And and so what's the uh [1:06:22, 1:06:26]: N now they're proposing uh two hundred, but staff is recommending a hundred and sixty. [1:06:27, 1:06:47]: And of the hundred and sixty, how many are studios? Uh they haven't they haven't come back because we haven't come back. We don't know the outcome of this meeting yet. Okay. So certain certainly when they do come back, I I I think we should probably put more of a focus on um multifamily, like a larger family, like two and three bedrooms than so many studios. It seemed like there was a a higher [1:06:47, 1:06:51]: Yes, it was. Mm-hmm. [1:06:55, 1:06:57]: So you were proposing that as a potential condition? [1:06:58, 1:07:00]: You got this. I'm right there now. [1:07:01, 1:07:05]: Yes, but what what's uh okay. I you can y well yes yes ma'am, go ahead, please. [1:07:07, 1:07:13]: Um, I kinda begged to differ if I can I can't really see this number of studios. I I kinda get it though. [1:07:14, 1:07:18]: It's ninety five, ninety five, um six two bedrooms and [1:07:19, 1:07:23]: Four three bedrooms. Well, the the more multifamily you have [1:07:25, 1:07:28]: It becomes it seems like to me [1:07:29, 1:07:49]: Um the trend is more like for yuppies, young urban professionals. So if you if you mi get more three bedroom, you're talking a different type of atmosphere compared to the commercial at the bottom, this live, work and play environment where those families [1:07:49, 1:07:54]: usually go to maybe a home a a home or start a home. [1:07:55, 1:08:03]: instead of like a studio that looks like this is more for young urban professionals. So the studios are more popular. [1:08:03, 1:08:04]: Thank you. [1:08:04, 1:08:24]: Also think of more like roommate style as well. So like if you have a roommate, two working people who who are sharing the load or maybe even an office. Yeah. Definitely more two bed I was thinking more two bedrooms. Yeah. Because the the number is I think four. Four, three, and six, two. Two six six two bedrooms. Yeah. [1:08:24, 1:08:33]: Yeah. Um for instance, um, there's an apartment complex that is being built in my area. Um [1:08:34, 1:08:38]: And it's uh supposed to have a lot of commercial components to it. [1:08:38, 1:08:58]: And they may have a two-bedroom, but that that second bedroom is really like an office space. Exactly. Exactly. Um, it's small. So you know, there's no playground that's a part of this development. So the probably the more the feel and the vibe and intentions, I guess we can listen to you know, one of the [1:08:58, 1:09:04]: developers or whatever was for a particular crowd. Okay. That's what that's purpose was. [1:09:05, 1:09:07]: Any other comments on this issue, this particular issue? [1:09:08, 1:09:18]: I do. I'll go right. Mr. Anderson, can you talk about the the bottom floor of this proposed development? Okay. The commercial component. [1:09:24, 1:09:26]: Let me find that slide, Councilmember Barker. [1:09:29, 1:09:33]: Okay, here's this the first floor, yes. So there's [1:09:36, 1:09:50]: There are three store frontages for um residential stores. Like I said, this probably will change after tonight, more than likely will, but this is what they're proposed originally. [1:09:51, 1:09:51]: So [1:09:54, 1:09:58]: Со диспропос чан то за спас рачь. [1:09:59, 1:10:02]: Was that something suggested by staff or was that? [1:10:02, 1:10:22]: Well they they applied for a variance that's one of the variances. They tried to they wanted to have a uh a a certain percentage of residential versus commercial. So that's but there there is no provision in the UDC for that. There's nothing in the code regulating that. So we tossed that variance out. But it was advertised so we kept it down. [1:10:22, 1:10:25]: But we will we won't really discuss it tonight. [1:10:26, 1:10:36]: Thank you, sir. Um Mayor Ford. Yes, ma'am. Um, I do have a series of concerns in regards to this proposal. Um [1:10:37, 1:10:40]: One, I think we the council. [1:10:41, 1:10:44]: Just had discussions in regards to Splost. [1:10:45, 1:10:46]: He's lost. [1:10:47, 1:10:52]: There was no mention of any infrastructure improvements along. [1:10:52, 1:10:53]: East Atlanta Road. [1:10:54, 1:10:55]: Nor O'Connors Road. [1:10:56, 1:10:59]: The area is already congested. [1:11:00, 1:11:03]: I know that we cannot consider roads. [1:11:03, 1:11:04]: As a [1:11:05, 1:11:07]: point to deny any [1:11:07, 1:11:08]: Zoning. [1:11:09, 1:11:10]: Applications. [1:11:12, 1:11:18]: The slide that you showed with the uh surrounding land use. Yes. [1:11:18, 1:11:20]: Can you show that again, please? [1:11:23, 1:11:23]: Okay. [1:11:24, 1:11:28]: So the Spanish village subdivision [1:11:29, 1:11:31]: Which is this the one you're talking about? [1:11:31, 1:11:36]: No, um in our books is page three. [1:11:36, 1:11:37]: Page three. [1:11:38, 1:11:42]: The title is Surrounding Land Use Densities. [1:11:44, 1:11:51]: It's a chart that shows the name of the subdivisions, okay. The developments, the units, the estimate density per acres. [1:11:53, 1:11:54]: Right here. [1:11:57, 1:12:02]: Right. That that one. Right there. Yes. Um Spanish Village Subdivision. [1:12:03, 1:12:07]: Is that off East Atlanta or O'Connors Road? Yes. [1:12:07, 1:12:19]: Okay. Um this H H Duval subdivision. Yeah, these are all the surrounding um no no similar developments. I'm asking specifically about East Atlanta and Old Connors Roads. Okay. Yeah. [1:12:20, 1:12:25]: is this H H Duval subdivision that's off East Atlanta. [1:12:25, 1:12:26]: Let me see. [1:12:27, 1:12:38]: Or old Conyers.'Cause I'm I just want to focus on those developments or land uses that are within a mile. [1:12:40, 1:12:42]: of this proposed development. [1:12:43, 1:12:45]: You've listed Pine Grove and Pineview. [1:12:46, 1:12:51]: They're both more than two, three miles from this proposed development. [1:12:51, 1:12:55]: I just wanna look at just a slide with the with the with the streets on it. [1:12:55, 1:12:56]: Sorry, say it again. [1:12:57, 1:13:02]: I said I I pulled up the slide that has the streets. Okay. The addresses on I mean the struct the roads on it. [1:13:03, 1:13:05]: Okay, this H H Duval subdivision. [1:13:06, 1:13:07]: Where is that? [1:13:07, 1:13:27]: Uh it's down at the bo at the south of Spanish Village. Uh right in front of Clark Community Park. Um Oh okay, so that's not even anywhere near. It's in the vicinity. Oh we try to get it anywhere near where all of them are. It's at least two, three miles away. The Del Monte town homes is [1:13:27, 1:13:31]: um close by. The D. R. Horton town homes [1:13:31, 1:13:33]: have been approved and they are [1:13:33, 1:13:35]: close by to this development. [1:13:36, 1:13:38]: The one thirty five east town homes. [1:13:39, 1:13:42]: It's closed. Are those the twenty seven three story townhomes? Yes. Okay. [1:13:44, 1:13:46]: All right, so [1:13:46, 1:13:47]: For me [1:13:47, 1:13:53]: Looking at just if you'll go back to that slide that shows the surrounding land use densities. [1:13:55, 1:13:56]: It's only three of them. [1:13:57, 1:14:07]: That are in the vicinity of where this proposed development will be. The Del Monte town homes, the D.R. Horton town homes, and the 135 East Town homes. [1:14:09, 1:14:09]: Okay. [1:14:12, 1:14:26]: Well we just expanded our vis vicinity out a little further just to incorporate um similar developments. Okay. Town home developments, anything MFR. These are town homes in single vam family homes. [1:14:28, 1:14:29]: There are no apartments. [1:14:30, 1:14:34]: No, there are no apartments. Okay. Yes. Thank you, sir. All right. [1:14:35, 1:14:48]: Go go ahead, sir. Yeah, the last note that I had was uh the E V charging station r that we uh implemented in several developments to would be certainly a condition I would suggest. Yes, sir. Thank you. Got that. All right. [1:14:49, 1:14:58]: Right. Uh any other question on this particular part? If you I want to um I want to go to the um the traffic study that they go ahead. Um [1:14:59, 1:14:59]: Who was her? [1:15:01, 1:15:21]: Um they have a traffic study. Uh and um we did look at this uh analysis of their um traffic study and it stated that one of the reasons why we went with the um with a higher density base was based particularly on some information from the traffic. [1:15:21, 1:15:40]: traffic study um stating that um the road and infrastructure system could handle the increase of uh traffic increase of daily trips from this development. So they did do a traffic study and that's the chart on the on the screen now. [1:15:40, 1:15:40]: Okay. [1:15:42, 1:15:49]: Yes sir. Yes ma'am, sorry. Go ahead please. Okay, so they've already performed a traffic study. Yes, ma'am. Um [1:15:50, 1:15:52]: Del Monte Townhomes. [1:15:52, 1:15:54]: The ones with the two hundred? [1:15:54, 1:15:59]: units. Yes. Mm they are still in the process of building. So [1:16:00, 1:16:01]: You won't capture [1:16:02, 1:16:03]: The travel. [1:16:03, 1:16:03]: Yes. [1:16:04, 1:16:05]: On this traffic study. [1:16:06, 1:16:06]: Nor would I [1:16:07, 1:16:09]: Have any traffic count? [1:16:09, 1:16:13]: For the D R Horton town homes, that's a hundred and sixty five units. [1:16:14, 1:16:26]: That's true. I don't know if this traffic study is really even valid um at this point. Is there an engineer here to speak in on behalf of this traffic study? [1:16:28, 1:16:29]: Uh do you have the engineering? [1:16:32, 1:16:36]: No, he's not. They're injured their trafficking is not present. Thank you, sir. All right. [1:16:39, 1:16:45]: I have no other question on this portion, then uh Ms. Ryan, continue on please. Okay, now I'll go into the um variances. [1:16:49, 1:17:09]: Uh applicants are requesting the variant to reduce the parking requirements according to the number of bedrooms per unit. So um, and modify the ground floor retail ratio square footage by changing the residential to retail ratio from the required 75 to 25 to a proposed 87.5%. [1:17:09, 1:17:29]: To 12.5 and increase um number two. Uh like I previously mentioned, there is no provision in the UDC for this. So this will be contingent upon uh the conceptual site plan that is approved by um council tonight um in the conditions uh because he's going to PUD and um [1:17:29, 1:17:30]: Yeah. [1:17:30, 1:17:36]: the the zoning will be a will be based on the PUD zoning. So the site plan will be conditioned on on the zoning. [1:17:36, 1:17:37]: Based on [1:17:38, 1:17:58]: What we come to agreement to on tonight. And the last one is increase the project density from 24 units per acre to 29 units per acre. Staff recommend a reduction in the total required number of um parking spaces to 30 by by 30. Uh the calculation that the applicant did was um was off because it was [1:17:58, 1:18:18]: was based on 257. So they were closer to the um to meeting the parking requirement than they originally proposed because they they they uh went down to a reduction of 200 units and uh and we don't know what type of commercial spaces they will have now um that won't be resolved until later uh after the meeting [1:18:18, 1:18:18]: And uh [1:18:19, 1:18:39]: So the we'll we recommend approval of a parking reduction of 30 units for variance number one. And uh variance number two, modifying the ground retail square footage requirement by changing the residential to retail space ratio from the required 75 to 25 to a proposed ratio of 87.5 to 12.5. Like I previously mentioned, that will be. [1:18:39, 1:18:50]: be part of the um of the conceptual site plan, uh the approved site plan that the zoning will be conditioned on. So whatever the applicant proposed in his final site plan, it will be conditioned on that number. [1:18:51, 1:19:07]: uh increase the project density from twenty-four units per acre to twenty-nine units per acre. Um staff recommended denial on that one because our comp plan do not allow a density rate in the city of Stockbridge over twenty-four units per acre. As I previously mentioned the the most dense project in the city. [1:19:08, 1:19:20]: It's currently sixteen point three six units per acre. Um the applicant's proposal twenty-nine units per acre would be more than a fifty percent increase over what is currently allowed in the city. And we just recently um [1:19:21, 1:19:24]: Updated our comp plan to increase our density rate from [1:19:24, 1:19:38]: from a high of sixteen units per acre to twenty-four units per acre. So um at this time stealth doesn't feel like twenty-nine per unit per acre is feasible and nor is it in in uh compliance with the UDC. So we have to recommend denial on that one. [1:19:40, 1:19:41]: So that's it. [1:19:41, 1:20:01]: All right. Any questions, Council, before we open up public hearing? Any additional questions thus far? Uh yes, go ahead, Ms. Thomas. Um I don't see Mr. Aaron. Um Okay. Maybe Mr. Gardner could expound on this. Mr. Gardner, could you come to the podium please? [1:20:05, 1:20:16]: Mr. Gardner, I know from our perspective and in uh approving or not approving many of these developments. [1:20:16, 1:20:34]: I want to sort of get into the impact that it would have on the city as far as our responsibilities, especially public works. Um, can you express any I guess concerns or [1:20:35, 1:20:38]: how it will impact, you know, public works. [1:20:38, 1:20:58]: the city's responsibility um with developments as we are sort of going forward because you know over time um as we continue to develop the city uh is from our perspective are we keeping up. It's public work [1:20:58, 1:21:00]: Yeah. [1:21:01, 1:21:07]: Yes. So this development obviously because of where it's located would be on city water and sewer. [1:21:08, 1:21:13]: By where it's located. Um, as you know, the majority of the city and when new development is happening. [1:21:13, 1:21:16]: Uh, a lot of that is actually Henry County. [1:21:17, 1:21:37]: um water and sewer or further north from here, there's Clayton County water and sewer um that also serves par parts of the city. But this would be on our water and sewer. It's my understanding that the water and sewer infrastructure is adequate to serve this proposal in terms of its [1:21:37, 1:21:57]: Capacity, uh daily load. Um, obviously, uh they did a traffic study, so there'll be traffic generated on the on the roadways. Um we just think we just resurfaced old Konyas, if I'm not mistaken. Um and then I think the um as it relates to East Atlanta Railway [1:21:57, 1:22:00]: Road. I think that's on the splos, if I'm not mistaken. [1:22:00, 1:22:01]: On the county side. [1:22:02, 1:22:06]: Um and as well as on our side, but obviously that has to be approved. [1:22:07, 1:22:13]: Um, for splus six. Um, outside of that, I mean it's a wholly private development on private land. [1:22:13, 1:22:19]: Um the impacts would obviously be just cars coming in and out, but that's typical. You have it over there at the shopping center. [1:22:20, 1:22:20]: Um [1:22:21, 1:22:39]: the water and sewer is adequate enough to serve this development. Um obviously at some point as development happens in that corridor, even more so, we have to look at capacity for new development. How do we improve um our ability to treat um sewer in that area? [1:22:43, 1:22:57]: Yeah, Mr. Alzheimer's. Yeah, talk about I didn't say what about uh in terms of the improvements, the traffic improvements, uh XL and D cell lane required on these particular properties for act or during the uh ingress and egress? [1:22:58, 1:23:03]: Yes, there will be um let me go back, see what the study says. [1:23:43, 1:23:46]: Yeah, he got in presentation mode. [1:23:50, 1:23:50]: Mm-hmm. [1:23:55, 1:24:00]: That's the ingress, ingress. Deceleration line. Yeah, where? [1:24:02, 1:24:04]: Yeah. [1:24:04, 1:24:05]: Yeah. [1:24:09, 1:24:10]: Which way? Oh. [1:24:14, 1:24:15]: Okay, uh I [1:24:15, 1:24:17]: Yeah, they are and have counsel my melee down. [1:24:18, 1:24:21]: Okay, so so they are on there? Yes, they're. Right in there. [1:24:24, 1:24:36]: And the other thing that I think that they were doing now in these uh multi fa is like a school bus shelter or something like that where there's a central pickup location for the kids. Okay, so you do have that is in there. [1:24:37, 1:24:52]: We can add it as a condition, but it's required by code. Just wanna make sure that that that is applicable. Okay, just wanna make sure it's there. All right. [1:24:54, 1:25:09]: Any other questions right now? Miss Barber first am I? Ms. Barber, go ahead, but Mr. Anderson, there is only one entry and exit point to this development, proposed development, correct? Um I think let me double check. I think so. [1:25:10, 1:25:10]: Mm-hmm. [1:25:20, 1:25:21]: Thought they had more and more. [1:25:24, 1:25:25]: Second yeah. [1:25:33, 1:25:34]: So there are um [1:25:36, 1:25:37]: Yeah. [1:25:39, 1:25:43]: There's a one, two, looks like three. [1:25:45, 1:25:46]: What are you counting? [1:25:47, 1:25:47]: Let's see. [1:25:49, 1:25:57]: I see this main entrance off the the intersection of Old Cunnyers and East Atlanta Road. And you see this where my cursor is? [1:25:58, 1:25:58]: Mm-hmm. [1:25:59, 1:26:00]: That's just one. [1:26:01, 1:26:05]: What about the what about it? Entry and exit point. So it's two. [1:26:06, 1:26:07]: Two [1:26:08, 1:26:11]: If you see if you follow what my curse is, when you follow the pink arrow. [1:26:12, 1:26:17]: That's one access point. Yeah, then you come up to the front right here. Oh it's off of O'Connor's. [1:26:19, 1:26:19]: Correct. [1:26:20, 1:26:25]: Why yes, yes, yes. Okay. Yeah. Mr. Garner, I know we talked about [1:26:28, 1:26:40]: Did they consider anything off of East Atlanta Road? With this kind of density, um with this kind of density, there needs to be multiple access points and this doesn't have it. [1:26:44, 1:27:00]: So in order for them to be able to get off onto Old Cornis Road, they would have one, this is the only point of con not Old Cornish but Eastern Landa Road. This area here is the only area where they actually truly abuts Eastern Landa Road. [1:27:00, 1:27:20]: I'm sorry, ma'am. So if you see my curse the cursor moving right here. Mm-hmm. That is the only area where their property line actually abuts East Atlanta Road. Most of their frontage is on old corners. So they wouldn't be able to get um an access point at this point at this point because it's so close to the the intersection. Uh like [1:27:20, 1:27:40]: There's no way that it could get that that that would be approved. Um, it would just cost chaos. Um outside of that, they would have to acquire property on the other side, cross that creek and the wetlands, which obviously would be cost prohibitive, acquire land and then be able to get an access point onto [1:27:40, 1:27:50]: um onto Eastern Lana Road. That's the only place they can. Most of their frontage is on old Cornus and that's where they're illustrating their access point into the property. [1:27:51, 1:27:51]: Okay. [1:27:54, 1:27:58]: Thank you, sir. Mr. Thomas. Um [1:27:58, 1:27:59]: Uh [1:27:59, 1:28:09]: Two two things. I really had really one question, but that discussion led me into the second one. And and I know we don't get into traffic, but [1:28:10, 1:28:14]: Thing one of the things that I'm concerned about on old Cunny is [1:28:14, 1:28:22]: and with the various schools down the street, especially Stockbridge High School, uh football season and graduation. [1:28:24, 1:28:44]: It is crazy on old cunions. And I just don't know how this is going to affect folks living in that subdivision when it comes to football season and graduation. I just want to throw that out. My original question, uh [1:28:44, 1:29:04]: Dennis, if you could just go back to street lights, and I just want to be clear and I wanted everybody to be clear about it. Who pays for that? I just want that to be out. I I'm okay with it, but I just want to make sure that everyone understands these decorative poles of streetlights. [1:29:04, 1:29:05]: Like, who pays for that? [1:29:07, 1:29:09]: But we request the data. [1:29:09, 1:29:15]: Yeah. Well I I'm just saying I just want it to be spoken. Yeah, that the app the developer. Yeah. [1:29:17, 1:29:20]: I I just wanted to be spoken out loud. [1:29:20, 1:29:30]: That the d H O A will have to pay the um the the street light bill for the development. Thank you. Yeah, put that as a condition too case it isn't. [1:29:31, 1:29:36]: All right, any other questions right now? Um Mr. Hightower is here, is that correct? [1:29:37, 1:29:38]: Yes, sir. [1:29:38, 1:29:40]: Represent. Come come on up, sir, please. [1:29:41, 1:29:41]: Well. [1:29:44, 1:29:51]: Your name and address uh Cassius Coleman, uh five ten Stone Glen Chase, City of South Fulton. [1:29:52, 1:29:55]: He she wasn't able to hear the Cross got to hear speaking of mic, please. [1:29:55, 1:29:59]: Cassius Coleman, five ten, Stone Glenn Chase. [1:29:59, 1:30:01]: City of South Fulton. [1:30:02, 1:30:09]: Okay, so you're representing Mr. Hightower here, I guess. Uh I'm the developer. Uh Charlie is the uh I call him the horizontal guy. I'm the vertical guy. [1:30:10, 1:30:30]: Okay. So anything that you need to say to the council before we open the public hearing or anything that you or the mayor have some questions, the council may have a question for you specifically. Go ahead, sir. Uh absolutely. Uh first and foremost, I want to say thank you for at least getting this far and uh staff for approving uh most of what we're asking for. Um uh we [1:30:30, 1:30:40]: We chose Stockbridge for obvious reasons. It's it's a really great place. Uh we actually have a development over in McDonough, so we're familiar with Henry County. Um [1:30:40, 1:30:44]: And saw that this was a pretty good opportunity based on the location. [1:30:45, 1:30:46]: А і хай майже [1:30:47, 1:30:49]: you know, grocery store across the street. [1:30:49, 1:31:00]: with some retail um and then your proximity to what I'm considering um a place where everybody comes and having development [1:31:00, 1:31:08]: You know, in a strategic location like that, I think does a lot for the city. Um, I couldn't believe this property was actually available. [1:31:09, 1:31:10]: Um [1:31:10, 1:31:10]: So [1:31:11, 1:31:13]: Іно, ам'їрс, а гит. [1:31:13, 1:31:16]: Um people are always concerned about development. [1:31:16, 1:31:17]: But [1:31:17, 1:31:22]: Uh, we're doing a project in uh Union City right now. It's three hundred twenty units. [1:31:22, 1:31:23]: Five acres of [1:31:23, 1:31:24]: commercial. [1:31:25, 1:31:31]: Uh now granted, same issues came up because people that live in communities sometimes do not like to see [1:31:32, 1:31:33]: Um I I won't say [1:31:34, 1:31:36]: Anything but they only want to see what they want. [1:31:36, 1:31:39]: But to get what you want sometimes you have to [1:31:39, 1:31:41]: Sacrifice a little bit. [1:31:41, 1:31:43]: Density brings a lot. [1:31:44, 1:31:45]: It brings [1:31:45, 1:32:00]: better businesses, more development, more tax dollars. And I think that's you know that's how you grow. I think there are thirty-five, thirty-six thousand folks in um Stockbridge. Um [1:32:00, 1:32:04]: And it's probably comfortable and I know sometimes density scares people, but [1:32:05, 1:32:11]: I I just think it makes sense. Um and the type of development we're trying to do and we are trying to to your point [1:32:11, 1:32:12]: Um [1:32:13, 1:32:20]: You know, workforce, younger folks, downtown supporting the businesses. Um, I'm actually doing a senior development in [1:32:21, 1:32:21]: And um [1:32:22, 1:32:24]: In the city of South Fulton, in the Santa area. [1:32:24, 1:32:25]: Uh [1:32:26, 1:32:26]: And [1:32:28, 1:32:33]: You know, the city council woman that came to me and asked for that because they didn't have any market rate senior. [1:32:34, 1:32:35]: And they're growing. [1:32:35, 1:32:42]: At an exponential rate, as you already know, and so is Union City, because they are allowing some of this development, although they hate apartments. [1:32:43, 1:32:59]: But they know they need them in order to k continue to grow. Increase your tax space. This is a fifty million dollar project. Um I I I think the positives far outweigh the negatives. Okay. Council, kind of questions you may have. Ms. Gantt, go ahead, please. [1:33:00, 1:33:05]: Mayor, I don't have a question. I have more so of a comment to my colleagues and just in general. [1:33:05, 1:33:08]: I think this type of development is [1:33:08, 1:33:12]: Well the last time we went on a retreat, we saw an area that we really liked. [1:33:13, 1:33:17]: And we saw the type of lifestyle, the living [1:33:17, 1:33:37]: And the different developments that were nearby. I think this fits because it's literally almost right across the street from a park, right? And it's so close to our amphitheater. It is close, it's gonna be close to our uh youth and senior our community center. I call it community center, but youth and senior center, it's gonna be close to [1:33:37, 1:33:43]: [5624.1, 5627.4]: a great example of what we want our downtown [1:33:47, 1:34:07]: To be. And it's in our downtown area. It's within that vicinity. And I appreciate you bringing this development to us. Um, I say that because it's part to me, it's part of our vision and it makes sense. Um, when we look on other areas that we want to do something very similar. [1:34:07, 1:34:09]: Similar. [1:34:10, 1:34:16]: That may cause us to have to buy a lot of properties or homes or whatever, but we have a developer that's ready to go. [1:34:17, 1:34:23]: And um it's something that we've been planning and longing for and I so I I love it. I love the idea. [1:34:23, 1:34:30]: because it fits within what we are trying to do for our downtown. And it is in our downtown. So thank you. [1:34:30, 1:34:38]: Yeah, talk about you said uh good. I'm glad you're already in the community already. What development is that in McDonough? [1:34:38, 1:34:58]: Um so our JV partner uh Dominium um did a deal. I'm that's been about four years ago. Uh it's about two hundred and forty plus units. Um those are apartments, but that was a tax credit deal. So a lot different from what we're saying, which is market rate. So that [1:34:58, 1:35:13]: That's a huge difference actually. Certainly. Uh that's a that's a big deal. Um talk about uh you said you're doing something over in in Union City too. Talk about that project a little bit. Yeah, so um right at the corner of Hall Road and Highway 92. [1:35:14, 1:35:25]: directly across from a public's, uh 21 acres, uh 320 units, and five acres of uh commercial fronting um Highway 92. [1:35:25, 1:35:45]: which is right down the street from Langston Hughes High School, Renaissance, and I mean so so many similarities. I mean it you you can't make this up. It's very similar. And um uh Mayor Vince uh really welcomed it. Now they have a tremendous amount of jobs have come to that area. [1:35:45, 1:36:04]: But once again, that's how you attract. You know, you got Grady that just announced, you know, two months ago or a little bit less, they're putting a new hospital over there. So that's how you get these other uses into a community. You have to have the bodies to support it. [1:36:04, 1:36:24]: Well certainly we've seen that over at Joe Dakota density has really paid off. Talk about the ameniti this is the lifestyle that they deserve uh is that the the these amenities, the young people want to be there on the f on the property to be able to use these amenities. Talk about the amenities that you included in your various projects. Um so [1:36:24, 1:36:25]: Uh [1:36:26, 1:36:46]: A lot of it's based on the property itself, what we can do outside versus inside. You know, the basic stuff will be there, the gym and uh storage lockers, um, uh obviously a pool. Um uh we like to do amenity decks, gazebos, uh a lot of things to get people out of the units. [1:36:46, 1:36:50]: Uh the same thing we do with our seniors. Uh we want them out of the units, out of the building. [1:36:51, 1:37:07]: because you know that's a better lifestyle. So we try to plant as much around the outside of the property as we can, uh walking trails, uh dog parks if there's enough land. We're doing that in Union City, by the way. We have a dog park um and we're [1:37:07, 1:37:22]: Because we have twenty one acres, we're even doing private garages. So um a lot of it is really, really based on now. We're limited here because of the weapons. We would like to do a lot more. Uh we're just gonna make that green space, obviously. [1:37:22, 1:37:32]: So the the private garages are always something that the residents like, especially the young people. And uh talk about um your god uh your [1:37:34, 1:37:45]: I uh lost my train of thought there. I'm sorry, we'll come back to it. Thank you. Uh Mr. Thomas Quay, sir. Uh Mayor, my last question. Um [1:37:45, 1:38:05]: Sir, over the years we've had in the city of Stark Bridge many uh focused groups um asking citizens what they want to see in Stark Bridge, in particular downtown. And what I like about mixed use, uh I really like the commercial. [1:38:05, 1:38:06]: [5886.9, 5906.9]: I know it's a little premature and you may not be able to speak to the type of commercial and I know that these are not standalone, you know, commercial entities. Um, but do you have any focus that you may can expound on as far as [1:38:26, 1:38:30]: what some of that commercial may look like. [1:38:30, 1:38:50]: Um I would be lying if I said yes. However, we use the shopping center group, which is probably the number one um brokerage firm in the country, uh at least in the southeast. We're using them over in Union City. I'm using them on a property down in Deerfield Beach. Um they basically are [1:38:50, 1:39:10]: Charged with doing the feasibility study to see what works and what doesn't. Now, as I spoke to staff, uh we're all we're very open to what you don't want, and you can put that in the conditions. No liquor stores, no, you know, all the kind of stuff that most neighborhoods don't want to see. Um we're we're on board for that, but uh [1:39:09, 1:39:16]: Um I'm gonna leave that up to the people who know that space the best, uh which is the shopping center group. [1:39:18, 1:39:38]: Okay, let me I got caught my train of thought. So in terms of where we're trying to go, like you said, the you know the the professional. So what is the uh the target for your rates in terms of a one bedroom, two bedroom? Quality certainly dictates a higher price. Well, y you you're gonna make me say this now. That's why we asked for more density. [1:39:38, 1:39:42]: Um uh the the issues with development now, we got high interest rates. [1:39:43, 1:39:45]: Uh construction costs are still somewhat inflated. [1:39:46, 1:39:48]: So great. [1:39:48, 1:39:51]: You know, higher unit count uh will improve your yield. [1:39:52, 1:40:10]: And basically that that's how you get financed. Um more is always better, but doesn't always work. So we understand that. Um but we're we're looking at, you know, for one bedroom, fourteen, fifteen hundred dollars, uh be well, I'm sorry. [1:40:10, 1:40:19]: depending on the size. We're about a buck fifty a square foot is what we think is going to come in at. And that's pretty much standard, I think, for the area. [1:40:20, 1:40:22]: So a thousand square feet would be about fourteen hundred dollars. [1:40:23, 1:40:26]: See, we're getting about seventeen or eighteen hundred over at Jodico. [1:40:27, 1:40:47]: Okay. Well we that's I would love to get that. That's that's the old template that we were looking for, but yeah, that rate has changed since the development quality has changed over there. So they're, you know, getting upwards of twenty five, twenty six hundred for three minute rule. I I don't think that's feasible in a lot of places to be quite frank, and and we don't want to [1:40:47, 1:41:07]: get there. Now we're not gonna sacrifice quality, you know, for that, but um um have to be real careful about it. I'm not trying to encourage you to raise the price. Oh no no I understand I'm not trying to do that. I just want to see where you're gonna be at and just have you kind of calibrate the market uh in terms of that down there. That's the higher end and [1:41:07, 1:41:13]: And then certainly so you're talking about maybe around four fifteen hundred or something like that. Yeah. But when a two bedroom would be what? [1:41:13, 1:41:26]: Uh, I would say somewhere around eighteen, nineteen hundred dollars. Okay. So your target demographic would probably be f you know, the so like police officers, firefighters, the professionals, the teachers. [1:41:26, 1:41:46]: Yeah, hopefully we're we're looking at there's a average medium income here about 72,000. So, you know, we take that into consideration when we're s you know talking about rents to make sure it's affordable for um our public workers as well as teachers, um, so on and so forth. So because you can't can't price yourself out of the market. [1:41:47, 1:42:07]: Right. And that's why I'm asking to make sure that it is affordable for i because you know, certainly those are getting up seven, eighteen, nineteen hundred is getting m very much expensive for those professionals. So you're kinda hitting kind of where we need to be at to make sure that it is affordable uh to go in the community. So I was trying to gauge where you were. [1:42:07, 1:42:12]: As opposed to where they were. So that that's your target. That's a pretty good target. That's what we're looking at. [1:42:12, 1:42:26]: Okay, and and are you opposed to any prohibitions such as things like we have in the city, vape shops, assignment shops, or type of specific types of businesses? You you can put in there anything you want. Uh I clearly understand that. [1:42:27, 1:42:37]: Certainly,'cause we're trying to draw a better type business and we don't just want anything opening up. We want to have well there will be some prohibitions that we already have. Understood. Associated. Yes. Thanks. [1:42:38, 1:42:39]: Ms. Barber, go ahead, please. [1:42:40, 1:42:42]: Yes. Thank you, Sarah. Um [1:42:43, 1:42:52]: I don't want you to think that I am completely opposed to developments. I support the re revitalization of our city. [1:42:52, 1:42:54]: And our downtown. [1:42:54, 1:42:55]: I do. [1:42:56, 1:42:58]: I have the unique responsibility. [1:42:59, 1:43:05]: Of caring for those residents who live in the area, and I've spoken with them. [1:43:06, 1:43:07]: Um [1:43:09, 1:43:15]: I don't know a whole lot about urban planning, but I do know when it comes to apartments. [1:43:15, 1:43:18]: Those are supposed to be in order. [1:43:18, 1:43:18]: I guess [1:43:20, 1:43:21]: To align with smart growth. [1:43:22, 1:43:23]: They would be developed. [1:43:23, 1:43:24]: During [1:43:25, 1:43:28]: Along major corridors. [1:43:28, 1:43:32]: and highways, such as the apartments that Councilwoman Gantt mentioned. [1:43:33, 1:43:35]: It's along Highway one thirty eight. Mm-hmm. [1:43:36, 1:43:37]: Um [1:43:38, 1:43:40]: I suppose the [1:43:40, 1:43:45]: a hundred and fifty plus town homes that were approved off of North [1:43:46, 1:43:47]: Henry Boulevard. [1:43:48, 1:43:52]: with what used to be Henderson and Sons Mortuary. [1:43:53, 1:43:55]: Those could have been apartments. [1:43:55, 1:43:57]: Um as opposed to town homes. [1:43:58, 1:44:02]: But to have these amount of town, these amount apartments. [1:44:03, 1:44:05]: In the interior, roads. [1:44:05, 1:44:06]: is a bit concerning. [1:44:07, 1:44:08]: It's going to clog up the area. [1:44:09, 1:44:11]: We're challenged because we have the railroad. [1:44:11, 1:44:12]: That's right there. [1:44:14, 1:44:14]: Um [1:44:17, 1:44:32]: Have you considered town homes or even single family homes in this particular area? Uh not for this property, primarily because uh the wetland issue. We just don't have enough acreage to make make it work. [1:44:33, 1:44:34]: I understand. Yes. [1:44:34, 1:44:35]: Um [1:44:35, 1:44:36]: When I think about [1:44:37, 1:44:38]: A development. [1:44:38, 1:44:40]: Across from Cochran Park. [1:44:40, 1:44:41]: It's a park. [1:44:42, 1:44:44]: You think about families. [1:44:44, 1:44:47]: Most of the units that are being proposed [1:44:48, 1:45:00]: are a studio and one bedroom. It's not a family. Um it's you're targeting single professionals, but the area is more conducive to [1:45:00, 1:45:02]: Families where kids will enjoy. [1:45:03, 1:45:04]: The park across the street. [1:45:07, 1:45:09]: I'm finding it challenging to try to [1:45:09, 1:45:10]: Make this fit. [1:45:11, 1:45:11]: Right now. [1:45:12, 1:45:13]: I certainly appreciate [1:45:13, 1:45:21]: The fact that this proposal is a mixed use development that offers some commercial component to it. [1:45:21, 1:45:24]: Are there any commercial commitments? [1:45:25, 1:45:31]: You have already? Um no, we don't know what we've been approved for yet, so yeah. Um [1:45:36, 1:45:56]: And to speak to your um to the park issue, um, I mean, young adults use uh I got a development we're doing on the belt line. They use it and it's nothing but single folks to be quite frank, and they use it a lot. Westside park is highly used by families for sure, but a bunch of [1:45:56, 1:46:16]: uh younger folks for sure. So I think everybody can enjoy the part collectively. And I know where you're coming from, uh when you say families mixing with uh just say much younger d demographic of single folks, sometimes, you know. Uh but I I you know, I don't see Stockbridge [1:46:16, 1:46:27]: Stop Rich, not Atlantic. That's all I can say about that. And I don't want to get into why I'm saying that, but I think um, you know, you got a better uh you're gonna have better outcomes. [1:46:27, 1:46:32]: If that's your if that's your concern. I'm not sure that's what you're doing. [1:46:33, 1:46:33]: That is [1:46:34, 1:46:35]: I go to the park too. [1:46:35, 1:46:38]: Right. Um I'm just talking about Cochrane Park. [1:46:39, 1:46:42]: That is a very popular baseball park. [1:46:42, 1:46:44]: suitable for kids. [1:46:45, 1:46:46]: Um [1:46:47, 1:46:52]: That's really my concern. Um I just don't want us just trying to make it fit. [1:46:53, 1:46:56]: Um in understanding the impact. [1:46:56, 1:46:57]: To [1:46:57, 1:47:05]: Everybody and everything else around it. I just want us to be smart about what we're doing. Understood. Um there is a couple of other [1:47:05, 1:47:10]: developments that have been approved by the council that wasn't on this list. [1:47:12, 1:47:16]: Um the town homes off Davis Road, you didn't include those either. [1:47:17, 1:47:19]: The ones near the [1:47:19, 1:47:28]: If you can respond come if you're gonna respond, come to the mic, please. I don't wanna call'em trailer. Trailer park. But um those and then We didn't include everything. [1:47:29, 1:47:32]: I'm sorry. I said no, we didn't include everything. [1:47:33, 1:47:45]: And see that's what my concern is though. Um we can't see a true, accurate um number of units that have been approved in that area. [1:47:45, 1:47:46]: Specifically. [1:47:47, 1:47:54]: Um that's why I wanted to narrow it down to new developments that have been approved within a mile. [1:47:55, 1:48:03]: Um so I have some serious concerns and of course I have to represent the people who live in the area. So [1:48:03, 1:48:21]: That's all I have. Thank you. One last question. Stand by a second. Miss Barber, along with for the gentleman here, you gotta realize also you mentioned about the railroad track in North Worth Southern. You realize that we now have a quiet zone. So this development is within the s a footprint of the downtown area and the quiet zone itself because Valley Hill is part of the quiet zone. [1:48:21, 1:48:37]: And then you get to Love Street and then Nolan Street to the very south. So in all actuality, North Force Southern should those engineers should not be blowing on their horns as they come through. So and I didn't know if you know that, sir, or not, but uh but just wanna let you know that we finally got that approved several months or so ago. I didn't know that. Thank you. Okay, no problem, appreciate it. [1:48:38, 1:48:45]: Yes, ma'am. Yeah, I was mentioning the railroad because once again, um, we're challenged with how to [1:48:45, 1:48:50]: um grow the area. We can't expand or widen East Atlanta Road. [1:48:51, 1:48:53]: Because of the railroad. [1:48:54, 1:49:00]: And we're adding more density and populations and cars on the road. [1:49:00, 1:49:01]: In the area. [1:49:02, 1:49:03]: It's challenging. [1:49:04, 1:49:05]: Um [1:49:07, 1:49:27]: That's all. Okay. Ms. Alexander, you have something to say. I just want to m make sure we're you are the developer. You are the developer. You own this property. You're No, I we have it on the contract. You're on the contract. Okay. Okay. You have it on the co well, you will be the owner of the property. One hundred percent. You will be developing this property. [1:49:27, 1:49:44]: Yes. Your track record says Union City, McDonough has been successful for those. But we can look to you as the owner. You're not looking to develop it and then say you're gonna be the owner of this property and then the HOA will take over. Absolutely. Yes. Okay. Thank you. [1:49:44, 1:49:45]: Mayor Pro Tem, go ahead, please. [1:49:46, 1:50:06]: Yeah. Again, thank you for putting together a very nice presentation. I really like the project. Uh I just wanna put my concerns out there for uh public consumption about the traffic pattern of the one way in and one way out. Um my biggest concern is the left turn out onto old Conyers Road during morning traffic, school traffic, whatever the case. [1:50:06, 1:50:08]: Um [1:50:08, 1:50:16]: I I frequent that intersection a lot. Uh my daughter works across the street from there. And so I know when the buses and things are coming in and [1:50:16, 1:50:18]: Eight AM, three PM [1:50:18, 1:50:38]: That's a very difficult place to navigate. Uh, I don't know if a traffic sign signal helps or some some some other route or or some other concession that can be made, but I'm definitely concerned with uh additional hundred plus folks commuting out of that intersection around the same time. [1:50:38, 1:50:53]: at the same morning when it's already a congested spot. And like Councilwoman Barber said, we don't really have the ability to expand the space in the road. Love the project, but really wanna make sure that we do something to accommodate [1:50:53, 1:51:06]: The flow. The flow of traffic, being considerate of the people who are already using that as a main thoroughfare. Um, that's pretty much our main thoroughfare getting into Ellenwood and and coming back and forth. And so [1:51:06, 1:51:09]: We have to be considerate of that if we can. [1:51:10, 1:51:16]: Uh I I think you're I mean you have a good point. Um we would love to have a traffic signal there. [1:51:17, 1:51:19]: You know, but you know, that's not [1:51:20, 1:51:27]: You know, we we can't control that. Um and we we're actually having issues with um our hall road and highway ninety two. [1:51:27, 1:51:29]: Uh, they're doing a roundabout. [1:51:29, 1:51:33]: And they just built a Starbucks right there, and now they want to push into our property. [1:51:34, 1:51:39]: But same thing, because you have density coming, they have to come in. [1:51:39, 1:51:40]: And [1:51:40, 1:51:43]: you know, figure out a better flow of traffic. So I I I don't disagree with [1:51:45, 1:51:47]: I'm sorry, Mayor. Let me add on to you done, Mayor Protein. [1:51:48, 1:52:08]: Now this is where the X there will be this is where the improvements are. This is where the XL and D sell lane. So there will be an acceleration lane and a deceleration lane that should move say the school bus or whatever out of the lane of traffic. Correct. So that that the other traffic can pass through. And on the other side, residents will have an X. [1:52:08, 1:52:28]: XL lane where they can leave and not be running directly on O'Connors. And I want to correct something that was just there. It is not out of it has not ever been said that we can't widen East Atlanta Road. That's not true. Okay. We will that that there is challenging to be able to do so, but that certainly is in the long [1:52:28, 1:52:48]: term plans to be able to widen East Atlanta Road, taking the right of way to the east side of the road to be able to widen it at some point. The challenge is the funding not actually not being able to do so. And I certainly support being able to widen East Atlanta Road at some point. [1:52:48, 1:53:05]: But the traffic considerations are the XL and the D cell lane that you will be building there and then some uh uh to assist with traffic, not having the bus on East Atlanta on Old Canyon blocking traffic, right? Exactly. Okay, thank you. Ms. Barber you have something else? [1:53:05, 1:53:19]: Well I echo um the point that Council Mayor Pro Tem Berry made about left turns out of this development. Um that's difficult. [1:53:20, 1:53:25]: Okay. That's why I was asking about other access points. [1:53:26, 1:53:28]: This cannot be the only one. We gotta figure [1:53:30, 1:53:32]: How can we Mr Gardner? [1:53:32, 1:53:40]: Because thank you, sir. I appreciate you bringing forward a proposal for us. Um it's just that [1:53:41, 1:53:45]: It's complicated trying to make this fit and it just [1:53:46, 1:53:48]: It's not a good fit for this area. [1:53:48, 1:53:49]: At this time. [1:53:50, 1:53:52]: Містер Гартнер, вокзанти? [1:53:53, 1:53:53]: With [1:53:54, 1:53:55]: Um this gentleman. [1:53:56, 1:53:58]: Um to try to find some other [1:53:58, 1:53:59]: Option. [1:54:00, 1:54:02]: Apartments is just not conducive here. [1:54:03, 1:54:05]: We know that. It's just not. [1:54:06, 1:54:07]: There's no way around it. [1:54:09, 1:54:11]: That density onto Old Conyers Road. [1:54:12, 1:54:14]: And trying to turn left out of it. [1:54:17, 1:54:23]: Yes, ma'am. So I mean, they're providing right now a mixed use development with commercial residential. [1:54:23, 1:54:27]: Um the only other alternative is and I think he mentioned [1:54:27, 1:54:28]: That [1:54:29, 1:54:42]: You can't really put residential on here that's gonna make sense, b single family detach because of almost half the property being in a floodplain and with wetlands. So you can't make it happen that way. Um [1:54:43, 1:55:02]: I know that is zone in commercial and see what he could get from a commercial development and that if that's his intent. Well it's probably not. That's why they're showing a mix of residential and um commercial. But that's the only other option that's out there. Um, as he mentioned, the property is constrained. [1:55:02, 1:55:11]: Um, as it relates to putting enough single family homes or a tad single family that would make sense from a development standpoint. [1:55:11, 1:55:15]: Uh and so that's the reason. Not even town homes would work. [1:55:15, 1:55:35]: No ma'am, because I I think the issue is gonna be for him, and he can speak to this more than I can, is gonna be being able to put in the development costs and be able to recoup that development costs by the sale of enough units that would make him profitable. Nobody's in the business to lose money. Um so that's that's what's driving [1:55:35, 1:55:42]: The vertical part of the development is you're able to capture the amount of residential units by going up versus going wide. [1:55:44, 1:55:44]: Thank you, sir. [1:55:45, 1:55:47]: Ms. Gann, go ahead, please. Wait, Mr. Gardner, real quick. [1:55:48, 1:55:48]: Um [1:55:49, 1:55:51]: Based off of this plan and the [1:55:52, 1:55:54]: Based off the retreat we went to. [1:55:55, 1:55:57]: And our future plans for downtown. [1:55:57, 1:56:01]: Do you think that this is a good fit for the area? [1:56:01, 1:56:06]: Would it tie into what we are planning to do throughout our downtown? [1:56:06, 1:56:12]: Uh and within the proximity. Yes, ma'am. Initially when I saw when I heard about it coming through, I was like, Oh, well, okay, cool. [1:56:13, 1:56:16]: Um, it would kinda make sense if you were able to [1:56:16, 1:56:18]: to do some things on the property, but [1:56:19, 1:56:21]: The property is constrained. I mean [1:56:21, 1:56:31]: if I was able to lay it out, I wouldn't have the the props the project sitting to one end, but now we understand why the property is sitting to the eastern side of the property line. [1:56:31, 1:56:35]: It's because it's constrained by the floodplain that runs right through here. [1:56:36, 1:56:56]: Right. And so that limits what he could develop or it would have been cool to turn it this way, maybe with a portion in the back and and make it happen that way. Um, not unseen, um obviously you're still within a ten to fifteen minute radius walk to downtown from here, um, from this location. Um [1:56:56, 1:57:08]: It would make sense. It's just so obviously it's difficult because the property is so constrained. And that's what's forcing them to go more vertical than anything else. Um and then they can't go horizontal. [1:57:08, 1:57:28]: Um with Old Corners Road because it's only so much you could get the building in before you start hitting the wetlands. So you can't so it's it's constrained property. Um you know, the concept makes sense. Um trying to fit it in here, obviously you're seeing some of the challenges that they're having. [1:57:28, 1:57:32]: Um but all in all the concept is a good concept. [1:57:34, 1:57:36]: Do you have another question, sir? Go ahead, please. [1:57:36, 1:57:50]: I I I just wanna echo this out. I personally think that this is a great plan. I just feel like our our road infrastructure needs to be explored down the road so that we can better accommodate. Like it has to be prioritized. [1:57:51, 1:57:57]: So I I like I said, I d I do wanna put that point and let that be known. Like I think what you're doing [1:57:57, 1:58:17]: is phenomenal and it's phenomenal to the plan that like what we've seen, the vision for what we s what we seen. However, we we can't keep it ignoring the expansion and the and the roadway of what of that area because as it grows, the road have has to grow with it. And so I'm not opposed to right what we're doing. I just [1:58:17, 1:58:35]: think we need to put our focus on what would be. I would caution us, right? Because um I think as counts district councilmember said, I mean, Georgia law requires that we cannot use roads and schools as a means to deny zoning. And the w purpose behind that is [1:58:35, 1:58:41]: You have a property owner, whether they own the property for a hundred years, pay taxes for those things to be improved and it's up on the local government. [1:58:42, 1:58:43]: To improve those things. [1:58:43, 1:58:44]: Right? [1:58:44, 1:58:47]: And if it didn't get done, their property shouldn't be held accountable for it. [1:58:48, 1:58:50]: Байстон. Нас тамс Бинна. [1:58:51, 1:58:53]: Right, that we need to understand. [1:58:53, 1:59:04]: So it's not their fault that the road isn't falling, divided or whatever. That's the that's the fault of the county and s local government if he's on the property for sixty, six seventy years. Recognize it. [1:59:05, 1:59:06]: The you go back. [1:59:07, 1:59:14]: There wasn't no there were less than five, six thousand people living here in the entire Henry County in the nineteen seventies. [1:59:14, 1:59:18]: So people need to keep that in perspective. It wasn't a big county back then. [1:59:18, 1:59:38]: Um so growth has come and yes, um those improvements are there, but you cannot basically use those as a basis. Um, you know, to to to deny it. But that's gonna be a problem every time we look at zoning property. You're gonna have those issues. Um all of us live in subdivisions still. [1:59:38, 1:59:51]: that when they got built for the most part. Uh when they got built, the roads weren't capacity. I mean, you have thousands of homes built off of Walt Stevens Road and they all go down a two lane road from Spear Road to get to one thirty eight. [1:59:53, 1:59:54]: So it happens. [1:59:55, 2:00:14]: Okay, if you know the questions from the council, I'm gonna open up to for public hearing. Thank you, sir. Appreciate your time. Thank you. No problem. Okay, I'm gonna open up public hearing. So all in favor of individuals that want to speak for this, want to speak for this development on my far left. On my far left. Anybody want to speak positive for this development in the middle? [2:00:15, 2:00:21]: Anybody on the far right? Positive positive comments. I'm gonna go with any negative comments. [2:00:21, 2:00:22]: I'm sorry. [2:00:23, 2:00:25]: Oh yes, sir. Oh yes, ma'am, sorry. [2:00:25, 2:00:30]: Yeah, okay, yeah. Um you if you're the only one, come come to the podium and give your name and address, please. [2:00:36, 2:00:40]: Hello, my name is Maria Clay. Um, I live at [2:00:43, 2:01:00]: I need to know specifically which item that you are speaking for. I th well yeah, I don't know if you have a specific item or it's just overall concept, overall comments that you want to make here. Um yes, just over the uh apartment complex that's coming to the city of Stockbridge. [2:01:00, 2:01:02]: All right, there you go. Name and address, please. [2:01:02, 2:01:22]: Uh Maria Clay, 103 Springwood Valley Road, Stockbridge, Georgia. Go ahead, please. Okay, I've been a resident of Stockbridge um since middle school, um over twenty years. Um I think this is a great development for our community. Uh we don't have a lot of stuff like this for us. We have to go downtown. [2:01:22, 2:01:42]: Which is far. Like why can't we have laws um for our young adults? Um another thing is it's hard for a lot of people my age to purchase homes. So I feel like you yeah, we have the DR Horton town homes down the street, but not everybody has twenty [2:01:42, 2:02:02]: 30,000 to put down on a house. So this is in our community. It's perfect for us. It is across the street from the baseball field. My daughter, she used to play baseball at that field. It would be nice for us to have somewhere to walk. It's right across the street. We can walk, we want to walk on the trail to a nice trail. [2:02:02, 2:02:22]: You also have the publics across the street, which I think will bring down some of the traffic flow because we don't have to drive everywhere. It's right up the street from the amphitheater. We can walk to the amphitheater, which is great. I really hope we can get something like this for Stockbridge. [2:02:22, 2:02:40]: I personally would like to live there. Um, it seemed like it's gonna be very, very nice. Um, but we do have to I want something here for our young adults because it is a lot of three bedroom apartments. Like n we want something for us. Um and [2:02:42, 2:02:53]: Okay. Well appre is that it? Appreciate your comments if that is all. Thank you. Thank you very much. Okay, any any other comments for? Okay, any comments against from our far left. Any comments against this development? [2:02:53, 2:02:55]: Anybody in the middle, guess this development? [2:02:56, 2:02:58]: On my far right, anything that gets the development. [2:03:00, 2:03:02]: What is this, sir? [2:03:03, 2:03:06]: All right, take come come forward. So give your name and address, please. [2:03:08, 2:03:17]: How y'all doing? Luke, Luke Williams, uh 4661 North Air Boulevard. Okay, go ahead. Uh uh while I was uh asking about the development um [2:03:17, 2:03:21]: Now this is like a gated community, uh, you know, um [2:03:22, 2:03:38]: Would it be like any y'all plan on like any buses, uh buses coming through the uh help out for the community? And um my last question would be, when um if if you decide to approve it, when would uh the when would y'all start breaking ground on the uh community? [2:03:39, 2:03:39]: All right. [2:03:40, 2:03:46]: I appreciate that. Yeah. Okay. That's all the questions you have? A couple of qu okay, thank you. Um, Ryan, Anderson, could you come back please? [2:03:47, 2:03:54]: In reference to the b bus traffic, I know that we're working with matter of fact we have uh just um remembered that we have a a tour. [2:03:54, 2:04:10]: a schedule for tomorrow to with the Henry County bus route. I don't know I can't recall this being on a bus route, but I know that we're looking at uh having a bus route internally into the county and the and with all the other cities. So this may be something that we may possibly look at m maybe adding as time goes on. [2:04:11, 2:04:31]: I'm saying that in passing. Now that's something obviously that we council members and myself can can maybe do tomorrow. Well, I schedule to do tomorrow. Matter of fact, on what the existing stops are. But in reference to um uh the timeline of upon approval, I don't know if you have any idea of the timeline, sir, on this. Uh I'm not sure what what the developers timeline is. [2:04:31, 2:04:32]: I mean he can address that. [2:04:33, 2:04:36]: Okay, come on up, please, sir, for a second, don't go anywhere, Brian. Uh please stay back. [2:04:39, 2:04:55]: Um, if approved, uh we will start on the plans immediately, which takes about, you know, around five months and then you're permitting maybe about three months, four months, uh depending on the municipality. So, you know, you're talking ten, eleven months before you can actually go to shove on the ground. [2:04:55, 2:05:10]: So if if on once approved ten, eleven months or sometime early, it'll be sometime early f uh next winter well late winter maybe, I guess it is. Yeah. Late winter, early spring. Third fourth quarter twenty twenty five. Okay. All right. And I believe that's the only questions you had at that point. I think that covers that. Okay. [2:05:10, 2:05:13]: After go ahead, Ryan, do you have something else to add? Uh no, sir. [2:05:14, 2:05:15]: [7516.0, 7517.7]: So I believe I covered it all. [2:05:18, 2:05:19]: What else is I think? [2:05:22, 2:05:40]: Gate oh no, I don't think I'm sorry. I'm I'm sorry, I missed that. I got you. Gate what I I'm sorry I missed that area. Okay. I don't think there's no gates involved in this at all. Not at this time. Not playing at this time, no. Okay. And I'm pretty sure that there they're no yeah, no idea. Okay, okay, got it. All right. [2:05:40, 2:05:55]: Okay. I've I've asked this I've been around uh you all need to listen to what I'm saying now,'cause I've asked for for and against. You know, uh Ryan, could you move out the way for a second, please? Ma'am, what what is on your mind? I'll let you c come now come to come to the mic and give your name and address. [2:05:55, 2:06:15]: Y'all gotta pay attention. I'm I'm going through this and this you need to speak up when I come through you. What's your name? What's your name? Hello, my name is Shavaka Harris. My address is one oh one oh seven Cobalt Way, Stockbridge, Georgia. It's neither. It is just a a qu a mere question that I have as it pertains to the um Go ahead. The new construction. Right. [2:06:15, 2:06:35]: Allow me to apologize for inconveniencing the court or the counsel today with my late question. However, I understand that it has been posed that we would be able to walk from the um construction or whatever it's going to be to the amphitheater. Would there be sidewalks and places? [2:06:35, 2:06:54]: to ensure safety for those that would be downtown development plan in reference to uh having uh uh pathways, yes. It's all part of connecting folks to the downtown areas. That's part of our future. So that is part of that process. Okay? Okay. Thanks. Thank you. Okay. I'm gonna close the public hearing on that note. All right. I'll close the public hearing. All right. So [2:06:54, 2:07:08]: We've done that. Council, uh we're gonna go through uh we're gonna go through each one of these. Ryan, I'm gonna need you back up, please, sir. We're gonna go through each one of these and then we'll uh take a vote. They're uh one, two, three, four, what's it, five? [2:07:09, 2:07:18]: It's it's five but you can vote on four. Five differ five different vote on four. Excuse me now? The second variance you can disregard. Second variance disregard? Yes, sir. [2:07:20, 2:07:21]: Okay. [2:07:23, 2:07:24]: We'll be voting on four items. [2:07:24, 2:07:25]: Well the [2:07:25, 2:07:38]: The second variance, well, uh that's what it says here, seven point seven five percent to twenty-five percent proposed ratio eighty seven point five to twelve point five. That's what you're referring to? Yes, sir. We don't have a provision for that. It will be based on the conceptual site plan. [2:07:38, 2:07:43]: It'll be based on the final site plan. Oh, you're saying we don't have to vote on that tonight? Yes, sir. You don't have to vote on it. [2:07:44, 2:08:01]: Okay. So what I have first is a comprehensive plan amendment K CP twenty twenty four-zero two, co-course council district four, and this deals with uh the designation from low density residential to special purpose to allow for the construction of misuse development, including commercial and residential uses. [2:08:01, 2:08:07]: Does that cover that, sir? That's right? Yes, sir. Okay, is there is there a motion to accept this? Mayor Ford. Yes, ma'am. [2:08:08, 2:08:15]: I motion to deny the comprehensive plan amendment case number CP two zero two four dash oh two. [2:08:16, 2:08:17]: Is there a second then motion? Point of order. [2:08:18, 2:08:20]: I don't think we make motions to deny. [2:08:21, 2:08:23]: Well well to see well [2:08:23, 2:08:25]: Well, I don't know my attorney's not here but [2:08:26, 2:08:30]: If she wants well, if it gets a sec if it doesn't get a second, it fall it falls off anyway because the second will vote on it. [2:08:30, 2:08:32]: Okay, so there's our second emotion. [2:08:33, 2:08:35]: Is there a second to the motion? [2:08:36, 2:08:38]: I hear no second. Motion's denied. [2:08:38, 2:08:39]: I need a motion, folks, to approve. [2:08:41, 2:08:41]: So moved. [2:08:42, 2:08:42]: Okay. [2:08:42, 2:08:45]: Sir Second? Sir. Mr. Hazan said in all favor, please indicate. [2:08:49, 2:09:01]: Okay. You okay, t to to approve and you all you all deny the the motion to accept this motion? I oppose. I oppose. Okay. Yes sir. Gentlemen. [2:09:03, 2:09:15]: The motion was made by Mr. Gantt and then to Mr. Alexander to u to approve this uh the change of this uh low density residential special purpose, level for construction, misuse, development, including commercial and residential uses. [2:09:15, 2:09:20]: They approved it. They've they've motioned and they raised their hand approved. So is there so you gentlemen approve or deny? [2:09:22, 2:09:23]: You approve it, sir? [2:09:24, 2:09:27]: I oppose. Okay, one second. Okay, Miss Barber opposes. [2:09:28, 2:09:33]: Okay, Mr. Berry approve approves. That's three approval. Mr. Um you have sustained. Okay, so it's uh three, two, one. [2:09:34, 2:09:45]: Right? Yeah, three no, three one one, three one one, motion pass. All right, three one one, motion pass. Uh the approval uh madam clerk, the approval was from Gantt, Alessander and Berry. [2:09:46, 2:10:05]: Okay, got it. Okay. All right. Next is a rezoning case RZ twenty twenty four dash zero two council district four. This deals with the rezone the property from SR suburban residential to PUD plan unit development to allow for the construction of misuse development, including commercial and residential uses. If I got that correct, sir. [2:10:06, 2:10:08]: Okay, is there the motion for this? To for approval. [2:10:10, 2:10:17]: I oppose, I deny, or oppose the rezoning case RZ two zero two four-02. [2:10:18, 2:10:19]: Is there a second to that motion? [2:10:21, 2:10:23]: Is there a second to that motion? [2:10:24, 2:10:42]: No second motion fails. Is there approval motion for this result? Okay. Some movie. This is where the conditions will or does that that the next one? I'm sorry. Yeah, yes sir. The staff recommend approval with conditions. Okay, let's talk about the conditions now. And then we added some conditions. Exactly it's yeah, is there this point? Is there a second to this motion? [2:10:42, 2:10:56]: I s well he's gotta make the motion with the conditions. He's making a motion. Okay, could you come and and get all the additional conditions for this mo uh conditions for this please? Why me the additional con con uh conditions uh Do we have to name'em all again? If they're on the list? Which one? [2:10:58, 2:11:18]: Well it it looked like some ones that were added. Yeah, we had uh council. The ones that were added. We added a ten foot multi-use path along the furniture of East Atlanta and Old Cunyons Road. Decorative street lights installed. Um we had um I'm not sure it was a formal um um condition because it was infrared. [2:11:17, 2:11:32]: Yet but less studio and more two to three bedrooms. I don't know I don't know if the developer wants that. Um an EV charging station shall be installed. And um and a bus stop shall be installed for kids. [2:11:34, 2:11:48]: Cade I would imagine that there would have to be a bus well kids for school. I'm imagining there, the the school system. The shelter is automatic is automatic. Well the shelter to make sure they have a cover and they're just not standing out there. Yes. That's that's automatic. [2:11:49, 2:11:51]: Okay. It's already in the code. Okay. Okay. [2:11:53, 2:11:55]: So I'm there. Yes, ma'am. [2:11:55, 2:11:57]: So with the other eight on the board. [2:12:02, 2:12:03]: Yes, ma'am. [2:12:08, 2:12:16]: Okay, this is uh this is a rezoning case. This deal talks about plan you're at suburban residential plan unit development. Okay. [2:12:17, 2:12:29]: Mayor. Yes, ma'am. I don't know if the applicant is in a provement or not, but normally we just say what the staff recommends and we vote on that and that's what this that's what the applicant has to go by. So [2:12:30, 2:12:32]: We base it off of what our recommendations are. [2:12:32, 2:12:35]: And then we vote on it based off of that. [2:12:35, 2:12:36]: На видерна [2:12:37, 2:12:45]: the the applicant agrees. If they disagreed, they would have had to say something then, but we're telling them that it's gonna be a hundred and sixty units. [2:12:47, 2:12:47]: Okay. [2:12:50, 2:12:58]: So so we need to make a motion to include all these th uh conditions for this for this approval for this particular change to a plan unit development. [2:12:58, 2:13:17]: Right. It would I would certainly want to be supportive of the hundred and sixty units. Okay, certainly. Let's go ahead and do that with those conditions added. Uh that is my motion. With the standard conditions that were already included, plus the additional uh conditions that were read into the record. So move. [2:13:17, 2:13:19]: What is the provision for the sidewalks? [2:13:20, 2:13:26]: It's it's it's in the UDC but ten foot multi purpose trail along East Atlanta and Old Cunyers Road, or along the frontage. [2:13:29, 2:13:31]: Mm. [2:13:32, 2:13:33]: Yes, ma'am. [2:13:37, 2:13:39]: Well that's coming that's another variant. [2:13:39, 2:13:53]: That's that's that's the next variant's coming up. Well the city manager is going to staff. The the staff is going to work through that process to see if that's appropriate. If there's if that if they can work that out on the property. If they're possi if it's possible, they shouldn't. [2:13:54, 2:14:14]: That's next coming up. That's right after this one. Up or down. That's coming up in reference to the parking spots you were referring to. Yeah, that's number eight on the staff reporting. Yes, sir. Okay. Uh Mayor, before you take the vote, Mayor. Yes, sir. Um, I'd like to ask if if it's appropriate before the vote on [2:14:14, 2:14:28]: the next agenda item. Um if a motion to reconsider is appropriate at this time before the vote uh on the other agenda items. Reconsidered what which were you talking about? [2:14:29, 2:14:35]: I mean just to recit reconsider my vote. Oh reconsider your vote. On item agenda item six. [2:14:35, 2:14:55]: Well you before before the council. But you you abstained, sir. You abstained on that and I think the only reconsideration would come from the individuals that were approved at. So you you were not the right person to reconsider or or or that aspect I think. I I our attorney's not here, but I but I would think that um [2:14:55, 2:14:58]: [8100.0, 8106.7]: In reference to whoever whoever passes that whoever uh passes that particular uh an affirmative, I believe. [2:15:07, 2:15:07]: Right. [2:15:08, 2:15:09]: Okay. [2:15:11, 2:15:16]: This is what it's what I understand. Unfortunately, uh attorney's not here right, but I believe that's the way it's done. Yes. [2:15:16, 2:15:18]: Okay, I won't I won't challenge that. [2:15:18, 2:15:22]: Okay. Well I appreciate it. Appreciate that. All right, so um [2:15:23, 2:15:34]: Let's see here. Back to uh the rezona case. Okay, Mr. Alexander, you made a motion with all with all the different uh additional conditions uh that were read into the record. [2:15:35, 2:15:38]: Correct? That is correct. Is there a s second to the motion? [2:15:40, 2:15:45]: I second. Ms. Gantt second that. All in favor, please indicate. Comment. Yep, I'm sorry. Comment. [2:15:46, 2:16:03]: What's your comment? Hold on, say, hold on, relax. Relax. What is your comment, please? This is the district that I represent. The residents who live in the area have grave concerns about this mixed use development with [2:16:04, 2:16:07]: А худа сипамент униц. [2:16:09, 2:16:15]: Mayor Pro Temberry raised a very valid point when he talked about the safety concerns of turning left. [2:16:15, 2:16:17]: out of this development. [2:16:18, 2:16:19]: Nobody is addressing that. [2:16:21, 2:16:24]: The only time none of us live in the area. [2:16:25, 2:16:29]: None of us live off East Atlanta Road or Connors Road. [2:16:29, 2:16:33]: The closest person who lives to this area is Councilman Thomas. [2:16:36, 2:16:40]: If you're gonna impact the people who live in this area. [2:16:40, 2:16:43]: Make sure you're addressing the safety concerns. [2:16:44, 2:16:47]: This is a district that I represent. [2:16:47, 2:16:54]: So you you best believe every time there is a proposal that is presented to this council. [2:16:54, 2:17:00]: Regarding this downtown area, it is more than just revitalizing the area. [2:17:00, 2:17:03]: Have to consider the people who live here. [2:17:03, 2:17:05]: Those who are most impacted. [2:17:08, 2:17:13]: Now are we gonna address the safety concerns and the staff's recommendation?'Cause they didn't address it. [2:17:15, 2:17:15]: Mayor. [2:17:16, 2:17:18]: Okay. Ms. Gantt, do you have a question? [2:17:18, 2:17:24]: I thank you. Uh well it's not a question, it's a comment. Go ahead, what's your comment? Um, just so the public knows [2:17:26, 2:17:28]: Public hearings are always advertised. [2:17:29, 2:17:32]: They're advertised to the public. And anytime we have a hearing like this, [2:17:32, 2:17:34]: Usually we have a room full. [2:17:35, 2:17:49]: If they're objecting, we have a line. If they're for it, we have a line. Well, not necessarily for it, mainly when they object to something. We have a line of people that are commenting and stating that they object to the project. [2:17:51, 2:17:52]: With all respect, [2:17:54, 2:17:56]: Downtown has to be [2:17:56, 2:17:58]: in a council member's district. [2:18:00, 2:18:05]: Councilwoman Barber's district was drawn to include our downtown. [2:18:06, 2:18:08]: But it is a known fact that [2:18:09, 2:18:11]: But downtown. [2:18:11, 2:18:13]: The heart of downtown. [2:18:13, 2:18:15]: Which this project resides in. [2:18:16, 2:18:19]: Mayor council considers it all of our district. [2:18:20, 2:18:24]: Because we all want to focus on [2:18:24, 2:18:28]: The development of our downtown. [2:18:29, 2:18:32]: There are gonna be there always [2:18:33, 2:18:38]: Always and I sympathize there always gonna be someone not happy, I mean [2:18:38, 2:18:43]: We can never please a crowd. You can give people [2:18:43, 2:18:47]: Each council member up here can attest to the fact that we can give them [2:18:48, 2:18:52]: Everybody gets a million dollars apiece and somebody's still gonna complain. [2:18:53, 2:18:56]: There's n uh you're never gonna make everyone happy. [2:18:57, 2:19:05]: But this is a part of our future development plan. We actually have a developer who's trying to implement what we what our goals are. [2:19:05, 2:19:10]: Each and every one of us went down to r on a retreat [2:19:11, 2:19:12]: To a northern city. [2:19:13, 2:19:26]: And was high fiving and looking and ooin' and awing and looking at buildings were built where you walk out and you're like ten foot, ten feet right there. You walk out, you walk on to your to the main sidewalk, you're literally on the street. [2:19:27, 2:19:33]: And we decided we knew what we wanted our downtown to look like. [2:19:33, 2:19:34]: It's not [2:19:35, 2:19:46]: the place where I'm not saying you're not we're not supposed to have families here or whatever the case may be, that's not the case, but there are specific areas in our downtown. [2:19:47, 2:19:52]: We all agreed as part of our goals, as part of our mission statement. [2:19:53, 2:19:57]: That we want a live, work, and play environment. [2:19:57, 2:20:00]: Now we can say what we want, but [2:20:00, 2:20:04]: Nobody came up here and said that they were against this development. [2:20:05, 2:20:07]: This room is not full. [2:20:09, 2:20:10]: This development [2:20:11, 2:20:13]: is a kickoff. [2:20:13, 2:20:18]: to what we have been requesting or wanting for our downtown. [2:20:18, 2:20:20]: It is a a kickoff. [2:20:21, 2:20:35]: So I just hope that we consider that. I'm I'm not and I sympathize. I sympathize with people who wouldn't want it. But guess what? We're not building three bedroom apartments with families. We're talking about young urban professionals. [2:20:36, 2:20:38]: It is clear that this is geared towards them, but [2:20:39, 2:20:40]: This is not [2:20:42, 2:20:43]: A development [2:20:44, 2:20:47]: That's gun that looks like it's a whole bunch of riffraff going on. [2:20:47, 2:20:52]: When you get a development like this, or you get a senior living facility development. [2:20:53, 2:20:55]: You're right on the money of what we're trying to do. [2:20:57, 2:21:03]: And so I just want us to consider that that this is a part or see the whole picture. [2:21:04, 2:21:08]: That's where I am with this project. And I know some people aren't gonna be happy. [2:21:09, 2:21:13]: But we have certain areas. Our downtown is our downtown. [2:21:14, 2:21:18]: And it's been planned out to be that density area. [2:21:20, 2:21:40]: That's it. Mayor, just one other comment. Mayor Ford, my hand was raised. I have a comment. You don't speak if I may. Go ahead. Go ahead, Miss I'll tell you Miss Barber a second. Go ahead, Mr. Alexander. You get to speak twice. No, five minutes. So now doing it. [2:21:40, 2:21:58]: Calm down. Are we enforcing the speaking rules? If we are standby adhere to all of this. You will get an opportunity. What part of the speaking rules are you going to enforce? Okay, tell me. [2:21:58, 2:22:05]: Be consistent with it. I'm sick and tired of going through this. Will you call it? Every time there's a public hearing for my district. [2:22:06, 2:22:07]: You all are controlling. [2:22:08, 2:22:28]: And impacting the people that I am supposed to be representing. They're not here because they're expecting for me to represent them. They're not here because every single thing is. [2:22:28, 2:22:48]: Many units into an area that does not fit. This does not look like it's in the best interest of our city. It does not. This is not what we can this is not what I consider smart growth at all. I'm not gonna let you keep disrespecting me. I'm not gonna let you keep disrespecting the people who live in this area. There's been two [2:22:47, 2:22:53]: They have so much. [2:22:54, 2:22:54]: Just [2:22:55, 2:23:02]: You all have disrespected those people who've come here on a consistent basis within the past year. [2:23:03, 2:23:07]: Five new high density developments have been approved in this district. [2:23:07, 2:23:08]: Five. [2:23:09, 2:23:12]: Now you are approving an apartment. [2:23:12, 2:23:14]: Apartment development. [2:23:14, 2:23:19]: Right here in the downtown area with no plans to expand or widen. [2:23:20, 2:23:25]: Um East Atlanta Road. I brought that up when you approved the twenty seven three story townhomes. [2:23:26, 2:23:32]: You cannot widen East Atlanta Road when you have town homes that are right up against the sidewalks. [2:23:33, 2:23:39]: I am not going to be quiet. I'm not. And I'm gonna I'm not gonna allow you all to keep disrespecting me. [2:23:39, 2:23:44]: They won't come back here because y'all are not listening to the people in the community. [2:23:45, 2:23:48]: There are no apartments that have been built. [2:23:48, 2:23:51]: Or developed in the middle of our city. [2:23:52, 2:23:56]: All of the apartments have been developed along highways. [2:23:56, 2:23:58]: Not in the middle of a city. [2:23:59, 2:24:06]: What it looks like is you all are trying to squeeze these people out. You're making them real uncomfortable to make them want to move. [2:24:06, 2:24:10]: There are no political implications to you all, so you don't care. [2:24:12, 2:24:15]: Mr. Alexander Guay, please. Listen. [2:24:15, 2:24:16]: Uh you know. [2:24:16, 2:24:21]: Ms. Alexander Ms. Alexander has some time. [2:24:22, 2:24:42]: Certainly as a part of the condition staff has would be charged with continuing to look for opportunities to improve the traffic as Mr. Mayor Pro Tem has indicated. That certainly will be a priority for us to continue to look for improvements when we can do so. That is always the charge. [2:24:42, 2:24:57]: And I certainly concur with Mayor Pratin Berry that we would continue that and that is part of the motion. Well I know earlier in the conversation you mentioned and we got clarification about the XL D cell lane as well. We talked about that as well, this aspect. So on that note, um [2:24:58, 2:25:02]: Uh well we you made it we made a motion second by Ms. Gantt. So all in favor of that motion, please indicate. [2:25:03, 2:25:16]: Opposed. Okay. So pa pass okay it's three three three approvals. All right, and um zero zero abstained and zero opposed. The two members are missing. So emotion passed. Three zero zero. Okay. All right. [2:25:19, 2:25:39]: All right. Next was the variance case uh twenty four twenty twenty four dash zero one council district four and this is involving the parking requirements according to the number of bedrooms per uh apartment unit, whereby studio and one bedroom apartment units will have only one parking spa spot instead of required one point two five parking spots and a a two bedroom [2:25:39, 2:25:55]: the units will have only one point two five parking spots per uh unit instead of the one point seven five parking spots per unit. That's what I have here for that variance. Is that correct so for for a reduction of thirty units? For to a reduction? Of thirty units. Reduction of thirty units. From code. [2:25:55, 2:25:57]: Okay. From court requirements. [2:25:58, 2:26:03]: All right. That needs to be in the motion. Is there a there's a motion uh for that to accept that as is. [2:26:04, 2:26:14]: With the with the additional comment that Mr. Ryan just mentioned. Mr. Ryan, real quick before we make the motion, are you saying that now because it's been reduced to a hundred and sixty units, then this is okay? [2:26:14, 2:26:19]: Yeah yeah, uh for it will be a reduction of thirty units from the origin from originally opposed proposed. [2:26:20, 2:26:40]: Okay. So Mayor, I move that we reduce the parking requirements to a reduction of thirty units. Yeah, thirty nine units. From the what what from what was originally proposed? From what was originally um proposed. Okay, so second the motion. Okay, the original proposal was two hundred units. Since we've gone down to one [2:26:40, 2:26:46]: sixty then that is the reduction. Yes. Yeah. That the reduction is in order. Yes. All right. Thanks. So m second. [2:26:47, 2:27:07]: 160. So correct, give me the the clever. So we're going down from two original units. From 200 units to 160. So that that means the parking calculations became lower. The requirements became lower. And so they automatically fit with the lower. Well well, a reduction of 30 is is necessary. Staff approval that reduction of [2:27:07, 2:27:08]: Thirty units. [2:27:10, 2:27:15]: You you understand, sir? You good? All right. You good? I need a motion motion to accept this. [2:27:15, 2:27:19]: So moved. Is there a second? Second. All right. All in favor, please indicate. [2:27:21, 2:27:27]: Opposed? You you approved, Mr. You approved? Opposed. Okay, four zero one uh four one zero. Motion passed. [2:27:29, 2:27:39]: Okay. Now the next one was variance of that's uh twenty twenty four dash zero two. And you said Mr. Ryan in reference to we don't need to do this right now. Uh no not that one. [2:27:40, 2:27:50]: Which one are you referring to, sir? Uh modified uh the ground floor retail square footage requirement from 87.5 to 12 to uh 7525. [2:27:51, 2:27:56]: Yeah, from seventy five, tw twenty-five to eighty seven. [2:27:56, 2:28:03]: Point five, two point five. Twelve point five. Yeah, that's not necessary. We don't That's not necessary. No sir. So we you're saying we don't need this one? No, sir. [2:28:03, 2:28:13]: And b asked because can you explain why we don't need this one now? We don't have a provision in our code regulating this. Okay. So it's it's not applicable at this time. At this time? Yes. [2:28:13, 2:28:15]: All right. [2:28:15, 2:28:19]: Most places do have that, but we don't have it in our code at this time. [2:28:20, 2:28:40]: So what I have next would be a variance case RV 2024-03, Council District 4 variance to increase the project density from 24 units per acre to 29 units per acre. Is what I have next. Staff recommended uh denial based on the fact that we'll have 160. [2:28:40, 2:28:42]: Clerk's confused here. Clarification. [2:28:50, 2:28:50]: Yes. [2:28:54, 2:28:55]: Okay. [2:28:56, 2:29:16]: Yeah, uh you can we can do that. Can you make the motion to deny to to deny the the variance twenty four twenty twenty four zero two. Variants about the seventy five per okay. Yes sir. Well see that's why she's clerk of the year. That's why she's clerk of the year, yes. That's exactly why. Well wait, Mayor, do we not just ask a vote to remove this agenda item?'Cause I didn't [2:29:16, 2:29:18]: think we could deny [2:29:19, 2:29:22]: A gen do we vote to remove it? [2:29:23, 2:29:25]: Why would we vote to deny? [2:29:27, 2:29:37]: It's not so okay, so it's not applicable. So I wouldn't want to do that. I wouldn't want a record doing that. I would vote to remove the item. Yeah. Well yeah, that would be better. [2:29:37, 2:29:41]: Mayor, I would like to make a motion that we remove agenda item number nine. [2:29:42, 2:29:49]: Sir. Okay. And based on the fact that it's not applicable? Based on the fact that it's not applicable. Okay, all in favor of that, please indicate. [2:29:50, 2:29:56]: All opposed? Abstain? I abstain. Okay, four zero one. Okay. [2:29:59, 2:30:19]: All right, now to the variants uh case twenty twenty four-zero three, council district four variants have increased the project density from twenty-four units per acre to twenty-nine units per acre. Mr. Uh Ryan, Ryan Anderson, Mr. Anderson. We we staff recommended uh denial, and that's based on the fact that we're [2:30:19, 2:30:25]: We're going with 160 units instead of two hundred. Okay. So it cannot exceed twenty four units per acre. [2:30:25, 2:30:31]: All right. Is there a motion to accept the the staff's recommendation and uh keep it at twenty four units per acre? [2:30:33, 2:30:37]: You so move. Mr. Berry so moved that is there a second? Is there a second? [2:30:40, 2:30:52]: Okay, there's not a Sec. Okay, so deny? To to staff refer recommendation is to take it to keep it at take it to twenty-four units, not to twenty-nine units. [2:30:52, 2:31:03]: Oh is that correct, sir? Yeah, we recommend the denial of that variance request. Okay, so they were asking for 29 units. Right. So we're we send 24 instead. Okay. [2:31:03, 2:31:11]: So we're denying the request of twenty nine and a an approving twenty four and and not more than twenty four. Mr. Berry understood that he says so move. And I need a second. [2:31:12, 2:31:19]: So we're proving twenty four. Not more than twenty four. Okay, not more than twenty four. Okay. Mr. second on fair, please indicate. [2:31:21, 2:31:34]: Okay. All pose. Okay, so it's four, one, zero. It passes. All right. All right. Thank you, Mr. Anderson. All right, thank you. All right, thank you, sir, for being here in this aspect. [2:31:34, 2:31:54]: All right, announcements of upcoming meetings and events. Council meetings will be held in the city council chambers. Noting some board committee meetings will continue to take place via Zoom. Meeting dates and times are subject to change. Please visit the city's website at WW City of Starbrace dot com for the meeting invitation link, Facebook page, or contact City Hall offices at seven [2:31:54, 2:32:14]: 70389-7900 for updates. The Citywide Development Authority meeting, second Tuesday of each month, 6 p.m. City Hall Levi Meeting Room, July 9th. Okay, that is tomorrow. Startbridge Citizens Police Advisory Council meeting first Thursday of each month, 6 p.m. in Stockbridge Police Academy Room, police community. [2:32:14, 2:32:34]: Room, excuse me. In 4545 North Henry Boulevard, July 11th. Well says here the meeting's been canceled now. Okay. New council meeting, second Monday of each month at 6:30 p.m. City Hall Levi Meeting Room. And of course, no meeting due to summer break. The Main Street Advisory Board meeting, second Friday of each month, and 9 [2:32:34, 2:32:54]: 9 a.m. location downtown Connection Center, 130 ML King Senior Heritage Trail, July 12th. The Millage Rate Public Hearing Number 1, Monday, July 15th, 6:30 p.m. City Hall Council Chambers, of course on the 15th. The Downtown Development Authority meetings third Tuesday of each month, Stockbridge Downtown Center, 130 ML King. [2:32:54, 2:33:12]: Senior Heritage Trail July 16th. U Council Advisory Committee meeting, 6:30 p.m., third Tuesday of each month, the Levi Meeting Room, City Hall Chambers on the 16th as well. The Planning Commission meeting the third Thursday of each month, 6.30 p.m. the City Council Chambers on the July 18th. [2:33:13, 2:33:15]: The millet rate public hearing number two. [2:33:15, 2:33:19]: Friday, July nineteenth at ten AM City Hall Council Chambers. [2:33:20, 2:33:40]: Millis rate public hearing number three, Monday, July 22nd at 10 a.m. in the City Hall Council Chambers. The City Council Work Session meeting last Tuesday of each month, Tuesday, July 3rd, 6 p.m., City Hall Council Chambers. The community zoning and information meeting, Thursday, August 7th at 6 p.m., 7, uh, 6 p.m. to 7 p.m. [2:33:39, 2:33:59]: City Hall Council Chambers. And the city council meeting is the second Monday of each month, 6 p.m. City Hall Council Chambers on August 12th. Upcoming city events and initiatives, Food Truck Tasty Tuesdays back. Join us at Clark Park at 111 Davis Road, Stockbridge on Tuesdays from 5:30 to 8 p.m. for live music, great food, and host of free. [2:33:59, 2:34:19]: Games and activities for the kids. Join Councilman Councilwoman Yolana Barber as she partners with the second year of Kicks for Kids to collect Snickers for Kids on Saturday, July 13th at Starbury's first United Methodist Church. And those will be distributed at the city's back to school kickoff on July 20th. Please plan to donate what you can for the [2:34:19, 2:34:21]: [9262.5, 9282.5]: Join the Stockbridge Youth Council in partnership with the City of Stockbridge at Clark Park to fill the bus with school supplies during the tasty Tuesday on July 16th from 5:30 to 8 o'clock p.m. Let's make sure our students have what they need to have a successful school year. Join Councilman Afonso Thomas for the monthly Senior Bingo Bash on Wednesday, July 17th from 10 a.m. to 12. [2:34:42, 2:35:02]: twelve noon at Merlin Manors Conference Center 111 Davis Road for raffles, prizes, games, snacks, and fun. Join Councilwoman Lakeese Gann in partnership with Atlanta Food Truck Park and Night Market and Stockbridge Amphitheater parking lot from six PM to 9 30 p.m. July 18th. There will be vendors, food trucks, activities, gains, music and [2:35:02, 2:35:09]: Vibes, contact tanbowers at tan at Atlanta Foodtruck Park dot com for registration additional information. [2:35:10, 2:35:25]: Join the City of Stockbridge for the annual back to school kickoff event Saturday, July 20th at the Stockbridge Amber Theater for free school supplies from 11 a.m. to 1 p.m. Join Mayor Anthony Ford for the monthly Meet the Mayor on Wednesday, July 22nd, 10 a.m. to 12 noon at Stockbridge City Hall. [2:35:25, 2:35:35]: Join Councilman Elton Alexander for the community cleanup event on Saturday, August 10th, at 10 a.m. to 11 a.m. parking at Costco parking lot at 20 uh 2022 45 Jodico Road in Mad. [2:35:36, 2:35:56]: It Madonna, even though it is actually in a Stockbridge. Okay. Join Councilman Thomas for Don't Try Stockbridge Initiatives centered around education, education, education highlighting, screaming the causes and effects of littering and illegal dumping. More information to follow. Enjoy Councilman Thomas and honoring veterans and a continued salute all year long. Please send your pictures, your veterans' names and [2:35:55, 2:36:12]: and branch, rank, and years of service. Please contact uh course Ros and Rawls, get an appointment with meet the mayor. More information on council initiatives and events, call Ros and Rawls at 678-833-3348 or R Rawls at stopbridgega.org. [2:36:13, 2:36:22]: The 2024 Starbirds Amphitheater Summer Concert continues with Saturday, July 13th, and Sunday, July 14th, a night with Kim and special guest Leela James. [2:36:22, 2:36:26]: Saturday, July twentieth, is Ladies Night Out, featuring Jodice and Johnny Keel in Silk. [2:36:27, 2:36:29]: Twenty things to twenty first, as a matter of fact, two nights back to back. [2:36:30, 2:36:50]: And Saturday, July 27th, the 70 Soul Jam featuring the Shylights and Manhattan's legendary blue notes and bloodstone, the peach, and the herbs. And that 70 Soul Jam is going to be what they'll call our white part. Everybody comes dressed in white for that night. And then Saturday, August 3rd, 2024, is Babyface and Special Guest Avery Sunsign and Forecast. Hopefully, you all had a great day. [2:36:50, 2:37:10]: July 4th. We had an outstanding July 4th free concert in Firebirds at the Amphitheater. July 6th this past uh Saturday. We had Karen Briggs and Contemporal Orchestra and a lot of different guests. Wonderful jazz concert there. And of course, last night, July 7th, we had scheduled Charlie Wilson and Robin Thick. Robin Thick was able to perform, but Charlie Wilson had to be [2:37:10, 2:37:30]: Be postponed due to the weather. And if you if you bought a ticket, you'll get a you should receive the email from fresh ticks and also informing you that it will be rescheduled. It's on our website and a Facebook page for the city of Stockbridge that it will be rescheduled. I look forward at least a month to six weeks out before we have that again, and your tickets will be honored. All right, and on that note, uh [2:37:30, 2:37:37]: Uh council we actually have a second session dealing with real estate. All right, so I need a motion to go into the executive session, please. [2:37:38, 2:37:41]: Mayor, I move that we go into executive session for real estate. [2:37:42, 2:37:43]: Is there a second? [2:37:43, 2:37:45]: Okay, on fair please indicate. [2:37:47, 2:37:49]: Okay, okay, all posed? [2:37:49, 2:37:52]: All right, you sustain, sir. [2:37:53, 2:37:53]: Oh. [2:37:54, 2:37:57]: I can do personnel. You want me to do personnel too? [2:37:58, 2:38:00]: Real estate and personnel. Okay, all in favor, please indicate. [2:38:02, 2:38:05]: The the the from uh Gantt to uh [2:38:05, 2:38:06]: Alexander? [2:38:06, 2:38:10]: You second that motion, Alzheimer? You can't Alzheimer. I'll find please indicate. [2:38:10, 2:38:25]: All right, is there anonymous decision? Okay, we good? Miss Barber, did you vote for, against, or sustain? Which one does that mean? Okay. All right. So Nanus decision. Thank you. We'll go we'll be back, ladies and gentlemen. Let's go into second session. [2:38:43, 2:38:46]: Hello. [2:38:46, 2:38:47]: Yeah, okay. [2:38:48, 2:38:52]: All right. [3:03:30, 3:03:31]: Ms. Holiday, you can't see it yet? [3:03:33, 3:03:34]: Shut it down. [3:03:36, 3:03:38]: Well I mean he just walked, I just saw him go by. [3:04:25, 3:04:26]: Are we live yet, Ms. Holmes? [3:04:27, 3:04:31]: Okay, all right, good deal. Okay, council, I need a motion to end the second session, please. [3:04:32, 3:04:36]: Mr. Berry, is there a second? A second. Ms. Gantt, second, all in favor, please indicate. [3:04:37, 3:04:47]: I need a motion to uh re reconvene our city council meeting, please. I moved. Ms. Gantt, is there a second? Sir. Mr. Alzheimer's, a second in all in favor, please syndicate. [3:04:47, 3:04:54]: All right, and ladies and gentlemen, we have nothing to report from the executive session, so I now need a motion to end our council meeting. So move. Okay. [3:04:54, 3:04:56]: Mr. Berry, second down, all in favor, please indicate. [3:04:57, 3:04:58]: Good night everybody. God bless you all. [3:05:06, 3:05:07]: Mm-hmm. [3:05:10, 3:05:26]: So we should be seeing color to his mom waiting because he doesn't know how to describe it to GMA because he's never seen what we do on a daily basis. So what I have to do is now to find turn to
  • 2024-06-26 · City Council · Transcript · Work Session

    2024-06-26 · City Council · Transcript · source: 10yr-transcripts · sha256 2bda09c1 · pages – · method: official

    Full text — searchable
    --- title: Work Session date: 2024-06-26 source: 2024-06-26_Work_Session.wav --- [0:00:30, 0:00:35]: But I think I don't know why it's [0:00:45, 0:00:46]: We're good. [0:00:47, 0:01:03]: I madam clerk, I've been informed we are now live. All right. Council, ladies and gentlemen, want to start our council work session on June 26, 2024. I now have 607. [0:01:03, 0:01:05]: Please stand for the invocation. [0:01:08, 0:01:28]: I'll do this this evening. Lord, thank you for bringing us together once again as we continue to move our city forward, make the right logical decisions to make sure our citizens are taken care of and we're able to d deliver on our particular um a mission in reference to our our services that we we give to our citizens. Be us always, Lord, we continue to have great dialogue and as we continue to [0:01:28, 0:01:48]: To go forward with the with things that are happening within our city. Be us always Lord in your name. Amen. Pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands, one nation, under God, indivisible, liberty and justice. [0:01:48, 0:01:50]: Madam Clerk, Rocal, please. [0:01:51, 0:01:59]: Mayor Ford. Present. Mayor Pro Tem Berry. Let the record reflect. Mayor Pro Tem Berry is not in attendance. [0:02:00, 0:02:13]: Councilmember Alexander. Present. Council Member Barber. Present. Councilmember Gantt. Present. Council Member Thomas. Present. Mayor Ford, you have a quorum. Thank you, Madam Clerk. Appreciate that. Council, I need a motion to adopt the agenda, please. [0:02:14, 0:02:15]: [135.6, 140.1]: So move from Mr. Alexander, second. Ms. Barber? Okay, all favor, please indicate. [0:02:20, 0:02:26]: Okay, so improved. Thank you very much. And please review the uh minutes that you have before you uh for a council meeting. [0:02:27, 0:02:28]: Um on June tenth. [0:02:29, 0:02:33]: And review that and we'll be able to approve those at our next uh council meeting in July. [0:02:33, 0:02:35]: Madam Clerk, do we have any public comments at all? [0:02:37, 0:02:57]: Okay, thank you. So on that note, we'll go to New Business. New business. Council consideration to approve the purchase of two F one fifty uh F three fifties with service body and light package under the Georgia statewide contract number nine nine nine nine-spd ES four zero one nine nine three seven three-shaped. [0:02:57, 0:03:11]: It says with Alan Vigil Ford an amount of$143,001. Funding source from the Public Works Department budget items presented by it says Mr. Aaron here. I guess I was gonna do this. Okay. Please, sir. [0:03:15, 0:03:17]: Evening. Is it Mankon? Mikeon? [0:03:17, 0:03:20]: Yes, honor. Good evening, Mayor and Council. Evening. [0:03:23, 0:03:29]: We're asking that the council approve us getting the F three fifties. [0:03:31, 0:03:43]: Uh, for our fleet. Our fleet is old, um and this is past due. So we're looking to upgrade vehicles at this present time. So we're asking just, you know, for these two F three fifties. [0:03:45, 0:03:50]: Okay. Any questions? M Ms. Gantt, did you have a question for Al at all? [0:03:50, 0:04:01]: I know. All right. Um I see that we're going back to the old vendor on this. What was how did how did you guys choose the vendor of which to go to? [0:04:01, 0:04:05]: Uh whoever's has the state contract. It's not many [0:04:05, 0:04:15]: It's not many that have state contract as far as the vehicles that we're uh requesting the Fords. It's gonna be either Allen Vidigal or Wayford. Then also too with that [0:04:16, 0:04:21]: The way um as far as getting approval and everything, we meet. [0:04:23, 0:04:43]: We come kind of last as far as the block of vehicles when other municipalities, you know, saying submit theirs, the way our budget runs and the approval and everything, that we're kinda on the last end of getting our vehicles. So, you know, when Wave Ford may have it, by that time they close out, then we have to go to Alan Vigil. [0:04:43, 0:04:49]: is like a back and forth thing. But pretty much that's how we choose the um all-state contractors. [0:04:50, 0:04:56]: So those are only two places we can get those vehicles. M Mr. Aaron's coming up with that real quick. [0:05:01, 0:05:15]: Well the reason why is Alan Vigil,'cause they have the state contract for the F three fifties. So it's broken down. Some have the F one fifty, some have the F two fifty, but Alan Vigil is the only one on state contract that has the F three fifties. [0:05:15, 0:05:18]: Okay, thank you. Ms. Elzar. [0:05:18, 0:05:36]: Yeah, so what exactly is the usage for this truck that you require this level versus a traditional one fifty? What is the what what additional work is g being done with this one? But F three fifties, um off road, um towing. [0:05:38, 0:05:45]: Um So how how much are you how much are you towing with this? Excuse me? Oh how much weight are you fli are you talking about towing with this? [0:05:45, 0:06:05]: Oh well no, we're towing we have dandy dumps that we have to tow. So when we're doing cleanup and we're doing um dump sites and everything, sometimes we don't always have to take a dump truck. We can use our F-350 to pull a dandy dump. And that's be one of the things that we need to upgrade actually um next year as well. [0:06:05, 0:06:25]: You know, and that helps with not having to have, you know, a backhoe or tractors, whatever, to lift so high to put in a uh dump truck. We can use our dandy dump where we can kind of throw stuff in ourselves or we can use a smaller bobcat to use that. But mainly, you know, we did a uh somebody got evicted. [0:06:25, 0:06:33]: We had to go out there Friday and pick that stuff up. You know what I'm saying? So we had a tow of dandy dump as well. So the homeless and camps. [0:06:34, 0:06:39]: that we have to break down and everything. So we had a toe, you know, a dandy dump for that. [0:06:40, 0:06:48]: So and then as well as holding the crews as well. So it's enough room for these gentlemen to be in. We get the power and all of that stuff. [0:06:48, 0:07:08]: Okay, so pretty much you are being exercised the use of this equipment uh for uh the cleanups in the city, which we have had. Correct. Uh we have had one over uh off of Joe Car. Correct. We had no law Davidson Parkway, so correct. This particular equipment is aiding in the cleanup of the city when we have it's illegal dumping company. [0:07:08, 0:07:16]: Correct. And then also it provides us to go off off road as well to some of them areas. So that's not, you know, right off the street. [0:07:17, 0:07:18]: Okay. [0:07:18, 0:07:19]: Thank you. [0:07:20, 0:07:24]: Mr uh Mr um Thomas, please, sir. Thank you, Mayor. Um [0:07:26, 0:07:27]: They [0:07:27, 0:07:33]: And I'm I'm familiar with some of the issues that the city has has has a challenge in cleanup. [0:07:34, 0:07:39]: Let me see if I can put this in a better perspective going forward. Um [0:07:39, 0:07:42]: When the city has to [0:07:43, 0:07:44]: A bait [0:07:45, 0:07:46]: An issue. [0:07:47, 0:07:52]: So the answer that you gave to Mr Alexander, that's what it's ought to seem like and I know [0:07:53, 0:08:11]: Uh Mr. Aaron and I have had this conversation about nuisance and the city's ability to abate these issues. So are we sorta looking forward, Mr. Aaron, uh with this equipment and when the city has to abate [0:08:12, 0:08:32]: With with the F-350s, it allows you to pull and tow equipment. If they had to pull a uh backhoe out to the site, they can tow it with and pull it with the F-350, but you can't do that with an F-150 or F-250. Also, when they take a bobcat out to the site, they're using an F-350 to get that equipment. [0:08:32, 0:08:52]: out to the site. So you're choosing a higher level, higher powered vehicle so that you can tow equipment when you have to. Instead of them taking a dump truck out there, because they can pull something with it, they can take the F-350 and also have more available options because the F-350 have tools on it and things of that nature. So we're using it [0:08:52, 0:08:57]: is pulling power versus why we don't get a F-150 for what they're trying to do. [0:08:58, 0:09:00]: All right, thank you. Well Ms. Barber, go ahead, please. [0:09:02, 0:09:08]: Yes. Um, Mr. Aaron, this F three fifty purchase here. [0:09:09, 0:09:09]: Yes, ma'am. [0:09:10, 0:09:15]: Was this prepared by internal staff? [0:09:15, 0:09:29]: That sheet right there? Yes. That's just a spreadsheet of the cost of each one of those behaviors. I know. I'm trying to understand the calculations though. It says the original budget is two forty, and that is correct. But it says the remaining budget. [0:09:30, 0:09:43]: What is the remaining remaining budget is what's left after we purchase those two trucks. It's what was allocated was two hundred and forty thousand for vehicles. But this has remaining budget of a hundred and eighty-four thousand eight seventy. [0:09:45, 0:09:48]: So if your original budget is two forty and this [0:09:49, 0:09:52]: These purchases are a hundred and forty three thousand. [0:09:52, 0:09:54]: That would leave ninety six thousand. [0:09:55, 0:09:59]: So I was just confused as to what this remaining budget is. [0:10:03, 0:10:04]: Station. [0:10:21, 0:10:41]: So that might have been when we did the transit van. There's also a transit van in this calculation for the vehicle purchases. Okay. So that's included in that number. Thank you, sir. And I want to know, so the current trucks, the mileage, you normally give us that. [0:10:41, 0:11:01]: Are they still operable? These are vehicles, we're replacing vehicles that were surplus three to five years ago that are still at public works that have been on gov deal that we've we've tried to get rid of. So these are replacing those vehicles. And also, we gotta understand, too, that when we annex those are different. [0:11:01, 0:11:03]: [663.8, 669.7]: There's also a need for additional vehicles to support the work that we're doing in those locations as well. [0:11:10, 0:11:11]: Okay, thank you. [0:11:12, 0:11:32]: All right, if there are no other questions for the council, I need a motion to accept this proposal. So moved. Okay, is there a second? Okay, Ms. Ganttz, second that. All in favor, please indicate unanimous decision. Thank you very much. All right, thank you. Okay. And next we have the council consideration to approve the purchase of one transit van under Georgia statewide contract nine nine nine nine. [0:11:32, 0:11:45]: SPD-ES four zero one nine nine three seven three dash zero zero nine S, the Wade Ford and amount of fifty-five thousand one hundred thirty dollars. Funding sourced from the Public Works Department budgeted funds. And Al, I guess you have this one as well. [0:11:46, 0:12:06]: Yes. Uh we're requesting a transit van for facility maintenance. Um again, this is the van that we currently have. It'll be over$20,000 or$30,000 to kind of replace it. That's an older van from 2014, I believe. So again. [0:12:06, 0:12:26]: And we're asking that the council, you know, saying approve this as well. Okay, Mr. Alzheimer's, go ahead. Yeah, I know you have a question, sir. Yeah, I think uh certainly uh w during the class, all of us just went to Savannah uh and we discussed this with the city manager and Mr. Aaron as well about the use of the alternative fuel vehicle which be [0:12:26, 0:12:46]: uh an EV vehicle as far as it's concerned. The price markup on this is fifty-five thousand dollars and the EV is uh practically the same price basically and under the state contract we would be able to do that and I can't tell you how many times I've heard about the [0:12:46, 0:13:06]: the transmissions going out, the you know, the engines going out and various things happening with uh with with this equipment as far as the maintenance is concerned. And I think we all heard uh the benefit of the EVs uh vehicles uh being used in this capacity uh as well as we [0:13:06, 0:13:26]: We have the charging ports available out here at City Hall, and with the increased battery capacity of 300-350 plus miles, then certainly we want to be able to take car take care of the maintenance saving. And we are hoping that the city can continue to move forward with uh easy. [0:13:26, 0:13:46]: EVs and alternative fuel vehicles to cut down on some of the maintenance as we look at cost savings for the city and being good stewards of the citizens' money in this fashion. But I sent out the the sales pitch for the salesperson out there was pretty genuine. [0:13:46, 0:14:06]: in that uh what they told us and I learned a few things that I had not learned. I did not I did not realize the EV did not have a transmission to go out in it. It was directly to the fuel, directly to the uh tires to move the vehicle along and certainly that would save us no belts, no hoses uh to go out and those [0:14:06, 0:14:26]: Those are tremendous maintenance items that we have to maintain these items on. So certainly that would be the encouragement to explore that and to make that happen. Okay, but yes. And that and that's that's really good. And we are exploring that, but that's in the near future. You know, um, we're in talks with enterprise as far as, you know. [0:14:26, 0:14:46]: Leasing vehicles. And we would try to take that option when it comes to leasing vehicles. As of right now, with that van, it would be used as far as maintenance, it'll be tools and all the types of equipment on it. And then our only charger stations is leaving it at City Hall in the open versus at the maintenance shop. [0:14:46, 0:14:50]: where, you know, saying it's behind, you know, gates and locks of that nature. [0:14:50, 0:14:57]: But I mean, we're definitely not trying to exclude out having, you know, E V vehicles, but at this present time. [0:14:57, 0:15:03]: There's just a need for us to have, you know, that transit van as far as gasoline and everything like that. [0:15:03, 0:15:11]: But we're not but we're not definitely, you know, saying that's not off the table for us to go EV, but we would rather try to use [0:15:12, 0:15:32]: Enterprise for that, the least and options. But let me just say this right now. It's it's sometimes it's later, later, later. We've been hearing that for three years. This is the direction uh I think we should go in. Sometimes you gotta you gotta bite the bullet and and make it happen. So certainly this is if it's the food the the cost is comparable and [0:15:32, 0:15:52]: and and and the savings is there and we're trying to leave this for a better place than we found it for our children and the and folks down the down down the line. This is the direction that we want to go and I'm certainly that from talking to the salesperson that wait for the vehicle is available right now. [0:15:52, 0:16:12]: So you don't have to wait. So basically it's a choice of which um fuel option that you would wanna use for the vehicle. Charging port would be every three to four days and three hundred and fifty miles uh in distance. So I know there's always apprehensive to change, but certainly change is something that [0:16:12, 0:16:20]: That we see coming in the future that really needs to happen. So I certainly would allow Mr. Aaron to say a few words as well. [0:16:22, 0:16:42]: Well, we would contact Wade for it and then we'll get a price comparison EV versus uh regular gasoline vehicle. But one of the things I say, Enterprise is coming in July to speak with us about vehicle program. And along with that program comes a a maintenance agreement as well. So EV is relatively. [0:16:42, 0:17:02]: New for a lot of people as far as maintenance. Where do we take the vehicle to get service? If it we got to go 50 or 100 miles to get it serviced, then there's an issue. But enterprise already has a program, so they have contract with different vendors and things like that. So the maintenance will be a lot easier. We're just trying to say, we're not ducking the [0:17:02, 0:17:03]: Yes, we understand. [0:17:04, 0:17:24]: That you know, we work and protect the environment and one of the things we're gonna do is certain vehicles can be EV because they're not going anywhere, they're in the city. But certain vehicles, like I said, my main concern would be as Al said, you got a truck with fifty plus thousand dollars worth of tools in it, and somebody breaks into it and steal our tools while [0:17:24, 0:17:27]: at City Hall charging you know [0:17:27, 0:17:47]: I just think right now if we just go ahead and get the gasoline power it's always a reason not to and I've heard a bunch of excuses and we continue to hear them. I'm not voting for anything other than uh than us to explore that option. The rest of the council can do what they want to do, but we've been up here making excuses for five years. [0:17:47, 0:17:52]: Enough of that. [0:17:53, 0:17:56]: Okay, any other any other questions from the council thoughts? [0:17:57, 0:17:58]: No. [0:17:59, 0:18:19]: All right, so uh well need need a motion then. What would Sir I'm gonna make a motion for them to explore the option as the city manager has said on the price comparison uh for an EV vehicle for this, if the cost is uh comparable and for us to move forward and then certainly as we um go toward enterprise, we certainly will [0:18:18, 0:18:26]: Or would encourage enterprise to uh supply us with EV vehicles uh as well. Thank you. Is there a second motion? [0:18:27, 0:18:30]: Is there a second to the motion? Is Barber second that? [0:18:31, 0:18:32]: All in favor, please uh [0:18:33, 0:18:33]: Indicate. [0:18:34, 0:18:35]: All polls? [0:18:36, 0:18:43]: You you okay, okay. I got three over here, sir. You you for it? Four, zero, you standing? Yeah. [0:18:43, 0:18:46]: Okay, 401. Motion passed. Thank you, gentlemen. [0:18:49, 0:19:06]: All right. Council consideration approved the request for proposal RFP twenty twenty four dash zero zero zero one for civil engineering to Whitley Engineering Services an amount of five thousand dollars per month with option for renewal years at the city of Stockbridge discretion. Mr. Anderson, please. Good evening. Um [0:19:08, 0:19:28]: The purpose of this item is to award our civil engineering contract for the community development department. On our March 4th, we received three responses to our RFP for our civil engineering services. The firms were CPL Architecture and Engineering, Stand. [0:19:28, 0:19:31]: Tech Consulting Services and Whitley Engineering. [0:19:33, 0:19:36]: Um staff I mean the cities [0:19:37, 0:19:40]: організм a review committe. [0:19:40, 0:20:00]: composed of uh various city employees from different departments and uh they ranked the firms based on the proposals that they submitted. Uh Willie Engineering was number one, CPL architecture engineering was number two, and Stantec was number three. Uh on this slide right here [0:20:00, 0:20:02]: It lists all the requirements. [0:20:03, 0:20:06]: and duties that that particular firm would have to do. [0:20:07, 0:20:21]: And then the right column is what uh is the cost proposal amount submitted by Willie Engineering. That amount is at least fifty percent less than the city hiring its own civil engineer, and it's more than fifty percent less than the market rate. [0:20:22, 0:20:30]: Uh, here's um CPL's cost proposal. This cost proposal right here would have cost us tens of thousands of dollars a month. [0:20:32, 0:20:52]: Um, if we had accepted that one. Uh also the one from KCI Technologies Stand Tech, it would have been tens of thousands per month based on the amount of reviews that we currently have because we are really busy. Um staff recommendation is to um award the contract to Willie. [0:20:52, 0:21:03]: Willie Engineering for um for a proposal not to exceed seventy five thousand for one year with the option at the city's discretion for four one year renewable option, for four year renewable periods. [0:21:05, 0:21:15]: All right, thank you, sir. All right. Okay, questions, counsel. Yes, sir. Go ahead, please. Mr. Anderson, yes, sir, sir. All right, how are you doing, Councilman? Um [0:21:16, 0:21:30]: What uh when does this contract go into effect? Currently Willie Engineering is is on the emergency contract that that's slate that's slated to expire at the end of uh next month. So it will go into effect August. [0:21:31, 0:21:32]: When will it be in? [0:21:32, 0:21:34]: Uh August of twenty twenty five. [0:21:37, 0:21:39]: Okay, um [0:21:41, 0:22:00]: As one of the council members mentioned, uh we just come out of training. Yes, sir. And some information that we received is sort of contrary to contracts. But I'd have this discussion with you uh later. Okay. So um [0:22:00, 0:22:20]: At the end, it states here that this agreement is for one year. Yes, sir. With the option of renewal for four years. So you will come before the council every year when the contract ends for the renewal period, you will come back to the council. Yes sir. Each and every time. Yes, sir. Okay. But I do re [0:22:20, 0:22:33]: reserve um to have this conversation about when contracts end, regardless of when it starts but when it ends. Okay. Thank you, Mayor. Go ahead. Questions down this way. [0:22:33, 0:22:53]: Yeah, let me just say I echo Councilman Thomas's thoughts. That was something that was eye-opening for me as well in terms of uh contract expiration being the count being the end of the calendar year, and certainly something that we need to look at and to examine to see whether or not the practice [0:22:53, 0:22:57]: [1379.6, 1385.3]: Okay, any other questions? All right, no other questions on the motion to accept this. [0:23:07, 0:23:07]: Uh. [0:23:07, 0:23:27]: I move to approve the request for a proposal for civil engineering to Whitley Engineering Services and the amount not to exceed$75,000 for one year. Okay. Okay. Mr. Azine, you second that? Yes. Okay, good. Ms. Ms. Gannon, you must have a no. Okay, good. All in favor, please intend. [0:23:27, 0:23:28]: Okay. [0:23:28, 0:23:48]: Um councilman Thomas raised a very valid point. So with this being a one year contract, that means this contract will end this time next year. In August, but he'll bring them back. I think through the conversation is what I understand, he'll bring [0:23:48, 0:23:57]: back several months prior to that for for of us to to approve for another one year extension. That's what I understand. But what I'm saying is [0:23:57, 0:24:00]: This original contract that we're proving right now. [0:24:01, 0:24:21]: We need for it to end in December. I'm sorry. Are you gonna bring it back December of this year? So you're gonna bring it back next year? Uh it will be next year. So I what you're trying to line it up with the budget year? Is that the is that the goal? Yes. Okay, so we'll have to do that during our budget process. We'll just adjust our budget to line up with to make sure that it lines [0:24:21, 0:24:22]: [1462.6, 1472.7]: So you're gonna bring it back to us this year or no It would be next year. Okay, so that would be I understand the goal, so we will so we will line it up based upon [0:24:33, 0:24:53]: So that would be a seventeen month contract if it is to end December thirty-first of twenty twenty five. No, no, well I understand what you're saying, Councilmember Bar, but no it won't be if that is the wishes of the council. I certainly support it, just so that we can align it with our budget. Yeah, we we probably can do that some other kind of way. [0:24:53, 0:25:06]: Mayor Ford, let me resend that motion so I can restate it. All right. If you want to rescind the motion, go right ahead. You since you made it, you can resend it. Okay. All right. Mayor Ford. Yes, one stand by one place. Yes, sir. [0:25:07, 0:25:08]: Some [0:25:08, 0:25:16]: Yes, sir. I'm sorry, I thought you were recognizing. No. Um a couple of things, and and and I'm glad that she she did res saying that. [0:25:16, 0:25:19]: From my understanding, Mr. Uh Anderson, is that [0:25:20, 0:25:21]: Um [0:25:22, 0:25:42]: Regardless of when it is initiated, all contracts end at the end of the year. It doesn't matter what cycle you're on. But I think our procurement manager's here, uh Mayor Ford, if if it's okay if we can get some clarification on this issue of when contracts really end. [0:25:42, 0:25:47]: And if she could share uh could share in the light on that, I would love to hear that. [0:25:48, 0:25:49]: Alright. [0:25:50, 0:25:51]: Is the procurement manager here? [0:25:52, 0:25:53]: It's so hot. [0:25:54, 0:25:58]: Procure me. [0:25:58, 0:26:00]: Okay, well stand by folks, stand by. [0:26:01, 0:26:20]: Legally the contract ends when the term of the contract ends. Okay, we need to So when you sign a contract, the term of that contract governs when the contract comes to an end, is when the term of that contract says. Right. Now I'm sorry. [0:26:21, 0:26:26]: I think is I don't know if that's where you're going, kinda. Certain contracts can't go beyond [0:26:28, 0:26:33]: Certain contract and this is why I wish the city attorney was here, but certain contracts can't go beyond the term of counsel. [0:26:34, 0:26:34]: Um [0:26:35, 0:26:55]: If so, they have to be obviously that's where you have the renewal process on a on a given basis for you to extend it. So for instance, they had a two year contract because the term of the mayor ends within that two years, but with three year extension, the next council or the next mayor gets to see and approve that contract, even if it's for another year. Um but I don't know if he's [0:26:55, 0:26:57]: Yeah, it's money. [0:26:58, 0:27:18]: And I agree with with what what um Councilmember um Barber wants to do. It makes a sense it makes a lot of sense that rather than having the contract in next year this time, aligning it with the with the budget cycle would actually work. That way we can bid it out, know what our price is, and then incorporate that price in the next year, upcoming fiscal year for the for that period for that. [0:27:18, 0:27:31]: annual period. So what she says actually makes makes a lot of sense. Than thank you sir. Mayor Ford. Yes sir. Um I I I didn't get a response. I would like the procurement manager come forward. All right. To share some light on procure procurement. [0:27:32, 0:27:37]: to share some light on it and I and I think what we've been doing here in the Cities for practice [0:27:37, 0:27:45]: I won't say we've been doing it incorrectly, uh, but there's some issues and hopefully we can we can get some clarification. [0:27:47, 0:28:06]: Thank you. So yes, sir, that is correct. We are moving forward to aligning all our contracts up with the um physical year. So we on the calendar year. So all of our contracts, the initial term will be should have been from August to December the thirty first, and then the first renewal starts then. [0:28:07, 0:28:10]: But yes, we are in that process. That is a good practice. [0:28:10, 0:28:30]: Okay, back to Miss Ms. You've done certain Well I'm I'm still a little concerned about this particular contract. Okay. And I know Mr. Anderson saying that in the current contract ends next month or something. Yes. So it ends next month. So now here we are, we need to do something when this one [0:28:30, 0:28:33]: So I guess the question though is that the other one is a little bit more than [0:28:34, 0:28:36]: Do we initiate this contract? [0:28:37, 0:28:42]: to start at the end of this one. But the question is when does it end? [0:28:42, 0:28:47]: So um, like Miss Barber was saying, if we can add the additional four months. [0:28:47, 0:28:51]: to the contract and then bring it back um [0:28:52, 0:29:12]: Bring it back the following year. That would make sense. Since we are right here at the end of the year. Yes. So So just roll it. Yeah, those roll those additional four months, August to December together and then start the other twelve months. So I would if that makes sense. I would recommend in the motion. [0:29:12, 0:29:16]: Mrs. Councilwoman Barber that this be stated in the motion. [0:29:18, 0:29:29]: Oh you have w you c well go ahead, sir. Is there is there a substantial price difference between doing it the month to month as we're on now under the emergency versus the renewal, or are we talking apples to apples? [0:29:29, 0:29:45]: Um it's the price. Be on the mic. But when you get re if if we go on a if we run it from August to December thirty first, there might be a chance that it could be renegotiated to a higher fee. There's a possibility. [0:29:47, 0:29:51]: Okay. Okay, good. Okay, back Miss Barber. [0:29:52, 0:30:12]: Yeah, that's exactly why I wanted to go ahead and lock this in for a year and four months. Yeah, twenty twenty five. Yes. Yes. This is a pretty good rate, five thousand dollars a month. But I'll go ahead and make the motion if everybody is fine. [0:30:12, 0:30:22]: Before you do that, Miss Ms. Anderson Anderson, you understand what we're gonna do here? Yes, sir, I understand. Okay. So she's running it for for sixteen months instead of twelve months. Okay. All right. Go ahead, please. [0:30:22, 0:30:25]: I motion to approve [0:30:25, 0:30:26]: The requ [0:30:26, 0:30:39]: The new contract for civil engineering for Whitley Engineering Services in the amount of five thousand dollars per month with an option for renewal years beginning [0:30:39, 0:30:45]: In August through December thirty first of twenty twenty five. [0:30:45, 0:30:50]: Okay, is there a second emotion? Look, uh mist I got Mr. Alexander. All in favor, please indicate. [0:30:50, 0:30:57]: Genau decision. Okay, thank you. Appreciate it. Thank you. All right. Thank you. Thank thank you. Okay, okay, Mr. Washington. Thank you. [0:30:58, 0:31:12]: This just so everybody knows, we will do it that way, but just as a a point of of you know professional education, it'll be for a year with four one month renewals to get to the sixteen months. [0:31:12, 0:31:15]: With all. All right. Appreciate [0:31:19, 0:31:21]: Alrighty. [0:31:23, 0:31:43]: four one one okay council consideration approve request for excuse me council consideration to approve request for proposal RFP twenty twenty four dash zero zero five for janitory maintenance services intercontinental commercial services incorporated amount of one hundred forty three thousand dollars and one hundred forty three one hundred thousand [0:31:43, 0:31:48]: A hundred and forty three one hundred thousand dollars. Okay, presented by Mr Barnes, please. [0:31:51, 0:32:05]: Yes, we're asking for the uh council's request uh to approve this. We're switching janitorial companies and we're actually um going back with ICS from the BMS um services. [0:32:06, 0:32:07]: Questions, Council that you may have. [0:32:09, 0:32:12]: You go ahead, Mr Mr. Barnes. [0:32:13, 0:32:19]: How you sir? I'm doing fine. So in the janitorial contract [0:32:20, 0:32:22]: Can you share with us any [0:32:23, 0:32:32]: um improvements or any in in your in your discussion with the various uh applicants, uh shared with the council [0:32:33, 0:32:38]: uh some improvements that you have detected um [0:32:39, 0:32:51]: I I think we always should look to improve uh our service delivery as we do to the citizen, but even the contracts that that that we uh implement. [0:32:52, 0:32:56]: Especially when it comes to something like a janitor. So can you speak to [0:32:57, 0:33:06]: any of the improvements um that you have detected or even in your conversation with the with the various uh vendors. [0:33:06, 0:33:26]: Well actually that's one of the reasons why we're um that we're going with another company because the current company is not keeping up to the standard that you know we're requesting you know as a um staff and as a city. Um they've only been with us since September. You know, we're not satisfied. We had maybe on [0:33:26, 0:33:46]: Honestly, three meetings with them. And they're still, you know, when we call them, they'll come out here. And I'm sure you all work walking these buildings and kind of see, you know, saying stuff that's out of place that should not be. Um, so even with ICS, we actually have a meeting with them tomorrow. Um, they were currently with us um last year. [0:33:46, 0:33:56]: last year. So I'ma stress to them the importance of, you know, them keeping a level of standard of cleaning. Cause if not, then we'll be right back at it again. [0:33:56, 0:34:01]: But we're not gonna settle for just mediocre cleaning when, you know, we're [0:34:02, 0:34:04]: you know, spending this type of money for their services. [0:34:04, 0:34:24]: So so how do you evaluate or are there periodical points in time that you meet with the vendor to discuss uh improvement, but mainly how do you evaluate? I know you get word of mouth from Well you get word of mouth to evaluate, but it'll you can just look and see if it ain't being clean. [0:34:24, 0:34:26]: It's not being clean. [0:34:26, 0:34:31]: You know, so also, you know, if I'm meeting with uh the manager that's on site [0:34:32, 0:34:36]: You know, as far as letting them know, you know, taking pictures. [0:34:36, 0:34:37]: Walk in the buildings with them. [0:34:38, 0:34:56]: It's evident if they're not cleaning, you can see that they're not cleaning. Right. Um so then also too, going, you know, speaking with the regional manager, we don't had numerous, uh talking about BMS, we don't had numerous conversations with them. But how many more conversations should we have until, you know, saying we just move forward as a city? [0:34:56, 0:35:16]: Right. So do you make a a purpose walk through the various buildings to to actually to see? We do a walkthrough every morning as far as facility maintenance. You know, so we walk through here when we get in uh when we get maybe by six fifteen in the morning. But again, if we're walking through it. [0:35:16, 0:35:18]: Івен має офис. [0:35:18, 0:35:23]: If it's not clean, it's not clean, you know, so you know saying you can see. [0:35:23, 0:35:26]: You know, so I again, well, with that being said, [0:35:28, 0:35:37]: after so many meetings, it's just time for us to move forward. Right. Mayor, this is my last question. Um in the years after COVID, [0:35:38, 0:35:58]: There was an item called COVID cleaning. So is that still a part of um the evaluation, a part of the services, or is that still um an identified item in the contract that says covet cleaning? That's still provided. That's in the scope of work from my understanding. [0:35:58, 0:36:18]: And also, too, as you may understand, COVID has not gone anywhere. So you do have small cases. And then when those cases do arise, we fog and we take, you know, wipe downs and everything seriously. So we're still going by, you know, saying the guidelines that we set as far as when COVID was in place. [0:36:18, 0:36:38]: Thank you. I yield back, man. No problem. Any other questions from this end? Yeah, is the air conditioner working in here? I'm sorry. I I know, I know. We're we're having issues with that. Uh we actually had a technician out here this morning. So I mean, actually this late late afternoon. So and they're coming back out in the morning. So uh [0:36:38, 0:36:45]: I apologize for that. But I was actually out here till four forty with them trying to get this up and going. So [0:36:46, 0:36:47]: Any other questions on this this topic? [0:36:48, 0:36:57]: And so I do have a so this particular company out of the uh five that were evaluated, this is the best value? [0:36:57, 0:37:17]: as far as the quality of what you've seen in the past, is that what was the key decision based upon this one? Um we also we have a panel and everyone looks at all the you know the um bids and everything as far as what they submit. So they submit a packet we all go through it is gonna have you know [0:37:17, 0:37:36]: um everything pretty much about their businesses, references, as well as, you know, the managers, history of the company. And actually ICS actually came, you know, they they scored high out of everybody. So there's some close, you know, but ICS came out, you know, victorious. [0:37:37, 0:37:40]: Okay. If no other question I need a motion to accept this proposal. [0:37:42, 0:37:47]: So I moved. Okay. Is there a second Ms Barber second there from Miss Canton, Miss Barber Officer? [0:37:47, 0:37:48]: I'm sorry. [0:37:48, 0:37:52]: Do we wanna do the contract extension? Thank you, Ms Hull. [0:37:53, 0:37:53]: Um [0:37:53, 0:37:54]: Councilwoman Gantt. [0:37:55, 0:38:15]: The you mean from the year to the end of December twenty twenty five to the in the fur the four months? Absolutely. But let me ask a question. Let me let me So you reset an original motion to the first one. Wait one second. But but but now with this being a new vendor, do we w might might want to wait until to see whether they work out or not before we get [0:38:15, 0:38:35]: them an extend extended contract or might we be able to back out? We don't know the quality we want to see the quality of their work before giving an extended contract. I'm not sure but I believe that we're always able to back out if they're in an event that they're not holding up to their service. Purchasing manager should be able [0:38:35, 0:38:43]: To share with you there are stipulations in the contract that they do not perform to the level that we expect. [0:38:44, 0:38:56]: And and while you're asking that, w what are the consequences of us doing month to month? Is there a penalty? Do we pay more? Um, why is it that I mean, because it would it it is easier for us to go [0:38:57, 0:39:01]: from year to year by ending in December. So [0:39:02, 0:39:13]: Once we get all the contracts lined up eventually, hopefully it will look like from December to December. So whatever year, whether it's one year or four years or five years, all of them will end. [0:39:13, 0:39:31]: In Decem December, by the time we is there anything that is going to make it complicated that we do those Ford months, like with the other contracts, anything else if we had individual months year to month to month?'Cause I we've had to do it in the past. So I'm I don't see I just wanna make sure. [0:39:32, 0:39:39]: So usually when you do a month to month contract with the vendor, the prices will be renegotiated and it's gonna be more. [0:39:40, 0:39:45]: So the f the initial year should be from July seventeenth. [0:39:46, 0:40:00]: July the seventeenth through December the thirty first. That should be the initial first year. And then we're asking you all, since it's so late in the game, if you could approve it for the following year. Then we come before you again. [0:40:00, 0:40:04]: in September and ask for a renewal for the next following year. [0:40:04, 0:40:22]: So so that'd be option year number two when we come to you again for this particular contract. So would it be safe to say it'd be easier to do from July of 17th until December 31st, 2025? [0:40:23, 0:40:43]: Um twenty twenty five no, because it's it's a a di it's a initial year. So we have to all our contracts we're trying to get'em to end on December the thirty first. Okay. So that's gonna be the initial year regardless of when it was awarded. Okay. So once it's awarded, um since it's so late, this contract is so late in the game. [0:40:43, 0:40:47]: Therefore we're asking that we just go ahead and [0:40:48, 0:40:54]: get it going until the following December the thirty first, which would be the twenty twenty twenty five. [0:40:54, 0:41:14]: That's what okay. I just that's that's what I just that's what you say. Yes, ma'am, that's it. That's it. Just making sure. Yes, that's it. If that makes sense. Go ahead. So, you know, if we needed to we're moving on because we weren't satisfied with the work. So [0:41:14, 0:41:22]: this vendor we're not satisfied with the work, are we gonna be locked into this or is it No sir, we have a clause in our contract that we can terminate. [0:41:22, 0:41:25]: Okay. So we said now said okay. Yes, sir. [0:41:26, 0:41:36]: I you want to restate your motion now? Yes, I would like to restate the motion to include the expiration termination date as of December thirty first, twenty twenty five. [0:41:36, 0:41:46]: Sir second the most Ms. Barber second, all in favor please indicate. Wait, I do have a question though. So the additional months beyond the initial twelve months. [0:41:46, 0:41:49]: Will you be prorating that per month? [0:41:50, 0:41:51]: Based on [0:41:51, 0:41:52]: These terms. [0:41:52, 0:41:58]: Yes, ma'am, that's correct. So it only will be they only will pay us their monthly fee for that four months. [0:41:59, 0:42:08]: Oh they have to agree to that. Yes, they will agree to that, yes ma'am.'Cause it's actually in the contract, if you look at the contract, it uh it says the initial [0:42:08, 0:42:20]: It's gonna expire on December the thirty first. I know you mentioned that there we would probably have to pay a higher rate. That's why I asked. Oh no ma'am. You're welcome. [0:42:20, 0:42:24]: Mirful. Yes, sir. Clarification. Go ahead. So [0:42:25, 0:42:41]: In this motion and in this agreement, are we saying that we will we will do a contract from now to December 2024 plus a full 12 months. [0:42:42, 0:42:43]: Contract as well. [0:42:44, 0:42:46]: So my question is will you come back to us [0:42:47, 0:42:50]: At the end of December twenty twenty four. [0:42:51, 0:42:52]: Hopefully not. [0:42:53, 0:43:07]: No ma'am, no sir. We're not coming back twenty twenty four. We're asking you today to approve the contract for four months. That's gonna lead us out until well, five months. That's gonna lead us out to December the thirty first. [0:43:08, 0:43:13]: Then we're asking for a additional twelve months, which is the first option year. [0:43:14, 0:43:15]: So what [0:43:16, 0:43:25]: My concern is, and I thought I heard you you say earlier was that we were trying to bring all contracts in line. [0:43:26, 0:43:32]: And so this seems not to be coming in line with the practice. So that's why I'm a little confused. [0:43:32, 0:43:40]: Yeah, it's come so if we since we are so you all are you all request us to renew a contract within a hundred and twenty days. [0:43:41, 0:43:46]: So therefore, it's not gonna be a hundred and twenty days because we're just now renewing this contract. [0:43:46, 0:43:51]: So if we go ahead and renew the contract now. [0:43:52, 0:43:53]: Until December the [0:43:55, 0:44:07]: December the um 31st of 2024. And then we're asking you to exercise the first option year, which is gonna be January the first, twenty twenty-five. [0:44:08, 0:44:16]: to December the thirty first, twenty twenty five. And at that time we come back to you and ask for the um actual the second renewal date. [0:44:17, 0:44:26]: Renewal option, I'm sorry, if that makes sense. Great. So, Mayor, last question. Yes, sir. Uh are there any other contracts? [0:44:27, 0:44:43]: that falls in this same predicament as far as expiring in the next month or so that we need to come back and actually to do the very same thing. So my my concerning question is how and when [0:44:44, 0:44:53]: Do we bring everything in line with contract in and it renewal? I know it's i you may not be able to answer that, you know, point but that's sort of my concern. [0:44:53, 0:45:13]: Yes, and that's a good concern. And um basically all we can do is move forward from now for when we get new bids and have the uh have the contract set that way. That's the only thing that we can do at this point. All right, thank you. Mayor, I yield back. Okay. Any other questions? Not a but we had a motion. [0:45:13, 0:45:19]: Motion on the floor in a second. All right. All in favor of the motion, please indicate. Now she says thank you very much. Appreciate it. [0:45:21, 0:45:41]: Okay. No. Okay. Definitely not. Announces upcoming meeting events, uh council meetings will be held. The city council chambers noting some board of committee meetings will continue to be place uh take place via Zoom meeting, dates and times, and subject to change. Please visit the city's website at W [0:45:41, 0:46:01]: www.citofstarbridge.com for the meeting invitation link, Facebook page, or contact city hall offices at 770-389-7900 for updates. Community zoning informational meeting Thursday, June 27th, from 6 p.m. to 7 p.m. in City Hall and the Council Chambers, June 27th. [0:46:01, 0:46:21]: Choice PLOS six meeting, Thursday, June 27th, 630 at the Henry County Admin Building, 140 Henry Boulevard, excuse me, 140 Henry Parkway, Pedonna, Georgia, June twenty once June twenty-seventh, of course, and uh we'll be there for that. Stockbridge Citizens, uh Police Advisory Council meeting first Thursday of each month, six PM at [0:46:21, 0:46:41]: Stockbridge Police Community Room, 4545 North Henry Boulevard. Slide meeting, of course, will be councilled due to the Fourth of July holiday. All right. City Council meeting, second Monday of each month, six PM, City Hall Council Chambers, which is July 8th. Youth Council meeting second Monday of each month at 6 30 p.m. [0:46:41, 0:46:46]: City Hall, Levi meeting room, and there is no July meeting due to the summer break. [0:46:48, 0:47:08]: Citywide Development Authority meeting, second Tuesday of each month, 6 p.m. City Hall Levi Meeting Room, July 9th. The Main Street Advisory Board meeting, second Friday of each month at 9 a.m. Location, of course, the Downtown Connection Center, 130 ML King Senior Heritage Trail Trail, which is July 12th. Millage Rate Public Hearing Number 1. [0:47:08, 0:47:13]: Monday, July fifteenth at six thirty PM right here in the City Hall Council Chambers. And um [0:47:15, 0:47:35]: Yes, on the fifth says July okay, July eighth must be the first well at City Council, it's gotta be July fifteenth here. Downtown Development Authority meetings uh third Tuesday third Tuesday of each month, Stockbridge Downtown Center, one thirty ML King Senior Heritage Trail, July sixteenth. Youth Council Advisory Committee meeting six thirty P. M. Uh [0:47:35, 0:47:40]: Uh third Tuesday of east month in Levi Meeting Room, City Hall, Council Chambers, uh July sixteenth. [0:47:41, 0:47:46]: Planning commission meeting second uh Thursday of each month, six thirty PM, Seahall Council Chambers, July eighteenth. [0:47:47, 0:47:53]: Damillage rate uh public hearing number two, Friday, July nineteenth at ten AM, City Hall Council Chambers. [0:47:54, 0:48:12]: The millers rate public hearing number three, Monday, July twenty second at ten A.M. And actually it's ten fifty millets to be set at ten fifteen, C Hall Council Chambers, July twenty second. City Council work session meeting last Tuesday of each month, two uh Tuesday, july thirtieth, six PM, uh the city council chambers. [0:48:13, 0:48:33]: Food Truck Tasty Tuesday is back, of course. Join us for Le Clark Park at the eleven one one Davis Road, Stockbridge on Tuesday at Stockbridge on Tuesdays at five thirty eight PM for live music, great food, a host of free games and activities for the kids. Now this next following Tuesday it will not be happening because of the fourth of July holiday. Join Castleman Elton. [0:48:33, 0:48:53]: for district five town hall meeting on Saturday, June, June 29th, 2024, of course at ten A.M. at Argento at the Bridges at Jodico, three hundred Argento Drive in Madonna. And once again it's a City of Stockbridge, of course. We got a Madonna address. Go figure, right? Join the City of Stockbridge for the annual free [0:48:53, 0:49:13]: Fourth of July uh concert, uh July Extravaganza with fireworks, which will be at ten forty five on that evening, live music. The gates will open up at five PM and the concert will start at seven and end to it at eleven. Uh the concert features soul cartel, algebra and bless it. [0:49:13, 0:49:21]: Bobby V and a Michael Jackson live tribute and Kumol D has been added. So come on out folks for a free concert. [0:49:22, 0:49:42]: Join uh councilman uh councilwoman Yolanda Barber as she partners with the second year with Kicks for Kids to collect sneakers for kids on Saturday, July sixth, it's and uh Saturday, July thirteenth at Stockbridge First United Methodist Church. It will be distributed at the city's back to school kickoff on july twentieth. Please plan to donate what you can uh [0:49:42, 0:50:02]: to this life-changing initiative. Join Councilman Elton Alezana for the community cleanup event, which will be Saturday, a Saturday designated in August. Uh be uh 9 a.m. to 12 noon. So more information to follow us on the Zach Saturday date in August. Join Councilman Fonzo Thomas for the monthly senior Bingo Bash on Wednesday, July 17th, uh from [0:50:02, 0:50:22]: 10 a.m. to 12 noon, Emberomana's Conference Center, 111 Davis Road for rifles, prizes, games, snacks, and fun. Join Councilman uh Councilwoman Lakeesia Gantt in partnership with Atlanta Food Park Truck Park for the night market at Starbury's Amphitheater parking lot from 6 p.m. to 9 30 on uh [0:50:21, 0:50:26]: July eighteenth and there'll be vendors, food trucks, activities, games, music and vibes. [0:50:26, 0:50:28]: And the theme is island flavor. [0:50:29, 0:50:49]: And so contact Tan Bowers at tan at Atlanta FoodtruckPark.com for registration and additional information. Join the city of Stockbridge for the annual back to school kickoff event on Saturday, July 20th. Stockbridge Amphitheater for free school supplies from 11 a.m. to 1 p.m. Join me, Mayor Anthony Ford, for the monthly meet the mayor on Wednesday, July 20th. [0:50:49, 0:51:09]: 22nd from 10 a.m. to 12 noon, right here at Stockbridge City Hall. And please contact uh Rosalind Rawls to schedule an appointment for more information on council initiatives and events and call her at 678-833-3348 or by way of email at ralls at starbridgega.org. Join Councilman [0:51:09, 0:51:26]: Thomas for Don't Trash Stockbridge Initiative Center around education, highlighting the causes and effects of littering and illegal dumping. Of course more information to follow on that as well. [0:51:28, 0:51:37]: Okay, Saturday, this Saturday July, uh excuse me, this Saturday uh twenty-ninth of j uh June, we have I Got Away Tour concert uh gospel concert. [0:51:37, 0:51:57]: Uh gates will open up at five. The concert starts at uh seven. Uh Dietrich uh Hadden, uh Patrick Pastor Mike Junior Bria uh Bra Bereno, if I've got to pronounce white, Anthony Brown, and this is in partnership with McDonald's, and they're having this concert this uh this this Saturday. Saturday, July. [0:51:57, 0:52:17]: Six, Karen Briggs Com Temple Orchestra featuring Phil Perry, Alita Adams, Regina Bell, Shelley Mencino Missini, I guess how it's pronounced, Jasmine Gantt, Brian Broomberg, and Tommy Davison. Sunday july seventh, uh the end of Fourth of July weekend featuring Charlie Wilson, the special guest is Robin Fick. [0:52:17, 0:52:18]: Yeah. [0:52:18, 0:52:38]: Saturday, July 13th and Sunday, July 14th, a night with Kim, K E M, and special guest Lila James. Saturday, July 20th and 21st will be Lazy Night Out featuring Jodice, Johnny Gill, and Silk. July 27th, 70 Soul Jam. Everybody's supposed to wear white to that particular concert. You will have the Shylights, Manhattan. [0:52:38, 0:52:58]: Blue notes, Bloodstone, and Peaches and Herb. And of course, Saturday, August 3rd, which is the last one posted on the Star on the website, is Babyface with special guests, Avery Sunshine, and Forecast. Obviously the more concerts to occur before the concert season at StockbridgeAnp.com. And July is going to be a very hot, hot month at the bridge. [0:52:58, 0:53:05]: in my comments here uh that uh we all attended the Georgia Municipal Municipal Annual Conference in Savannah. [0:53:05, 0:53:14]: Twenty-first to twenty-fifth, uh is the annual occurrence that comes up and we have a couple couple of things to mention. And first of all, very proud and and very happy. [0:53:14, 0:53:22]: uh that the Vanessa holiday is considered and is the twenty four GMA's uh twenty twenty four Clerk of the Year. Fantastic mission. [0:53:29, 0:53:31]: [3212.4, 3232.4]: And she will she will go down in history with the GMA as they keep track of all those clips of the years through all these years. So your name is forever and still with that. Outstanding. Outstanding. And also uh the GMA conference and uh we have we take classes and get educated and it's been talked about a little bit this evening. So Councilman uh Alfonso Thomas got the dedication award [0:53:52, 0:54:04]: More than two hundred and seventy six hours t to his a credit. And then Councilman Elton Alexander got the distinction award and that's a little more than two hundred and four hours of of education. So congratulate gentlemen to you as well. Okay. [0:54:07, 0:54:27]: So my initial comments, of course, it is June going into July, so keep cool, drink lots of fluids, and uh be careful, and we don't need any heat strokes or folks passing out here. And uh I have to say to you again, once again, it's hot and hot in hot summer, hot, hot July coming up with all these concerts at the bridge. And so um and please uh come out for the fourth July. [0:54:26, 0:54:45]: Line celebration independence holiday. Look forward to seeing you there at our city sponsored event. And at this time, I'm not sure if do we have an executive uh session that we need? No executive session. Okay, so on that note then, I need a motion to end our meeting, please. We did have a change in the time on July fourth, if you mentioned that. [0:54:45, 0:55:05]: Uh yeah. It's uh what I had here was um yeah seven seven to eleven and gates open at five because gates typically open two week two hours prior. So seven to eleven. Yes sir. Yeah. Thank you. All right, no problem. All right, I need a motion to end our meeting, please. So is there so for Mr. Azan? Is there a second? I second. Okay, Mr. Gansay all favor, please indicate. [0:55:05, 0:55:06]: We have now adjourned. God bless you all.
  • 2024-06-20 · City Council · Transcript · Planning Commission

    2024-06-20 · City Council · Transcript · source: 10yr-transcripts · sha256 c6b46c27 · pages – · method: official

    Full text — searchable
    --- title: Planning Commission date: 2024-06-20 source: 2024-06-20_Planning_Commission.wav --- [0:00:18, 0:00:19]: Fire. [0:00:24, 0:00:25]: [ 26.4, 30.5]: Red on the [0:00:59, 0:01:06]: It is now six thirty. The Plan Commission meeting for june twentieth, twenty twenty four will now come to order. [0:01:09, 0:01:10]: Must do [0:01:11, 0:01:31]: Williams, would you do the invocation, please? Sure. Please bow your heads. Lord God, thank you for allowing us to come before during this meeting to conduct the business of our community. We thank the constituents for coming out, God. So allow us to conduct this meeting in the matter of business. Guide our hearts and our minds in the spirit of fairness through truth and speech, God. [0:01:31, 0:01:34]: Make it fair and easy. In Jesus' name we pray. Amen. [0:01:35, 0:01:37]: Does that stand for the place, please? [0:01:41, 0:01:53]: [120.6, 123.1]: Madam Secretary, could we have a roll call, please? [0:02:07, 0:02:11]: Stanley Dumas. Present. Anthony Mitten. [0:02:14, 0:02:15]: Right. [0:02:17, 0:02:18]: President [0:02:23, 0:02:23]: President. [0:02:31, 0:02:33]: Believe we have a quorum, is that correct? [0:02:35, 0:02:37]: Thank you, Madam Secretary. [0:02:45, 0:02:50]: I need a motion please to adopt the agenda. Chair, motion to adopt the agenda. [0:02:51, 0:02:52]: Zero segment. [0:02:53, 0:03:05]: Mr. Williams has made a motion to adopt the agenda. Mr. Thibodeau seconded. All in favor, let it be known by the sign of aye. Aye. Any opposed? Ayes have it. The agenda is adopted. [0:03:08, 0:03:12]: You have before you the minutes from the april eighteenth, twenty twenty four meeting. [0:03:14, 0:03:18]: If you haven't already done so, I would ask that you take a moment to peruse the minutes. [0:03:20, 0:03:22]: For any necessary corrections. [0:03:37, 0:03:43]: There are no corrections. I need a motion to approve, please. Well Ms. Chair, I think we have one discorrection. That would be uh [0:03:44, 0:03:45]: Turn your microphone on, please, sir. [0:03:47, 0:03:56]: think I have one one correction. That would be uh May sixteenth, am I correct? Not eighteenth? May sixteenth. Yeah. [0:03:57, 0:04:05]: Look at that. I think that the the agenda is incorrect. It says April eighteenth, but it's really Ma sixteenth. [0:04:09, 0:04:11]: Any other corrections? [0:04:15, 0:04:29]: On the agenda item number six, it's asking for approval of the minutes from April eighteenth, twenty twenty four. I think that's a typographical error. It should be saying May sixteenth, twenty twenty four. [0:04:36, 0:04:38]: I need a motion to approve, please. [0:04:40, 0:04:44]: Mr Chairman, I'd like to make a motion to approve the minutes as [0:04:45, 0:04:45]: Corrected. [0:04:46, 0:04:47]: Is there a second? [0:04:48, 0:04:54]: Ms. Harrow, I'll second it. It's been moved by Mr. Planchon and seconded by Mr. Tibodeau that we [0:04:56, 0:05:04]: Approve the minutes from the May 16th meeting. All in favor, let it be known by the sound of life. Aye. Any opposed. [0:05:04, 0:05:07]: I have it, the minute saw approved. [0:05:12, 0:05:25]: I'd like to welcome you all of you to the City of Stockbridge Planning Commission meeting. I am Stanley Dumas. To my left, to my far left is Mr. David Plancher. [0:05:25, 0:05:34]: To my far right is Mr Anthony Williams. I'm sorry, Jaden Williams, and to my immediate right is Mr Harold Tibador. [0:05:36, 0:05:43]: The staff members fether or Ryan Enerson is the community development director seated down at the table. [0:05:46, 0:05:49]: Valerie Ross is the city's owning attorney sitting next to him. [0:05:52, 0:05:55]: To my right I have Keedwell Jackson, the chief planner. [0:05:57, 0:06:00]: Linda Logan, who I believe is not present. [0:06:02, 0:06:06]: And Gordon Linter is a planner one. [0:06:08, 0:06:21]: There are a few protocols that I need to make you aware of before we start the meeting because this is a public hearing. I ask that you listen closely on how tonight's meeting will be conducted. [0:06:23, 0:06:28]: Number one, keep all your comments and presentations on a professional level. [0:06:29, 0:06:30]: With facts that are [0:06:30, 0:06:33]: Important for this commission to make its decision. [0:06:35, 0:06:37]: We will not accept comments that are considered [0:06:38, 0:06:43]: by the chair to be a personal attack on any individual or groups of individuals. [0:06:45, 0:06:58]: You receive will you will receive a warning from the chair if you deviate from this requirement. The second deviation will result in the request for you to leave the meeting and the premises for the evening. [0:07:00, 0:07:05]: We ask that you refrain from any applause, comments from the audience. [0:07:07, 0:07:10]: Only one person will be talking at a time. [0:07:11, 0:07:16]: All comments will be made at the podium after the speaker has been recognized by the chair. [0:07:21, 0:07:27]: Please direct all comments to the chair and the commission, not to the audience or staff. [0:07:29, 0:07:44]: Please do not applaud or react to speakers, speak from the audience, cheer or carry on a conversation with others in the audience, or disrupt the order of the meeting in any way. [0:07:46, 0:07:55]: Please be aware that these hearings are not a debate or an opportunity to ask questions that which must be answered by any individual tonight. [0:07:57, 0:08:00]: but a merely an opportunity to present information to the Commission. [0:08:03, 0:08:06]: Other than the applicant, no person may speak more than once. [0:08:08, 0:08:20]: The applicant may reserve part of his speaking time as rebuttal and may speak next and last and may use the entire ten minutes allotted for the pro side of the application. [0:08:21, 0:08:25]: Other than the applicant, no person may speak longer than five minutes. [0:08:28, 0:08:36]: If you have a cell phone or other electronic device, I ask that you power them off. I'll put them on a silent mode. [0:08:39, 0:08:41]: If anyone wishes to speak tonight. [0:08:43, 0:08:49]: We ask that you fill out a form on the table up front and hand it to staff before approaching the podium. [0:08:53, 0:09:03]: After each case is called, we'll hear from the city staff and we'll hear from the applicant or their representative about what their plans are for the property. [0:09:04, 0:09:08]: along with any other relevant information they wish to present. [0:09:10, 0:09:17]: The commission members will be free to ask any questions at any time before voting on a project. [0:09:19, 0:09:30]: Following the applicant, anyone who wish to speak for or against the project or just ask questions will have an opportunity to do so. [0:09:33, 0:09:41]: Each side is restricted to a maximum of ten minutes, or time may be waived at the discretion of the presiding officer. [0:09:44, 0:09:57]: If questions are raised, may be asked the applicant to s we may ask the applicant to speak again. Afterwards, we will call for a motion and a second and have any necessary discussion. [0:09:57, 0:10:00]: And if the matter is not tabled, [0:10:01, 0:10:06]: We will vote to recommend approval or denial of the application. [0:10:08, 0:10:10]: This commission is only a recommending body. [0:10:12, 0:10:18]: The item will be heard by the mayor and council, whether we recommend approval or we recommend denial. [0:10:20, 0:10:29]: Unless tabled, these items will be heard by the city, the mayor, and the city council at their meeting on Monday, June 12th. [0:10:31, 0:10:36]: I believe that date is incorrect. I believe that should be July twelfth. [0:10:38, 0:10:43]: Okay. And it will be voted on by them at the meeting. [0:10:46, 0:11:00]: Okay. The first case we have tonight is case CP twenty twenty four dash zero two, the comprehensive plan amendment case. And it's in the properties located in Council District Four. [0:11:01, 0:11:17]: Consideration of request for a comprehensive plan amendment for property at one eleven Old Conyers Road to change the property's future land use designation of low density residentials to special purpose. [0:11:18, 0:11:25]: to allow for the struct construction of a mixed use development including commercial and residential usage. [0:11:26, 0:11:28]: The applicant is Charlie Hathawa. [0:11:29, 0:11:32]: On behalf of First National Land Trust LLC. [0:11:33, 0:11:47]: The property is located in land lot sixty eight of District twelve with six point seven one acres more or less within the city limits of Stoppridge. [0:11:50, 0:11:50]: Go ahead, Sarah. [0:11:52, 0:12:07]: Thank you, Mr. Chair. Um my name is Gordon Linton, as mentioned, uh Platter one for the city of Stockbridge, and I'm here to present the cases for RZ twenty twenty-four-zero two, CP twenty-four-zero two, and VR twenty-four-zero one. [0:12:12, 0:12:32]: These are the case facts. The applicant is Charlie Hiretower. The owner is Solutions Development LLC. And the agent is Charlie Hiretower. The number of proposed units per acre is 29.8 units per acre. The address, as mentioned, is Water Level Old Connors Road, with the number of acres being 6.71. [0:12:32, 0:12:52]: And the project characteristics is that it's vacant, it's undeveloped with an intermittent stream that's located near the southeast corner of the site, and at least three acres of properties of the property is in the Brush Creek wetlands. Currently, the future land use designation is low density residential, and the current zoning of the property. [0:12:54, 0:12:56]: It's mentioned below. Okay. [0:13:00, 0:13:00]: Uh [0:13:00, 0:13:20]: So this is the vicinity map, and this is the site right here. It's adjacent from the public shopping center. And you also have the Stockbridge Lakes Bed and Breakfast. And you also have the church, the God First Breakthrough Ministries, the Public Works Department, you got the corner store, Downtown Food Market, Cochrane Park, and you have series of topics. [0:13:20, 0:13:27]: Townhomes, which is the Diamante Townhomes, and he also had the recently approved 55 Villie Hill Road Townhomes. [0:13:31, 0:13:35]: This is the aerial photo with the side plan, which is located right here. [0:13:40, 0:13:51]: So this is the site visit that we did on May twenty-first, twenty twenty four. This is the site, uh it's vacant. And over here to the far right is uh Brush Creek uh wetlands. [0:13:54, 0:13:56]: Over here, this is the location of the stream. [0:13:59, 0:14:06]: And the property is adjacent from the public's shopping center. Um one of the retail stores is JSJ Cleaners. [0:14:10, 0:14:13]: And this is the access entrance to the proposed mixed use development. [0:14:14, 0:14:14]: Right here. [0:14:17, 0:14:25]: And this is the location of the stream. And as mentioned earlier, this is location of the Broad Street Common Wetland, which is located over here. [0:14:29, 0:14:36]: So as mentioned, three acres of the studject property are located on the Brush Creek wetlands, which is shown highlighted in the orange. [0:14:41, 0:14:44]: And this is the presentation for the CP twenty four dash zero two. [0:14:45, 0:14:57]: The applicant's request is to change the future current future land use designation from low density residential to special purpose to allow for the construction of a mixed use development that will include both commercial and residential uses. [0:14:59, 0:15:01]: And this is the special purpose in the acre. [0:15:03, 0:15:12]: Since the proposed density has a high density rate of 29.8 units per acre, the applicant requested a change from low density residential to special purpose. [0:15:13, 0:15:15]: And this is his definition? [0:15:18, 0:15:34]: And the this is the future land use map, which is shown, the property is shown in green. And the area is surrounded by the future current land use destinations of low density mixed use, low density residential, public institution, and park recreation conservation. [0:15:37, 0:15:57]: And this is the surrounding land use destination as mentioned. You have the property to the north, which is public shopping center, which is low density mixed use, along with the Stockbridge Lake Bed and Breakfast. You have the downtown Food Mark Corner Store to the south, along with the Public Works Department, which is currently with the future land use destination of low density residential. [0:15:57, 0:16:09]: Property to the east, which is the Godfirst Breakthrough Ministries, is public institution. And property to the west, which is Cochrane Park, is has a current future land use designation of park, recreation, and conservation. [0:16:11, 0:16:13]: And this is the surrounding land use densities. [0:16:17, 0:16:27]: Densities of the surrounding subdivisions as shown here ranges from one unit per acre to sixteen point three six units per acre, and the applicant has twenty nine point eight zero units per acre. [0:16:30, 0:16:36]: And this is the surrounding land use density map. And the site is shown here along with the other surrounding land use densities with the number of [0:16:37, 0:16:38]: Density units per acre. [0:16:41, 0:17:01]: As mentioned in the project information, the applicant proposes to build a mixed-use development that will consist of a five-story building with 200 apartment units and commercial spaces that will be located on the ground floor. As mentioned earlier, the subject property has a current future land use designation of low density residential. However, due to the high proposed density of 29.8 units per acre, [0:17:01, 0:17:07]: The applicant has requested to change the future land use designation from low density to special purpose. [0:17:10, 0:17:22]: The key points to highlight it from the staff analysis that we did is that the property is the proposed mixed use development is consistent with the pro current comprehensive plan goals and policies, which are shown here on the far right. [0:17:25, 0:17:34]: Among them is to provide additional housing in the downtown core, and it will provide a mixture of housing options to attract young, professionals, singles, and small families. [0:17:36, 0:17:54]: And the other key point from the staff analysis is that the proposed mixed use development is suitable for the site since it's point zero seven miles away from both the Stockbridge Amphitheater and the downtown air. It will provide a walkable community since it is close to both Cochrane Park and the public shopping center. [0:17:58, 0:18:00]: And a staff recommendation is for approval. [0:18:04, 0:18:07]: Any questions for staff from the commission? [0:18:10, 0:18:30]: Question. Um first let me say I think this is a great proposal for uh the comprehensive plan amendment. Um one of the questions I had was you said that a part of the development is in the wetlands, of the actual development, how much of the the actual development is in the wetlands? [0:18:39, 0:18:44]: Three acres. Three three point eight seven acres. Thank you. That's all I have to you. [0:18:47, 0:18:48]: Мне это пласт. [0:18:55, 0:18:56]: Perfect. [0:18:56, 0:19:00]: And this is the presentation for RZ twenty twenty four dash zero two. [0:19:02, 0:19:08]: The applicant's request is to rezone the property from SR, which is suburban residential, to PUD, which is plan [0:19:19, 0:19:23]: You have to you have to read it to the record. [0:19:25, 0:19:26]: I don't know what it is. [0:19:33, 0:19:35]: Is the appetite present? [0:19:35, 0:19:37]: Would you come forward and state your name? [0:19:40, 0:19:48]: And tell us why you're here. Good evening, everyone. Charlie Hotel, applicant of uh 111 Old Congress Road. [0:19:49, 0:19:50]: Okay, go right ahead, sir. [0:19:51, 0:20:11]: And exactly what am I requesting? I I think Gordon did a great job, but I can kind of recap what he done. It's my speaking to the microphone, please. Yes, sir. It's my understanding that the subject property has a hardship, which is the three acres approximate in the wetlands. Therefore, the need for the series of applications. [0:20:11, 0:20:18]: That were submitted is required in order to facilitate this project. The first one being the [0:20:18, 0:20:24]: the rezoning from uh suburban res residential to uh PUD, the second one being the [0:20:25, 0:20:26]: Amendment to the comprehensive plan. [0:20:27, 0:20:27]: Oh from [0:20:28, 0:20:48]: Low density to special purpose. The third one being the variance that we're requesting to increase the density from 24 units per acre to 29 units per acre. The fourth one being to decrease the parking. I believe two bedrooms require parking 1.75 units per two bedrooms. [0:20:48, 0:21:02]: bedroom to reduce that to 1.25 units. And for the one bedroom, I believe the requirements is 1.25 units per one bedroom studio to reduce that to one car per one bedroom. [0:21:02, 0:21:18]: The last but not least, I believe the um ratio for commercial versus residential by default is 75% to 25% ratio. Um, we would like to reduce that from 85.5% to twelve point five percent. [0:21:19, 0:21:27]: And that is our request. And the reason for that request is simply based on the hardship that the property has presented with half of the property being in the wetlands. [0:21:31, 0:21:34]: Any questions for Mr. Hatow from the commission? [0:21:34, 0:21:39]: Yeah, I have a couple of questions. Um have we done a traffic study? We have. [0:21:40, 0:22:00]: And also, have we done a study about the wetland in terms of the stream? Uh is that stream gonna be relocated? Uh is it gonna cause any flooding area? It would not impact the part that uh studies is underway for the wetland. As far as the traffic study, it does not impact apart that. [0:22:00, 0:22:06]: either. Uh I'm unable to speak intelligently on a traffic study. I will lead it to the traffic engineer. [0:22:07, 0:22:17]: And my next question is, have you talked to the the neighbors around there or Yes. We did a committee meeting, received feedback, no concerns or reservations. [0:22:18, 0:22:20]: Now my next question is [0:22:21, 0:22:41]: What are you gonna do about water runoff? That's a possibility that uh you may flood property by redeveloping the land, things to that nature. I'm quite sure that's what they're gonna ask. Definitely great question. And um we lead that to the civil engineers to propose a solution. Uh from what we see, we don't see any [0:22:41, 0:22:52]: impact the actual structure is not in the wetlands. A partial of the parking would be rearranged off the wetlands, but as we see, we doesn't see any impact. [0:22:54, 0:22:56]: Thank you. Yes. [0:22:56, 0:22:57]: Any more questions? [0:22:57, 0:23:17]: I have a question. Um one I just want to say thank you because anytime we have development for young professionals specifically, I'm always for it. But um just confirming, you did say you did complete an impact study for the development, right? Traffic study. Okay. Um any community meetings with the with that surrounding area? [0:23:17, 0:23:37]: We uh yes, we approximately mailed out 23 letters to 23 partials within 500 feet of the subject property, which is a requirement based on the city of Stockbridge. And we took summary of that meeting and no reservations from the community. Okay. I'm just looking at the area because it's you right beside the park, so now you're looking at kids and [0:23:37, 0:23:43]: in that area at a high volume. Um another thing I wanted to ask, uh [0:23:45, 0:23:55]: What was the last thing? Oh, did you by chance, uh going back to like the streams and s and like water flooding, did you s like think about water tables for the property at all? [0:23:55, 0:24:14]: Yes, we are proposing um underground retention for the project, but again, I I believe we're at the point where it's pretty premature and there's a significant investment that needs to go into the planning and studies and the proposed site plan was a preliminary to at least address this phase. [0:24:14, 0:24:15]: Okay, thank you. [0:24:18, 0:24:19]: Thank you, sir. [0:24:20, 0:24:21]: Thank you. [0:24:38, 0:24:38]: Yes. [0:24:47, 0:24:48]: I'm sorry I can't hear you. [0:24:54, 0:24:55]: Go right ahead. [0:24:56, 0:25:02]: We do have a comment or a question by a Miss Johnson uh regarding this property. [0:25:03, 0:25:09]: Okay. Uh I would ask you to hold that until we open it up for public hearing. [0:25:13, 0:25:17]: Місте Антон, до єfer да ви го ін [0:25:18, 0:25:23]: rezoning in various before we open it up for public or do we Yes yes, sir. Okay. [0:25:29, 0:25:31]: The next case that I have [0:25:33, 0:25:53]: It's the VR, I'm sorry. It's RZ 2024-02. It's a consideration of a request for rezoning of the property at 111 O'Cunas Road to rezone the property from SR, which is suburban residential, to PUD. [0:25:53, 0:25:56]: D plan unit development. [0:25:56, 0:26:03]: to allow for the construction of a mixed use development including commercial and residential uses. [0:26:04, 0:26:20]: The applicant is Charlie Hartower on behalf of First National Land Trust LLC. The property is located in land lot sixty eight of District twelve with six point seven one acres more or less in the city of Stockbridge. Go ahead, Staff. [0:26:22, 0:26:26]: Okay, so this is the presentation for R Z twenty twenty four dash zero two. [0:26:29, 0:26:42]: As mentioned, the applicant's request is to rezone the property from SR, suburban residential, to PUD, plan unit development to allow for the construction of a mixed-use development that will include both commercial and residential uses. [0:26:45, 0:26:46]: This is the zoning map. [0:26:47, 0:26:51]: And the property is surrounded by b C two. [0:26:52, 0:26:55]: C three and O R. [0:27:00, 0:27:06]: This is uh location of the subject property. Uh part of it is in the Parkway Mixus Overlay District. [0:27:14, 0:27:23]: And the subject property is part of the tax allocation district otherwise TAD, which is designed to attract quality development into distressed redevelopment area. [0:27:26, 0:27:35]: And this is a LCI study that was conducted by by in twenty twelve, which labels the subject area as a growth area, which means that is recommended for growth. [0:27:37, 0:27:55]: And this is the side plan, so he has uh therapy garden, a pergola, which is sitting per pergola, uh grill, trash bin, playground, bicycle parking, and this is the location of the ground parking, and this is a dog park with mulch. [0:27:57, 0:28:03]: And the adult pool is in labeled in blue and the retail space is labeled in orange and you have another bicycle parking. [0:28:08, 0:28:13]: And this shows how far the proposed mixed use development is from the amphitheater and the downtown area. [0:28:16, 0:28:20]: And this is the development data summary for the site plan of the property. [0:28:28, 0:28:30]: And this is the exterior of the townhomes. [0:28:36, 0:28:45]: And this is the first floor plan of the proposed mixed use development. You have the three retail use spaces located here, along with the number of parker spaces here. [0:28:49, 0:29:09]: And as mentioned earlier, uh the applicant proposes to build a mixed-use development that consists of a five-story building with 200 apartment units and commercial spaces that will be located on the ground floor. Of the proposed 200 apartment units, 95 will be studio, 95 will be one bedroom with one bathroom, six will be two bedroom with two bathrooms. [0:29:09, 0:29:27]: And forward will be three bathroom units with two bathrooms. There will be a total of three retail spaces with a combined total of fifteen thousand square feet on the first floor of the proposed building. The proposed mixed use development will provide vehicular access to the site with a deceleration lane that will be located along Oconyous Road. [0:29:33, 0:29:41]: And the key points to prov uh from the staff analysis is that it is consistent with the goals and policy of the comprehensive plan. [0:29:42, 0:29:42]: Was just mentioned here. [0:29:44, 0:29:47]: It is consistent with the unified development code. [0:29:50, 0:30:10]: And the three positive effects is that this will be the first mixed-use development in the downtown area, Stockbridge. It will provide alternative type of use housing for young professionals who are looking for apartments, and additional of the retail spaces will provide additional job opportunities. And both the LCI and the downtown [0:30:10, 0:30:15]: Residential and retail market analysis encourages growth in the downtown area. [0:30:18, 0:30:38]: And on page seventy six of the downtown market retail analysis said that the position stop rates for change in local, regional, and national market and demographic trends, particularly the needs of Asian residents and the so-called millennials, the downtown must be rid of revitalized in a way that builds on its historic character and position as a walkable, [0:30:38, 0:30:45]: Mixed use alternative to surrounding areas, many of which will be less suitable to adapt to those changes, which the proposed development meets. [0:30:50, 0:30:55]: A water service is available and the they did a traffic impact study. [0:30:56, 0:31:06]: which is shown on this screen, and it will generate a total of one thousand four hundred and seventy eight net daily trips with seven hundred and thirty nine inbound and seven hundred and forty outbound. [0:31:09, 0:31:29]: And staff recommends approval with conditions to rezone the property from SR to PUD with the following conditions. The number of proposed units will be reduced from 200 to 160, 23.84 units per acre, due to the maximum density allowed by the requested special purpose future land use destination, which is [0:31:29, 0:31:49]: 24 units per acre. Clock cameras will be located at the entrance of the mixed-use development. On the eastern side of the subject property, a 25-foot land strip will be extended past the pool area found on the conceptual site plan. The front facade of the residential building shall be comprised of not less than 50% of the combined material. [0:31:49, 0:32:09]: Such as brick, stone, or stucco, or a combination of brick and stone. The remaining 20% may be comprised of stone, stucco, shake, or andor cement fiberboard siding. The side and rear facade of the residential building should be comprised of any combination of primary materials, including brick, stone, and secondary materials. [0:32:09, 0:32:29]: Included stucco, shake, and/or cyber cement fiber board, but not to exceed 30% of the entire building. The colors should consist of a cohesive complementary palette, and limited use of the accent color is permitted as long as they are not bright or fluorescent and complement of the [0:32:29, 0:32:35]: The overall palette of the material and the proposed mixed-use development should not exceed four stories. [0:32:39, 0:32:41]: Any questions for stay from the commission? [0:32:48, 0:32:49]: No questions? [0:32:52, 0:32:52]: Thank you, Gordon. [0:32:55, 0:33:07]: I won't ask the applicant to return unless you have something to add or if you if the commission have questions that you need to answer. [0:33:14, 0:33:15]: Okay, no questions? [0:33:17, 0:33:32]: The next case is the rezoning RZ-2024-02. This is in Council District 4. Consideration of request to rezone. I'm sorry. [0:33:33, 0:33:34]: What's the [0:33:35, 0:33:47]: Oh yeah, you're right. You're right. Case VR twenty twenty-four dash zero two. Variance case VR dash twenty twenty four dash oh one. [0:33:48, 0:33:52]: It looks like a typographical arrow, but [0:33:52, 0:33:54]: I'm reading what it says. [0:33:54, 0:33:58]: Council District four, a consideration of requests for three variances. [0:34:00, 0:34:05]: As are listed below for the property at one eleven O Cunha Road. [0:34:06, 0:34:12]: To allow for the construction of a mixed use development including commercial and residential uses. [0:34:13, 0:34:30]: The applicant is Charlie Hathawa on behalf of the First National Land Trust, LLC. Properties located in landlot 68 of District 12 with 6.71 acres more or less within the Stockbridge City limits. [0:34:31, 0:34:34]: The three requested variances are as follows. [0:34:35, 0:34:36]: Variance request one. [0:34:37, 0:34:44]: The variance to reduce the parking requirements according to the number of bedrooms per apartment unit. [0:34:45, 0:34:56]: Brother studio and one bedroom apartment units will have only one parking space instead of the required one point two five parking spaces per unit. [0:34:58, 0:35:04]: And the two bedroom units would ha have only one point two five parking spaces per unit. [0:35:04, 0:35:09]: Instead of the required one point seven five parking spaces per unit. [0:35:12, 0:35:13]: Fairness of question number two. [0:35:14, 0:35:19]: Variance to modify the ground floor retail square footage requirement. [0:35:20, 0:35:23]: By changing the residential to retail space ratio. [0:35:24, 0:35:28]: From the required ratio of seventy five percent. [0:35:30, 0:35:37]: twenty five percent to a proposed ratio of eighty seven point five percent to twelve and a half percent. [0:35:39, 0:35:50]: Variance request number three. Variance to increase the project's density from twenty-four units per acre to twenty-nine units per acre. [0:35:52, 0:35:55]: Mr. Linton, you may proceed. Yes, sir. [0:35:57, 0:36:10]: Again, Mr. Chair, if I may just read in the record the correct case number. It is VR dash two zero two four dash zero one. [0:36:10, 0:36:10]: Thank you. [0:36:16, 0:36:36]: As mentioned, the applicant is requesting three variances that found in the UDC. These variances are as follows: reduce the parking requirements according to number of bedrooms per apartment unit, whereby a studio and one bedroom apartment would have only one parking space instead of the required 1.25 parking spaces per [0:36:36, 0:36:45]: per unit and two bedrooms would only have one point two five parking spaces per unit instead of the required one point seven five parking spaces per unit. [0:36:47, 0:37:07]: The second variance is to modify the ground floor retail square footage requirement by changing the residential to retail space ratio from the required ratio of 75 slash 25% to reposed ratio of 87.5% slash twelve point five percent. And the third variance is to increase the project. [0:37:07, 0:37:11]: product density from twenty-four units per acre to twenty-nine units per acre. [0:37:14, 0:37:21]: So this is his parking the parking requirements that are found in section four point eighty four A of the Unified Development Code. [0:37:22, 0:37:37]: This is the current parking requirements, which is the one bedroom of efficiency unit, which is 1.25 parking spaces per unit, and the two bedroom unit, which is 1.75 parking spaces per unit. And the request from the applicant is to reduce it from one bedroom [0:37:38, 0:37:45]: Or efficiency unit one point parking spaces per unit and the two bedroom unit to one point two five parking spaces per unit. [0:37:47, 0:38:07]: And this is proposed. The studio will have 195 units, which a total of 119. The one bedroom will also have 95 with 119 parking spaces. The two-bedroom will have six units with 11 parking spaces. And the third three-bedroom will be will have four units with eight parking spaces. [0:38:07, 0:38:15]: Spaces. So the total residential parking spaces is 200, and the number of parking spaces will be 257. [0:38:17, 0:38:20]: And this is the overall proposed number of parking spaces. [0:38:21, 0:38:30]: It will be 257 total with seventy-nine commercial parking spaces, which brings the overall number of parking spaces to 336. [0:38:32, 0:38:45]: And this is the required. Staff discovered that the increment parking calculations were used. Therefore, the required parking calculation resulted in two hundred and eighty-seven residential parking spaces with [0:38:45, 0:38:59]: Seventy nine totaling three hundred and six parking spaces. The applicant did not provide the proposed total reduced parking spaces, therefore staff recommends reducing the residential parking spaces by thirty parking spaces totaling three hundred and thirty six parking spaces. [0:39:06, 0:39:26]: And this is the key point from this from the staff report is that three acres of the subject property is located in the Brush Creek wetlands. Therefore, the developer is likely to color several hardships due to the wooded areas, their varied elevations, and the location of the Brush Creek wetlands, and it is consistent with the UD. [0:39:26, 0:39:40]: DC since it will allow the developer to comply with the parking regulations, alleviate the number of potential cars that will be located on the proposed mixed use development, and it will eliminate impervious parking spaces that will be located on the mixed use development. [0:39:43, 0:40:03]: Based on the staff analysis above, the planning and zoning staff therefore recommends approval for the warrant for the following variances. The first variance will be approved. And the second, we couldn't find it in this in the UDC development code, therefore, it will be non-applicable. And the third, which is to increase the project density from 24 units. [0:40:02, 0:40:20]: units per acre to twenty nine units per acre. That is approved with conditions, which is the number of proposed units will be reduced from two hundred to one sixty units, twenty three point eight four units per acre due to the maximum allowed by the required special use, special purpose future land use destination. [0:40:31, 0:40:32]: Are you done? [0:40:36, 0:40:43]: Mr Chair, if Gordon just clarified number one, the number of parking spaces that we're approved. [0:40:44, 0:41:04]: Okay, so to reduce the parking spaces according to number of bedroom units per apartment unit, whereby a studio and one bedroom apartment units will have only one parking space instead of the required 1.25 parking spaces per unit, and the two bedrooms will only have 1.5 parking spaces per unit. And as mentioned, staff has discovered that. [0:41:04, 0:41:24]: That the incorrect parking calculation and the parking reduces were used, and therefore the required parking calculation resulted in 287 residential parking spaces with 79 retail, totaling 366 parking spaces. The applicant did not provide the proposed total reduced parking spaces, therefore staff. [0:41:24, 0:41:34]: Staff is recommended to reduce the residential parking spaces by thirty parking spaces, which will result in a total of three hundred and thirty-six parking spaces. [0:41:37, 0:41:40]: Any questions for staff from the commission? [0:41:45, 0:41:47]: No questions? Thank you. Go on. [0:41:50, 0:42:00]: This is a public hearing, so this is how we will conduct it. If there is anyone present who wish to speak in favor [0:42:01, 0:42:09]: Of just development, the comprehensive plan amendment, the rezoning, and the variance request. [0:42:10, 0:42:17]: If you are in favor, we ask that you s form a line in the center aisle here. [0:42:21, 0:42:22]: At a pros the podium. [0:42:24, 0:42:28]: Fill out a form, give it to the secretary if you haven't already done so. [0:42:30, 0:42:31]: Anybody in favor of the [0:42:34, 0:42:48]: Okay. Seeing none, I will ask the questions of anybody present who is opposed to the project, the comprehensive plan amendment, the rezoning, and the variance requests. [0:42:51, 0:42:53]: Into one opposed. [0:42:58, 0:42:59]: I see one individual. [0:43:01, 0:43:02]: Uh uh [0:43:03, 0:43:06]: You may approach the podium since you're the only one. [0:43:08, 0:43:10]: Hope you feel audible. [0:43:10, 0:43:13]: Okay. Give us your name and address please for the record. [0:43:14, 0:43:25]: Hi, I am actually Pastor Natasha Johnson. I'm from God first breakthrough one one five Old Conyers Road. We just had some questions. Um I don't think we're either opposed, we just had some concerns and questions. Is that okay? [0:43:26, 0:43:34]: Questions for commission or the staff or the staff and the commission regarding the overall project. [0:43:34, 0:43:35]: Go right ahead. [0:43:35, 0:43:44]: Okay. So just let me just stay up front, we are yes. I'm sorry, missage. Can you make sure your green light is on? It is. Perfect, thank you. Can I am I not loud enough? [0:43:44, 0:43:52]: Oh, okay. So um we're very excited about the f forward vision for the city of Stockbridge. We love the [0:43:52, 0:44:12]: comprehensive plan and we're excited about the potential that um, you know, the new things that Stockbridge is bringing in. Um the only questions that we had is, you know, in keeping with overall the city of Atlanta has been known for not having the right infrastructure in place prior to growth and expansion. [0:44:12, 0:44:12]: Yeah. [0:44:12, 0:44:22]: And while we appreciate bringing that many residents into the city of Stockbridge, our major concern is traffic and what it would bring. Um [0:44:22, 0:44:25]: Аз на част the [0:44:25, 0:44:26]: Um [0:44:26, 0:44:27]: The [0:44:27, 0:44:44]: vehicular traffic but also foot traffic. Um and we don't see part of the plan as far as expansion. We know that there's a deceleration lane that's planned at some point. Um are there walkways, etcetera. Even like I was driving down uh [0:44:45, 0:45:05]: East Atlanta yesterday and uh during Juneteenth, and someone just stepped out in front of my vehicle. You know, there are no clear walkways or identified pedestrian crossings. I mean, those are the questions that we have, um, considering that this is targeted for young professionals and small families with. [0:45:04, 0:45:08]: the park being across the street for Co Cochrane Plan. [0:45:08, 0:45:11]: Cochrane Clark, we anticipate that. [0:45:11, 0:45:14]: There will be additional pedestrian traffic. [0:45:14, 0:45:33]: And has there any thought been given to that? Um, the question that you asked, Mr. Williams, regarding the wetlands, that was one of the questions that we had as well. Um, and what thought and how they are planning to work around that and the impact to flooding as well as infrastructure. So we appreciate that. Um [0:45:34, 0:45:47]: I think most of the questions have been asked regarding what we want. The other one question we did have is there going to be any restrictions as far as ordinances for what kind of commercial um [0:45:47, 0:45:56]: establishments would be in that mixed use. Um we don't we would not like to see a liquid store. Um are there any restrictions? [0:45:56, 0:46:16]: uh going to be put in place by the commission regarding overall we are neither opposed to or in favor. We are just wanting to get more insight into what the plans are because it is adjacent to the church and we want to ensure that um, you know, the and as well as the buffer zone between the church and the apartment building is [0:46:16, 0:46:26]: sufficient to accommodate um any noise restrictions, etc. That's it. Thank you, Evan. Mr. Anderson, would you uh [0:46:27, 0:46:30]: Be willing to address some of her questions. [0:46:34, 0:46:47]: As as far as it relates to um walkability and pedestrian crosswalk, uh one of the city's primary goals is to make the whole entire area walkable and then and to have sidewalks. [0:46:48, 0:46:50]: on the side we all [0:47:06, 0:47:26]: The other concern she had, all that is currently governed by the UBC and state law, the liquor store cannot be any close proximity of the church. There are distant requirements, so chances are the liquor store won't be able to go there. And uh plus the city uh won't be able to issue any more liquor license until the city reaches a certain [0:47:25, 0:47:40]: population threshold we're in the process of issuing two new liquor licenses now and uh that area is not included in as one of the target areas for one of those new liquor stores. So the answer about the little store is nope, it won't be a little store. [0:47:40, 0:47:42]: And what was the other person? [0:47:45, 0:47:58]: The traffic set uh concerns and deceleration lane coming out from East Atlanta to Old Cottages, et cetera. [0:47:59, 0:48:00]: Well. [0:48:09, 0:48:14]: Thank you, Mr. Anderson. Is there anyone else who wished to speak in opposition? [0:48:20, 0:48:23]: Seeing none, the public hearing is now closed. [0:48:26, 0:48:33]: Uh Mr. Chair, I have a question from Mr. Go right if you don't mind. Are are we speaking? Speaking of the microphone, please. [0:48:33, 0:48:44]: Are we still going to uh have a road that comes from Rock Cory to O'Connors? Is that still in the in the makings, uh, Mr. Gordon? Do you know anything about that? [0:48:47, 0:48:49]: At one time they were gonna uh [0:48:51, 0:48:54]: Make a straight through through fare from uh [0:49:04, 0:49:24]: Uh if you don't mind, that'd be something I would like to get an answer to. Are we gonna develop uh a road from Rock Quarry to Old Kanye's Road? I'm I'm just putting it out there, okay? Mr. Tribado, thank you for your comment. I uh would encourage you to speak privately with Mr. [0:49:24, 0:49:33]: Anderson or whoever you deem necessary. The item is not on the agenda and I don't wanna take up a whole lot of time talking about that tonight. [0:49:37, 0:49:38]: The [0:49:41, 0:49:54]: Time now to vote on the cases that's before us. I need a motion with regard to comprehensive plan amendment KCP 2024-02 in Council District 4. [0:49:55, 0:49:57]: I need a motion from the commission, please. [0:49:58, 0:49:59]: Cheer. [0:49:59, 0:50:00]: Yes. [0:50:00, 0:50:13]: I make a motion to um approve comprehensive plan CP-2024-02 to include staff recommendations. [0:50:15, 0:50:17]: Or approval with the staff conditions. [0:50:18, 0:50:19]: Is there a second? [0:50:19, 0:50:21]: Mr. Chairman, I second that. [0:50:21, 0:50:28]: It's been moved by Mr Williams and second by Mr Plancham that the [0:50:29, 0:50:30]: C P [0:50:31, 0:50:39]: 2024 dash zero two comprehensive plan amendment case be approved. All in favor, let it be known by the sound of I. [0:50:39, 0:50:41]: I in your polls. [0:50:43, 0:50:47]: The eyes have it. Unanimous. The motion passes. [0:50:50, 0:50:52]: The next case is [0:50:53, 0:50:58]: Up for a vote is R Z twenty twenty four dash zero two resounding case. [0:51:03, 0:51:05]: I need a motion from the commission, please. [0:51:10, 0:51:20]: Chair. Yes, sir. Motion to approve the R Z dash twenty twenty four dash O two rezoning case. [0:51:21, 0:51:22]: Is there a second? [0:51:24, 0:51:31]: I second it. Harold. It's been moved by Mr. Williams and seconded by Mr. Thibodeau. [0:51:33, 0:51:42]: That we approve the rezoning case R Z twenty twenty four dash zero two. All in favor, let it be known by the sound of it. Aye. Aye. Any opposed? [0:51:45, 0:51:50]: The eyes have it. It's unanimous. The resulting case is approved. [0:51:53, 0:51:57]: The next case is the VR twenty twenty four-zero two. [0:52:00, 0:52:02]: Death three variances. [0:52:04, 0:52:06]: I need a motion from the commission. [0:52:07, 0:52:08]: Cheer. [0:52:08, 0:52:09]: Yes, sir. [0:52:09, 0:52:29]: Um before I make my motion, I did wanna uh tell the applicant. I had a few concerns with the actual d site development itself. So I would just implore you to work with community development. Um, Ryan and the entire team, they're amazing when it comes down to site plans. Cause there's some safety issues I kind of see, um, as well as just [0:52:29, 0:52:48]: really just that it's that wetland and that that stream that's really bothering me, especially in that area. Um with downtown development being built so far by mayor and council, I I I would have confer with them to try to reconfigure that. Um and then I would also [0:52:50, 0:52:52]: I also wanted to say [0:52:53, 0:53:05]: Something that I forgot. So I'm gonna make my motion. Um chair, I'd like to make a motion to deny variance one and variance two and approve variants three with the staff conditions. [0:53:09, 0:53:11]: Do I have a second to that motion, please? [0:53:13, 0:53:19]: Motion to deny variance one, variance two, and to approve variance three. Is there a second? [0:53:23, 0:53:29]: Do you mind if we have a conversation about that? I if you understand development [0:53:29, 0:53:36]: You can change anything you want to go in whatever direction. And also what I'd be concerned about basically [0:53:37, 0:53:39]: Is that they would know better. [0:53:39, 0:53:58]: about how to landscape property for flooding and anything else for drainage. So I personally would not deny that because you can make those changes and you can make re requirements to that. So that that's just a development issue that could l literally be controlled. [0:54:03, 0:54:07]: Since we have no second to the motion, then the motion fails. [0:54:08, 0:54:14]: Do we have an uh alternative motion? Mr. Tibetal, do you wish to make a different motion? [0:54:17, 0:54:21]: Yeah, I'd like to make a motion, uh present a motion that we'll approve of it. [0:54:22, 0:54:25]: Then we approve variants one, two, and three. [0:54:27, 0:54:31]: Yes. Okay, is there a second to that motion? [0:54:32, 0:54:41]: Mr. Planchon is seconded. It's been moved by Mr. Thibodeau and second by Mr. Planshon that we approve. [0:54:41, 0:54:42]: Yes, sir. [0:54:51, 0:54:54]: So the proper motion will be to approve one and three. [0:54:59, 0:55:03]: That's fine. You know, I would have appreciated it if you had written the script that way. [0:55:05, 0:55:05]: Yeah. [0:55:11, 0:55:18]: Did everyone hear that? Mr. Anderson has indicated that the variance request number two [0:55:21, 0:55:25]: should be taken off the table because it's not in the ordinance. [0:55:28, 0:55:32]: So I need a motion with respect to variance one and variance three. [0:55:36, 0:55:48]: Mr. Thibodeau, do you wish to make that motion? Yes, I'd like to present a motion that we uh put variants one and three back for the voting. [0:55:50, 0:55:57]: You making a motion to approval? Yes. I'd like to position it. Mr. Planchon is seconding. [0:55:58, 0:56:14]: It's been moved and by Mr Thibodeau that we approve variance one and variance three. And it was seconded by Mr. Plinchon. All in favor, let it be known by the sound of aye. Aye. Aye. Any opposed? Nay. [0:56:15, 0:56:26]: Mr Planchon and Mr. Thibodeau voted yay to approve the variance. Mr Williams voted nay to deny the variance. [0:56:27, 0:56:28]: The eyes have it. [0:56:29, 0:56:32]: Or the Yays have it, if you will, and the motion is approved. [0:56:47, 0:56:50]: Are there any project updates from staff? [0:56:53, 0:56:55]: Any comments from staff. [0:56:57, 0:56:59]: Any comments from the board, please? [0:57:02, 0:57:11]: No comments from the board. This meeting is adjoined. Thank you very much for attending. Thank you for your cooperation.
  • 2024-06-10 · City Council · Transcript · Regular Council Meetings

    2024-06-10 · City Council · Transcript · source: 10yr-transcripts · sha256 7a554225 · pages – · method: official

    Full text — searchable
    --- title: Regular Council Meetings date: 2024-06-10 source: 2024-06-10_Regular_Council_Meetings.wav --- [0:00:26, 0:00:46]: All right, ladies and gentlemen, good evening to you. Um what we have going on now will be our ceremonial type of uh part of our council meeting for today. And the first thing I'd like to do is uh I'll have some recognition for city employees. So uh Ms. Smith Sellers, could you come forward please? [0:00:47, 0:00:49]: As well as [0:00:52, 0:00:53]: Stephanie. [0:01:01, 0:01:03]: Okay, follow. [0:01:08, 0:01:13]: Be careful allowing me to touch these things because all of a sudden things start falling apart, right? [0:01:13, 0:01:22]: All right, ladies, congratulations on your recognition. These are both um um certificates of pr want you come on this side just a minute. [0:01:22, 0:01:29]: Might I need a mic, uh yeah, let me stay near the mic here. Uh these are both uh certificate appreciation for uh [0:01:29, 0:01:42]: I'll yeah, come on this side please. Yeah, I'm sorry. Uh for um your ten for you for ten years of service. Uh so fantastic and uh it's uh ten years. That's that's a long time. [0:01:42, 0:01:56]: But you got about another twenty to go, right? About another ten. Another twenty? All right. And on that note, there is a ten year pin for you as well. Okay? Okay. Thank you. Fantastic. [0:01:57, 0:01:59]: You have any comments? [0:02:00, 0:02:04]: It's been great being here. Look for twenty more. [0:02:05, 0:02:05]: Mm-hmm. [0:02:06, 0:02:26]: And for you, Stephanie, uh certificate of appreciation. Uh so recognition and outstanding customer service. And I know that you uh do a lot down downstairs and meeting and greeting all the businesses and and customers and citizens and stakeholders and ribbon cuttings and so it's great. So congratulations uh to you as well. Thank you. Okay. And there is [0:02:26, 0:02:31]: A pen here for you as well. Oh, thank you. We appreciate you. Thank you. All right. [0:02:33, 0:02:39]: I do well yeah, well we'll do it. It's uh she's take uh would you have anything you'd like to say? [0:02:40, 0:02:43]: Thank you to City of Stockbridge. I'ma continue to do what I do. [0:02:43, 0:03:01]: You got you got ten, twenty more, twenty more years or so to go as well. Maybe twenty. All right. Hold on, this uh why don't you want you call them on this side? You go on this side and then we'll see uh oh uh I don't want to be necessarily be in the middle. You lay grasping on the end if you can get us and get better, okay? [0:03:09, 0:03:12]: Thank you. [0:03:14, 0:03:17]: You may eventually be our full our uh photographer the rest of the evening. [0:03:18, 0:03:32]: You're gonna you I'm gonna tag you to be our photographer for us, our photographer. Cause we got several more to go here, bro. Oh okay. All right. No problem. No problem. Good deal. What I have next is uh Georgia Municipal Court Clerks Week, ladies. Come on up. [0:03:42, 0:03:44]: Okay, Java. [0:03:46, 0:04:03]: So this this proclamation for the city of Stockbridge in recognition of Georgia's Municipal Court Clerks Week, June 10th to June to June 24th, 2024. Whereas municipal courts play a significant role in providing access to justice, preserving public safety, and promoting quality in life in Georgia. [0:04:03, 0:04:23]: Whereas more people encounter municipal court clerks than any other court personnel in Georgia, and a public impression of the entire Georgia judicial system is largely dependent upon the public's experience with municipal courts. Whereas municipal courts' clerks have pledged to be ever mindful of their neutrality and partiality. [0:04:23, 0:04:43]: Rendering equal service to all and conforming to the standards set by the uniform rules of municipal courts of the state of Georgia. Whereas in the most appropriate, and that, excuse me, whereas it is most appropriate that we recognize municipal court clerks representing over 380 Georgian municipal courts and a critical role they play. [0:04:43, 0:04:51]: Whereas the Governor Kemp has proclaimed June 10th to the twenty uh to the fourteenth, twenty twenty four, as Municipal Court Clerk's Week in the state of Georgia. [0:04:51, 0:05:11]: Whereas the state of Georgia recognizes the positive impact the municipal court clerks have had on its citizens and quality of life. Now, therefore, I, Anthony S. Ford, by virtue of authority vesting me as the mayor of the city of Stockbridge, Georgia, and on behalf of City Council members Elton Alexander, Yolanda, Barber Kyle, Berry, Lakeese Gantt and Alfonso Thomas, do hereby recognize the week of June. [0:05:11, 0:05:31]: June 10th through the 14th, 2024, as Georgia Municipal Court Clerks Week, and further extend appreciation to our municipal court clerk and members of the court clerks office team for the vital services they perform and the experimentary dedication to the Stockbridge community and witness thereof whereof, I have hereunto set my hand in the great seal city. [0:05:31, 0:05:34]: [334.9, 337.9]: two thousand and twenty four and I signed the proclamation along [0:05:38, 0:05:46]: with uh the clerk for Nelson Holiday. And congratulations. Thank you, ma'am. Thank you. Thank you. [0:05:46, 0:06:03]: Now you y mic is yours. If you have any comments that you'd like to make? I don't have any comments, just thank you to Kenya and Quinn, my great team. Okay. Fantastic lady. Okay, good. I uh you you now give now you're not official photographer now. All right. Come on there, ladies. Good deal. [0:06:08, 0:06:10]: Okay. [0:06:14, 0:06:22]: Mary, if you don't mind, you wonder um if you know what Shane taking the picture. Oh yeah, sure. Yeah, yeah. [0:06:25, 0:06:30]: We're gonna p right here, ladies, we'll take two. Take two. [0:06:30, 0:06:35]: That's all we're not quick. [0:06:36, 0:06:37]: Right. [0:06:43, 0:06:45]: Yeah, that's it. Okay. [0:06:46, 0:06:49]: [416.7, 436.7]: The next proclamation uh we have is Juneteenth. And so obviously you all know that the city of Stockbridge, I think it's going to be our third year. Third year. Third year celebrated Juneteenth, which is just right around the corner. So it's a proclamation recognizing Juneteenth. Whereas on June nineteenth, eighteen sixty five, about I need to get over here, I'm sorry. [0:07:17, 0:07:24]: Uh once again, whereas on june nineteenth, eighteen sixty five, about two months after the Confederate general Robert E. Lee surrendered at Atomatics, Virginia. [0:07:25, 0:07:34]: Gordon Granger, a Union uh general, arrived in Galveston, Texas to inform Envl enslaved African Americans of their freedom and that the Civil War had ended. [0:07:34, 0:07:38]: General Granger's announcement put into effect the Emancipation Proclamation. [0:07:39, 0:07:43]: issued on january first, eighteen sixty three, by President Abraham Lincoln. [0:07:43, 0:08:03]: Whereas the word about the signing of the Emancipation Proclamation was delayed more than two and a half years to June 19, 1865, in reaching authorities and African Americans in the South and Southwest, Southwestern part of the United States. Whereas the last enslaved African Americans in Texas were pronounced free people and that the [0:08:03, 0:08:10]: Momentous date of june nineteenth, eighteen sixty five, have been proclaimed Juneteenth, combining the words June and nineteenth. [0:08:10, 0:08:15]: The holidays also call Juneteenth Independence Day, Freedom Day, or Emancipation Day. [0:08:16, 0:08:36]: Whereas on june seventeenth, twenty twenty one, President Biden signed the bill into law making Juneteenth, the eleventh na uh national holiday recognized by the federal government. All fifty states in the District of Columbia recognize Juneteenth as a holiday or observance. The national observance of Juneteenth provides a full a fuller and more accurate portrayal of America's history. [0:08:36, 0:08:56]: Whereas on June 19th each year, we celebrate and honor African Americans' heritage, history, freedom, culture, and events and ceremonies that reflect the power of the community, family, art, and traditions. In 2024, National Juneteenth theme, the wildest dreams, honors the history of our ancestors, highlights present uh accomplishments. Now, therefore, our [0:08:56, 0:09:08]: Anthony Sfor, by virtue of authority vested in me as the mayor of the city of Stockbridge, Georgia, and on behalf of City Council members Elton Alexander, Londa Barber, Cowberry, Lakesa Gan, and Afonso Thomas, do hereby proclaim [0:09:08, 0:09:11]: June nineteenth, twenty twenty four, as a juneteenth. [0:09:11, 0:09:31]: Excuse me, as Juneteenth day in the great city of Stockbridge, we call upon everyone to observe Juneteenth as an important milestone in our long march towards equality. The reminder of the great uh contributions of African Americans have made as free citizens of our nation, as well as the injustices they suffered as slaves and the courage of our forefathers. [0:09:31, 0:09:41]: forbearers of all races and creeds who gave their lives to fight against slavery. A witness thereof I have hereunto set my hand in great seal city, Stockbridge, Georgia, [0:09:42, 0:09:49]: On the tenth day of June of uh year of our Lord, two thousand and twenty four, and I signed a proclamation along with a clerk for Nessa Holiday. Okay. [0:09:54, 0:10:02]: Sure. [0:10:03, 0:10:03]: [604.5, 606.7]: Staff, folks, wanna come on up? [0:10:08, 0:10:21]: Come on, Miss Weber. Come on, Miss Dress. Come on. Come on, folks. Come on today. Rhonda. Rhonda. Rhonda. Rhonda. [0:10:21, 0:10:41]: We probably I think we need to shift. I think we're out of the we're out of the um how but this is gonna probably block some of us here. We may have to double up. If you come in, some of you come on double up. Shift a little bit and come up. Some of you ladies come on up front. [0:10:41, 0:10:49]: [653.8, 656.1]: In far on that. [0:11:00, 0:11:09]: No, you're not in the whole thing. [0:11:11, 0:11:13]: Yeah. [0:11:21, 0:11:23]: Ready? Mm-hmm. [0:11:27, 0:11:34]: Thank you so much. [0:11:39, 0:11:44]: Be fine. No problem. [0:11:45, 0:11:53]: Okay. Well that reading makes me parts, huh? [0:11:54, 0:11:57]: Oh yeah. [0:12:01, 0:12:05]: The next proclamation we have is Father's Day. So uh [0:12:05, 0:12:14]: Both Councilman Alexander and I are father. So I tell you what, anybody that's out here if you like, if you're a father, if you wanna come on up, come on up if you know. [0:12:15, 0:12:22]: Yeah. This is this is a Father's Day proclamation. Any fathers? If you if you like any fathers, come join me. [0:12:23, 0:12:25]: If not, I'll continue I'll [0:12:27, 0:12:32]: Your father all right, all right. Come on, Mr. Your father, come on up here, [0:12:34, 0:12:36]: Father's Day. [0:12:37, 0:12:40]: How about you, Anderson? Ryan, your father? [0:12:44, 0:12:45]: Ryan, you Ryan, your father? [0:12:47, 0:12:49]: Come on, come on, guys. [0:12:52, 0:12:55]: Yeah, I guess I need I guess that I need to speak out. [0:12:56, 0:12:59]: All right, gentlemen. Uh come come on up here, get on. Okay. [0:13:01, 0:13:01]: Okay. [0:13:02, 0:13:07]: All right, so this is a proclamation city star bridge recognizing Father's Day 2024. [0:13:08, 0:13:16]: Whereas a gift of fatherhood requires commitment and dedication to the rising and raising and preparing our children to grow into productive, positive adults. [0:13:16, 0:13:36]: Whereas fathers teach by example the values of love, trust, work, responsibility, and faithfulness to family and others. Whereas we set aside the third Sunday in June to honor our fathers for their valuable contributions and selfless sacrifice. Fathers, whereas fathers impart to the sons and daughters a sense of heritage, duty, responsibilities, [0:13:36, 0:13:39]: as part of their family, friends, community and country. [0:13:39, 0:13:48]: Whereas in homes across the great nation, state, and local communities, we look to the fathers to provide the strength and stability which recognize a successful family. [0:13:48, 0:13:58]: And whereas if the father's responsibilities are many, his rewards are also great, the love, appreciation, respect of children and spouse, there is a desire to acknowledge publicly [0:13:58, 0:14:18]: these feelings to have for their fathers and of the beloved Stockbridge community. Now therefore I Anthony's for by virtue of authority less than me as the mayor of the city of Stockbridge, Georgia. And on behalf of City Council members Elton, Alexander, Yolanda, Barber, Kyle Berry, LakeesaGantt, and Afonso Thomas, to hereby recognize June 16, 2024, as Father's Day in the Great City of Stockbridge. Let us honor [0:14:18, 0:14:33]: honor our fathers, living and deceased, and show them the love and gratitude they deserve. A witness thereof I have hereunto set my hand, the great seal city of Stockbridge, Georgia, on the tenth day of June, year of our Lord, two thousand and twenty four. And I signed a proclamation along with our cliff with Nessal Holiday. [0:14:34, 0:14:37]: [878.9, 884.7]: Now I have to admit I have to admit my my on my own father passed away five years ago, but I think about him often. [0:14:44, 0:14:53]: Uh so uh gentlemen, you're all fathers. So I uh any comments? Any comments, any fathers you have any comments at all? F I mean really. [0:14:54, 0:14:58]: Mr. Alexander, uh why you ha I'm I know you probably have some comments, I would imagine. [0:14:58, 0:15:18]: You go ahead, Pray. Well, but I got well I'll you know I can give you the proclamation. Go ahead. So, what kind of comments do you have? Well, I just want to thank uh all the fathers out there if you're tuning in and everyone up here recognizing the contribution of fathers in the community and everything that you do uh to make sure and sustain the [0:15:18, 0:15:38]: Community and to protect the village and do everything necessary to make the city prosperous. Understand, statistics don't lie. Fathers matter in the household and doing what we do and to make sure that we are fostering a family and doing what's necessary to be involved in the children's lives. [0:15:38, 0:15:58]: Because even though fathers who are not in the home are actively involved in their child's life and making a difference. And so let's make sure that we continue to recognize the contributions of fathers not just today, but every day, three hundred and sixty-five days a year. [0:15:58, 0:16:04]: Anybody else? Anybody come on gentlemen, we're gonna take a picture. Come on, we're gonna take a picture. Anybody else have any comments that you wanna make? [0:16:05, 0:16:25]: Well I know you're all great men, all great fathers. So uh let's let's double up. Come on, come on, so let's kinda get in here tight. Remember, you have to have a different uh second row. You jumped on the book. [0:16:25, 0:16:27]: Oh, it's my own. [0:16:40, 0:16:41]: Mm-hmm. [0:16:41, 0:16:50]: Probably not. We got a limited amount of time. Yeah, we're limited. [0:16:52, 0:16:52]: Mm. [0:16:55, 0:17:07]: We got one more proclamation. Stand by folks. Uh yeah. Oh C okay C is here. Okay. All right. Okay. Well come on up. Y'all come on? [0:17:08, 0:17:16]: All right, so this this proclamation here is for LGBTQ and National Pride Month. So anybody wants to re recognize or as I read this, come on up. [0:17:17, 0:17:17]: Okay. [0:17:20, 0:17:31]: How you doing? How you doing? Good. I said thank you for making it all short. I was here at Saturday. Absolutely. No, I know you said you were gonna be late. Anybody else at all? Okay. [0:17:31, 0:17:44]: And co how you doing by the way? I'm fine, how are you? Anybody else wanna join us, feel free to join us as well. We wanna make sure everybody feels welcome here. Feel free to join us. Anyone else to join us? Okay. [0:17:45, 0:18:05]: Proclamation, City Stockbridge, and recognition of LGBTQ and National Pride Month. Whereas June is Pride Month, although it runs through June 30th, Pride Month typically wraps up with a series of events scheduled on or about June 28th, the anniversary of Stonewall Rising. Whereas in June 1969, a courageous group of Americans rolled [0:18:05, 0:18:25]: Goes up to protest the violence and materialism, marginalism, excuse me, they face in what became known as the Stonewall Uprising. Police have raided the Stonewall Inn, a gay bar located in New York City. And for the next six days, they clashed with LGBTQ plus protesters who bravely [0:18:25, 0:18:45]: Stood their ground. The courage sparked the civil rights movement for the liberation of the LGBTQ plus community and changed the nation forever. Whereas during lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender, queer, and intersexual LGBTQ plus Pride Month reflects on the progress we made as a nation in the [0:18:45, 0:18:55]: fight for justice, inclusion and equality, while reaffirming a commitment to do more about more to support LGBTQ plus rights at home and abroad. [0:18:56, 0:19:08]: Whereas all human beings are born free and equal in dignity and rights, LGBTQ plus individuals have had immeasurable impact on to cultural, civic and economic successes to our of our country. [0:19:09, 0:19:29]: Whereas, while society at large increasingly supports LGBTQ plus, equality is essential to the knowledge acknowledgement that needs to for the need of education, awareness remains vital to the end discrimination and prejudice. Whereas this nation is founded on the principle that every individual has [0:19:29, 0:19:49]: In definite uh dignity and work. The city of Stockbridge embraces the principle of and we will continue to work to eliminate prejudice everywhere it exists. Now therefore our Anthony Sforr, by virtue of authority, vesting me, is the mayor of the city of Stockbridge, Georgia. And on behalf of City Council members out, now Zandy, Londa, Barber Cowberry, Lakeesha Gantt and Afonso Thomas, you [0:19:49, 0:20:01]: We hereby proclaim June 2024 as National Pride Month and call upon the Sustabbers community to recognize the achievements of LGBTQ plus community and to celebrate the great diversity in America. [0:20:01, 0:20:20]: And witness thereof I have hereunto set my hand in great seal of the city of Stockbridge, Georgia, on the tenth day of June, year of our Lord, two thousand and twenty four. And I signed a proclamation along with our clerk Winness Olive. And I'd like to issue this to you. Oh, thank you. Thank you. No, you have we have no comments at all. [0:20:21, 0:20:34]: I just like to say thank you to the city of Stockbridge for acknowledging the LGBTQ plus community. There are a lot of us here. You make us feel welcome and we will continue to contribute to the community. [0:20:35, 0:20:36]: Oh really? [0:20:37, 0:20:39]: So you know we want to take a picture over here? [0:20:40, 0:20:40]: Yeah. [0:20:41, 0:20:46]: So that should be right. This is good for this part. Okay. Okay, sure. Come on. [0:20:48, 0:20:57]: [1263.2, 1268.6]: Thank you. All right. Thank you all for the [0:21:09, 0:21:20]: Okay, you said now. You too. All right ladies and gentlemen, that is the the last of our proclamations and part of our uh ceremonial portion for the meeting. It's ten minutes to six, so we'll start the meeting at six o'clock. All right? [0:21:22, 0:21:25]: So relax yourself and stand by, okay? [0:22:53, 0:22:57]: Council, let's let's take our seats so we can get started with the meeting, please. [0:23:11, 0:23:13]: Gentlemen, let's uh let's start the meeting. [0:23:35, 0:23:37]: Ladies and gentlemen, I have six oh one. [0:23:37, 0:23:42]: I'd like to start our city council meeting dated um Monday, June nineteenth. [0:23:44, 0:23:51]: Excuse me, June tenth. I got Juneteenth on my mind. I can't wait to that celebration. Monday, June tenth, okay, six oh one. [0:23:52, 0:23:55]: Invocation, uh Miss Jackson, please, could you come to the mic? [0:23:56, 0:23:59]: Please stand folks if you're willing to do and can do so. [0:24:01, 0:24:02]: Make sure the mic's on for you, please. [0:24:03, 0:24:04]: Is the green light showing? [0:24:06, 0:24:07]: There you go. Thank you. [0:24:08, 0:24:12]: Good evening, Mayor and Council. May we all bow our heads. [0:24:12, 0:24:32]: I pray for this council meeting tonight. Give the council members wisdom and guidance as they deliberate on the items before them. May every decision be righteous in your sight, for our benefit and for your glory. In the name of the Father, of the Son, and the Holy Spirit. Amen. Amen. We will pledge allegiance. [0:24:32, 0:24:45]: I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the world for which is hands, one nation under God, individual, with liberty and justice for all. [0:24:47, 0:24:49]: Anclock uh Rokaw, please. [0:24:50, 0:24:52]: Mayor Ford. Present. Mayor Pro Tem Berry. [0:24:54, 0:25:14]: Let the record reflect Mayor Berry. Mayor Pro Tanberry is not in attendance. Councilmember Alexander. Present. Councilmember Barber. Present. Councilmember Gantt. Present. Council Member Thomas. Present. Mayor Cord, you have a call. I thank you, Madam Clerk. I appreciate it. Uh Council, I have before me, there's a motion before me to amend. [0:25:14, 0:25:20]: To remove item number six, the lottery to be put to be published, and announce at a future [0:25:21, 0:25:28]: date to be determined. Is there a second to that motion? Or is there a motion to say so moved or a second? So move. Is there a second? [0:25:28, 0:25:34]: I second. Okay, from uh from Mr. Alexander to Miss Gann. All in favor, please indicate. [0:25:34, 0:25:45]: Okay, thank you, Namus. Thank you very much. So ladies and gentlemen, item six will not be seen this evening. All right, so on that note, I need a motion to adopt the reining the remaining of the agenda, please. [0:25:45, 0:25:57]: Mayor. Yes sir. If I would like to make a note, I think there was a previous advertisement that um there was a rezoning on Hudson Bridge Road for tonight, but it will not be heard tonight'cause I don't see it on the agenda either. [0:25:58, 0:26:07]: Uh what item you referring to, sir? Well, it wasn't only agenda, but I think that there was some confusion about that being on this agenda tonight, but it's not. Okay. Yeah. [0:26:09, 0:26:11]: Ma'am may applaus. Yes, ma'am. [0:26:12, 0:26:20]: It's my understanding that the Planning Commission deferred the item, so it has to go back to the Planning Commission before it can come to the council. [0:26:21, 0:26:25]: Okay. [0:26:30, 0:26:35]: Who's who's determined if the applicant will give me some information cannot be decided to refer? [0:26:36, 0:26:54]: Okay. That's why it's not on the agenda tonight. Yes. Okay? So so be it. Ms. Alexander? Yes, thank you. Okay. So moved. All right. Uh so move to the amendment to the uh rest of the agenda. Yes. If so moved, is there a second to the motion? My second. Ms Ms. Gantt, second and all in favor, please indicate. [0:26:55, 0:27:11]: All right, we'll go forward with the agenda. Before you council, you have the adoption of the minutes, um, the adoption of minutes for May thirteenth, the city uh city council meeting May thirteenth, and also city work session, council work session on the twenty eighth. Is there a motion to uh to approve those minutes, please? [0:27:12, 0:27:17]: So move. Okay, Mr. Alzheimer's, is there a second? Ms. Barber, second that. All in favor, please indicate. [0:27:18, 0:27:22]: Okay, unanimous decision on that moment as well. Uh Madam Clerk, any public comments at all? [0:27:24, 0:27:24]: Okay. [0:27:25, 0:27:36]: Ladies and gentlemen, before we started a meeting tonight, we had uh uh several different ceremonial type of presentations. First of all, uh we recognize uh a couple of our own employees. [0:27:37, 0:27:57]: Um Miss Unita Sellers, um or ten years of of working in the city of Stockbridge and she says she's gonna be around for another twenty, so I said, Okay, fantastic. And uh Stephanie Milton uh for special recognition doing a great job down in the in the um in his in the office downstairs dealing with all you the customers and all the [0:27:57, 0:28:06]: anybody coming in for do businesses in the in this aspect. So uh those ladies were identified and recognized and honored in that aspect as well. [0:28:07, 0:28:27]: We have proclamations for Municipal Court Clerks Week, and we have several members of our court clerk that were here present for that as well. We want to recognize all the good work they're doing. And uh a proclamation reference to Juneteenth, and uh we will have a Juneteenth celebration, of course, here soon, in another nine days city event. It'll be third year in a row. [0:28:27, 0:28:47]: That will have that event. And obviously that's in recognition of individuals, African Americans finally receiving, an entire country finally receiving that the fact that the Civil War has ended and they're free from slavery. And so we want to recognize that as well. And then we recognize Pride Month here in the city of Stockbridge. [0:28:47, 0:29:07]: And Miss Lisa Carter received uh that particular proclamation. And we recognize Father's Day. We had several of us that were joined for that, include myself and Miss Alizander, several other staff members, gentlemen that are fathers, and so we want to give them recognition as well. A lot of times the recognition normally goes to mothers, but there [0:29:07, 0:29:21]: our fathers so and we do our part as well so we wanted to make sure we did that. On that note I have a um next on the agenda would be a a public hearing. May I we'll go back to the public comments. [0:29:21, 0:29:26]: Oh yeah, oh I missed that. Yes we did. Um Mr. Lewis Fonseca. [0:29:26, 0:29:35]: Okay. Okay, go right here, I'm sorry. Come on up come up, sir, if you have public comment and uh give your name and address. You get three minutes, sir. [0:29:44, 0:29:49]: That's i is a green light on, sir? Green light? Okay, go ahead, please. [0:29:49, 0:30:09]: Uh good afternoon, everyone. My name is Louis Van Seca. I'm actually uh I come from New York City and did this back for the past two years. Okay. Unfortunately I'm not I'm standing here and had to make great comments. It's unfortunate to tell you that the police department you have sort of people that are racist against my Latin community. [0:30:09, 0:30:17]: the clean spackage. And that's very disappointing because I thought it's supposed to protect the serve. [0:30:17, 0:30:33]: You know, and we need to start paying attention to all that. We provide a lot of a lot for the for the community. Also, over the weekend, you know, I also represent Royal Sports Park, yeah, down down on North Liverpool Park. [0:30:34, 0:30:54]: And our company was raided by the city. I don't know who made the phone for me on the audio of you guys. If you make the phone to shut us down, I would appreciate for you to start talking to us and start doing great business and protect the local businesses. We're here to support the LA community, the Korean. [0:30:54, 0:31:14]: community which we have a lot of community in this in the city you know to work together with the city we are bringing a lot of business to the city and actually one of you guys shut us down and that's a very paid move we start we need to start working together and this very disappointing you affect other people you help but [0:31:13, 0:31:33]: A lot of people that need second chance because they get out of jail. And we can work to make sure to support the children. It is unfortunate because I started doing my research. It's very upsetting and I'm very [0:31:33, 0:31:53]: I'm very disappointed to say this. One of them are the police department, like I mentioned. You need to start looking into that because like I said, we were very uh we were treated like criminals over the weekend, like pigs, and that's the way the boss was supposed to work. Let's do this thing the right way. [0:31:53, 0:32:13]: proper way and I know how I know exactly how they move because I used to work for city council in the mayor in New York City. So you know you have a person like myself that speaks three languages that you could actually use to work together with the city. But no right now you don't have to access because we're being shut down. We can't work here. We're being kicked [0:32:13, 0:32:33]: Out instead of kicking us out, why don't we just educate businesses to make sure we do the right moves, the right things which we want to proper progress, not to delete us from the city? And that's how I feel this community right now. Very disappointing. And a lot of the community, Korean, Afro-American, was very happy with what we were doing. [0:32:33, 0:32:53]: doing at what you're supposed to are you know bringing businesses uh to the big uh into where you're uh into stack which is very important because we could work together we could build this together you know thank you and i'm sorry for for being very very upset but whoever did make that phone call think about it before you do have [0:32:53, 0:33:00]: because you know that community is ready to come out and protest about this move and then you just it's a right. [0:33:00, 0:33:12]: Thank you for the comments. We'll check further into this. The first I've heard of it. I don't know if the council knew anything about this before, but we'll check further in into your concerns, sir. Any other and that's that's the only comment? Uh yes. Ms. Suzette Wilkinson. [0:33:13, 0:33:18]: Mayor Ford. [0:33:19, 0:33:25]: Yes, um yeah, you go ahead, sir. Um I I didn't get the name of the sports bar. [0:33:27, 0:33:33]: Okay. Royal. Right. Okay. Thank you. Thank you. All right. Go come on, ma'am. Your name and address, please. [0:33:41, 0:33:42]: Okay. [0:33:45, 0:33:47]: Uh taxes would be [0:33:47, 0:34:00]: lower that it wouldn't affect us, but in actuality we were not told like I have homestead exams with Henry County. I was not told prior that I would have to file a separate homestead exam. [0:34:00, 0:34:02]: What the city of Stockwell is. [0:34:02, 0:34:10]: Also, we were built, I was built$264 for trash, and then they came and took one of my trash can. [0:34:10, 0:34:29]: When I requ inquired about getting the can back, they told me under the city ordinance, you're only entitled to one can and in order to get the second can back, I would have to pay additional thirty-six dollars quarterly. Which in actuality that takes me from paying$192 a year. [0:34:29, 0:34:44]: To$264 plus in order to get my other can back, that's an additional$144. So that takes me a disabled resident to$404 a year for the same trash that I was paying$192 for. [0:34:45, 0:35:05]: And then you have other people in the subdivision that are paying cycle works, and they don't realize that they're being billed through the city of Stockbridge for their training. So they're being double paid. Then I have an elderly neighbor that lives next door. Their son takes care of their bills. He wasn't aware. He's still paying waste management, but he was [0:35:05, 0:35:09]: Bill and his parents will bill the two hundred and sixty-four dollars for trade. [0:35:09, 0:35:15]: So why are they still accepting payments from the people in the neighborhood but they're getting paid through the city? [0:35:17, 0:35:35]: All right, well I'll tell you we'll have to check into this. Obviously you as a as city residents you have two trash cans. You have a regular trash can and you have a recyclable can. You're supposed to have also a recyclable as well, ca w everybody gets recyc has recyclable service. Uh the city manager's taking note of this, we'll have to get you got your name and address and we'll have to follow up with this ask this for you, okay? [0:35:40, 0:35:41]: I had two tradifications. [0:35:41, 0:35:44]: And I'll be paid forty eight dollars for [0:35:44, 0:35:51]: Now I'm telling being told in order to get my old can bash. I'm gonna have to pay separately to get that can. [0:35:51, 0:36:03]: All right. Mr. Gardner, take a note of this please so we can follow up with this. This is resident. Thank you. Thank you, ma'am. Thank you. All right. Um no further comments. Okay, thank you. On that note. [0:36:05, 0:36:08]: We're going to public hearing, ladies and gentlemen. And so um [0:36:09, 0:36:11]: When we go into public hearing, um [0:36:15, 0:36:19]: Let me go I'm gonna read this now and then uh then Ryan you'll give you a briefing. All right. [0:36:20, 0:36:40]: Public hearing rules, please mute all mute all your cell phones and other electronic devices. If anyone wishes to speak tonight on public hearing item, please fill out the form available on the table and hand it to the city clerk before approaching the podium. After each case is called, the city the council will hear from the city staff, followed by the applicant or the representative. [0:36:40, 0:36:50]: regarding the proposed plans for property along along with any other relevant information. The council will be free to ask questions at any time before the vote. [0:36:51, 0:37:11]: The following the applicant, anyone who wishes to speak in favor or oppose the case will have an opportunity to do so. Each slide, each side, excuse me, will be allotted ten minutes total. Additional time may be extended at the discretion of the counsel. Please keep comments and presentations professional, referring only to the facts that are permanent to the council. [0:37:11, 0:37:31]: Case. We will not allow comments or personal attacks toward any individual group. Please refrain from applause or comments from the audience during the public hearing. After the presiding officer recognizes the speaker, which is me, he or she shall direct all comments to the presiding officer and never to members of the council, staff, or the audience. [0:37:31, 0:37:51]: All comments will be made from the podium where you will be where you'll be required to state your name and address for the record. Please note that these hearings are not a debate. Failure to comply will cause you to be removed from the chamber and the building by law enforcement if you deviate from these proceedings. Other than [0:37:50, 0:38:10]: applicant no person may speak more than once. The applicant may reserve part or part of his time, his or her speaking time, as a rebuttal and may speak next and last and may use the entire 10 minutes to allow for the pro side of the application. If questions are raised, the council may ask the applicant to address questions and or concerns. [0:38:10, 0:38:11]: Yeah. [0:38:11, 0:38:29]: Providing officer will call for a motion and second to that motion and have a necessary discussion. If the matter is not tabled, the presiding officer will call for the vote to recommend approval or denial of the request. The first item for public hearing deals with text amendment case tx. [0:38:30, 0:38:50]: That's two zero two four-four for housing shelters citywide. Consideration of tax amendment to the Stock Bridge Unified Development Code UDC to allow for the location of various types of housing shelters within the C2 General Commercial, C three, heavy commercial, OI office institutional, and [0:38:50, 0:39:06]: ally light industrial zoning districts use as special uses requiring the approval of the special use permit through the public hearing process. Planning commission recommendation 05 on 1624 denied that. Mr. Ryan please. [0:39:07, 0:39:16]: Good evening. Um the yes, the Planning Commission did recommend denial. However, they were um mostly influenced by um unincorporated [0:39:16, 0:39:19]: Henry County residents. Uh no one from the city spoke. [0:39:20, 0:39:22]: Uh out against this text amendment. [0:39:24, 0:39:28]: Um the general definition of um of what we're proposing. [0:39:29, 0:39:33]: An amendment to our UDC is a sh it will be ca is a specialized housing facility. [0:39:34, 0:39:37]: Is a shelter home a refuge for those in urgent needs. [0:39:37, 0:39:53]: or in times of emergency, it is designed to provide temporary living accommodation to individuals, family families who are experiencing homelessness in general. We have we have proposed three different types of shelters. Tier one, a shelter providing specialized housing, [0:39:53, 0:39:59]: Whose primary purpose is to provide temporary shelter for no more than thirty days, uh a tier two shelter. [0:39:59, 0:40:03]: A shelter providing homelessness services whose primary purpose [0:40:03, 0:40:06]: Is provide temporary shelter for no more than six months. [0:40:06, 0:40:13]: And a tier three shelter, which is a long term shelter, which is to provide temporary shelter for no more than one year. [0:40:18, 0:40:33]: Um like in the in the agenda item that the mayor read, um to operate one of these facilities you still have to come before the city council to get a special use permit. Uh they will be allowed in uh OI, C2, C three. [0:40:33, 0:40:40]: and L I they will not be allowed in the downtown overlay district or the parkway mixed use overlay district. [0:40:40, 0:40:49]: Uh, we're amending section three point one of the UDC, the table to add specialized housing facilities as a special use. [0:40:51, 0:41:00]: Um listed in section D are the sec are the requirements um in rel in relation to setbacks and buffering and things of that nature. [0:41:02, 0:41:05]: Uh the the map on the screen right now is [0:41:05, 0:41:12]: Is all the of all the potential locations for a specialized housing facility. As you can see, it's not allowed in the DT. [0:41:12, 0:41:25]: Downtown Overlay District or the PMU, the Parkway Mixed Use Overlay District. Uh the parcels available are all zone L I, C2, OI, and C I mean C two, C three, L I and O I. [0:41:26, 0:41:33]: And uh on the map lists all the potential locations for those facil types of facilities. Uh we feel like [0:41:34, 0:41:54]: This potenti uh particular text amendment is needed to help combat um the issue we have with the unhoused in the city because currently there is no provision allowed to uh no provision in the UDC to allow for these types of facilities. And we feel like this will be beneficial for the public health and safety of the overall city. [0:41:54, 0:41:58]: So staff uh staff recommended approval of this. [0:42:00, 0:42:05]: Okay. All right. Thank you for that. Appreciate it. Council, questions that you may have? [0:42:09, 0:42:11]: Ms. Ms. Barber, are you ready for a do you have a question? [0:42:12, 0:42:12]: Okay. [0:42:13, 0:42:21]: Thank you, Mr. Anderson. Um what's driving this change? Did you get a request or something? [0:42:22, 0:42:38]: N not not not in particular. I mean we just um we have several uh citizens, um residents complaining about our the housing encampments and things of that nature and uh people in need don't have a place to go within the city. [0:42:39, 0:42:43]: So we felt like it was uh done, it needed to be done out of a need basis. [0:42:48, 0:43:08]: Thank you, sir. All right. So let me ask go ahead. So there's no particular applicant or anything at this time. This is just a preemptory a preemptory preemptive move. Yeah, we're trying in anticipation of something that may or may not happen in the future. Well, we have several people that want to apply for one of these facilities, however [0:43:08, 0:43:15]: Or uh we don't have an application process for it, or we don't have any provisions in the UDC to allow them to. But we get inquiries all the time. [0:43:16, 0:43:35]: Right. I d uh I didn't hear you so this this the are these allowed in residential areas potentially no only C two, C three, O I and L I only districts and uh and they are excluded from the downtown overlay district area and the Parkway mixed use overlay area. [0:43:35, 0:43:49]: So how were how were the uh i uh y how did you go about the process of determining the location? Did you have consultation with the particular vendors or you how d how did you formulate these particular loc go back to the locations if you [0:43:50, 0:44:10]: Staff and I um we basically made the determination we wouldn't want these type of facilities in in our areas, but we're where we were trying to encourage growth and we want and we don't want them in our residential areas. So um and and we did some comparative analysis with what other cities have and these are the four districts that most [0:44:10, 0:44:13]: other cities have these types of facilities located in. [0:44:14, 0:44:16]: Okay, l put the map back up there if you wouldn't. [0:44:21, 0:44:41]: Wait a minute. And if it would be helpful, I've had several individuals approach me or come to my office, have conversations with me about this issue. So I talked further with Mr. Gardner and uh about what how what we can do if it can need to accommodate this. And that's what drive Mr. An uh Anderson to do some research on this and bring it back before the council to see if this is something that the council [0:44:41, 0:44:48]: we want to do. So that's how that I believe this how this got started with conversations initially some of the citizens had with me when it came to visit me. [0:44:49, 0:44:56]: Okay. Thank you for that. I want to follow up when it gets to the back up. Hey Demetris. [0:44:58, 0:44:59]: Was the victor. [0:45:01, 0:45:02]: Like you. [0:45:09, 0:45:09]: Oh. [0:45:11, 0:45:15]: I can't get it to go back to slide number seven. What you got in um? [0:45:15, 0:45:16]: Slides up. [0:45:28, 0:45:30]: One more is that one. [0:45:32, 0:45:35]: Mm. There we go. [0:45:38, 0:45:58]: Okay, so these areas that are indicated aren't traditional uh residential areas that you have outlined. Is that what you indicated? Uh no sir. Uh these are C two, C three, L I and O O I districts. And the properties are already zoned for those the in those designation as you've indicated. [0:45:58, 0:46:18]: Yes, sir. Okay, certainly, Mayor, I certainly do concur uh with the need uh and uh Miss Councilwoman Barber and I actually served on a commission uh seeking to do something similar to this to be able to provide a a homeless shelter working [0:46:18, 0:46:38]: With the county partners, and at some point when uh the funding is available or entity is present, then uh we would need some locations in the city uh as potential locations for this. Obviously, you know, folks will be sensitive to uh the locations and because of the population. [0:46:38, 0:46:58]: You're dealing with you certainly want to be very sympathetic as we encounter the homeless population weekly at my food drive. And I'm sure uh Miss Linda Jones and cur and in uh comes in contact with them frequently during her food drive and all the nonprofit organizations, and we're scrambling because we don't have the resources. [0:46:57, 0:47:17]: To do so. So I do believe this is a very necessary move in order to have these done. But certainly they got to be done right in partnership with the community so that when funding does become available, we see it every day out there at the interstate. We see it at re-retail locations. [0:47:17, 0:47:37]: With people panhandling. And then we had a situation where Councilwoman Barber and I participated in this commission where we were looking to establish a homeless shelter. And during the cold weather, when it was so cold, and they went out and they were [0:47:37, 0:47:57]: actually picking up folks in various areas of the city because it was so cold in the wintertime that the death was a real, real possibility. And housing these individuals in hotels, that was what they were forced to do. So certainly this is necessary. I just want to make sure we're [0:47:57, 0:48:17]: Doing it in line with what's what's appropriate for the city and that uh they're in appropriate locations. Yes, we follow national um standards uh when we devise this text amendment. Uh we put it in the most familiar familiar districts that other cities nationwide have these. [0:48:17, 0:48:20]: facilities permission to be located in. [0:48:24, 0:48:37]: So uh the vendors that you talked to, did anybody express a desire for a particular location? Uh no sir. It didn't it didn't go that far because after we told them we don't have a provision in our UDC for it, uh it just kinda was left at that. [0:48:39, 0:48:42]: Thank you. Any other questions from the council? [0:48:45, 0:49:00]: Any other questions from the council? Good. All right. So if that's the if that's no one of the questions, then obviously are we gonna make a change. Yeah, we need a public hearing. I'm sorry, sir. Public hearing. Uh yes, thank you, sir. It is a public hearing. You're absolutely right. [0:49:01, 0:49:17]: Before we start the public here. Talk about these locations. The map is kinda small. So you can blow up each location uh that that you had some determination for so folks can can see that. I see that. Um [0:49:19, 0:49:39]: Looks like the majority of them are in my district. Or well I'm not necessarily in uh Marypro Tim's district. Well'cause they're north of Eagles Land. There can only um there can only be three, one of each, one Tier One, one Tier Two, and one Tier Three in the city. So there won't be a proliferation of of these types of facilities. Okay. So there can only be [0:49:39, 0:49:40]: Be three. [0:49:43, 0:49:48]: Okay, so this uh the lo the one that's right there by Eagles Landing Parkway, that is in the business center, correct? [0:49:48, 0:50:08]: Yeah, um I mean some of these these properties could be are um could be filled already. Um they're not necessarily vacant. Um but these this is just an example or illustration of the LI the C C two, C three, OI, and LI parcels in the city as a whole. So some of them could be taken. [0:50:08, 0:50:09]: Bacon uh [0:50:16, 0:50:36]: Okay, if no other questions, then uh what I'd like to do is uh is open this up further for the for the public to uh give the comments. So if you're interested in approving or this one having good comments about what has been presented, uh from the very my very uh left section, is anybody wants to speak on this? [0:50:36, 0:50:56]: This in reference to it being a good thing to do in the city. Anybody on my left that wanna speak? And if that's the case, I need for you to line up on the right there in the in the aisleway if you're gonna if you wanna speak. Anybody in the middle wanna speak? This is four. Anybody four? This in the middle. [0:50:56, 0:50:59]: [3059.6, 3060.2]: Four. [0:51:01, 0:51:02]: Okay. [0:51:02, 0:51:05]: If you're the one four man, come to your mic, give your name and address, please. [0:51:08, 0:51:09]: Make sure the green light is on. [0:51:10, 0:51:25]: Good evening, Mayor Ford and the council members and all city stock of Stockbridge residents. Mrs. Paula Neely, 165 Banks Drive, Stockbridge, Georgia. There is a need. There is a [0:51:25, 0:51:26]: Critical need. [0:51:27, 0:51:29]: It has been addressed on the neighborhood [0:51:29, 0:51:30]: Email. [0:51:30, 0:51:34]: Від концерс абої тоді а за ситі. [0:51:34, 0:51:36]: For those that are homeless and in need. [0:51:37, 0:51:52]: many times coming out of the Walmart on Hudson Bridge, giving. We have seen many sleeping under the tower that says City of Stockbridge there at the corners of Rockbridge. [0:51:52, 0:51:55]: And Hudson Bridge. It's a shame. [0:51:55, 0:51:56]: It's a shame. [0:51:56, 0:51:58]: We're all God's children. [0:51:58, 0:51:59]: And they need help. [0:52:00, 0:52:20]: Because it could be us. But by the grace of God, there go I. Thank you. Thank you. Okay, if there are no other comments for comments that may be against and that that say that we don't want to do this, you know what the council to do this, that's against this. Anybody in my far left that wants to speak? My far left. [0:52:20, 0:52:28]: Anybody in the middle? Please, it's line up right there, please. Anybody in the middle who want to speak against this? Anyone by far right. [0:52:29, 0:52:31]: Okay, ma'am, please name and address. [0:52:36, 0:52:56]: Uh the green light is on Mayor. Okay. And uh my name is uh Jocelyn Williams, one ninety Banks Drive, Stockbridge, Georgia, three oh two eight one. Uh just like other residents, I totally agree with us being able to form three Tier One, Tier Two, and Tier Three. My only question is as a resident, I came to the last meeting when I don't understand or [0:52:56, 0:53:16]: Or not allowed to ask questions, I go to the opposition. Opposition because I want it at least to be documented that at least one person didn't understand because how many occupants will be in a building. I think I saw uh I live near Oak, uh Red Oak, uh is there and Banks Road is there. [0:53:15, 0:53:35]: Uh that there is a industrial area near me and I was just wondering um is that where one of the tiers will be and if it's a tier, what tier is it? So uh my opposition is because I don't understand and because I don't have enough information, but there is a need. I'm just opposing because I don't understand [0:53:35, 0:53:43]: And when given an opportunity to sit in on the discussion, but it's nothing I can do because it was approved. And I thank you so much. [0:53:44, 0:53:48]: M Mr Ryan, could you come back and further explain the different tier system for folks for their understanding? [0:53:52, 0:54:05]: Yes, sir. Uh a tier one facility, you um person can shelter there for up to thirty days. A tier two s uh shelter, a person can shelter there for up to six months, and a tier three up to a year. [0:54:05, 0:54:05]: Okay. [0:54:06, 0:54:11]: So I'm sorry, follow up. How many people would be basically Uh we got that in the regulations, let me see. [0:54:26, 0:54:41]: And for clarification, even if we did move forward with this particular um amendment and we approved at those locations, as you indicated, they would still have to come back to the council for uh final approval. [0:54:42, 0:55:02]: For a special use permit, yes. For a special use permit. So it would never would be the final step, so whatever details would be provided before any final approval or a special a special permit was issued. Yes, sir. That's correct. They would have to come back before council and fill out a special use application, go through the public hearing process. They would have to [0:55:01, 0:55:21]: Meet with her, meet with the affected. Well, it's not in a residential uh neighborhood, but the the closest affected neighborhood. They will have to attend a a CZIM, our new CZIM meeting. They will have to attend the Planning Commission meeting, and then they will come back before city council, and it will be advertised in the newspapers, and everybody would be. [0:55:21, 0:55:23]: [3324.0, 3325.0]: Mm-hmm. [0:55:25, 0:55:26]: Right. [0:55:26, 0:55:31]: Stand by any other questions for Mr. Ryan? Any other questions, concerns you council may have? [0:55:36, 0:55:45]: Well none of them can ex exceed forty beds. On supplemental regulations, um no more than fi forty beds are to be maintained within the shelter. [0:55:47, 0:55:49]: You said no more than forty beds? Yes, yes. [0:55:51, 0:55:52]: Is that for what tier? [0:55:52, 0:55:59]: Uh that's for all tiers. For all tiers. Yes. You there it goes on the screen. It's um item is uh alphabet number E. [0:56:01, 0:56:04]: These are the regulations governing the process. [0:56:09, 0:56:10]: Mayor. Yes, Mayor. [0:56:10, 0:56:20]: Thank you. Um I just wanna say that this has been an ongoing discussion on Nextdoor and other social media outlets. Um I think that we all [0:56:20, 0:56:31]: um understand that and hope that the I hope. I'm definitely in support of this. I'm in hope that um my colleagues are too. I have confidence that they are. [0:56:31, 0:56:32]: Um [0:56:32, 0:56:37]: because there is a need. Um and there's a need w throughout, not just Stockbridge. [0:56:37, 0:56:40]: But when I say c colleagues, that includes [0:56:41, 0:56:43]: My sister cities and our county. [0:56:43, 0:56:45]: Um in as a whole. [0:56:45, 0:56:48]: From Hampton, Locust Grove, McDonough. [0:56:48, 0:56:50]: Um and throughout. And I think [0:56:51, 0:56:54]: That stock bridge I applaud all of us and our staff. [0:56:55, 0:56:57]: And you mayor for taking the lead. [0:56:58, 0:57:00]: on something that this county hasn't had. [0:57:00, 0:57:03]: And unfortunately, when I first got [0:57:03, 0:57:06]: on council back in twenty fourteen. [0:57:07, 0:57:14]: Um and even before then I was told and even when we found out that there was a need for the community, we were told that [0:57:14, 0:57:18]: Shelters weren't warned it here because if you bring a shelter [0:57:19, 0:57:20]: You bring [0:57:20, 0:57:20]: And [0:57:21, 0:57:22]: homeless people. [0:57:23, 0:57:24]: Буре all [0:57:25, 0:57:27]: uh people of love. [0:57:27, 0:57:34]: And um with those shelters come, hopefully the right non profit will come. [0:57:35, 0:57:48]: Um we have now designated and found out locations we we're ahead of the curve and I applaud us for being ahead of the curve. We're spearheading this and I hope that other our county and our s other cities will follow. Um [0:57:50, 0:57:54]: If anyone is hearing that loud and clear, um, I I think that [0:57:55, 0:57:55]: Um [0:57:57, 0:58:15]: It's definitely a need and I hope that we all as a community embrace and love and understand that there are people who whether they need mental help, um, hopefully it's a facility that helps get people back on their feet, whether there are some moms with kids, we've had some shelters for that. [0:58:15, 0:58:25]: Um, who knows? But I I'm I'm glad that we're doing this and I thank you for tasking staff to do this. I think this is important to all of us. We see it all the time. [0:58:26, 0:58:35]: Okay, any other comments for the council? Um Ms. Barbagoy, please. I have a question for Mr. Anderson. Does this include like transitional housing? [0:58:36, 0:58:37]: Um [0:58:39, 0:58:42]: Like if a person lose their home and they're trying to to [0:58:43, 0:58:47]: So there are programs where um [0:58:47, 0:59:06]: Entities can purchase a residential home and use that um as a way to no mail. So it doesn't include like programming for this. This is just for the text amendment. Yes, yes ma'am. In our code. Yes, sir. Thank you, sir. Mayor Ford, um if there are no other questions, I'd like to make a motion. Go right ahead, please. [0:59:07, 0:59:22]: Go right ahead. A motion to approve the text amendment for housing shelters. Second. Okay. May the second. All favor please indicate Mr. NAMS decision. Thank you, Mr. Anderson. Thank you, Council. [0:59:23, 0:59:25]: Now we have um [0:59:25, 0:59:45]: Well c well s I'll say to you, we'll close out that particular public hearing, but we have another item, so we'll have another public hearing here. Uh rezoning case R Z twenty twenty-three-zero five, City Council District two. Consideration of a request to rezone three parcels on Davison Parkway and walked away from C three heavy commercial to the PU [0:59:45, 1:00:05]: Planned unit development to allow for mixed residential development. The applicant is D. R. Horton, Atlanta East, represented by Tiffany D. Hogan. The property contains three parcels, are listed below in the landlot fifty-seven of District 12 with 79.16 plus minus total acres. [1:00:05, 1:00:25]: Commission recommendation on 092823 denial. Council action on 12-1123 deferred per applicant's request, deferred by applicant on also on four April 18th, 24 and May 13, 24. Council meetings. Community held meetings, uh community meeting held [1:00:25, 1:00:45]: on May first of twenty four. Parcel number zero three zero dash zero one zero zero nine zero zero zero contains seventy three point eight five nine acres. Parcel number zero three zero dash zero one zero zero nine zero zero five contains three point six three six acres and parcel number [1:00:45, 1:01:01]: number 030-01009006 contains 1.369 acres. Mr. Anderson, please. Okay. Thank you. All right. On the screen now is an aerial photo of the low of the site. [1:01:01, 1:01:04]: Of the large parcel, there are three parcels of land. [1:01:07, 1:01:12]: Here's the second parcel. It's a smaller parcel. Located front known Walter Way. [1:01:14, 1:01:20]: Uh parcel three is the smaller of the three parcel it fronts on Davidson Parkway. Um [1:01:22, 1:01:31]: Staff originally um recommended denial of the project. However, our uh analysis was was based on um an LCI study that that is more than twelve years old. [1:01:32, 1:01:45]: And usually um the standard for a study is um 10 years. Um here is uh 2023 zoning map of the property. You can see that it's zone C three. [1:01:47, 1:02:00]: The Future Land Use Map, uh Low Density Mixed Vertical Originally, but uh when we adopted our comp plan back in October we changed it to uh medium density residential. So the applicant didn't need a uh comp plan amendment anymore. [1:02:08, 1:02:28]: So I've I m I made this presentation uh several times before, so I'm not gonna go in too deep on it. Um the surrounding land uses to the north of the property is is vacant land, northwest of the property is Clayton County, south is um vacant land, but it was recently approved by the city via CP 22-04. [1:02:28, 1:02:45]: RZ 2022 05 and DRI 3799 for a major mixed use development off Flippin' Road, which is also known as the Reeves Creek Project, Reeves Creek 2 Project. To the southeast, the automobile refurbishing business. [1:02:45, 1:02:48]: Dry time and also uh staff was made aware uh [1:02:49, 1:03:09]: that if the project isn't approved tonight, that drive time is interest is interested in purchasing the purchasing the property and uh expanding their operations in the area. Um they already have the zoning is C three. So if this project isn't approved, Drive Time will acquire the property and expand their operations in the area. [1:03:09, 1:03:24]: east of the property you got North Ridge Crossing 1 subdivision and that is the group that we met with on May 1st and uh they recommended approval and they were in favor of the project. To the west you got uh Interstate 75 and 675. [1:03:29, 1:03:37]: The applicant plans to construct 296 total units, 168 single-family detached dwellings, and 128 townhomes. [1:03:47, 1:04:05]: Here's the um LCI study that I referenced earlier. It's um it's twelve years old. It was done in twenty twelve and it's kinda outdated at this time because like I previously mentioned, um a plan is usually usually only good for ten years due to the changing conditions and development trends inside of the city. [1:04:10, 1:04:19]: The LCI did reference this particular land as to be commercial and wanted to be site of uh a large scale mixed use development. [1:04:20, 1:04:32]: However, due to the frontage, the lack of frontage for the uh property, um nothing has been developed at this time. Um this is the conceptual site plan for the project. [1:04:35, 1:04:36]: That's the layout. [1:04:41, 1:04:48]: So I I I I don't I don't have any additional um information, Mayor, uh and the applicant is is here. [1:04:48, 1:05:08]: Okay, stand by one second. Mr. Thomas, please. Thank you, Mayor. Thank you, Mr. Anderson. Okay. Um, just to give a little history, um, this item is in District 2. Uh I've met with the a number of residents in the Homeowns Association. Uh [1:05:08, 1:05:28]: Um Mrs. Hogan has met um with the residents as well. As you mentioned, it's been deferred a couple of times. So we we sort of been in and out with this issue, but what's sort of driving [1:05:28, 1:05:38]: the complexity of this issue, as you mentioned, um, drivetime refurbishing business and [1:05:40, 1:05:45]: that's a history that's been a little baffling because [1:05:45, 1:05:49]: Um past administration allowed [1:05:50, 1:06:05]: um this residential component plus um this other heavy commercial component which does not mix but um it is what it is now. [1:06:05, 1:06:08]: Um, and I've been asked by some council members [1:06:09, 1:06:11]: uh about this issue [1:06:11, 1:06:13]: And at one point we talked about [1:06:14, 1:06:18]: Um this area being a large tract. [1:06:19, 1:06:21]: And would be great for commercial. [1:06:22, 1:06:23]: Excuse me. [1:06:24, 1:06:29]: Because this is one of the um lasting areas that we could come with commercial. [1:06:30, 1:06:50]: And and from my understanding from the residents, and and some of them are here tonight, um, we're not 100% opposed to the mixture with commercial, but it's the unknown of what commercial may come in. But and I don't want to use the word [1:06:50, 1:07:00]: and and I won't use the word, but just the fact that um the present zoning is uh [1:07:00, 1:07:01]: For a heavy commercial. [1:07:02, 1:07:04]: And that's the fear. [1:07:05, 1:07:07]: that I know that many of these um [1:07:08, 1:07:13]: homeowners have is is that if it is denied and if it stays with [1:07:13, 1:07:33]: Uh and you mentioned this as well. If it stays heavy commercial, then that door is open for not only drive time but any other um heavy commercial that can actually come in. Um so that's sort of a little the history, but in meeting with Mrs. [1:07:33, 1:07:36]: Hogan a couple of times and with the residents. [1:07:36, 1:07:39]: We sort of talked about some [1:07:39, 1:07:59]: uh amendments and some some changes uh to the plan and I know she's gonna speak to some of that here shortly. And I think the citizens were and I'm not gonna speak for them, they're gonna be able to speak for themselves. But they was we were sorta okay with with some of the changes. But um [1:07:59, 1:08:19]: From the city standpoint, as far as this track of land being for that commercial. And I'm going to uh year to the concerns of the citizens uh as far as the unknown. Um and and this track [1:08:19, 1:08:39]: Of land is very close to the residential structure. So if you're talking about bringing in commercial and you're talking the unknown, that's that's fearful. So I just want to sort of give counsel a little history that, you know, we have met. [1:08:39, 1:08:51]: several times with the developers and some concessions have been made and hopefully um some of that will come out tonight [1:08:51, 1:08:55]: um that would be satisfactory for [1:08:56, 1:08:58]: um the homeowners and [1:08:58, 1:09:02]: I'm not sure if the council and the city I know we want it [1:09:02, 1:09:04]: A commercial component. [1:09:04, 1:09:09]: I I I just don't know if that's gonna happen tonight, but um [1:09:11, 1:09:25]: My role here tonight is just to share that information. And as again, as a representative for that particular area, I have met with the Homeowners Association of Citizen. So I do have a feel for [1:09:25, 1:09:27]: Uh their concerns. [1:09:27, 1:09:29]: And so I just want to share that. [1:09:30, 1:09:32]: Thank you. Yeah, okay, Ms. Alzheimer, please comment. [1:09:34, 1:09:54]: Uh thank you, Councilman. So certainly you've done the homework and you've done the work and you've met with the residents to uh garner their feedback and we'll hear from them tonight. Uh if you do recall, I certainly wanted to let you take the lead since it's in your district, that um they were tasked with bringing [1:09:54, 1:10:14]: Back a rendition with some amount of commercial before they came back to us. And the idea, as far as I thought, what we were going for was we're gonna try to give the residents in North Bridge Crossing some relief from having those tractors go through the middle. [1:10:14, 1:10:34]: Of their neighborhood. With this particular design, I don't see any pass-through roadway that will connect with the flippin' road development so that residents can have uh so those residents in those new, it's about a thousand units, will have access to Davison Parkway. [1:10:34, 1:10:54]: This neighborhood seems to close off all options going to Davison Parkway. And to me, we went, we took tireless hours in planning that flippin' road development so that this and I and maintain this so that [1:10:54, 1:11:14]: that it would offer those residents some access to Davidson Parkway. And you know, I don't know where maybe I'm just missing it on here, Ryan. Where this looks like it's a closed in subdivision and it does not offer any option to connect to the parcel to the south. So [1:11:14, 1:11:20]: So those residents will have access to Davison Parkway and they won't all have to go off on flipping. [1:11:20, 1:11:32]: Yeah, that's true. I'll let um Tiffany come up and speak on that, but uh she's in the audience. But it looks to be closed, appears to be, yes, sir. She'll have her opportunity in just a second to do that. [1:11:33, 1:11:53]: Right. And I think the second concern was again, um, you know, uh this is very intensive and certainly um as far as the residents are concerned, you know, um with that frontage along I seventy five, we did want to have some commercial uh in pretty much all of these developments. So [1:11:53, 1:12:13]: When you left your home in Northbridge or one of the surrounding subdivisions, that you would have, you wouldn't have to drive far in order to have some type of uh retail there for you to be able to access. Because driving out on 138, we want you to be able to walk to this commercial park. [1:12:13, 1:12:33]: parcel to be able to use it versus having just all uh additional homes. And then lastly, I think we just went through a really extensive presentation with the county about building residential and billing commercial. Some of that commercial has to be resolved with paying for some of these [1:12:33, 1:12:53]: additional homes uh that will go. Certainly I think this is a more desirable outcome than the that what was mentioned which is a C3 because uh being a C3 uh an expanding of the existing business that were there would actually create uh [1:12:53, 1:13:13]: more of the traffic that we see uh going through uh the North Bridge subdivision. And uh certainly uh that is regrettable that that ever happened, that uh though that that development was approved with the access for the tractors going through the middle of a subdivision, which is just unbelievable. So [1:13:13, 1:13:26]: So my desire in all of this has been a desire to offer the residents an opportunity to get those tractors out of the subdivision and have some type of access through this area to Davidson Parkway. [1:13:28, 1:13:48]: All right. Thank you for the comments. If uh if there are no other comments from the council right now. I do. Oh I'm sorry, go write it, please. I do. Um and perhaps uh when the Miss Logan does her presentation, it won't answer the question. That's what's coming next, but go ahead. Sh I was gonna call her up next, but go ahead with your comment. Okay, I'll wait then. All right, fine. Thank you. All right, on that I need the applicant, Miss [1:13:48, 1:14:08]: Tiffany quant won't you come up here and make it anything else right now, Ryan? I have one question. I'm sorry. Go right in. Well she can come on up, but I I do have a question. Okay. Like the houses look everything looks so close together based off of this. Now it could be very well be different. But we did discuss a commercial component. Um and I do have [1:14:08, 1:14:28]: have concerns about that. I also have concerns because I'm looking at the other surrounding neighborhoods around it. For instance, North Bridge Crossing, which has outlets on Davison Parkway and Walter Way, and to be constructed with those sidewalks, um, in addition to the other areas. And all of the [1:14:28, 1:14:33]: Are we not requiring mixed use? [1:14:33, 1:14:35]: Residential slash commercial. [1:14:36, 1:14:38]: If this is medium density, [1:14:38, 1:14:44]: Um, I just I have some issues about that. Um, and I just I don't [1:14:45, 1:14:46]: I don't see it working. [1:14:47, 1:14:50]: I don't think it's something I that the community would want. [1:14:50, 1:14:55]: And that that's just me talking in that instance. I'm I'm gonna go based off of [1:14:55, 1:14:57]: Whoever the district representative is. [1:14:57, 1:15:00]: But um and and I'll you know [1:15:01, 1:15:03]: Respect the wishes of the community. [1:15:03, 1:15:05]: But I'm looking here [1:15:05, 1:15:12]: Um, for instance, you know, we talk about that C three wick the QTOM or whatever the name of the group are are. [1:15:13, 1:15:14]: And um [1:15:14, 1:15:30]: They were established before the subdivision was established, just so people know. They were established in two thousand three, May fifteenth, two thousand three, that C three component was made and then they put a neighborhood in front of it. So for history purposes, just so you know. [1:15:31, 1:15:37]: That was poor planning. We weren't up here, right? But we're here now. And I wanna make sure. [1:15:37, 1:15:38]: Um [1:15:40, 1:15:40]: Um [1:15:40, 1:15:48]: that whatever we give right now is is quality and something that, you know, the our community will want. [1:15:49, 1:15:51]: And it looks very similar. [1:15:52, 1:15:53]: To what you brought back. [1:15:54, 1:15:55]: What you brought the first time? [1:15:55, 1:15:58]: I don't really see a lot of changes here, if if any. [1:15:58, 1:16:04]: And maybe you can help point those out to me, but we definitely talked about a commercial piece. [1:16:06, 1:16:06]: Okay. [1:16:07, 1:16:16]: May I miss the mayor? Yes, yes, Tiffany, you can go to along with your presentation now. Thank you. Tiffany Hogan, 1371, Dogwood Drive, Conyers, Georgia. [1:16:17, 1:16:37]: I am here representing D.R. Horton this evening as the Vice President of Ford Planning. Uh first to begin starting off addressing some of your main concerns. Uh the plan that you see is very similar, and the reason that it was deferred previously is because we did attempt for what six months now to add a [1:16:37, 1:16:57]: commercial component to the site. The reason that uh as we previously discussed, we had one of the uh largest commercial brokers in the metro area take a look at this to see if he could shop it around to some of his clients. Uh he made comments and did not believe that it was something [1:16:57, 1:17:17]: That was viable for him. You will see his quote in here a little bit later. And so what we did during the last six months is we actually went to this corner adjacent piece. Unfortunately, I don't have a pointer, but it's kind of that mint green piece that's there in the corner because we learned that it was under contract for a commercial. [1:17:16, 1:17:36]: Commercial use and we wanted to be able to connect with them for a commercial component here. What we have since learned is that is that it was a use that I think would have actually made this council even less happy, probably. And we did not feel like it would be a good connection for a community. [1:17:36, 1:17:42]: community of our future homeowners, which is why we did not choose to take that path. [1:17:43, 1:17:48]: Looking at this, I'm going to use this just for a second before I get deep into my presentation. [1:17:48, 1:18:08]: You do have Walter Way here, and then you have Davis Drive, and you have I-75 here. Although it is visible from I-75, there is not frontage access to I-75. So that is one of the main problems for a commercial use at this location, is those things that would be deemed your salt after crack. [1:18:08, 1:18:25]: commercial uses have not seemed to be interested in this piece because again, it has been zoned for 20 plus years and sitting here. And until we went under contract, there was very little movement other than an attempt to rezone it a few years ago that was unsuccessful as well. [1:18:29, 1:18:42]: Staff already showed you this map here. So this is the current piece. It was changed to medium density residential. And as you'll see from the next slide, we have 3.7 units per acre, which does fall into your medium density. [1:18:52, 1:19:12]: Uh three point seven units per acre is seventy-nine total acres with the development. So councilwallman, one of the things that you mentioned is when you're looking at it, the homes look very close together. It is a conceptual site plan. The layout of the community as far as the lot sizes are pretty similar to North Bridge phase one that is across the street. [1:19:12, 1:19:27]: There is actually 36% open space with this development or 45% of the entire site. And again, as staff mentioned, 296 total units, 128 of those is townhomes, 168 as single family detached. [1:19:28, 1:19:29]: Excuse me. [1:19:29, 1:19:34]: We are seeking to rezone it from C three, which is heavy commercial, to the plan unit development. [1:19:34, 1:19:54]: Ooh, that came out rather small there on my screen. It looked fine, but it sounds like you've all done a bit of your homework and you know the uses now that would be available as a C3 development. Um so those are those uses there, which include automobile brokers, automobile gasoline sales, so a gas station, commercial parking garages and lots. [1:19:54, 1:20:03]: Commuter transit, such as buses and trains, farmers markets, many warehouses and storage buildings, among other things there. [1:20:03, 1:20:23]: A few more details on the site here. There is a five-foot setback between each home, so 10 feet total between the homes, a 20-foot front yard setback, and if it's a corner lot, it is a five-foot setback. The townhomes are 24 feet wide, and those are two car garage townhomes. [1:20:23, 1:20:43]: And the lots are 50 foot by 110 feet deep. So that's a 50-foot frontage on those homes there. Uh we wanted to pay close attention as well to additional parking spaces for guests. So we were strategic with that. There is parking. Again, I apologize, there's not a corner here, but if you see the pond. [1:20:43, 1:20:50]: That's in the top north side of the project. There's a an additional guest parking space there. [1:20:50, 1:21:10]: And in the townhome section is really where we thought people would need more additional guest parking. And so there's guest parking when you enter, which is where the mail kiosk will be, as well as guest parking that's kind of down at the corner. So place those throughout the community so that people could park in various places and still walk to the home that they are coming to. [1:21:10, 1:21:30]: To visit. The area that has the little red patch there in the middle is where the main amenity area would be. We are proposing a pool, a clubhouse, a playground, and four play courts or pickleball courts in that area. Then in the lower corner of the project, there will also be a pocket park that's specific to the townhome. [1:21:30, 1:21:46]: community that may include adult walking area or a picnic area or something else in that pocket park as well. This is the quote that I was referencing a while ago from the commercial broker. He has been in the industry for more than 20 years. [1:21:46, 1:22:06]: He is one of the most sought after commercial brokers in the area. We wanted to go to an expert to understand why no commercial, such as what you all have spoken of, has sought out this piece. And this was his quote. And again, he did not seek the opportunity to shop around the site to get it to any of his commercial clients, which is pretty telling. [1:22:08, 1:22:28]: Uh North Bridge Crossing Phase Two, what we're currently calling it, because you'll see in a minute that one of the things that came out from meeting with the community is that they actually requested that we don't name it North Bridge Crossing Phase Two in order to alleviate uh confusion with their phase of the community original phase. But we want to maintain a family-friendly and [1:22:28, 1:22:48]: Environment in this area. That's one of the things that the community really, really expressed during our meetings with them was that they would much rather see residential stuff there and stuff that makes it a home environment for them rather than more commercial being in the area. We wanted to seek the ability to create a connection between research. [1:22:48, 1:23:08]: Creek and community of potential users, as Councilman Alexander spoke to. We did take a look at that. If I go back for a second here to the site plan, unfortunately what we have learned since we first filed this application is that some promises were made to you about a stub rope being placed on the Reeves Creek side and there being a potential for connectivity. [1:23:08, 1:23:28]: As you see, there's a creek there, and also there is a 30-foot drop on that side. So we did have our engineers explore the possibility of how to make a vehicular connection between that, and it is just so taxing to do it and potentially dangerous as well for a 30-foot drop to be able to build that. [1:23:28, 1:23:39]: that up from the other site and create that vehicular connection that it just was not feasible for this. Where that little arc is just above the creek is where the potential Reeves Creek site is located. [1:23:41, 1:24:01]: Um again there hasn't been interest in years for the existing site as a commercial development, and the community did express that they don't want any additional heavy truck traffic coming through. This development obviously would not be heavy truck truck traffic coming through for the community. We also have a traffic impact study that was provided to staff and to council. [1:24:01, 1:24:21]: previously that determined that there would not be a significant impact on the roadways from the additional traffic from the community. There will be two deceleration lanes that are added on each side, one at Walter Way and one at Davis Parkway, so that people can pull off the road in order to be able to turn into the community safely. [1:24:26, 1:24:36]: This is a rendering, uh actually a actual photo of a clubhouse that would be similar uh to the one that would be there and the pool. [1:24:38, 1:24:58]: And as I spoke about the proposed conditions, there are a few things first that I want to iterate reiterate. Uh there's no access from the site to I seventy five. There will be sidewalks on both sides of the streets internally for walkability and connectivity throughout the community. So if people want to walk for exercise, walk to neighbors houses, whatever. [1:24:58, 1:25:17]: they will be able to walk throughout the community. Where we have frontage on the exterior of the property, there will also be sidewalks that will be installed there so that people can walk wherever there's sidewalk connection to other properties or what the city has provided. We have also [1:25:17, 1:25:21]: Uh from the community meetings there was a concern [1:25:22, 1:25:36]: The site plan that you saw that staff had up had homes that were located in that dark green area at the top. The mint green homes are already existing. Those were a part of North Bridge phase one that were put in across the street. [1:25:37, 1:25:50]: where the the dark green is directly across from that. We had homes planned there initially and one of the comments that came from the existing residents was a request to remove those. So those have been removed. [1:25:50, 1:25:58]: So the original site plan was 311 units, which bring brought this one down to 296 units. That was the reason for the reduction there. [1:25:58, 1:26:13]: We also changed some of the road connectivity in order to make it connected throughout. Again, that was another comment and request that we heard was that people wanted to be able to have a continuous loop. And so we made that change as well. And then also, as I mentioned, [1:26:15, 1:26:27]: We thank you all and I will put the proposed condition screen up so that you can't. Council, I'm I'm assuming you'd be more than willing to give her more time to finish her presentation. Yes. Okay. Yes. Well. [1:26:28, 1:26:48]: Yes, I'm I'm in agreement with the addition of time, but I did want to address a question or two when we get a chance. Okay, sure, no problem. Continue on, please. Yes, sir. Um so again, the third thing was to not name it North Bridge Crossing Phase Two, which we have agreed to. The proposed conditions that we came up as a result of the meetings with the community [1:26:48, 1:26:50]: hearing feedback from staff and from the councilmen. [1:26:50, 1:27:10]: Or number one, developer will remove the 15 homes plan for the front of the community as were reflected on the 12-7-2023 site plan, and we have made that revision. Number two, developer will select a name for the development that does not reference North Bridge. Number three, developer will place the main entrance monument for the development at the Davidson. [1:27:10, 1:27:30]: Entrance in order to encourage usage of this entrance as the main entrance. A secondary entrance will be located off Walter Way and both entrances will remain as full access. That was something that also came from the community. They actually preferred that some of the traffic be diverted from Walter W and instead driven over to Davis Drive. [1:27:30, 1:27:46]: And so in order to help encourage that, we will put the main monument sign on that side. We have proposed a rental cap. No more than 5% of the homes may be used as rental property. And number five, there shall be a mandatory homeowners association within the community. [1:27:49, 1:28:02]: This is just some um notes on the homes that will be included in the community. Again, all two-car garages, even the townhomes. All of the homes have three to five bedrooms, the townhomes included. The townhome standard is three bedrooms. [1:28:02, 1:28:15]: There is an option for each one of the end units to have a four-bedroom unit, and that's only one of those per building, a mandatory homeowners association, and then the amenities that I spoke of. [1:28:16, 1:28:36]: D.R. Horton is extremely committed to creating home ownership. And so when we speak of having commercial in the area and bringing jobs to your area, employment, which all bring up the economic development of the area, the jobs have to have somewhere to go home at night and sleep. And so that's what we want to do here is bring some diversity in housing project. [1:28:36, 1:28:56]: product to the area where people can purchase affordable quality homes. A part of our commitment to that is D.R. Horton actually also provides incentives to certain folks that we consider hometown heroes. So military, law enforcement, firefighters, healthcare professionals, educators, all they have to do is show their IDs and they receive an automatic incentive. [1:28:56, 1:29:07]: incentive towards home purchase. Again, as a part of our commitment to home ownership and success in that, we have the Home Buyers Club, which is a free program for people to participate in. [1:29:07, 1:29:22]: even if they end up not purchasing a DR Horton home. And what that does is help them become creditworthy for purchasing homes, teaches them about the finances of home ownership, and hopefully that way they are able to maintain their homes for years to come and help to build generational wealth. [1:29:25, 1:29:40]: And I am happy to entertain any questions that any other council members Mr. Thomas, go ahead, please. Thank you, Mayor. Uh Mrs. Hovind, you you thought of answered uh a few questions that I had. Um, but if you would for the council [1:29:40, 1:29:43]: Um the the the fifteen homes that were removed [1:29:44, 1:29:46]: Uh just so council would know. [1:29:46, 1:29:51]: Uh they were located directly f across from the pool house. [1:29:52, 1:29:53]: And the whole intent [1:29:53, 1:30:13]: And even with the uh ingress and egress, as you mentioned, trying to direct more of that on Davison Parkway as opposed to Walter Way, uh, to try to minimize as much traffic on Walterway that we can. That was one of the things that the residents would. [1:30:13, 1:30:32]: really concerned about. Now with the removal of the fifteen units, um can you elaborate what will now substitute would it be green space, would it be a parking park? Um we sort of talked about trails. Can you elaborate on some of that? [1:30:32, 1:30:51]: Yes, sir. So what you're looking at on the screen right now is staff's version of the site plan, which shows those 15 homes there. And then if I switch over, you see the 15 homes have been removed. So that area we do have planned to be an additional pocket part. We talked about there being an edible garden there, um, perhaps some um [1:30:52, 1:31:10]: uh uh grill area or something like that to add an additional park pocket park to the community as well. And then you are correct, sir, again sidewalks on both sides of the street throughout the community. So right there off of that area, you'll be able to connect and walk the entire property if you chose to. [1:31:11, 1:31:24]: So i if you would, can you indicate how many units would be closer to Walterway and how many units would be closer to uh Davison Parkway? [1:31:24, 1:31:44]: Um, so the ones right now, if you're speaking on the side of the creek, so the north side of the creek, those green unit, the mint green units that you see there that have numbers in them, again, those are already existing there as of today. So we have not planned any new homes to be constructed north of the [1:31:44, 1:32:04]: Creek site that would be closer to North Bridge Crossing Phase One. All of the development that we currently have planned would start south of the creek crossing, which is a little bit into the development and pulls those away from the current North Bridge phase. The townhomes are over on the [1:32:04, 1:32:11]: the west side of the um property. And so there uh it's 128 townhomes total. [1:32:12, 1:32:25]: So it depends on, you know, your definition and what you're considering closer to Davis Way, but the town home units are the ones that are c planned closer to Davis. And and and and again I'm not gonna speak for the homeowners, but it was a concern about [1:32:25, 1:32:27]: Uh traffic on um [1:32:27, 1:32:29]: Walter Way. [1:32:29, 1:32:48]: Uh trying to minimize that. And so I was trying to give everybody a picture of how many even though we did remove the fifteen units, but how many um home would still be closer to uh entering and exiting um on the walk away side. [1:32:49, 1:33:09]: You know, honestly, with the design the way that it is now, if you come in off Davis, you have homes that are on um kind of the north side of Davis Road, and it's just a few of those. Uh it looks like probably between the town homes and the single family. I can't count them exactly a little small on my screen here, but less than twenty that are on that. [1:33:09, 1:33:29]: At Northside. So those would probably be the folks that would be coming from Walterway. And a bit of it depends on which way they're coming from town, to be quite honest, uh, where they're coming from. But with us directing that traffic to come primarily through Davis, uh, I would believe with the main entrance being there, particularly guest traffic, definitely would come. [1:33:29, 1:33:41]: through that access point more likely than the one off of Walway. But if you come in off of Davis, it connects throughout the entire community. So Walway is just an alternative essentially. Right. [1:33:41, 1:34:01]: And I know Councilman Alexander is gonna weigh in on this, but I would be okay with uh you or council speaking more to um the construction side. Uh I know we spend a lot of times dealing with some of the other issues and not with the [1:34:01, 1:34:05]: quality of the construction. Can you can you speak to some of that? [1:34:05, 1:34:25]: Absolutely. Uh so the homes would be constructed out of a mixture of materials for the front elevation. The materials that we use for siding is a Hardy cement, is probably the uh brand that you hear most often. It's a cement fiberboard. Hardy is a brand of it. Uh if there is shake on the homes, which we sometimes do for a decorative architectural feature. [1:34:25, 1:34:45]: Just like in the gable area, that is a cement product as well. So those products tend to last longer, have more durability. People need to press what pressure wash them a little bit less often, which keeps them looking really nice. We are the number one home builder in the country. Last year we closed the millionth home. This year we're on track to close our [1:34:45, 1:35:05]: 100,000 more homes with the closest competitor being probably 10,000 homes away from us. So, you know, I say all that to say there's a way that we've figured out to make things work. And, you know, we don't hide the ball. There's absolutely stuff out there that you will hear that's negative as well. But one of the things that's really excellent about us is we [1:35:05, 1:35:25]: We have a great warranty program. Our warranty manager for our particular division has been with us for almost 30 years. So she probably does this stuff in her sleep. But as long as we know about the issue and it's entered into the portal correctly, it is an issue that we can take care of, and I can assure you we do take care of. At these public hearings, [1:35:25, 1:35:45]: I've had people before come up and say, DR Horton didn't fix this, they didn't do this. I asked them for their address and stuff afterwards. We look in the portal. It turns out that they never reported it to us. We can't fix what we don't know. But what we in turn do is because we didn't have the address, we're able to reach out to them, say one of our representatives heard from you that they had an issue, and they're able to [1:35:45, 1:36:05]: To then see if there's something that can be done to rectify the issue. In some of the larger situations that you've heard about or may have read about, those cases are likely third parties that were doing some work for us. And I can assure you that those people no longer do work for us if there is a major issue that causes a problem. So we are very serious. [1:36:05, 1:36:15]: about our programming. We call it a five-star program. There are surveys throughout the process for homeowners to be able to let us know how we're doing and what needs may need repair. [1:36:16, 1:36:17]: Thank you. [1:36:18, 1:36:27]: Any other questions, Council? Yes. Cool. Ms. Barber Goy, please. She had her hand up. Okay, so I have several questions actually. [1:36:28, 1:36:48]: It's difficult for me to really understand the areas that you are describing. I want to see how many entrance and exit points from the total development. Sure. So there are two full access points for the community. Full access means you can come in and go out. [1:36:48, 1:37:08]: It's not a right-on entrance or anything. So there is one that is at Walter Way that the driveway should align with the development across the street because that is something that your DOT is going to require, is that those access points align for safety purposes. The other one is right there in that curve on Davis Drive. If you're looking at my screen now, [1:37:08, 1:37:14]: Closest to where it says presentation, that gray that comes out of there is the other full access point. [1:37:16, 1:37:16]: Okay. [1:37:19, 1:37:30]: Okay. Um did you mention five feet between each unit? Or is that just a setback? It's a five foot setback, side setback. [1:37:30, 1:37:31]: Okay. [1:37:32, 1:37:32]: Yep. [1:37:32, 1:37:35]: Which means ten feet between the units. Okay. [1:37:35, 1:37:36]: Um [1:37:37, 1:37:57]: I'm not really a big fan of high density residential. Sorry. Um and besides, that just seems like it's a lot of units just compacted together. But of course I will follow the lead of the city council representative for the district. [1:37:58, 1:38:13]: They would hope my councilmates would do the same when proposals are coming to my district as well. And again, this uh I'm sorry for you. Um just as a reminder, is three point seven four units per acre for density, which falls into your medium density category. [1:38:16, 1:38:17]: Thank you. Um [1:38:18, 1:38:21]: Tell me again the breakdown a hundred and twenty eight town homes. [1:38:22, 1:38:37]: Uh it's a hundred and twenty eight twenty four foot town homes and a hundred and sixty eight single family detached homes, which are your traditional homes. These are single family detached homes. The other the ones that kinda look yellow on the screen are detached, yes ma'am. Nice. [1:38:38, 1:38:42]: I'm sure they would prefer those, but just not the density. Um [1:38:43, 1:38:45]: The price points. [1:38:45, 1:38:46]: Can you talk about that? [1:38:47, 1:39:07]: Sure. So I can give you an estimate based on today's cost. So one of the things that I thought Councilman Thomas was leading to with this question was timing. And so I'll speak to timing a little bit because that speaks to the price point. So being here today, seeking this zoning, means that if approved today, we would then have to apply for the land disturbance process. [1:39:07, 1:39:27]: Permit and go through everything where your engineers and your planning department and everyone else digs through with a fine-tooth comb. We estimate approximately six to eight months for that process to take place. So if we're now in June, obviously it would be the end of the year before we anticipated getting a land disturbance permit, meaning that at that time, that's when [1:39:27, 1:39:47]: When we can actually start moving dirt to grade the site. Grading the site will likely take another uh nine months or so to get it to a point where we could go vertical with the first house, the first home being constructed. So it would be sometime around September of next year, 2025, before you're looking at actually beginning to sell your first. [1:39:47, 1:39:50]: home is what we would estimate and anticipate. [1:39:50, 1:40:10]: So if I were looking at today's market, keeping in mind we won't go vertical with the first one until sometime next year, then we would estimate that the townhomes would likely fall somewhere uh between the 325 range, starting probably up to 350-ish, um, and then the homes, the single-family detached homes. [1:40:10, 1:40:21]: would likely start around 350 and go up from there. We will always follow the direction of the market with the sales prices. And if there is an opportunity to, you know [1:40:22, 1:40:35]: arrange those prices based on the market, then we op we make those changes. There is someone in our office that every day her job is to just look at the price of materials and everything else and do the market analysis and adjust prices as such. [1:40:36, 1:40:56]: Okay. With the townhomes, I know you mentioned three bedrooms. Are they all three bedroom units? With the exception of one unit on the end of each building, could potentially be a four-bedroom. Okay. And what's the square footage of the three-bedroom? The townhomes. Uh it's a uh 1860, those start at they range from 1860 to [1:40:56, 1:40:57]: eighteen ninety. [1:41:03, 1:41:23]: And the single detached homes? The ranch product that we have planned for this community is a little bit over 1,800 square feet. That would be the smallest plan within there. It is the number one plan in the entire United States. Sells very well, very popular with folks that don't want stairs, that want kind of the house to be all [1:41:23, 1:41:32]: All be there in one area. So that would be the smallest, and it would range up to about just under 3,000 square feet for the largest. [1:41:32, 1:41:38]: I did not share a conceptual of the homes. [1:41:38, 1:41:39]: Do you have [1:41:40, 1:41:56]: Uh I do not have those with me today, but uh that eighteen hundred square foot plan that I mentioned, uh like I said, it's the number one selling plan in the market. Uh I can give you some communities uh in a moment that you could look at the website and see those homes. Okay. [1:41:58, 1:42:01]: That's all I have for now. Thank you. Mr. Alexander, go ahead, please. [1:42:03, 1:42:16]: I don't even know where to start. Let me just say, this is the exact same plan that we deferred. This is the exact same plan coming back to us with all of these homes on it with no commercial. [1:42:16, 1:42:36]: There th this plan destroys our transportation plan because there's no through road from Flippin' Road to Davison Parkway. And you got all of these homes going on a two-lane road with no access out there with no future improvement. I do have good news for the residents on Flippin' Road, it's gonna go on Splash 6. [1:42:36, 1:42:40]: You're gonna get a chance to vote to widen flippin' road. [1:42:40, 1:43:00]: If you say yes. If you say no, there won't be any money for it. So it's gonna be up to the residents to do that. So the major transportation plan and the DRI that Mr. Anderson spoke to, that he says is too old for this area, call for a through road through this development. [1:43:00, 1:43:20]: That would run parallel with I-75 and kind of connect the area and go over the flipping road. This development does not do that. I thought that was our number one charge was to have the through road. If you're a resident over there in North Bridge Crossing, this development means that you will be stuck with those tractor trailers. [1:43:20, 1:43:23]: Coming through your subdivision for the rest of your life. [1:43:24, 1:43:30]: This development offers an opportunity for us to move traffic through here. [1:43:31, 1:43:51]: From Flippin' Road to Davidson Parkway, and it would give you an opportunity to leave your house, go through this area, and go down the Flippin' Road where it'll be four lanes or access it, it gives you multiple access. This is not the plan that we asked for. We asked for some that the reason that uh we asked for the commercial was so that [1:43:50, 1:44:10]: We limited commercial, that there would be a through road. And the reason that this property has not had any commercial development with it at this point was because there was not enough residential. But we just approved 1,200 new residential units on Flippin' Road that's going to serve the [1:44:10, 1:44:30]: Commercial component of this. But I tell you, residents, I'm looking at this and saying, wow, you're gonna be stuck with those tractor trailers coming through your neighborhood forever if this is approved. I I say that you that there needs to be a revision to this plan, even if there is residential, so [1:44:30, 1:44:50]: There will be a through road. It destroys our trail plan because we had planned on having the road come through there, allow the trails to run along the road and connect the Davison Parkway so that you could leave your home, ride your bike from your neighborhood down the flipping road, down to Walt Stevens, through here. [1:44:50, 1:44:54]: this is built, we can't do any of that. So [1:44:55, 1:45:15]: I'm I'm confused at how we got to this point because when we deferred this, the whole point was to have it be so that we have a through road. I heard I with all due respect, ma'am, it is gonna be expensive. You gotta build a bridge. You don't wanna build a bridge. And the problem is that bridge needs to be built. And the reason [1:45:15, 1:45:35]: that we set this up so a bridge would have to be built at some point to connect this. And the and nobody wants to build that bridge. And the reason that we understood and what we wanted the mixed use is because the businesses and the commercial d development would help pay for the bridge and the development [1:45:34, 1:45:39]: Whereas residential probably would not. And and and for me. [1:45:39, 1:45:59]: Could I support this? I could not because it is it is a it is counterproductive to our transportation plan that we have talked about. It's country it's counterproductive to our trail plan and it is very dense development that offers no opportunity for transportation improvements that would get the residents out. [1:45:59, 1:46:19]: The residents are gonna be in a worse situation than they much worse situation today than they would be uh uh in tomorrow if this is approved versus they're in today without the commercial because the commercial would give you an opportunity, it would be less intense, the cars will be coming and going. These cars are gonna be there every day, every day. [1:46:19, 1:46:24]: Every day coming out onto uh there with no other access. [1:46:24, 1:46:44]: I I don't understand how we got from you were here and we talked about the commercial component. We talked about the through road. You took notes on that. There's no through road and there's no commercial component. But as I said, and I'm gonna finish with this, is that the reason that this commercial component, which is we've talked about [1:46:44, 1:47:04]: This forever has not moved forward because there wasn't enough residential. But that we've already approved the rooftops. We all on this council have seen it work. We go to those ribbon cuttings at Jodico every single week because this is what they want first. But this development right here, I'm I'm just scratching my head that we didn't. [1:47:04, 1:47:22]: And we didn't do any of the things that we deferred for. And I and I don't understand why we did not do the through roll and why do we not why do we not even attempt to do the through road and you said because of the the bridge, the bridge is going to be expensive, but certainly you're not willing to build a bridge? [1:47:23, 1:47:32]: May I respond, Mr. Mayor? Okay. So not to make this a debate, Mr. Alexander, but as stated previously, we did take those six months in order to [1:47:33, 1:47:53]: check feasibility, to check safety, to check engineering. And as previously stated, there is a thirty foot drop there. I understand what you have previously seen, but as discussed that LCI is from twelve years ago. The zoning for this property is over twenty years old. That rezoning with Reeves Creek that you speak of, those rooftops were approved about a year ago. [1:47:52, 1:48:12]: at this time, maybe just a little bit less. But what I can tell you, because we are in constant contact with the seller and he has advised us as to who has been in touch with him, it has not been any commercial as you speak of. As this far as this road being put in, it's not that we don't want to put a bridge in because that has been done on projects where it is feasible. [1:48:12, 1:48:32]: And it is efficient to do so. With a 30-foot drop, it's not. And I'm of it's unfortunate that promises were made to you and things were shown that actually do not make sense for development. So that is, we have some of the top engineers that have taken a look at this. We've looked at the traffic impact study, all of the costs. [1:48:32, 1:48:52]: Cars will not be leaving the community at the same time. As I said, the level of service that they evaluated from that traffic impact service will remain at a B or better for these roads. So, you know, that's where we are with it. The seller has not had anyone else that has reached out to him other than the use that staff has previously. [1:48:52, 1:48:56]: previously mentioned since the Reeves Creek development was approved. [1:48:58, 1:49:18]: Upon that, I'll follow up and then say generally, as we said, once we saw the construction started, uh Council, is that that's when we saw things started to happen. And we have it um coming here. And I I just I don't know, I'm not an engineer, but I went to Savannah and there's a two or three hundred-foot tall bridge. [1:49:18, 1:49:38]: That they use to cross that we cross when we go down there. So I don't know what engineers said we can't compensate for a 30-foot drop. But in the end, this plan right here, I would ask that you go back and look at some of the things that we originally asked for, and then you would come. [1:49:38, 1:49:47]: Back to us with what we will some of the things that we asked for. Because in this present state, it would just be nearly impossible for me to support this. [1:49:48, 1:49:49]: Ms. Gantt, go ahead, please. [1:49:50, 1:49:51]: Thank you. [1:49:52, 1:50:00]: I the the houses up closer to walk away, there's some spots there. Is that parking? Like it's gray with little s dots. [1:50:01, 1:50:12]: Wha what exactly is that? It's closer to that's the creek. That's the buffer for the creek area. That's the required state and federal buffers around the street. But there's like gray area like there's actually subdivided lots. [1:50:13, 1:50:20]: Those are the homes that are existing from phase one. The ones that are right adjacent to Walterway. Okay. Those are the phase one houses. All right. [1:50:20, 1:50:37]: And so they would add in addition to that? Those are existing as of today. Okay. That would not be a part of our proposed development. Well not that, but the yellow ones with the circle right next to it are added to the old existing, correct? Correct. All right. And you mentioned [1:50:38, 1:50:38]: Um [1:50:39, 1:50:50]: town homes and have an additional parking in certain areas. And w we Mayor and Council we had a development, I don't know if you remember Councilman Berry, but [1:50:50, 1:50:53]: We talked a little bit about that where [1:50:53, 1:50:55]: It's inconvenient for [1:50:56, 1:51:01]: uh people to park at the entryway or whatever and have to walk to a town hall. [1:51:01, 1:51:02]: So we [1:51:03, 1:51:07]: had decided that we wanted the driveways to be larger. [1:51:07, 1:51:08]: Longer? [1:51:08, 1:51:11]: Right? So that two cars could go in. [1:51:11, 1:51:13]: And two cars could be on the [1:51:13, 1:51:21]: actual driveway, right? Instead of parking in a parking pad somewhere and walking'cause that's unrealistic. [1:51:21, 1:51:36]: People are not don't want to do that, right? So I I definitely can't I I mean, I know if they were at an amenity, they were at a pool, they came to park at that that location, but to say that, oh, when they have guests, they're gonna park [1:51:37, 1:51:46]: in some parking pad and walk all the way down, I I doubt very seriously that would happen. So that's something that concerns me. It it concerns me that it looks like it tr it looks like [1:51:47, 1:51:50]: They wanna get as many houses as they can in here. [1:51:51, 1:51:58]: I mean that's what it looks like. And that doesn't look like quality in me. It just doesn't. And I'm not I'm not trying to be [1:51:59, 1:52:09]: insulting or I'm uh out of concern. It looks like I just wanna cram as much money as I can get out of this community instead of looking at it [1:52:09, 1:52:14]: where it's spaced out and you have maybe a pool here and a park here. [1:52:15, 1:52:17]: You got all these houses just [1:52:18, 1:52:38]: clustered together. It's not something that I want to live in. So I don't know what my community wants to live. I don't I don't think it's I think they should go back to the drawing board. I really do. And and I'm I'm sympathetic to that. I know that it's zone C three. I'm not threatened by that. And the reason why I'm not threatened by that is because there have been proposals [1:52:38, 1:52:54]: of green developments. There have been proposals of other commercial buildings and uses that might actually take place. We're growing by leaps and bounds. There's no secret that we barely have, we have, we don't have a lot of land to choose from. [1:52:54, 1:52:58]: So it's coming, right? It's here. It's already here. [1:52:58, 1:52:59]: And [1:52:59, 1:53:02]: I'd rather take the risk than to put up something poor. [1:53:04, 1:53:24]: So oh may I respond? Go go ahead please. So the guest parking that I mentioned, Councilwoman, is additional parking. The townhomes are two car garages and there's two spots in the driveway for additional two cars to park as well. So there is parking opportunity at each one of the units. There's just additional parking that we've added so that [1:53:24, 1:53:42]: additional guests would be able to park. And then as far as going back to the drawing board, you know, I'll be fully transparent. We've spoken with the seller and as you know we deferred twice already. This application started last year. So if it's not approved tonight, then we are likely going to have to walk away. [1:53:42, 1:53:43]: Okay. [1:53:43, 1:53:44]: Thank you. [1:53:45, 1:53:47]: Got a question. Oh Mr. Thomas Graser. [1:53:48, 1:53:55]: Yeah. Okay. Um let me just say I I as a representative for District Two. [1:53:55, 1:53:58]: Um, I don't have an issue with [1:53:58, 1:54:18]: Councils weighing in. I I think this is the way it's supposed to be because all of these developments throughout the city, you know, we are responsible for all of that. So I don't have any issues with councils weighing in. I I keep hearing, well, this is uh District 2, District 2. Trust me. [1:54:18, 1:54:38]: Me, I don't have issue with that because we have to look at the city as a whole. And I appreciate uh council weighing in with their concerns because when it all comes in, you know, it still falls on us. Because no, as I mentioned all the time, no one council person makes these. [1:54:38, 1:54:50]: decisions. This is a group decision and I appreciate that. But it is disappointing because as Kelson and Alexander indicated when we talked about the flip and road development. [1:54:51, 1:54:53]: You know, the whole stub issue. [1:54:53, 1:54:56]: Was highlighted and we felt then [1:54:56, 1:55:10]: that going forward in the future that this would be. And I do understand uh the thirty foot drop. I know Councilman wanted you to sort of go back. So now is that is that cost [1:55:10, 1:55:13]: Why that cannot be done is it costs? [1:55:14, 1:55:27]: It is not just cost, it's also safety and the development of that because it's not necessarily just a bridge. That's something that an engineer would have to evaluate what actually makes sense to be put there. Um in [1:55:28, 1:55:48]: Being that that was shown on an LCI 12 years ago, you know, is it something that the city is going to look at putting in at some point, putting that boulevard throughout? Um and it sounds like there's no plan for that. Councilman Alexander Alexander mentioned the Splash 6 uh with widening on flipping road. [1:55:48, 1:55:52]: But there doesn't seem to be a plan by the city to put that road in there. [1:55:52, 1:56:12]: So and the other issue when we get back into the commercial part of it. Um, and this is something that we really wanted to see. But I do understand that it's sort of when we spoke earlier and we we we met with the residents, it was sort of like [1:56:12, 1:56:16]: the chicken and the egg, which come first. [1:56:16, 1:56:36]: And what we were told, uh, based on, you know, your research and information, that a lot of those potential commercial felt that this development would sort of be off the beaten path and no one would know that this commercial was there and they wanted to wait. [1:56:36, 1:56:37]: And C [1:56:37, 1:56:39]: No. [1:56:40, 1:56:43]: My issue though is my concern is [1:56:44, 1:56:46]: And if the city of Starkbridge [1:56:46, 1:56:49]: Пудил після. [1:56:50, 1:56:56]: then an adjoining county can come in and put the commercial in. [1:56:56, 1:57:04]: And I don't want to get into that because that should not, in a sense, drive us to what we do. So [1:57:05, 1:57:10]: Let me ask you and maybe I do want Mr. Anderson to come back forward too. [1:57:10, 1:57:12]: But one of the concerns [1:57:13, 1:57:16]: And you're probably gonna hear this from some of the residents when they do come up and speak. [1:57:17, 1:57:37]: that the unknown, we're fearful of the unknown. We don't know what commercial is coming. I know we s we talk retail, restaurant, you know the ideal commercial, but we don't know. And I guess we as a council, I guess we can dictate some of that. And I don't I'm I'm just [1:57:37, 1:57:45]: Speaking from just from what I've heard, I don't think uh residents would be too concerned about those types of commercial. [1:57:45, 1:57:49]: But there probably are some undesirable commercial [1:57:49, 1:57:51]: that would come in because again [1:57:51, 1:57:53]: These units [1:57:53, 1:58:08]: are very close to where they live right now. And I know none of us would want a certain type of commercial business that close to us. So that is sort of a concern. So [1:58:09, 1:58:29]: Speak a little bit more. And I know you mentioned in your research that um that whole commercial piece was not viable for this particular era. But is there any other research that we could do to try to look at the commercial? Now, and I still understand. [1:58:29, 1:58:31]: [7111.5, 7116.9]: your statement that you just made that you all probably withdraw because see that's another issue. [1:58:37, 1:58:48]: If this zoning remains C three and I know I heard from one council person they weren't fearful of that, but my concern is the fear for the homeowners. [1:58:48, 1:58:58]: 'Cause I don't know and I wanted Mr. Anderson to speak to, I know there's not an application right now from drive time to to expand. [1:58:59, 1:59:00]: But [1:59:01, 1:59:05]: Let me just let me just be very clear. I is this a ploy? [1:59:05, 1:59:08]: Uh to for for dry time. [1:59:08, 1:59:16]: I would hate to think that drive time would do these residents like this, even though they were there first, and that someone mentioned. [1:59:16, 1:59:20]: Uh the city should never have approved of a residential. [1:59:20, 1:59:24]: Area anyway. But well here we are. [1:59:24, 1:59:25]: So [1:59:27, 1:59:43]: If you can, Mr. Anderson, speak to that possibility of dry time really expanding,'cause I know I I I just feel if I know if I live there, I would want I would not want that expansion. [1:59:44, 2:00:04]: Well, yes, sir. Um the property zone C three and um drive time is a commercial establishment. So if they purchase the land, they could expand without coming in to s to s before council or they will go straight to the development phase. They don't need a zoning action at all. So they have the zoning in place to expand. [2:00:04, 2:00:12]: If they purchase the land. And that's the fear. So have you had any communications? [2:00:12, 2:00:20]: Uh so how was this how how did we hear about this potential expansion? Well I heard [2:00:20, 2:00:22]: Through a developer. [2:00:25, 2:00:45]: Okay. Well Mayor, I know we need to get to the public hearing, but but I think I think the the Homeown Assace Association and I know the interim president is here and some of the others. I I I think they do appreciate this dialogue because it gives them a little bit more information and a little bit more knowled knowledge. So [2:00:45, 2:01:05]: So I don't think this is a waste of time, us going back and forth, Mrs. Hogan, and asking these questions. But I do understand we have deferred this twice to allow the community to get a little bit more understanding, to inject some of their feelings, et cetera. So, but here we are. [2:01:05, 2:01:05]: Today. [2:01:06, 2:01:14]: And and I I do feel, Councilwoman Gann and Alexander, I do feel where you're coming from, and I'm in agreement with that, but [2:01:14, 2:01:28]: uh I'm still going to uh represent the the homeowners and and it's uh it's just it's unfortunate. It's just one of these kind of situations, you know, blank if you do and blank if you don't. So [2:01:29, 2:01:49]: So maybe I'm just gonna yield back and give the citizens a chance to weigh in on it. Before we do that though, Mr. Barrett, did you have any comments at all? No, sir. You good? Okay. All right. And we're good down on this end, I would imagine. All right. So what we're gonna thank you, Miss Uh Tiffany, Ms. Hogan. We're gonna open up uh public hearing. I already read the public hearing guidelines. We went that initially on another [2:01:49, 2:02:04]: uh subject. So public hearing rules over establish that. So anybody's four. For this to happen, for this development, four on my very left side. If you're four, I need you line up in a aisle right over here. Four. [2:02:05, 2:02:09]: Anybody for it, all right, or agree with this development in the middle. [2:02:12, 2:02:13]: And maybe I'm on the right side. [2:02:15, 2:02:25]: Okay, seeing no one. Anybody's against this particular development the way it stands right now, what it's presented, from my very left side. That's against this development. Wanna make comments? [2:02:25, 2:02:26]: Anybody in the middle? [2:02:30, 2:02:33]: Came before right side. Anybody's against? Make any comments. [2:02:37, 2:02:40]: Any comments at all, folks? I'm gonna close or close it out. [2:02:40, 2:02:46]: If you've got comments, I've I'll offer in the comments so you have public comments at all. What are you a for against? Or you you're for? [2:02:47, 2:02:48]: Okay. [2:02:49, 2:02:58]: Please pay attention, folks. Line up I might line up on that side right there. If you got if you you want to make comments for, is that correct? For the development, please line up on this side. [2:02:58, 2:03:06]: Four folks. Four. We'll go back to four. Make sure. All right. Anybody from on the left side, middle or the right, that's for this development. [2:03:08, 2:03:08]: All right. [2:03:10, 2:03:14]: Ma'am, p come to the podium please, and uh state your name and address. [2:03:16, 2:03:24]: My name is Patricia Smith. Make sure the green lights on, please. It's on. Okay, go ahead. Please in the mic. My name is Patricia Smith. I live at North Bridge Crossing. Is that live or [2:03:25, 2:03:27]: Yeah, could you speak louder please so we can hear you? [2:03:27, 2:03:43]: I can't say that again. Could you speak a little louder, please, in the mic? Patricia Smith. There you go. And I live at North Bridge Crossing. Okay and the president of the H the um HOA. Okay. I am for the development. Okay. Only because [2:03:43, 2:03:51]: I don't want commercial in that area because of the trucks that comes through. We already deal with drive time and the way that the [2:03:52, 2:03:55]: Веркис дві девелмент. [2:03:56, 2:03:57]: Speeding. [2:03:57, 2:04:03]: It's crazy. Okay. So um no, I d I do not want drive time to expand. [2:04:04, 2:04:08]: Now if you're talking about commercial property as far I mean commercial home I mean [2:04:08, 2:04:11]: Developments as far as maybe [2:04:12, 2:04:13]: Good restaurants. [2:04:13, 2:04:15]: Or something you could walk to. [2:04:16, 2:04:17]: That's fine. [2:04:17, 2:04:19]: Беню гарантия? [2:04:20, 2:04:27]: That's the question. I don't know what kind of commercial gonna roll up in there and then have the all these big trucks. [2:04:28, 2:04:30]: coming through that they already tore up the road. [2:04:31, 2:04:38]: Um in our development. The bumpers that this that was put in by the city, they're pretty much flat. [2:04:39, 2:04:45]: From those big trucks that come through our development. They're supposed to come down waterway, they're coming through the side streets. [2:04:46, 2:04:49]: So there's no policeman coming through there to [2:04:49, 2:04:54]: to direct any traffic for us. So no, I don't I'm against um commercial. [2:04:56, 2:05:00]: Certain certain type of commercial I would imagine you can see. All right. Good deal. [2:05:00, 2:05:06]: Anything else? That's it? That's it for you. No, just want to make sure folks anybody for the development. [2:05:06, 2:05:08]: Ma'am, you can have your seat please if we don't. [2:05:08, 2:05:18]: Thank you. Anybody that's for? All right. Now we'll try this again. Anybody against the development from my that wanna make a comment, public hearing, my far left side. Anybody against it? [2:05:19, 2:05:21]: In the middle. Anybody against this development? [2:05:22, 2:05:22]: The middle. [2:05:23, 2:05:25]: Right side, anybody against the development? [2:05:26, 2:05:26]: All right. [2:05:27, 2:05:31]: We've done that. I will close this part of the uh public hearing. [2:05:31, 2:05:33]: Mr. Anderson, come back to the podium, please. [2:05:36, 2:05:50]: Council. I was I was I was gonna open up the council. What what kind of questions do you have? Mr. Alexander, you spoke, so I guess you go first now. See, I wanna I wanna speak to the residents concerned. It's terrible when you got a resident has to decide between [2:05:50, 2:06:10]: I'm gonna take drive time or I'm gonna take these trucks running through the middle of my neighborhood. That is a terrible dichotomy of the worst choices possible. I'm telling you, Miss Tiffany, come back to us with a better plan with some residential in it. I'm talking the whole the the the Tiffany, want to come to Tiffany. [2:06:10, 2:06:12]: Please come back to Mike. [2:06:12, 2:06:13]: B. [2:06:13, 2:06:33]: Commercial I'm talking about certainly I wouldn't I wouldn't vote for anything that would bring any more trucks in there. I certainly would not support anything that would involve any intense development. We're talking about this is reserve frontage, which is similar to what you would see up at the area where you would go through the perimeter or or the or you would go through [2:06:33, 2:06:40]: The Cumberland area that has expressway frontage. You have ex maximum exposure. [2:06:40, 2:06:58]: For not some cheap motel like they have on the other side, but a very nice hotel that would have like a steakhouse or something in it, or some commercial component or some retail stores in it. Certainly not any intense development. And I don't want you to have to make the choice between [2:06:58, 2:07:18]: If drive fearful because draw time will go in there or some commercial component. I can assure you that I would never vote for any type of truck or facility. Matter of fact, we turned one down about a year ago that wanted to locate over there a warehouse. We voted against it. And your choices aren't limited to drive time or [2:07:18, 2:07:20]: Some um [2:07:20, 2:07:40]: Or this development here. The developer can take some time, go back, bring us a better plan than this, because we will approve some residential, but this plan is just not it. So if you could take a certain amount of time, go back, come back to us within maybe thirty days or or less. [2:07:40, 2:08:00]: We'll bring you back up so we can talk about that through road. So we can talk about some commercial component that would be limited to where you would be agreeable. You would agree that it wouldn't be no trucks in that commercial development. You would agree that it would be restaurants. We could actually agree on what. [2:08:00, 2:08:20]: The commercial is going to be and put that in the zoning for approval and that it would exclude trucks and that type of thing. And I understand you've been going through this process. I won't we wanna be fair with you and approve some residential. This is too much. If you had some commercial to go with it to offset it. [2:08:20, 2:08:29]: And you had that through roll, I could see myself approving it if you would take a little more time to define this program of maybe about thirty days. [2:08:30, 2:08:35]: Alright, any other comments? Anyone else? Um [2:08:37, 2:08:48]: I'm having some some sidebar conversation here as y'all you really notice. Um and and and this is just one of those developments. I think this is unique. Um [2:08:49, 2:08:50]: And I'm um [2:08:51, 2:08:53]: I sort of lean toward [2:08:54, 2:09:00]: the right kind of commercial which we have no guarantee. So Mr. Anderson um [2:09:01, 2:09:04]: What control does the city have? [2:09:05, 2:09:08]: If we are, Mrs. Hogan, allowed to [2:09:08, 2:09:11]: get some interest from some commercial. [2:09:12, 2:09:12]: Um [2:09:13, 2:09:17]: Фот контроль до вича диктат. [2:09:17, 2:09:22]: The kind of commercial that can come in, you know, the retail, the restaurants. [2:09:23, 2:09:26]: You know, o of that nature. What what control do we have? [2:09:28, 2:09:31]: Usually by placing zoning conditions on a property? [2:09:31, 2:09:33]: Okay. [2:09:33, 2:09:36]: An and another thing is [2:09:39, 2:09:49]: With the threat of of dry time really coming and then misses Hogan, are you willing are you willing? If hard are you willing? [2:09:50, 2:09:51]: To [2:09:52, 2:09:55]: Put a little bit more time into this and see [2:09:56, 2:10:04]: I understand about the, you know, the whole s stub and and the and the and the drive-thru, but more of the the the right kind of commercial. [2:10:05, 2:10:06]: Are you willing to [2:10:07, 2:10:12]: to t'cause this will be a great development, I think, for for Horton and for the city of Stockbridge. [2:10:13, 2:10:33]: But uh uh are you willing to work a little harder to try to get some commitment, you know, from that because I I'm going to personally I'm going to lean toward uh the community that I I represent and we heard from the uh president of the association. [2:10:33, 2:10:53]: I've had the opportunity to meet with a number of them, even though it's just a few here tonight. So this is the way I'm going to lean toward. But ideally, I think all of us would be happy, and as the president mentioned, yeah, the restaurants, you know, the retail. Ideally, this is what we want to see in this area. [2:10:53, 2:11:06]: They can actually live with that. They can walk to the restaurants and the retail, but just dealing with that unknown, and that's the reason I asked uh Mr. Anderson, what control do we have? [2:11:06, 2:11:13]: to try to dictate or to mold that kind of retail and I'm pretty pretty comfortable in that, but [2:11:14, 2:11:16]: is hard and willing to [2:11:17, 2:11:18]: Stay in the game, said [2:11:19, 2:11:32]: and work with the city, work with the residents to try to fix it. I don't I I just don't want you to say, well, if it's not approved tonight, then we're gonna take all, you know, bats and balls and go home. [2:11:32, 2:11:34]: And so so [2:11:35, 2:11:40]: So sorta s share some of that with us if you if you could I know this is the public hearing phase of it, but [2:11:48, 2:11:56]: And and while they're talking, Mirror, I I s I still wanna sort of get a sense from uh from the president to [2:11:56, 2:12:16]: uh their willingness. Now I don't I'm not gonna uh roll the dice for them. Um I'm like I say I'm leaning toward cause I've met with them. They have indicated to me they have asked me to uh in a sense vote in that direction which I will but I don't have just one vote. [2:12:16, 2:12:20]: But I'm just trying to see how we can fix this. [2:12:20, 2:12:22]: And I don't want us to uh [2:12:23, 2:12:43]: take a chance on this other entity coming in and just you know and just knocking all of us out with the application. And like you said, they really don't even have they don't have to even come to us. We could just wake up the next day and and here we are. And so [2:12:43, 2:12:45]: I know we don't want that, so [2:12:45, 2:12:58]: Mr. Thomas I've already opened and closed at uh the public hearing and people th she was the only one that spoke and I mean pl I went through this uh two entire times. So I mean so i i I think it's clear there in this aspect. But uh [2:12:59, 2:13:02]: So yeah, so I appreciate that, Mayor. So let's just see [2:13:05, 2:13:07]: What we can do to [2:13:08, 2:13:28]: have everybody happy tonight knowing that we do have a a a great plan in place that's gonna satisfy the city, it's gonna satisfy the residents, and it's gonna give us a bright future for this area as far as the kind of um [2:13:28, 2:13:38]: commercial that's gonna come in and even the kind of uh residential. And I do appreciate uh Mrs. Gann, I do appreciate your comments [2:13:38, 2:13:39]: With the [2:13:40, 2:13:47]: interior of this of the development, I think that was great, great dialogue and and that's always a concern [2:13:48, 2:13:50]: You know, the quality of life. [2:13:50, 2:13:58]: How do you live within these subdivisions? And I think we had to take all of that in consideration as well, the quality of life. [2:14:00, 2:14:01]: Let's see what isn't it? [2:14:02, 2:14:04]: I thought it fifty. [2:14:11, 2:14:16]: Mayor. Yes, ma'am. Are the setbacks fifty feet? What are the setbacks? [2:14:18, 2:14:21]: For the town homes or the single family? [2:14:36, 2:14:38]: Ryan, do you know off the top of your head? [2:14:45, 2:14:47]: for the corner because it's a public. [2:14:48, 2:14:50]: We didn't. [2:14:53, 2:14:56]: Which one's that? [2:15:00, 2:15:20]: Because it's a put-up location. But as Ryan spoke to earlier, if there are some conditions that uh council wants to put on the property, then we can definitely entertain those. Um some of this feedback is first-time feedback tonight, unfortunately, because I don't have [2:15:20, 2:15:29]: have time to get our engineers online and check the feasibility of it, but obviously if it's approved with a condition of that sort, is that something that we would have to [2:15:32, 2:15:52]: Okay, so did you get your answer in reference to the setback? Well, I did. Sorry, I just realized the mic was off. That was townhomes, that was all of them twenty feet? Because it's a PUD application, it's based on the concept plan, so it's throughout. But I wanna say that in the past with our other applications, we required a additional amount of setback, like thirty five feet was it? Yeah, that was in if it's in the [2:15:54, 2:16:02]: If it's in the MFR district, it requires fifty feet frontage. Uh-huh. And we've been issuing variances to thirty feet. [2:16:03, 2:16:06]: Yeah, we've been reducing it to thirty feet. [2:16:10, 2:16:10]: Standard. [2:16:10, 2:16:11]: And this is twin. [2:16:13, 2:16:15]: Mm. Then this is twenty though. [2:16:15, 2:16:25]: Yes, she's basing it off her concept plan. When you do a a PUD doesn't have set PUD Plan Unit Development Zoning doesn't have setback requirements. It's based off a concept a concept plan. [2:16:25, 2:16:30]: Okay, but we can request those, right? Yes, you as a condition of zoning, yes. [2:16:30, 2:16:31]: Okay. [2:16:32, 2:16:44]: Mayor Ford. Yes, sir. Uh Mrs. Hogan, I I I I I may have missed it. I was uh asked the question, is Hogan still willing to [2:16:46, 2:16:47]: Stay in the game. [2:16:47, 2:17:02]: Ah, I'm I do apologize, Councilman, I did hear you ask that. Uh that question is a bit out of my hands. We are under contract with the seller of this property and so the seller would have to determine if he wants to stay under contract to get allowed additional time. [2:17:06, 2:17:09]: All right. So So uh Mayor, um [2:17:11, 2:17:22]: I was wondering, are you willing to make since you are the district representative, are you willing to make a motion with uh any type of conditions uh for the council's consideration to approve or deny? [2:17:25, 2:17:26]: Yes, sir. [2:17:27, 2:17:35]: And request to reduce the number of mutants to a hundred and fifty single family and a hundred and twenty five. [2:17:36, 2:17:38]: Okay. [2:17:40, 2:17:42]: Yeah, repeat. [2:17:43, 2:17:55]: The applicant proposed the condition for approval of a hundred and twenty-five townhomes and a hundred and fifty single family units for a total of two hundred and seventy-five units down from two hundred and ninety-six units. [2:17:57, 2:17:57]: Okay. [2:18:00, 2:18:02]: Well go ahe what's the question, sir? Two one seventy five. [2:18:03, 2:18:07]: Two seventy five. One twenty five town homes and one fifty single. [2:18:08, 2:18:17]: But the bu the buffer is five feet on the sides. So are the houses gonna be reach out and touch I'm five feet and I'm the shortest little thing there is. [2:18:18, 2:18:19]: So I I need to know. [2:18:20, 2:18:23]: You know, that might a little bit of town home. [2:18:23, 2:18:25]: So I mean I'm not trying to be funny. [2:18:25, 2:18:31]: Councilwoman Gat, it's ten feet total between the homes because it's a five foot setback for each. Yeah, that's two of me. [2:18:33, 2:18:34]: That's two of me. [2:18:35, 2:18:36]: And I'm not too big. [2:18:38, 2:18:39]: That's my concern. [2:18:41, 2:19:01]: All right, so right now 125 and 150 is what you're willing to to to do. Yes, sir. All right. Yeah, yeah. Well st stand by a second, please, before I did you Mr. I am prepared to make a motion. I wanted to to see where the conversation was going and uh Mrs. Hogan did say they are willing to to stay in the game. [2:19:01, 2:19:09]: I and I think this is good with the reduction. Uh and that may help Mrs. Gantt. Did that [2:19:10, 2:19:12]: Councilwoman Gantt, did that sort of [2:19:12, 2:19:15]: Help your concern any for the [2:19:15, 2:19:17]: Well, yeah. [2:19:17, 2:19:28]: I don't know if it did any good. I um I mean it's five feet side buffers, two on each side, so that's ten feet. Mm-hmm. That's two of me from one house to the next. [2:19:29, 2:19:30]: Right. That's it. [2:19:31, 2:19:32]: Just so you know. [2:19:32, 2:19:52]: Right, right. Well, I I I will say that um that the Homeowners Association uh wants to approve. I do represent them. Uh it is unfortunate that we could not get the uh commercial component in, but I think again the [2:19:52, 2:20:12]: The fear of the beast coming in and really just taking this over anyway. I think that is really the biggest concern right now that if we do deny that we leave that door open. [2:20:12, 2:20:20]: open. I don't from what I'm getting from the Homeowners Association, uh, they don't want to roll the dice that way. [2:20:21, 2:20:25]: They don't want to take that chance. So with that being said, [2:20:25, 2:20:27]: Um I will motion [2:20:28, 2:20:48]: to approve the rezoning case RZ 2023-05 consideration to request a rezoning for the three parcels on Davidson Parkway and Walter Way from C three heavy commercial. [2:20:48, 2:20:55]: To PUD plan unit development to allow a mixed residential development. [2:20:57, 2:21:07]: I do do we need to put in any conditions such as the the the change in the number of home yes, with the conditions to reduce [2:21:07, 2:21:08]: Um [2:21:09, 2:21:22]: the townhomes to one twenty five and the single detached to one fifty. Uh did I miss any other conditions other than that? Was it any set and and the setback [2:21:23, 2:21:29]: Setback. Thirty feet is my recommendation. Is that on the town homes only, Councilwoman Gat? [2:21:30, 2:21:42]: I n I whatever we've done with the other communities, it's all i they've been thirty feet or thirty five? Thirty feet on townhomes. Huh? Thirty feet on townhomes. Thirty feet for townhomes and what about the single family? [2:21:42, 2:21:49]: Uh they usually are fifty feet front yard seven. And fifty feet residential. [2:21:51, 2:21:52]: You see more comment. [2:21:53, 2:21:59]: Okay. Okay. Oh Mrs. Hogan is that acceptable by the the by the builder? [2:22:02, 2:22:03]: That's that's our proof. [2:22:03, 2:22:04]: Mm. [2:22:11, 2:22:12]: Right quick. [2:22:16, 2:22:21]: Staff recommended the denial but we but uh if you approved it we have several conditions that need to be read into the record. [2:22:22, 2:22:26]: Right. That's what that's why we're trying to make sure we we do that. [2:22:26, 2:22:33]: So let's can you for the record can you indicate those conditions uh from staff? [2:22:35, 2:22:38]: One question. Oh a question too. [2:22:38, 2:22:42]: Stand by, stand by speaker. All right, we'll go get to your question in a second. [2:22:56, 2:22:57]: Mm-hmm. [2:22:58, 2:22:59]: [8583.1, 8587.1]: People are interested in that cultures and [2:23:08, 2:23:21]: If if if if drive for would they have to do a special use permit? For drive time? They they don't they don't because [2:23:22, 2:23:42]: Yeah, but see, but they they they want me to you know, my homeowner so shit, they want me to go ahead and get through. You think I need to ask for a recess? Yes. Okay. Yeah. Um if you keep it. [2:23:42, 2:23:45]: Let me see if I can get a recess. [2:23:45, 2:24:05]: Mayor Ford, I know I'm in the middle of my motion. Yes, sir. Um I I think we all need to get a better understanding of the conditions. I did read into the motion uh the rezoning case, but when it comes to the [2:24:05, 2:24:20]: uh conditions such as the reductions, the setbacks, and even the uh staff recommendation, um I like to ask counsel for a five-minute recess. [2:24:21, 2:24:33]: All right. Council, we want a five minute recess? So moved. Is there s uh all f okay uh all in favor indicate? Five minute recess? Okay it's approved. All right, we'll take a five minute recess. [2:24:35, 2:24:36]: Mm. [2:24:40, 2:24:43]: Council, I need you back on the dies, please. [2:25:10, 2:25:13]: Council, I need you back on the dias, please, so we can get going. [2:25:20, 2:25:40]: Yes sir. I got a communication from the city management with the meaning uh uh COVID uh communication. So we wanted to move this uh makes that something more do we need to watch it? Yeah, we're gonna have to use. [2:25:40, 2:25:42]: Yes. Okay. All right. [2:25:42, 2:25:58]: All right, ladies and gentlemen, I need uh council back to the back to dial. So we made a motion to go in a five minute recess. It's a little more than five minutes. So I need a motion to reconvene our meeting, please. So move. Second. Okay, from Miss Barber to Mr. Alexander. All in favor, please indicate. [2:25:58, 2:26:12]: All right, so we're back we're back on a session. Now yes sir. Uh a move to move this agenda item down the agenda. [2:26:12, 2:26:14]: There's still some [2:26:14, 2:26:27]: conversation but I move to move this agenda item down on the agenda. Well down agenda so the uh the last agenda item is number eleven so this will go down past the eleven. Once we get to eleven then we'll bring this back up. [2:26:28, 2:26:29]: Okay. [2:26:29, 2:26:32]: Second. Okay. Miss Holliday. [2:26:34, 2:26:37]: Well the motion is to move this agenda item down. [2:26:37, 2:26:57]: First let me go back since we're reconvening. I will remove my original motion, which was incomplete, but I removed that motion. Now I'm motioning to move this agenda item down to agenda item It'll be after eleven. Eleven. Okay. [2:26:57, 2:27:10]: There's a second emotion. Mr. Allison has a second. All favor, please indicate. Okay, on that note, then we'll continue on. We'll go back to uh uh item five and we'll reopen that uh uh public hearing on that as well. [2:27:10, 2:27:30]: Okay, now let's see here. Item number six, we uh we took that off the agenda. We we're gonna reconvene on that at a later date. So item number six that dealt with the lottery process determined the rewarding of two additional alcohol licenses and possibly to two additional licenses for certain other types of businesses in the city of Stockbridge. It uh it's been deferred to a later date. So we've [2:27:30, 2:27:50]: here for that particular one specifically. Unfortunately we won't be here tonight. We'll have to re-announce at another public uh public meeting. Okay, so we'll move on to item number seven. Council consideration to approve the renewal of landscape maintenance services contract with Yellowstone landscape in the amount of$350,000. Funding source is from the government building amphitheater budgeting. [2:27:50, 2:27:55]: funds presented by Mr. Aaron, please. Mr. Aaron. Mr. Aaron. [2:27:57, 2:28:03]: Right, item number seven, sir. Okay, I'm sorry. There we go. Got Al doing this tonight. All right, sir. [2:28:04, 2:28:14]: Yes, I'll answer for uh for the Yellowstone uh landscaping company. We're just asking for approval of uh contract renewal for Yellowstone. [2:28:14, 2:28:15]: Landscaping company. [2:28:18, 2:28:22]: Yes, any questions that anybody have for council have for yeah, go ahead, Ms. Barber. [2:28:24, 2:28:27]: Um so our current contract that's active. [2:28:28, 2:28:32]: The amount that we're paying is it three hundred thousand dollars that we're currently paying? [2:28:37, 2:28:43]: Um, I'm not sure if if this is an increase or not, but from my understanding that it this was already budgeted. [2:28:44, 2:28:51]: Ms. Aaron's coming, sir. Okay. Um, I just need to know what we're currently paying and if this is an increase. [2:28:54, 2:29:14]: What we're currently paying is around three hundred and twenty-four thousand. So we added some additional funding in case council wanted to do some things during the year, like add additional pine straw. They're not going up on the contract, but we just added some additional funding in case there are some items that are not covered in the scope of service. [2:29:14, 2:29:16]: [8957.0, 8958.1]: Then perform. [2:29:18, 2:29:21]: Okay, so this is a contract renewal. Yes. [2:29:23, 2:29:25]: So we should be approving the amount. [2:29:26, 2:29:27]: Of the contract. [2:29:27, 2:29:28]: Renewal. [2:29:29, 2:29:33]: Not the extra, I'm sure it it's already in your budget, you already said. [2:29:34, 2:29:36]: Three hundred and fifty you budget for this. [2:29:36, 2:29:40]: So we should be approving the contract amount. [2:29:40, 2:29:41]: Not what you [2:29:41, 2:29:44]: Estimate might be overage. [2:29:45, 2:29:49]: That's why I always ask for the supporting documents. [2:29:50, 2:29:51]: I need no [2:29:52, 2:29:54]: This three hundred and fifty thousand. [2:29:54, 2:29:57]: That is not the amount of the contract. [2:29:58, 2:30:13]: So the supporting documents are included and like I say the reason why we ask cause there's always a request to do some things in addition to and there's no money for that. [2:30:13, 2:30:33]: So we're getting questioned about, well, why they don't do that. Well, there's not funding available to do those things you want to do because there's been some talking concern like mulch. You only get one application a year. We try to do that right before the concert season. But before the end of the year, the mulch needs to be replaced or replenished. [2:30:33, 2:30:41]: But if we just go with the budgeted amount, there's no money to refresh or replenish those kind of things. [2:30:42, 2:30:46]: A contract is set. There are set terms. [2:30:46, 2:30:49]: There are set scope of work. [2:30:49, 2:30:52]: That is the amount that we should be approving. [2:30:53, 2:30:55]: Well not what you budgeted. [2:30:55, 2:31:15]: I don't that is what's confusing. I don't have an issue with that, but like I say, I know we're constantly asked why we don't do this, why we don't do that. So we're trying to ensure that if there's some things that you want to see done, that there's money available to do that. And that's the only if you want to do it. [2:31:15, 2:31:27]: for the budget amount, we're fine with that as well. But then just know that if something comes up during the year that you want it done, it will not be done because you would not have money available to. [2:31:27, 2:31:29]: So in that instance [2:31:29, 2:31:31]: You would bring back to the council. [2:31:32, 2:31:33]: An amendment. [2:31:34, 2:31:36]: to the budget or to the contract. [2:31:37, 2:31:38]: And we would approve. [2:31:38, 2:31:42]: Whatever the added services are that we're requesting. [2:31:42, 2:31:46]: But this says for us to approve the renewal. [2:31:46, 2:31:47]: Of the contract. [2:31:48, 2:31:50]: So I need to know what the actual [2:31:50, 2:31:53]: contract amount is [2:31:53, 2:31:53]: Well. [2:31:56, 2:31:57]: That's just me. [2:31:58, 2:32:18]: Any other any other comments from the council? Yes, go ahead, sir. Let me just say this. Certainly those those emeritus points that need to be ironed out. So sounds like to me what you just really need to do is say, okay, we'll replace the mulch twice or three times. I thought we were on a quarterly basis. I thought at some point we had agreed that we were gonna do the [2:32:18, 2:32:38]: pine straw quarterly because that's what it called for in the past and uh because certainly once a year certainly is not enough in order to make that happen. So how what's the frequency that you will be able to do it by going up to the 350? I think that'll kinda uh tell tell us what the extra money is going to be for. [2:32:38, 2:32:43]: Yeah, we're gonna increase the frequency of the mulch replacement or the services. [2:32:43, 2:32:52]: Well some well, some of that we came predetermined because as you know that we finished some of the area as far as the amphitheater, the back parking lot area. [2:32:53, 2:33:13]: So there's a lot of stuff that's been added to that that we have to compensate for and we can keep it all uniform together. That whole North Lee street and everything like that. So um across from PD, South Lee, all of that was redone. That had it get moach and had it look uniform as well as with the amphitheater. [2:33:13, 2:33:25]: City Hall, and PD. So there's a lot of that stuff where we can account for, but we have data provements on East Atlanta. A lot of that was added on as well. [2:33:25, 2:33:45]: So so basically what you're saying is there are additional service'cause right now North Leastry ain't is not being the grass is not being cut to my I is before the concert this weekend is very long. Yeah. So maybe it was it's been a couple several weeks. So certainly that'll be in that we will be it we that will be added to this. Well [2:33:45, 2:34:05]: No, I wasn't addressing uh grass cutting as far as North Lee, but there is mulch. There is mulch. Right, but I'm saying that this is the Yellowstone contract here is for the grass cutting and everything, right? Right, for the landscape. Right. So in essence, you're adding the service. I'm hoping that's what you're telling me that you're gonna add service on North Lee Street, so it's maintained. Correct. [2:34:05, 2:34:25]: Like the rest of this is. That's what you're doing. Yes. Right. So that's what I'm saying. Her question was valid. You are adding additional services to what we're doing, which is something that we need to do because the grass is not being maintained on North Lee Street. So this would allow us to do that. It will also allow us to be able to uh replenish the [2:34:25, 2:34:39]: mulch uh at a more frequent basis uh as well. And this is kind of like doing a up to. You not you may not use the 350,000, but you will have authority to use the 350,000. So we do that regul we do that sometimes. [2:34:40, 2:34:48]: Regularly, what we say, you you basically you're asking for authority to spend up to three hundred and fifty thousand dollars. You may not do that. [2:34:49, 2:35:01]: Yes, like one of the things that came up is about the sound and noise. So there was a request made to plant some additional trees. There is no money budgeted. [2:35:01, 2:35:02]: To to do that. [2:35:03, 2:35:11]: Because we're actually at the contract limit. So in order to do things like that for the noise mitigation, to plan additional planning. [2:35:12, 2:35:32]: There's gotta be money from somewhere and you talk about a budget amendment, you still gonna have to amend the the budget where you take the m where do you take the money from? If the budget is X amount and then we need the additional money and it's not in the budget, where does that money come to do those additional things? So which basically you explained that you're gonna plant more trees, you're gonna [2:35:31, 2:35:51]: to do more mulch, you're going to increase the scope of services. Basically you asked her the question which is her originally you said you were not, but you are, you in any case it uh it seemed like you indicated and I won't speak for you that there were not going to be an additional services, but there are. So I do understand you need the additional money to do work on the sound [2:35:51, 2:35:56]: mitigation and that other stuff with the tree. So I understand where you're going. Yeah. [2:35:57, 2:35:59]: Any other questions for the council? [2:35:59, 2:36:00]: I do. [2:36:00, 2:36:01]: Go ahead, please. [2:36:01, 2:36:08]: The item as it is on the agenda says council consideration to approve contract renewal invitation. [2:36:09, 2:36:11]: Contract renewal. [2:36:12, 2:36:17]: There are specific terms, scope of work that this contract covers. [2:36:18, 2:36:23]: Anything outside of that will need to be brought back to the council if it exceeds [2:36:24, 2:36:25]: Fifty thousand dollars. [2:36:25, 2:36:30]: So planting some trees, that won't have to come back to the council. [2:36:30, 2:36:32]: You have the city manager who has the authority. [2:36:33, 2:36:34]: to spend up to fifty thousand. [2:36:35, 2:36:36]: What I don't want to do. [2:36:37, 2:36:38]: Is approved [2:36:38, 2:36:40]: Three hundred and fifty thousand. [2:36:41, 2:36:43]: Based on what your br budget is. [2:36:43, 2:36:44]: I wanna know. [2:36:45, 2:36:46]: Exactly. [2:36:46, 2:36:47]: What is the amount? [2:36:47, 2:36:49]: Of the contract. [2:36:50, 2:36:53]: Our current contract is at three hundred and twenty seven thousand. [2:36:54, 2:36:59]: I am willing to approve the renewal of three hundred and twenty seven thousand. [2:37:00, 2:37:04]: In your budget, you may have three hundred and fifty thousand budgeted. [2:37:04, 2:37:05]: Four [2:37:05, 2:37:06]: landscaping. [2:37:07, 2:37:12]: But I don't wanna approve three hundred and fifty thousand'cause that's what you're asking me for. It's already in the budget. [2:37:13, 2:37:14]: It's the contract. [2:37:15, 2:37:17]: Та ви а тобі консирань. [2:37:18, 2:37:19]: The contract amount. [2:37:19, 2:37:21]: That's what I wanna know. That's all. [2:37:23, 2:37:34]: So we're asking for a twenty-three thousand dollar increase to that contract amount to cover the additional things you had done when the road was widened. [2:37:35, 2:37:48]: and reconfigured. We added additional areas that like Mr. Barnes said, that are moats, that's gotta be taken care of. They gotta be replenished and refreshed as well. And and those areas gotta be maintained. So [2:37:49, 2:37:58]: Well then I would think that the scope of work for the contract will have to be revised to include all of those areas. [2:37:58, 2:38:02]: What you're asking us to do is to renew the existing contract. [2:38:03, 2:38:05]: If you're changing it and you're adding something else. [2:38:06, 2:38:08]: It's not the new it's not the same contract. [2:38:09, 2:38:10]: It's different. [2:38:11, 2:38:13]: That's all. I see now um probably [2:38:14, 2:38:16]: going to be opposing this. [2:38:17, 2:38:19]: Only because I don't have support and documents. [2:38:19, 2:38:35]: to support this 350,000 that you're requesting. That's all. Thank you. But also what was done though, prior to those areas on East Atlanta being redone and Lee Street, those areas did not have mulch. They just had grass. [2:38:35, 2:38:54]: If you recall on East Atlanta Road over there, that was grass. Over there where they reconfigured the road by the school, that was just grass. It's got mulch in it. On East Oh I'm gonna say Lee Street, South and North Lee Street. Now you got mulch instead of just grass. There's a difference between cutting grass and putting mulch down. There's an an additional cost. [2:38:54, 2:38:56]: And I understand that, Mr. Erin. I guess what I [2:38:57, 2:39:01]: What I was expecting was that you would either bring a quote [2:39:01, 2:39:05]: For whatever the extra services are. [2:39:05, 2:39:10]: That's beyond what we're already what we're currently contracted for. [2:39:10, 2:39:13]: If I knew how much the extra services were. [2:39:14, 2:39:19]: then I could support approving this, but I don't know how much the extra services are. [2:39:19, 2:39:21]: All I know is on the agenda. [2:39:22, 2:39:24]: It says for this particular item. [2:39:24, 2:39:30]: Council consideration to approve the renewal of the lands landscape maintenance services contract. [2:39:31, 2:39:32]: To renew. Yeah. [2:39:32, 2:39:34]: The existing contract. [2:39:36, 2:39:45]: What are there questions coming? I'm not confused. I'm real clear. Okay, thank you. Then can we just get approval for the regular the original contracted amount? [2:39:47, 2:39:49]: And what is that original contract amount? [2:39:50, 2:39:51]: Because that's not in here. [2:39:52, 2:39:56]: That's what I asked. The original contract amount. [2:39:56, 2:40:00]: Із три хандатосев тазен тухаренсік стін дала. [2:40:02, 2:40:05]: And where's what the contract amount is for. [2:40:05, 2:40:07]: It's on page one. [2:40:07, 2:40:09]: Yeah, for the member. [2:40:09, 2:40:18]: On the back the agenda item form that you completed? Yes. Yes, ma'am. Okay. Where is that in the supporting the actual contract? [2:40:18, 2:40:21]: The second paragraph specifies what the contract amount. [2:40:22, 2:40:24]: Of a contract. [2:40:25, 2:40:28]: It said three hundred and twenty seven thousand two hundred and sixteen no. [2:40:31, 2:40:37]: Is it this page that's hard to read? This one? No, it's this page. [2:40:38, 2:40:41]: It's your agenda item form. [2:40:42, 2:40:45]: That's the form that's completed by staff? Yes. [2:40:45, 2:40:46]: I want to see [2:40:47, 2:40:50]: the information in the contract. [2:40:50, 2:40:52]: Because I know stab can kinda [2:40:52, 2:40:55]: Transpose mistakenly numbers. [2:40:56, 2:40:57]: We're talking about [2:40:58, 2:40:58]: Three hundred. [2:40:59, 2:41:01]: And twenty seven thousand dollars. [2:41:01, 2:41:19]: The the resolution, there was several resolutions cause when it was originally adopted, there wasn't sufficient funding. So we brought it back to you. This says the initial contract was approved by council on September twenty, twenty twenty-one for an estimated annual amount of two hundred and fifty thousand dollars. [2:41:19, 2:41:39]: On December 14, 2021, Resolution R twenty one, thirteen eighty-two, the city council approved an increase in the amount of fifty thousand dollars, bringing the annual total amount to three hundred thousand. On May thirtieth, twenty twenty-three, resolution R twenty three fifteen seven, and council approved the landscape maintenance project with [2:41:39, 2:41:48]: Yellowstone for general maintenance and grass cutting in the amount of three hundred and twenty-seven thousand two hundred and sixteen dollars from the FY twenty twenty-four budget. [2:41:49, 2:41:54]: So that's what the contract amount is, three hundred and twenty seven thousand two hundred and sixteen dollars. [2:41:55, 2:41:55]: Thank you, sir. [2:41:57, 2:42:17]: Any other comments from the council? Listen, I'm about common sense. Is this what you need is this what we need to maintain the marriage? Well, if that's what you're gonna approve, then we'll go with the budget amount of the biggest. [2:42:17, 2:42:37]: Ms. Barber's concern, but she's only one council member. The deal is the rest of us up here have to work together to be able to understand. If you now, if you're telling me you don't need the money, then that's different. But if you're telling me you need the money to plant trees, to minimize this the sound the sound, you need money to take care of the extra areas that need money. [2:42:37, 2:42:55]: You need money to do the areas that we spent three million dollars to improve so they would look beautiful. I want them to look beautiful. I want them to look maintained just like they are today without you coming back to me saying they look like North Lee Street because the grass ain't been cut because it hasn't been approved. [2:42:56, 2:43:16]: So like I said, the reason why we ask for the three hundred and fifty, because there are always things that come up with. It makes sense. Somebody comes in City Hall and says, why is this looking a certain way? It's not looking like that, because there is not money to to do those. Yellowstone is only gonna do what's in the contract and what in there. [2:43:16, 2:43:20]: Scope of service. If it says one application or two applications. [2:43:20, 2:43:21]: That's all we're gonna get. [2:43:21, 2:43:41]: But if we got some additional money, there's some things you wanna see done, council wanna see done, then we have money available to do that. If not, then we coming back before council and funds wasn't weren't budgeted, so where are we gonna get that money from? You know, if you're gonna amend the budget or adjust the budget, that money's gotta come somewhere. So we just try [2:43:41, 2:43:58]: Trying to be proactive instead of being a media. Better yet, how about this? This is I I've asked several times for council comments, only two of you have spoke. That's why make a motion. Go ahead and make a motion. [2:43:58, 2:44:10]: I certainly I make a motion to go with the staff recommendation to be very proactive to be ready for these engagements to keep the area exemplary outside City Hall. Is it sa is there a second? [2:44:11, 2:44:12]: Is there a second? [2:44:14, 2:44:15]: Okay. [2:44:15, 2:44:16]: It's not a second. [2:44:17, 2:44:19]: All right. [2:44:20, 2:44:22]: Now no any other comments from the council? [2:44:22, 2:44:23]: Mayor Ford. [2:44:24, 2:44:25]: Yes, ma'am. [2:44:26, 2:44:27]: I will make a motion. [2:44:28, 2:44:28]: Mm-hmm. [2:44:28, 2:44:31]: That we renew the current contract. [2:44:31, 2:44:33]: And the amount of [2:44:33, 2:44:35]: A motion to approve. [2:44:35, 2:44:45]: To renew the current contract an amount of three hundred and twenty seven thousand. What was it? Two hundred and sixteen dollars. Three twenty seven two sixteen. [2:44:47, 2:44:49]: Three twenty seven two [2:44:50, 2:44:51]: Three twenty seven. [2:44:51, 2:44:53]: Two hundred and sixteen dollars. [2:44:55, 2:45:01]: Okay. And if there are additional expenses that are needed [2:45:02, 2:45:04]: And they exceed fifty thousand. [2:45:04, 2:45:06]: Please do bring it back to the council. [2:45:07, 2:45:13]: We know that anything less than fifty thousand, the city manager can sign off on it without bringing it to us. [2:45:14, 2:45:16]: That's my motion. Is there a second to that motion? [2:45:17, 2:45:20]: Is there a second to the motion? [2:45:20, 2:45:23]: Mr. Berry, second that motion. Any further discussion? [2:45:24, 2:45:30]: I have a discussion with the Go ahead, please. On the second page it says on September eleventh, twenty twenty three, council approved the payment amount of [2:45:31, 2:45:38]: Seventy thousand one hundred and fifty eight dollars and ninety-six cents to Yellowstone landscaping for the Campground Road and Hudson Bridge median enhancement work. [2:45:39, 2:45:40]: Is that in addition to [2:45:41, 2:45:57]: Our budget or is that that was that was a part of the budget? That was something that was outside the contract. That was a beautification project for Campground and Hudson Bridge Road. That's that wasn't included in the budget amount. This was something in addition to [2:45:57, 2:45:59]: So why is it in our notes here? [2:46:00, 2:46:08]: Did you submit that to the procurement prepares this form and we just we present it. [2:46:08, 2:46:16]: Okay. I don't know why they put that in there for because that's not included in the contract. It's not. This was a one time [2:46:16, 2:46:18]: Where's procurement? Are they here? [2:46:19, 2:46:19]: Oh. [2:46:20, 2:46:27]: But I also is one of the reasons why we were trying to be proactive for the calls and stuff that we get as far as that. [2:46:27, 2:46:33]: Okay. That and I get that. And I understand that. And that was for for needed at that time. [2:46:34, 2:46:54]: My question is, so the additional funds that you wanted was to just in case for other upkeeps and things that we would need in the future. There wasn't something in addition where the company said, well, that's gonna cost you more money right now. No, no. That's just like [2:46:54, 2:47:01]: that whole Hudson Bridge and Campground where maybe you all or someone complains and they want beautification that [2:47:02, 2:47:09]: We wouldn't have to go in front of you all for those extra funds. We can just go ahead and get it tackled and then just keep moving on. [2:47:10, 2:47:13]: I get it. Well I think we should wait until the budget to [2:47:14, 2:47:21]: put those that cushion, you know, put that in there if that's what we need, if we're gonna look at that. I appreciate you guys being proactive with it. [2:47:21, 2:47:25]: I mean the contract renews in September. I totally understand that. [2:47:25, 2:47:28]: And then our budget cycle doesn't start until January, right? [2:47:29, 2:47:35]: But we look at some of the things that we need based off of that, I would think. Um [2:47:39, 2:47:42]: I'm okay with re keeping the contract as is for now. [2:47:45, 2:47:47]: uh as far as m amount is concerned. [2:47:48, 2:47:51]: Okay, motion has been made and been seconded. Did Miss Barby have something else? [2:47:51, 2:48:09]: I do, I have a question. So m um Mr. Aaron, I know you pointed out the second page of this agenda item form. Um the amount what was it? Three hundred and twenty-seven thousand two hundred and sixteen dollars. Yes. But looking at the actual agreement. [2:48:09, 2:48:16]: The amount that it has on here is for two hundred and forty-four thousand nine hundred and ninety-two dollars. [2:48:16, 2:48:20]: Annually? No, that was written that was That's what it says. [2:48:20, 2:48:21]: And then it goes on. [2:48:22, 2:48:37]: It explains the equal monthly installments billed in the amount of twenty thousand dollars. So I'm I need to understand, I know that this was signed back in twenty twenty-one and we've had some renewals since then and the cost has increased. [2:48:37, 2:48:57]: No ma'am. Explain to me how we go from 244,000 to 327,000. Because when this contract was initially signed, the amphitheater was not online. Okay. And so it wasn't accounted for in the in the original scope of services for the landscaping. So it includes [2:48:57, 2:49:17]: Increased the ad the landscaping for the amphitheater. That's why it went from the$244,000 up to$300 because you didn't have the amphitheater at that time. Thank you for that. One more question. So I'm looking at the 2024 budget book. Can you tell me? [2:49:17, 2:49:31]: me I just want to know what was budgeted for landscaping. Can you tell me where I would find this? I don't I don't have the budget in front of me right now. I but I just want to see information. Can the um interim treasurer [2:49:32, 2:49:36]: Tell me where I can find what was budgeted for landscaping for this year. [2:49:37, 2:49:38]: Do you have a copy of the budget? [2:49:39, 2:49:45]: I have copy of the budget here, but I'm not able to find where landscaping is. [2:49:53, 2:49:55]: Yeah. Keep keep on it. [2:49:56, 2:49:57]: Because it goes all over here. [2:50:02, 2:50:05]: Cold sign and then six. Mm-hmm. [2:50:45, 2:50:49]: Why they're looking at that, but can I get some clarification real quick? Sure, go ahead. So [2:50:50, 2:50:59]: 'Cause I'm I'm torn in between. I like the fact I don't want staff to think that I don't appreciate you thinking ahead with that cushion amount. I love that idea. [2:50:59, 2:51:03]: I don't like being behind the curve on it. But I also [2:51:04, 2:51:05]: In thinking [2:51:06, 2:51:18]: If we have a contract agreement, which we did have and we we did increase the amount based off of what I'm reading here on page one and the history. I trust staff, by the way. [2:51:18, 2:51:20]: on what was written. [2:51:20, 2:51:25]: And my uh the amount is three hundred and twenty seven thousand two sixteen. [2:51:25, 2:51:27]: Currently for maintenance, right? [2:51:29, 2:51:32]: And so you're talking about a little less than [2:51:33, 2:51:42]: So you're talking about twenty-three thousand dollars more in addition to what we already have. So by the time we do the services here. [2:51:43, 2:52:03]: It would be okay to come back to us and ask for additional I understand you try to prevent that, but if it was something that was needed. Well, yeah, just in a timely matter, you know, we'll we'll get the calls like, hey, you know, can we get these flowers changed? Or, you know, saying, Can we get them to do this? You know what I'm saying? So [2:52:03, 2:52:17]: You know, we're being asked to act fast on, you know, saying the services and the results, you know, saying. So that's the reason for us to wanna, you know, make that increase. That we don't have to come back for, you know, to you all and say, hey [2:52:18, 2:52:25]: Which you were asking for last week, we need, you know, X amount of dollars to get that accomplished. But we're not over budget right now. [2:52:25, 2:52:37]: Right. Excuse me. We're not over budget right now. We're we're halfway through. I'm just asking'cause the winter months have come. I'm just trying to figure it out. Right, right. Okay. No, we're not we're not over budget. [2:52:37, 2:52:38]: All right. So [2:52:40, 2:52:45]: All right, Miss Barber, did you get your answer? I did. Um actually for landscaping. [2:52:45, 2:52:47]: According to [2:52:47, 2:52:49]: The twenty twenty four budget. [2:52:49, 2:52:52]: It's budgeted for three hundred and thirty thousand. [2:52:53, 2:52:54]: Put this here. [2:52:54, 2:52:59]: What you're asking us to approve is three hundred and fifty thousand, so it exceeds what you budgeted. [2:53:00, 2:53:20]: So this is actually for next year for twenty twenty-five because it was requested that contract be presented a hundred and twenty days before expiration for renewal. The current contract expires in September of this year. It would include three months of this year plus [2:53:20, 2:53:20]: Mm-hmm. [2:53:21, 2:53:32]: that you got enough money in this year's budget to cover us what we're doing. But for the 12 months, this you're proving really for like 15 months. [2:53:32, 2:53:35]: The you know, the three months [2:53:35, 2:53:45]: to the end of the year, then twelve months for next year. So we ti we're just actually asking for FY twenty five for it to be three fifty. That's what we was gonna budget. [2:53:46, 2:53:55]: One last question. So that seventy thousand um that was spent for the campground road maintenance or landscaping. [2:53:56, 2:53:58]: Is that a part of No. [2:53:59, 2:54:03]: What you it's not a part of that. [2:54:04, 2:54:06]: Okay. Thank you, sir. [2:54:08, 2:54:09]: Okay, so if another [2:54:10, 2:54:20]: I just want to make uh we we had discussion. Yeah, you had discussion. You have another point, sir? I just want to say listen. [2:54:20, 2:54:40]: We don't wasted another 30 minutes. Listen, I I appreciate you guys. I do. I tr I really do. I this is what I ask of you is to be proactive. Just like yesterday when we had that trash situation over off of uh right across from campground, y'all were able to jump right on that because you had the funding already in your budget. Otherwise, you would have [2:54:40, 2:55:00]: Had to come to us to get somebody to authorize the cleanup and we'd have that trashed area still be over there right now. I understand. We gotta have trust in our staff when they come to us with recommendations that make sense. They're trying to do something and be very proactive for the area. [2:55:00, 2:55:20]: They're trying to improve our operation. But are we going to micromanage them and tell, listen, don't do that. Don't bring us any good ideas. You just do what we've already done. It sounds like a great idea to me. You're going to approve a 15-month budget going through, you're just starting three months early. You're starting three months early, you're adding three. [2:55:20, 2:55:28]: Three months to a year's renewal so that next we'll be prepared for next year right now instead of in two in three months. [2:55:28, 2:55:45]: It makes sense. Now in other we we we could go and keep going on in this same argument, but I want to encourage our staff to keep coming to us with good recommendations that make sense. And I will vote for them every single time. And I understand [2:55:46, 2:56:06]: I don't understand our hesitancy to embrace good change and good ideas. That's what I want to do. Sometimes I uh um it mystifies me that we don't embrace the changes that are being brought to us by professional staff. They are the experts on the work that they do. Who are we to tell them, listen, you don't need that? [2:56:06, 2:56:12]: You you they just tell they just sit there and told us for thirty minutes they do need it and we talked them out of it. [2:56:14, 2:56:25]: All right. If there are no other comments, the motion was on the floor to uh keep with the s uh budget numbers, original budget numbers that are outlined here three thout three hundred twenty seven thousand two hundred sixteen dollars. [2:56:26, 2:56:31]: All right. So matter of fact, uh how'bout this? Miss Holiday? [2:56:32, 2:56:33]: Meshaudi. [2:56:34, 2:56:35]: Read the motion back, please. [2:56:42, 2:56:43]: I'm hearing. [2:56:50, 2:56:55]: twenty seven thousand two hundred and sixteen dollars and if needed [2:56:55, 2:57:00]: Or any purchases over fifty thousand dollars which is over to six million. [2:57:04, 2:57:05]: Is that it to a motion, Ms. Barber? [2:57:07, 2:57:15]: Is that your motion? Okay. And that was seconded by Mr. Uh Berry. Okay. All um all in favor of the motion, please indicate. [2:57:17, 2:57:31]: Okay, you abstain? All in favor of motion, please. I'm abstaining too because uh uh to show support for the staff. Okay. Because they came up with a good idea. Okay. Okay, I'll all okay. Once again, all favor. Okay, I got two favor of the contract. [2:57:31, 2:57:33]: Screw me. Staying as is right now. [2:57:35, 2:57:36]: I'm I'm in favor. [2:57:37, 2:57:48]: You're of of keeping it okay. Keeping it. So so you're in favor of this motion. That's right, ma'am. Ms. Ganttz in favor. Mr. Mr. Barr is in favor. And Miss Barber's in favor. Okay, all polls. [2:57:49, 2:57:52]: And it's uh we got two abstentions. So pass three zero two. [2:57:53, 2:57:53]: Okay. [2:57:54, 2:57:55]: All right. [2:57:55, 2:58:06]: You got it now? I just got one further question. So now that we don't have North Lee Street covered, what what's gonna happen with North Lee Street since it's do we have enough money to cover that? [2:58:07, 2:58:10]: Because it's not currently the you're not do you have enough money to maintain it? [2:58:11, 2:58:12]: We'll we'll take care of it. [2:58:12, 2:58:32]: You got but I'm saying you you gonna have to come back and ask for money for that or answer. I mean it it's it's it's a possible. So like you said, any requests that maybe have from, you know, council or you know, any ideas will we'll be right back up here. So technically what's gonna happen is we're gonna do it. The money's gonna be spent for it. It just yellowstones. [2:58:32, 2:58:41]: Won't spend the money, but we'll just try to find some resources within the budget to ensure that it gets maintained. So the [2:58:44, 2:58:45]: All right gentlemen, appreciate it. [2:58:46, 2:58:48]: Motion passes. [2:58:48, 2:58:49]: Thank you, Mayor Council. Thank you. [2:58:50, 2:59:10]: Thank you. Council consideration approved the contract renewal invitation to bid ITB for number 16RFP 101216-DRR, American Tank Maintenance LLC, food uh full service tank maintenance program and amount of sixty-one thousand four hundred nineteen dollars. Funding [2:59:10, 2:59:30]: source would be the water department uh budgeted funds. Uh Mr. Aaron, please. Yes, Mr. Mayor and Council. On October 1st, 2021, the city of Stockbridge entered into a water tank maintenance contract with the American Tank Services. It was the initial term was one year with nine one-year renewals. So we're coming up [2:59:30, 2:59:37]: Upon renewal number three. So we're asking the city to approve us to renew the contract with American Tank Service. [2:59:38, 2:59:39]: Mayor. Yes, ma'am. [2:59:40, 2:59:48]: I move that we approve the American tank maintenance full service program in the amount of sixty one thousand four nineteen. Okay, is there a second to the motion? [2:59:50, 2:59:53]: Is there a second emotion? Oh mister Mr. Barrett second that? [2:59:54, 2:59:55]: Okay, all in favor, please indicate. [2:59:57, 3:00:01]: Okay, all polls? Opposed. Um exhibit B. [3:00:02, 3:00:04]: According to the [3:00:05, 3:00:14]: The motion the motion passes three three three one. If I may add my comment, mayor. I'm just want to make note the motion does pass. You can go on with your comment. [3:00:15, 3:00:19]: According to exhibit B of the contract. [3:00:19, 3:00:20]: It's missing. [3:00:21, 3:00:22]: And it's the compensation piece. [3:00:23, 3:00:28]: It says contractors shall r shall receive compensation from the city as set forth. [3:00:28, 3:00:31]: In the attached exhibits B. [3:00:32, 3:00:33]: That's not included. [3:00:36, 3:00:37]: Opposed. [3:00:45, 3:00:55]: Well, uh once again, as I said, Public Works is presenting what procurements gave to us to present. So we all we can only present the documents that were given to us. [3:00:56, 3:00:58]: See that so proper. [3:00:59, 3:01:01]: All right. We'll move on. [3:01:02, 3:01:12]: Thank you, Mayor. Council of Consideration, thank you. Council of Consideration filled the vacancy of the youth council advisory committee appointment of a member to serve an unexpired term. Mr Washington, please. [3:01:37, 3:01:40]: Good evening, Mayor and Council. We have three different [3:01:41, 3:02:01]: App we have three different board we have three different boards that have applicants on them. And each one of the members that have each one of the people who have submitted do if you all vote for them to be on would be able to fill it at the seat that's on there. Well you got one person for Henry Count we have one person for the youth advisory council. [3:02:01, 3:02:03]: Miss uh Tariqah Powell. [3:02:03, 3:02:05]: And her applications before you [3:02:06, 3:02:07]: You have [3:02:07, 3:02:13]: Just take one at a time, sir. Each each each each different board at a time. We have several line items sir. [3:02:14, 3:02:20]: All right, so you have Miss Tariqa Powell who submitted her application to be a member of the youth advisory council. [3:02:20, 3:02:22]: And that's for your consideration now. [3:02:23, 3:02:29]: Okay. Council, any questions in reference to this uh individual coming forward? He appointed the youth council? [3:02:32, 3:02:36]: If no questions then uh I need a motion to accept this uh this appointment. [3:02:37, 3:02:38]: Some oh [3:02:38, 3:02:45]: Ms. So moved. Okay, is there a second? Second. M Mr Berry's second that from Ms. Scanton. Ms. Berry, all in favor, please indicate. [3:02:46, 3:02:48]: Okay, so now it's decision. [3:02:48, 3:02:57]: Okay, appreciate that. All right, Council of Consideration to fill vacancies and appoint uh appoint members to the citywide development authority. Once again presented by Mr. Washington. [3:02:58, 3:03:03]: I you have two. You have Mr. Antonio Gordon and then you have [3:03:05, 3:03:06]: Yeah. [3:03:06, 3:03:07]: Yeah, three. [3:03:09, 3:03:12]: I think they're two apples with three. Three. [3:03:15, 3:03:17]: So am I well, I mean [3:03:20, 3:03:23]: Right,'cause in my book I have three vacancies. There are two vacancies. [3:03:24, 3:03:27]: Three years only six people you're going up at nine. [3:03:28, 3:03:33]: That's correct. Remember you all approved. We approved it nine. Right. We approved it in nine. [3:03:34, 3:03:35]: Yeah, okay, I want to hear. [3:03:35, 3:03:39]: All right, so I've got first I have is Antonio Gordon. [3:03:40, 3:03:40]: Yeah. [3:03:41, 3:03:45]: I have a second application that at least it's in my book from Antonio Gordon. [3:03:47, 3:03:47]: Mm-hmm. [3:03:48, 3:03:51]: Then I have Miss Kim Mays. [3:03:55, 3:03:57]: Then I have Miss Monica Jones. [3:04:01, 3:04:05]: Then I have Miss Ivy D. Sears. [3:04:08, 3:04:08]: Okay. [3:04:10, 3:04:13]: And you have you have these applications but only three vacancies. [3:04:14, 3:04:14]: Okay. [3:04:16, 3:04:23]: So so it's three individuals that need to be selected and this is for a duration of the amount of time. [3:04:25, 3:04:27]: What's the amount of time for the duration once approved? [3:04:28, 3:04:32]: Oh the for the C DA membership? Right, right. It's t it's it's two years or three years. [3:04:43, 3:04:43]: Okay. [3:04:54, 3:04:56]: Oh yeah. Up to four years. [3:04:59, 3:05:02]: I think it's two each. So member. [3:05:04, 3:05:13]: I'm not sure. Ms. Holliday, what if a new appointment for the city wide is it is it initial new appointment, is that two years to extent? Initially two years? [3:05:22, 3:05:35]: I th uh Mayor. Yes, ma'am. I thought that we agreed that all new members would have like I know we have staggering terms for everyone, but I thought we were putting everyone on these two year terms. [3:05:36, 3:05:36]: No. [3:05:38, 3:05:39]: We can, correct? [3:05:40, 3:05:41]: We can do that. [3:05:42, 3:05:45]: We can do that. We can put'em on two year terms. [3:05:46, 3:05:48]: Yeah. That's what we need to do. [3:05:52, 3:05:55]: are still in there. [3:05:56, 3:06:00]: So they're able to stack we're able to put these on two years and it still be staggered somewhat. [3:06:01, 3:06:13]: So if I'm to understand we increase it by three so those three individuals can have two year terms and there's somebody that's a fourth person that needs to fill an unexpired term, is that correct? [3:06:13, 3:06:13]: Third person. [3:06:14, 3:06:17]: I see. Okay. Did you understand that? [3:06:17, 3:06:33]: Two two new seats and one filled No no no no no no three new seats. Three new seats, there'll be two year terms for three new seats, and there'll be a fourth person that's gonna fill unaspired term of an individual that's left. It's my understanding. We agreed the three new seats. That's not it? [3:06:33, 3:06:34]: So then what is it? [3:06:37, 3:06:42]: Right. [3:06:43, 3:06:43]: Okay. [3:06:44, 3:06:47]: All right. [3:06:49, 3:06:50]: [11210.8, 11219.5]: So we okay fine. That's what we need to know. All right. So on that s note, then we have to as we approve this, we've got to figure out who gets to one unaspired term and who get the two new seats then. [3:07:00, 3:07:01]: It's not it's gotta be decided. [3:07:02, 3:07:03]: And bowed it on. [3:07:04, 3:07:05]: I'll make a motion. Go right in, please. [3:07:06, 3:07:17]: I would like to move that Monica Jones replaces the um current uh member that left, resigned. [3:07:20, 3:07:21]: And [3:07:22, 3:07:26]: I moved for Kimberly Mays and Ivy Sears. [3:07:28, 3:07:33]: For two year terms. For two year terms. I mean two two years in the term. All right. Is there a second to that motion? [3:07:34, 3:07:36]: Mr. Alzheimer's second, all favor, please indicate. [3:07:38, 3:07:56]: Okay. All polls? Oh, it's a unanimous decision? Oh it's a unanimous decision. Okay. Miss Halder, you have that right? Okay. All right. And then we have one let me make sure this Yeah, we got council consideration to fill vacancy to a downtown development authority board and appoint a member to serve the unexpired term. [3:07:57, 3:08:01]: And we only have one applicant and that is Miss Kenya Cook and her information is attached. [3:08:03, 3:08:12]: Okay, from Mr. Alexander and Mr Um Berry. If you know further conversations on favor, please indicate. [3:08:13, 3:08:23]: Yes, unanimous decision. All right. So congratulations to all these individuals for joining the boards. And I would imagine then, Miss Holiday, you'll work it out uh with them and myself to when I can swear them in. [3:08:24, 3:08:24]: Okay. [3:08:26, 3:08:34]: Okay, so on that note, we are now going back to uh the rezoning case that we talked about earlier. [3:08:35, 3:08:44]: Dealing with district two. We're now part of that part of the agenda. So and this deals with uh this goes back to our public hearing. Mayor forward. Yes, sir. [3:08:45, 3:08:46]: Um [3:08:47, 3:08:58]: Not to prolong this, I'll be willing to make a motion, but before I do, uh I'd like to ask uh Miss Hogan and Mr. Gardner to come forward. Sure. [3:08:59, 3:09:01]: Mr. Hogan, Mr. Gardner, come forward, please. [3:09:12, 3:09:15]: Is there anything that you'd like to share before I make my motion? [3:09:19, 3:09:35]: Good evening, Council. Good evening. Uh at this time, applicant would request a rezoning to a PUD with the site plan specific to be worked out with your staff members for approval, retaining two acres of the site as commercial. [3:09:39, 3:09:57]: With the preference for vertical mixed use commercial, that's what we will try. Um, but at any rate it will be commercial, but the seller will have to retain someone for the commercial. So preference will be for vertical mixed use, but it will be up to the seller for c the commercial that is retained there. [3:09:58, 3:09:59]: True. [3:10:00, 3:10:02]: I'm not just such a good one that he's preferred to do. [3:10:06, 3:10:13]: PUD with site plan to be worked out with staff members at a later date. [3:10:18, 3:10:21]: And to retain two acres as commercial on the site. [3:10:22, 3:10:27]: And also to allow an easement for the city for trail connectivity. [3:10:34, 3:10:54]: And when we work with the site plant, so if you look at your that cul-de-sac and that's that roadway, that is a racetrack. And that needs to go away. Um, because a car in the back of that cul-de-sac with a straightaway is gonna speed. So we're gonna work with them to try to get some other mid block crossings and do some other uh [3:10:54, 3:10:57]: traffic harming devices so that that doesn't become a racetrack. [3:10:58, 3:11:03]: Um I could tell you because I've seen it happen before. If you have anything over a thousand feet in length, [3:11:04, 3:11:06]: You're gonna have somebody speeding on that road. [3:11:07, 3:11:08]: Um [3:11:08, 3:11:28]: And obviously getting speed humps and developments is a problem unless you want to mandate that they put it in there. Um but we could actually work with we could work with them to on the design to make it a little bit more pedestrian friend pedestrian friendly with the design and some a little bit more connectivity. But definitely to have the the trail system as well as the potential [3:11:28, 3:11:31]: for medical mixed use which we'll work with them on. [3:11:31, 3:11:44]: Uh and the number of units I think'cause they specified before. If that's fine with with the district council member we'll work to make sure that that site plan reflects what we say and uh with you. Sir, go ahead. [3:11:45, 3:12:04]: Uh are those conditions? Mr. Garden? Yes. Yes, sir. Because I want I didn't take a note of that for my motion that I'm going to make. Yes, sir. So when I do make the motion, I'm gonna refer back to you to include that. Yes, sir. Okay. Uh Mrs. Hogan, um, do you wanna speak to the setbacks before I make my motion? [3:12:06, 3:12:17]: Yes, sir. As previously discussed, we would agree to 30 foot setbacks on the townhomes as we work through the site plan for increased front yard setbacks. [3:12:18, 3:12:19]: The singer detached. [3:12:21, 3:12:26]: single family detached setbacks to remain at twenty feet for the front yard setbacks. [3:12:26, 3:12:31]: Because I know Councilwoman Gann had some issues that we wanted both to be at thirty. [3:12:32, 3:12:49]: So we did take a look at um because we did not want to misspeak for development that is around the area, but fifty foot front yard setback is for much larger lots typically. And we did take a look for similar lot sizes in Henry County and the front yard setback is twenty-five feet in the county. [3:12:50, 3:12:51]: Mm. [3:12:52, 3:12:59]: Mr R Ryan, Mr. Anderson, can you tell me what our normal single family dwelling setback is right now? [3:12:59, 3:13:13]: Depend it depends on it depends on what the zoning is. Um if it's S R R um it depends on Okay, so single So our s single f uh suburban residential is uh fifty feet. [3:13:14, 3:13:22]: Okay. So Berkeley residential's fifty feet. Yeah, but she's going um put so I don't care. Okay. [3:13:23, 3:13:35]: Go you got it, Mr. Go ahead, sir. So with a smaller lot with a smaller lot, but I've had to set back and reduce your your buildable area. And if they're proposing the build a two thousand [3:13:36, 3:13:43]: plus square foot house, it's gonna be hard to put that two thousand square foot house without a looking like a root foot box. Um [3:13:49, 3:13:55]: Mayor Ford. Yes, sir. Mr. Gardner. Yes, sir. So on the single detach, um [3:13:55, 3:14:00]: What's your opinion to for that to remain at twenty feet to set back on the second detach? [3:14:00, 3:14:15]: Just just as a uh a thing, I think that's been typical what what's being approved on priory zones. I think it's been either twenty five or somewhere around the twenty feet on on townhomes is what we've been doing. I think the Davis Road development is the same. [3:14:15, 3:14:31]: as that the other one that's that was zoned on Valley Hill Road is twenty five feet, correct me, or th sorry or thirty. Um so we've we've kinda been between twenty, twenty five and thirty feet on the on the setbacks for townhomes. [3:14:32, 3:14:33]: Um [3:14:33, 3:14:37]: If you're doing single f like I said, if you're doing single family single family cluster. [3:14:38, 3:14:40]: Um ten feet in between. [3:14:40, 3:14:55]: And I I kinda show showed you guys some examples of what five feet in between looks like. Uh it just depends on, you know, what makes the what makes the lot is the house. I could put a trailer on an acre and it's still a trailer. I could put a nice home on it, I could reduce that lot. [3:14:56, 3:15:06]: And I can put a nice quality house on it and that's what's gonna drive the price. It's not the land. Um so if they're willing to do a product that they say they're gonna do. [3:15:07, 3:15:13]: It's up to council whether or not y'all wanna give'em it, but typically on a cluster lot, a smaller lot. [3:15:13, 3:15:13]: Yeah. [3:15:15, 3:15:20]: So Y your your setbacks are a little bit more relaxed than they are at fifty feet for residential. [3:15:21, 3:15:37]: If I may, ma'am forward, um could we look at the difference? I know originally it was at twenty. Council wanna see thirty. Um council with with twenty five be satisfactory. What's the happening with that with twenty four? [3:15:37, 3:15:39]: And staff had recommendations too. [3:15:40, 3:15:55]: Yeah, there was there was some there were come back to Mike, please, sir. That's twenty that's twenty four. They were just outstanding recommendations. Yeah, so that's about what's the recommendation. So what's your me let me twenty five thirty three? Yeah, that's about twenty four. No recommended denial. [3:16:05, 3:16:06]: Um [3:16:07, 3:16:10]: The first condition was the rezoning should not be approved. [3:16:11, 3:16:16]: Unless the comp plan amendment was adopted. But that was already approved through our um [3:16:17, 3:16:20]: Ми удати аупрессив. [3:16:20, 3:16:22]: Playing in um October. [3:16:22, 3:16:26]: No permits shall be issued by the city of Stockbridge until the developer provides [3:16:27, 3:16:32]: to the planning and zoning office a copy of the recorded plat for the recombination of the three parcels. [3:16:32, 3:16:34]: Comprising the subject property. [3:16:35, 3:16:55]: The proposed mixed residential development shall be constructed according to the site plan, which is similar to the um uh condition she made. So the site plan that will be developing consultation with the staff. The developer shall submit construction plans to the Stockbridge Public Works Department six months prior to [3:16:55, 3:16:57]: [11819.5, 11822.7]: Um the applicant shall submit a traffic impact study. [3:17:03, 3:17:08]: environmental impacts. The d developers shall submit an environmental impact study [3:17:08, 3:17:28]: Or hydrology geology studies, which provides satisfactory environmental data. The developer number seven, the developers shall submit an acceptable landscape design plan for the proposed development. Number nine, preservation of the city's lift station. The developer shall take appropriate steps to preserve and protect the city's station. [3:17:28, 3:17:31]: [11851.8, 11852.2]: All right. [3:17:32, 3:17:37]: Architectural design, the design of the single family detached units which are to be located [3:17:37, 3:17:54]: says hold off for a second, please. I was on number nine. Go ahead, sir. Uh I think the issue is the setback for the single detach um it was at twenty according to conversation Miss Gann and Mr. Alexander, they wanted at thirty. [3:17:54, 3:18:14]: I'm trying to see where is the the the the medium here and I think that's really the issue um for the conditions uh in the motion. So um I guess the question is um and I know Mr. Gardner sort of indicated his [3:18:14, 3:18:27]: his concerns um of the 20 and he said fluctuate somewhere between twenty-five and thirty. But I'm just wondering, are we good at twenty-five? [3:18:28, 3:18:28]: Feet. [3:18:32, 3:18:37]: Thirty. Did I see some thumbs up down here? No, he said that thing is thumbs up for twenty five, I think. [3:18:40, 3:18:48]: Oh, well we just trying to get some clarification right now. I'm just trying to see if council is okay with uh twenty five. [3:18:50, 3:18:53]: You wanna be able to see that? [3:18:55, 3:18:56]: I kinda like thirty. [3:18:56, 3:19:02]: Thirty. But I I I kinda think thirty would be the s safest route. [3:19:02, 3:19:07]: Okay. So Mrs. Hogan, w would you like to re reiterate [3:19:07, 3:19:11]: The objection to the thirty feet set back on the uh single detached. [3:19:11, 3:19:13]: That have blessed houses. [3:19:14, 3:19:15]: I was a little bit smaller. [3:19:16, 3:19:16]: Yep. [3:19:18, 3:19:36]: We'll agree to thirty feet front setbacks for the single family detached and thirty feet for the town home units. Okay. Um, working with staff on the site plan for approval. Okay, sound good. So Mayor Ford, not to prolong this issue if there's no other issues. If I could, Councilman. [3:19:36, 3:19:52]: Real quick. I'm sorry. Can I ask a question? Go go ahe go ahead, sir. What what the the is the through road included in there too? In my motion it will be. Okay. Thank you. Go ahead, sir. Councilman, we can't agree to the through road. Speak to that as a condition. Speak to that. [3:19:52, 3:20:12]: The through belt is just not feasible for multiple reasons. Number one, the engineering reasons that I've already stated about the connectivity through the side for vehicular traffic. Number two, it significantly would reduce and change everything as far as the buildable area for the site. Everything that we've agreed to already is. [3:20:12, 3:20:32]: reducing the buildable area of this site. So I think that working with staff to break up some of those roads, to redesign that plan as we've discussed would help as it remains, is not going to change anything for the traffic that currently comes through from drive time for the community that's existing. [3:20:32, 3:20:32]: [12034.1, 12037.2]: Uh, Mr. Garden, you have any comments on the on the through roads? [3:20:39, 3:20:45]: Yes, sir. So I know that was a requirement that we looked at at the the flip and road development. I [3:20:45, 3:20:50]: I can't see um I don't have any elevations in front of me. [3:20:50, 3:20:58]: So I could only go by the applicants until they submit plans to us that reflect that there's a thirty foot difference in elevation. [3:20:58, 3:20:59]: Um [3:20:59, 3:21:07]: But one of the things we wanted to do is to try to see if there's a way for us to least allow for connectivity as part of the trail system because this is an area. [3:21:08, 3:21:14]: that we looked at um that we were investigating with the Path Foundation as a connectivity. [3:21:14, 3:21:34]: um to bring the parts over to this portion of Stockbridge via the adjacent property of a flippin' wheel. They've donated to us the property for the park in the back section of this development. We want to tie into that and bring that as best we can over to um this piece of property and then move it through this piece of property that takes you over to [3:21:34, 3:21:39]: towards the Walmart area. So i is it your recommendation. May I may I forward? [3:21:40, 3:21:41]: Okay. [3:21:41, 3:22:01]: Um is it your recommendation that this does not need to be a part of the condition that we will independently work with the PASS Foundation to try to make this work? Yeah, we will we'll definitely want to have the connectivity for our trail system. Um so that way these folks can take advantage of being able to. [3:22:01, 3:22:05]: connect via the trailer system which should be and I know that [3:22:05, 3:22:15]: probably trying to cross Rees Creek with a with a road is gonna be expensive, but at least with the path, it shouldn't be as and more and allow for that, say, to d the [3:22:16, 3:22:31]: pedestrian connectivity between this development, Flippin' Road, and then to the existing trail system that we have on Flippin' over to Memorial Park. And then at some point when we make the connections over, it'll be able to take you over to Clark Park, Gardner Park, and then beyond from that point. [3:22:32, 3:22:42]: Okay. Thank you, Mrs. Hogan, Mr. Gardner. If council is satisfied, Mayor, I will read into the record uh the motion. Go right here, please sir. [3:22:44, 3:22:50]: I move that in rezoning case number [3:22:51, 3:22:56]: R Z two Zero Two Three Dash Zero Five [3:22:58, 3:23:01]: To rezone the three parcels [3:23:01, 3:23:05]: on Davison Parkway and walked away from [3:23:05, 3:23:12]: C three heavy commercial to PUD Plan Unit Development. [3:23:13, 3:23:22]: To allow for a mixed residential development with the following conditions. [3:23:22, 3:23:24]: To include [3:23:25, 3:23:27]: A retail component. [3:23:29, 3:23:49]: To reduce the number of units to from a hundred to a hundred and twenty-five town homes, a hundred and fifty single detached, setbacks from twenty feet to [3:23:49, 3:23:55]: [12237.0, 12240.0]: And I believe I covered all of the conditions. [3:24:01, 3:24:02]: So [3:24:05, 3:24:09]: What Madame Clerk. What do you have, Madam Clerk? [3:24:10, 3:24:13]: To retain two acres. [3:24:13, 3:24:20]: as commercial with a preference for vertical use and to allow for an it for an easement for the trail plan. [3:24:20, 3:24:28]: Okay, on the retail to retain two acres. [3:24:30, 3:24:32]: for commercial. [3:24:35, 3:24:37]: Um commercial. [3:24:37, 3:24:38]: One example. [3:24:40, 3:24:41]: I'm sorry. [3:24:42, 3:24:42]: Preference for [3:24:43, 3:24:51]: Vertical mixed use. For commercial. Retail commercial. Ver vertical mixed use, which means they can put they can put residential above above the retail. [3:24:52, 3:24:53]: Okay, um [3:24:55, 3:25:03]: Let me get the amendment to the to the motion to retain two acres for [3:25:04, 3:25:05]: Let me get the language correct. [3:25:11, 3:25:12]: Go ahead, Ms. Halliday. [3:25:15, 3:25:16]: Okay. [3:25:18, 3:25:25]: So with that added to the motion, is everything else? [3:25:28, 3:25:28]: Um [3:25:30, 3:25:36]: With rank the number three on the staff condition. And all the staff recommendations had to be added to the case. And to include staff recommendations. [3:25:36, 3:25:39]: With the exception of number three. [3:25:39, 3:25:45]: I'm I'm gonna have the city clerk to read it back. Yeah. We got a couple more. [3:25:45, 3:26:04]: You're not prepared. All right. Because it says there's one. So let me make like Mrs. Hogan and Mrs. Number three. So number three. Staff condition number staff condition number three says that it's approving the current site plan. [3:26:05, 3:26:10]: So that needs to be the save plan is being altered, correct? Yes. Yes. [3:26:12, 3:26:16]: So they're gonna we're we're gonna work to redesign this this site plan. [3:26:17, 3:26:37]: Okay, so I'm gonna ask the Madam Clerk if she's able to stand stand by one second, please if you don't mind. Stand by one second, please. Okay. Mr. Mr. Alexander, you have something to say. Yeah, we had the customary ten-foot multi-use path along the main corridor, which is Davison Parkway, which we've been considering. [3:26:37, 3:26:57]: consistent with uh for all of those standard um in addition to uh what we had the that'll be along the frontage along davison parkway which is consistent with we've been doing said that that is standard that's standard that's required we we require that now on Davison Parkway it's not a corridor is it on all on on all the all the major developments [3:26:57, 3:27:16]: You better make sure. That's not a park where corridor is a good thing. Let's ask Mrs. Hogan is she understanding of that. We're fine with that. Okay, and then something else we've been been attempting to do, Ms. Hogan. You okay with adding street light, decor the street lights along the frontage, along the path? Decor the street lights. [3:27:17, 3:27:17]: Yeah. [3:27:17, 3:27:20]: Yeah. We're fine with that. [3:27:21, 3:27:31]: All right, that's good. See? Yes, you get it. We worked it out. Mr Alexander M Madam Clerk. Making sure we got all this included. Mr. Lights, we put him in. [3:27:33, 3:27:39]: Okay. Um that was an addition or two decorative s uh lighting. [3:27:41, 3:27:48]: Okay. Okay. So now are we talking street lights or the lanterns? [3:27:50, 3:27:58]: I'm just for clarification. Decorative streetlights. Decorative street lights. Okay, Mrs. Holiday, if you would the motion re read the motion. Okay. [3:27:59, 3:28:19]: Well this is D um specified. But you'll do that. Let's stand it anyway. I'm sorry, can't we? [3:28:19, 3:28:20]: Like [3:28:23, 3:28:31]: We're ready, Council. I'm sorry. I I want to make sure you hear this motion to make sure we all in agreement. Yes, sir. Okay. Mr. Toller. Okay. [3:28:32, 3:28:40]: So Councilman Thomas has made a motion to approve RZ twin twenty three oh five to include a retail component. [3:28:40, 3:28:56]: And reducing the townhomes to 125 and the single family detached to 150 would set back to 30 feet for both town homes and single detached homes with decorative street lights and [3:28:57, 3:28:58]: Um rezoning. [3:28:59, 3:29:02]: With a PUD with site plans to include [3:29:03, 3:29:05]: Working out the site plans with the staff. [3:29:05, 3:29:07]: Retain two acres. [3:29:08, 3:29:21]: Can read my writing for commercial with the preference for vertical mixed use and to allow an easement for the trail plan, including staff recommendations removing staff recommendation number three. [3:29:22, 3:29:23]: I miss anything. [3:29:26, 3:29:45]: Sounds like oh and the ten foot multipass that councilman Alexander mentioned is standard and already included. So it does not need to be added. Okay, I've added anyway. So with that being said, uh council, I concur that this is the [3:29:46, 3:29:52]: Mayor Ford. Second. Mr. Alexander second that motion. All in favor, please indicate. [3:29:52, 3:29:53]: Yeah. [3:29:54, 3:30:08]: I have one final question. I wanted to make sure flock cameras. I know Councilwoman Gantt usually asks about that. Flock cameras, are those also included? No, you are not. Mr Anderson. [3:30:09, 3:30:15]: It's not standard. Is that something you want to consider, Councilman Thomas? [3:30:16, 3:30:26]: Isn't that a constitutional agent right now design their own things? They want protection, right? Yes. [3:30:28, 3:30:31]: Yeah, she needs to hear it. They're talking right now. She needs to hear this. [3:30:33, 3:30:35]: And also is this development is it gated? [3:30:37, 3:30:39]: No. No. [3:30:39, 3:30:40]: Sorry, gave it. [3:30:42, 3:30:42]: Okay. [3:30:47, 3:30:48]: Plat camera. [3:30:49, 3:30:51]: Hold on a second, just still talking. [3:31:05, 3:31:16]: Okay, so Mr. Tobin. My last addition to this motion. I want to make sure that you you hear this. Mrs. Barber. [3:31:18, 3:31:21]: Go ahead, go ahead, go ahead, uh Al. What it's about flock cameras, go ahead. [3:31:23, 3:31:26]: Block cameras at entrance. [3:31:30, 3:31:31]: Okay. [3:31:32, 3:31:34]: I can tell again that this is the [3:31:35, 3:31:35]: Well shit. [3:31:38, 3:31:43]: Second. Ms. Alzheimer's second that again. All in favor, please indicate. [3:31:43, 3:32:03]: Unanimous decision. Thank God. All right. All right. Thank you, Ms. Hogan. Thank you. Appreciate it. All right. Announcements of upcoming meeting and events. Council meetings will be held. The city council chambers noting some board and committee meetings will continue to take place via Zoom. [3:32:03, 3:32:23]: Meetings, dates and times, if subject changed, please visit the city's website at WW City of Stockbridge.com. For meeting invitation, link, Facebook page, and contact City Hall officers at 770-389-7900 for updates. Citywide Development Authority meeting is second Tuesday of each month, 6 p.m. City Hall. [3:32:23, 3:32:43]: Hall, Levi Meeting Room, June 11th. The Main Street Advisory Board meeting second Friday of each month, 9 a.m. Locations Downtown Connection Center, 130 ML King, Senior Heritage Trail, June 14th. Downtown Development Authority meetings third Tuesday of each month. Stockbridge Downtown Connection Center. [3:32:43, 3:33:03]: 130 ML King Senior Heritage Trail June 18th as well. Okay. Uh the youth council advisory committee meeting, 6 30 p.m. uh third Tuesday of each month. The leave by meeting room city hall June 18th. Planning commission meeting is a third Thursday of each month, 630 p.m. City. [3:33:03, 3:33:17]: Hall Council Chambers June 20th. I have here the joint Henry County Beals uh Board of Commissions Stockbridgehampton Madonna Locus Grove Splash 6 meeting is scheduled for Tuesday, June 25th, but I'm that's going to actually be changed. That's going to be changed. [3:33:17, 3:33:18]: It's Wednesday now. [3:33:19, 3:33:20]: Wednesday at six thirty? [3:33:22, 3:33:25]: Six o'clock on Wednesday, June twenty sixth. [3:33:27, 3:33:28]: Okay. [3:33:30, 3:33:37]: Our city council work session meeting spe uh well, the city council work work session meeting is on [3:33:38, 3:33:44]: Wednesday at six o'clock. Now w our meeting is Wednesday, six o'clock on the end no no no. [3:33:45, 3:33:45]: No. [3:33:48, 3:33:50]: Right. So [3:33:51, 3:34:02]: City Council work session meeting is going to be Wednesday, June twenty sixth at six PM City Hall Council Chambers. Now the SPLOT six meeting I think is still being negotiated on the time frame. I I will say it's not on Tuesday. [3:34:03, 3:34:08]: We're still trying to negotiate that one. We'll have to let the public know when we get a conf confirmation on that. [3:34:09, 3:34:29]: Okay, community zoning and information meeting, Thursday, June twenty-seventh from six to seven PM, Starby City Hall Chambers, June twenty-seventh. Starbury Citizens Police Viralfield Council meeting first Thursday of each month, six p.m. at Stockbridge Police Account uh communion room. Forty five forty five North Henry Boulevard July meetings is council due to fourth of July holiday. [3:34:29, 3:34:30]: Yeah. [3:34:30, 3:34:50]: City Council meeting second Monday of each month, 6 p.m. City Hall Council Chambers, July 8th. Youth Council meeting, second Monday of each month, 6:30, City Hall Levi Meeting Room. And Snow July meeting it says due to summer break. City Citywide Development Authority meeting, second Tuesday of each month, 6 p.m. at the City Hall Leave. [3:34:50, 3:35:10]: By meeting room uh July 9th. Upcoming events. Food truck tasty Tuesday is back. Of course, join us at Clark Park at level one one one Davis Road, Stockbridge on Tuesdays, 5 30, 8 p.m. for live music, great food, and a host of free games and activities for the kids. Join Councilman Afonso Thomas for the monthly senior. [3:35:10, 3:35:20]: at Bingo Bash on Wednesday, June 12th, 10 a.m. and to uh 12 noon at Merrill Manor's Conference Center, 111 Davis Road for Raffles, Prizes. [3:35:21, 3:35:41]: Games, snacks, and fun. Bring the kids out to the annual Main Street movie night at Clark Park, Friday, June fourteenth, with free games and activities starting at six PM and features a movie starting the movie's gonna start at sundown. Train Councilman Elton Elz uh Elton L. Zenter District Five Town Hall Meeting Saturday, June twenty ninth. [3:35:41, 3:35:50]: Uh at 10 a.m. Argento at Bridges at Johtoco, 300 Argento Drive. It's got a Madonna address, but it's in stoppers, of course. [3:35:50, 3:36:04]: Join the city of Starbury's for a free annual Juneteenth. Celebration on Wednesday, June 19th from 5 to 9 p.m., the Starbury's Amphitheater. There'll be unique food and art and vendors, fun activities for the kids, DJ, and live performances. [3:36:04, 3:36:24]: Join Councilwoman Lukeia ShaGantt in partnership with Atlanta Food Truck Park for the night market at the Stockbridge Amphitheater parking lot from six PM to nine thirty PM. Special date ju June nineteenth with uh June nineteenth with Juneteenth. There will be vendors, food trucks, activities, games, music and vibes. Contact Tan Bowers. [3:36:24, 3:36:44]: At Tan and Atlanta FoodtruckPark.com for registration and additional information. Join Mayor Anthony Ford for the monthly Meet the Mayor on Wednesday, June 26, from 10 a.m. to 12 noon, Stockbridge City Hall. Save the date for the city of Stockbridge free, 4th of July Extravaganza. [3:36:44, 3:37:04]: Fireworks and live music. Gates open at 3 p.m. And concert uh will feature Soul Cartel, Cartel, excuse me, Soul Cartel, Algebra Bless it, Bobby V and a Michael Jackson live tribute. Take place from 5 p.m. to nine p.m. on Starbury's Amphitheater. Save the days for uh Councilwoman Yelanda Barber and [3:37:04, 3:37:24]: Once again partnering with Kix for Kids to collect shoes on Saturday, July 4th, excuse me, Saturday, July 6th and July 13th. The Stockbridge First United Methodist Church, please plan to donate all you can for a life-changing initiative. Join Councilman Thomas for Don't Trash Stockbridge Initiative Center around education highlights. [3:37:24, 3:37:44]: lighting and causes and effects of littering and illegal dumping. More information to follow on this as well. Councilman Thomas in honoring veterans and continuous salute to all year long. Please send your pictures of the veterans and their names, branch, rank, and years of service. Please contact Rosalind Rawls to schedule appointment to meet the mayor for more information on council initiatives and events [3:37:44, 3:38:04]: is six seven eight eight three three three three four eight or by way of email rawls at stopbridgega.org. The twenty twenty four Stockbridge Ampathe Concert Series July sixth, Karen Briggs, Contempo Orchestra featuring Phil Perry, Otta Adams, Regina Bell, Shelly Month. [3:38:04, 3:38:10]: [13091.8, 13095.7]: All right. That's on the sixth of July. [3:38:20, 3:38:40]: And Sunday, July 7th, end of the Fourth of July weekend, featuring Charlie Wilson and Uncle Charlie with Robin Thick. Saturday, July 13th, and Sunday the 14th, the night with Kim and Leela James, Saturday the 20th, and uh actually the 21st, 20th and 21st, Lee's Night Out featuring Joseph John. [3:38:40, 3:39:00]: Johnny Gill and Silk. Saturday, July twenty-seventh, the 70s Soul Jam featuring the satellites, the Manhattans, the legendary Blue Notes, Bloodstone, and Peaches and Herb. And right now, Saturday, uh August third, and we'll be babyface with special guests every sunshine and forecast. And this past weekend and the concert we had [3:39:00, 3:39:20]: TLC here and we recognize them for 30 years of the Crazy Sexy's A Cool album. And we had a great pre great concert concert, I was to say, and and a presentation for a prom proclamation for them as well. So it was a very well attended and excellent concert. So Starbucks A and P. [3:39:20, 3:39:40]: Ladies and gentlemen and check out the concert series. And uh it's the summertime, so be help be safe and healthy out there and be and when you're out in the heat, make sure you have you're well hydrated. And if you uh need to get your regular checkups, you know, COVID is still out there with other types of viruses, so make sure you get uh boosted and documented. [3:39:40, 3:39:53]: properly. Keep your health up. On that note, um council, we actually have a second session that we need to go into for legal, real estate and personnel. I need a motion to let's go into second session, please. [3:39:55, 3:40:04]: I move that we go into execution for real estate personnel and litigation. Is there a second? Okay Mr. Berry's second. Dan all in favor, please indicate. [3:40:06, 3:40:12]: Can you announce decision? We'll go into second section. We'll be back soon, ladies and gentlemen. Thank you. [3:40:23, 3:40:23]: I know. [3:40:24, 3:40:44]: Council, I need a motion to end the second session, please. So move. Okay. So move for Mr. Alzheimer's and I need a second. Second. Second one, Mr. Berry. All in favor, please indicate. Okay, unanimous decision. Now I need a motion to reconvene our city council meeting. Mr. Berry, so move. Second. Mr. Alzheimer's, so moved. All in favor, please. [3:40:44, 3:41:04]: Please indicate. Okay, announce decision. So repeat that. Huh? Go ahead. I got the second. Okay. Okay. Okay. From the meeting, we have an announcement to make. Go ahead, Mr. I make a motion for us to enter to an intergovernmental agreement with the ward authority. Second. Okay. All in favor, please indicate. All right. So announcement. [3:41:04, 3:41:16]: decision. All right, now I need motion to end our our meeting. So Mr. from that's Mr Okay, from Mr. Thomas and Mr. Berry. All favor please indicate. Good night. God bless you all. Thank you, thank you, thank you.
  • 2024-05-28 · City Council · Transcript · Work Session

    2024-05-28 · City Council · Transcript · source: 10yr-transcripts · sha256 14bf6ccc · pages – · method: official

    Full text — searchable
    --- title: Work Session date: 2024-05-28 source: 2024-05-28_Work_Session.wav --- [0:04:19, 0:04:28]: I pray for this council meeting, the city of Stockbridge and all of its members. Give the council members wisdom and guidance as they deliberate on items before them. [0:04:29, 0:04:30]: The presenter is the [0:04:34, 0:04:35]: Every decision we break. [0:04:41, 0:04:44]: Amen. Pledge allegiance here. [0:04:44, 0:04:55]: I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands, one nation, under God, invisible liberty and justice for all. [0:04:56, 0:04:57]: Roll call, Madam Clerk, please. [0:05:03, 0:05:04]: Present. [0:05:05, 0:05:10]: Present. Councilman Alexander. Present. Councilwoman Barrett. Present. Councilwoman Gantt. [0:05:11, 0:05:15]: Let the record reflect Councilwoman Gantt is not in attendance. Councilman Tom. [0:05:15, 0:05:16]: Right. [0:05:17, 0:05:20]: Thank you, Madam Clerk. Uh Council, I need a motion to adopt the agenda, please. [0:05:22, 0:05:42]: M miss Miss Barber. So I'll move that. Mr. Alzheimer's second that all in favor please indicate. Thank you very much. And uh council before you had reviewed the minutes of the draft uh draft minutes there for our council meeting on May thirteenth. Review those and we'll be able to approve those minutes at our next uh council meeting next month. On that note, uh [0:05:42, 0:05:45]: Madam Clerk, do we have any public comments? [0:05:46, 0:05:54]: Okay, thank you very much. Appreciate that. New business council review and consideration of the TAD downtown rendering. Mr. Gardner, please. [0:06:07, 0:06:27]: Good evening, man, council. Hopefully you guys can hear me. Unfortunate. I went to Florida for a tournament and came back with a virus. So I apologize. Yes, sir. Only reason why I'm here is because I had these items on the agenda. Otherwise, I'd still be at home. Um what you hope before you [0:06:27, 0:06:47]: you uh man counsel uh some of the renderings that you know we were told that we needed to to present to henry county board of commissioners um we've been working and refining them working with the with the architectural firm to actually get the get it the renderings done and as you can see it gives you an idea [0:06:47, 0:07:07]: Of the intersection. The first rendering that you have gives you an overview of what's gonna happen to the three acres across the street from City Hall. Um, this is the intersection of Eastern Ladder Road and Highway 138, North Henry Boulevard. And as you go north, you'll be heading pointing north. [0:07:07, 0:07:16]: on on Eastern Ladder Road. So it's a multi story mixed use development. It'll be on that on that site. [0:07:17, 0:07:36]: Across from City Hall and you can see past City Hall there's a second secondary building, um roughly about four three to four stories. That's also gonna be uh residential mixed use development as well. And then further from that is a parking lot. Um if you turn to your second page, you will see the overall plan. [0:07:36, 0:07:40]: for the reuse, adaptive reuse of our city properties. [0:07:41, 0:07:42]: And [0:07:42, 0:07:43]: In the plan. [0:07:44, 0:08:04]: You can see where City Hall is. It's a crude rendering of City Hall, but it's there. Um the mixed use development by five, designated as number five, and you'll have a a ski uh a legend that's to your to your right, keynote legend, I'll give you a good idea of uh what those are. So those are your mixed use development. There's an opportunity for us to [0:08:04, 0:08:24]: Take this this rendering reflects about three parking spaces, parking decks. Right. And if we do the TAD, those will be some of the funding areas that we'd be funding for TID. So I'll run some basic numbers and I will present those to you before we go to Henry County, but I'm refining them with our FA. [0:08:24, 0:08:44]: Um, but that'll give us ideas. About close to about$30 million of of infrastructure investment that would be a part of what uh we estimate between$170 to$225 million project. And so with that, uh and then the second, the third review. [0:08:44, 0:08:47]: [528.5, 547.2]: And that's a view of you directly behind the old Ted Strickland building, the economic development building where the courtyard is, and looking back towards uh North Henry Boulevard and that area there takes into account some of the renderings from the RSVP plan. [0:09:09, 0:09:21]: But it just gives you a different scape a s uh streetscape and scale of uh mixed use development, two story mixed use development, an opportunity to bring more people downtown, but also to expand on our commercial uses. [0:09:24, 0:09:43]: And with that, I just wanted to give you ideas. This is what we're gonna be presenting to the Henry County Board of Commissioners and the School Board to get approval to move forward. Um this is what we were told from the chair lady that she wanted to see. Is that overall master plan and what we're projecting? I will say that [0:09:43, 0:10:03]: Um and this will be held as when you guys meet as the Urban Redevelopment Authority that we have a strong offer in and we were going over that plan uh last week, uh Tuesday before I left. Um Mr. Gardner, I can't hear you. I'm sorry, I d I don't want to take my mask off because I don't want to spread my virus. [0:10:03, 0:10:22]: Um I said that we do have when we meet as an urban redevelopment authority, hopefully very soon, we do have a strong proposal for the development of all of these properties um from a consultant group. And uh I'll go over that. I think I presented that proposal to you guys so we went back, refined it. [0:10:22, 0:10:25]: But um we'll be bringing that back to you as soon as they send us the new [0:10:26, 0:10:27]: New documents. [0:10:27, 0:10:31]: So there's strong interest in making this project and a few others happen. [0:10:32, 0:10:39]: Curry, obviously, I maybe I might have missed it. What what are the proposed dates to talk to bring this to the the uh commissioners and then the school board? [0:10:40, 0:10:55]: So once you guys say you guys are good with it, I'll be meeting with Sherry Matthews to get on their calendar. And once that date is announced I'll let everybody know. And she's seen a sneak peek of this and was very impressed by what we're doing. [0:10:55, 0:11:01]: So we have to go to commissioners first and then to the school board. Yes, sir. That's the route. All right. Mr. Azna, go ahead, please. [0:11:01, 0:11:06]: Yeah, so uh is what we're seeing right now is not visible to the people watching, though. [0:11:10, 0:11:30]: Yes, I think uh it's very important. This is uh some amazing renderings uh that the public really needs to see of uh things that are going on. This is so realistic because you got the city hall in there, they can see what the uh new proposed development would actually look like. [0:11:30, 0:11:50]: And then uh there's some concern about parking. You can see the parking deck, the proposed parking deck, and all of this uh laid out uh in a proposed layout and the value uh of uh all parties coming to the table because this would be some exemplary development that we have never [0:11:50, 0:12:10]: uh seen before uh in our particular area. So certainly I would like to see the public to be able to take a look at this. And I know I don't want you to go into too much detail because of how you your your your current condition, but I I just wanted to just reiterate again this is not just [0:12:10, 0:12:22]: a futuristic kind of thing. This is actually attainable and there are potential suitors at the table who may be very well uh propositioned to do that uh should we move forward. [0:12:24, 0:12:24]: Yes, sir. [0:12:26, 0:12:35]: Or thank you. M Ms Barber, go ahead please. I do um wanna suggest or perhaps you are already considering having some town halls. [0:12:36, 0:12:52]: To answer questions regarding the homeowners and businesses that are in the area. I certainly support redeveloping and revitalizing our downtown, but it's still important to me for those homeowners and business owners who are. [0:12:53, 0:12:58]: in the mediate area of this and will be affected by it positively or negatively. [0:13:00, 0:13:07]: Do you have um have you considered hosting some forums or town halls or something to share this information? [0:13:08, 0:13:19]: Oh yes. Um once we go to the county commissioners, uh unless you guys want me to do it before then, um definitely uh we could we'll open it up for public public cons [0:13:19, 0:13:30]: I said yes, we can definitely do that and open it up for public public view and comment. Um do y'all wanna do that before we go to the county or after? Before? [0:13:31, 0:13:45]: Well, I would I would th I mean I would think we'll do it after after we get approval from the county and then you go open it up to the public. That's what I would think. But well you got a council here so they can make up their mind how they want to handle that. Considering this is the district that I represent. [0:13:46, 0:13:50]: А спіккова інтерс атаки, аллерс і не з арія. [0:13:50, 0:14:03]: And before I will vote on anything, this is just a presentation today, correct? It's it's a presentation and we wanna make sure we wanna go I want you all to see what's going to be presented to the Henry County Board of Commissioners. [0:14:03, 0:14:09]: So that's why I put it in the bring this back at the next meeting or a future meeting for us to vote on it? [0:14:10, 0:14:26]: Uh no, that's why I asked for it to be reviewed and considered so we can get to the county commissioners because remember we do have folks out there who want to do this project. The key is making sure we get consent from the county because without it it's our tit is dead if we don't get consent. But [0:14:27, 0:14:45]: Um we could do some town hall meetings in the next week or two. I'll try to get some something on the schedule. That way we can get we can get some public input. Hopefully before we I guess within the next two weeks we should be able to do put some notices out and and hold a town hall meeting here or at the Murraymanders. [0:14:46, 0:15:00]: That's not that's not'cause people need to understand, yes, this is what's come potentially what's coming. Um and understand that yes, um it's going to be a change, obviously, and what that change would look like and the benefits thereof. [0:15:01, 0:15:09]: So yes, I'm I'm fine with us doing it. Uh I will get with Sherry tomorrow. Um I won't be in the office, but I'll give her a call. [0:15:09, 0:15:18]: I'll give Ms. Matthews a call, find out when we can meet, and if she give me that date, I can schedule something in between for a public town hall meeting in between. And I'll let you guys know. [0:15:19, 0:15:39]: Thank you, sir. Yes, ma'am. Mr. Hassan, go ahead, please. Yeah, I just want to reiterate this is a very high level kind of thing. It's not uh the detail a lot of the details will be filled in uh as we kind of go along with the process. And there is room for uh tinkering should there be some public input. [0:15:39, 0:15:41]: At that at that time, correct? [0:15:41, 0:16:01]: Yeah, yeah. Um so it's a it's a it's it's it's a plan that can be navigated uh contingent upon uh that public feedback when we get it. So it's not written in stone, correct? That that is correct. And you know, as much as we we we we put this in place, um you'll see some elevation differences. [0:16:01, 0:16:12]: difference when the developer brings a project in. You see it'll be some differences in there. Um, but for the most part, it's going to be a a mixed use building that's gonna be about four to five stories tall. [0:16:13, 0:16:32]: Uh absolutely and certainly uh I I think uh what we want to do is to make sure that we get as get the parties on board, which is the city which is the county and then the school board to understand. And I think what has really happened is folks need to understand that zero sum game which is [0:16:33, 0:16:53]: In the current condition or the former condition that was in, there was no gain to be had. And should all players participate in moving forward with the enhanced redevelopment, then there will be some reinvestment in the area. Citizens are always concerned about uh infrastructure. And as you said, this project would include. [0:16:53, 0:17:13]: How much$30 million or so in infrastructure enhancements, which uh the public has uh in addition to what we've already done uh in terms of uh the um stormwater and everything on the amphitheater campus. So what you're positioning right there is in the background, that's the part. [0:17:13, 0:17:33]: Parking garage, correct? Yeah. So the parking garage would be back here. Right. On the amphitheater parking lot campus, which wouldn't take up any additional space. As a matter of fact, it would tighten the parking to where that section would be it that paved section would actually already be um it would. [0:17:33, 0:17:53]: It would already be a paved section. You'd just be going vertical. Yes. So there's no stormwater impact from that because it's already impervious surface. So whether impervious surface is three stories or four stories or one story is still impervious surface. The water's gonna hit the top and drain down just like it does. So there'll be no need to change any of the detention for the water. [0:17:53, 0:18:13]: facilities in the project because we're t we're dealing with imperv existing impervious surface. We're not changing those dynamics anyway. Now last thing I'm gonna say with all due respect, Ms. Barber, we all love this area. We do. We we listen to the citizens that live here as as as as same as you do. And [0:18:13, 0:18:33]: And we value what their opinions are and try to um bring them what they want. We've been doing that now, I know myself for eight years, Councilman Thomas probably about twelve, mayor's about twelve. So certainly I don't wanna make it seem like we uh do not want to take into consideration what the citizens are doing because this process is being [0:18:32, 0:18:41]: Ongoing now for years. Before I arrived in at probably after I leave, this process has been going on with many of [0:18:41, 0:19:00]: uh involvement in the public with the ARC has had a lot of put input in how we got to this point and certainly we want to make sure that they're at the table uh as we go forward. But certainly we all share your sentiments that we want to make sure that we build the best downtown uh that is possible. [0:19:00, 0:19:14]: for everybody in Stockbridge because I want my district five residents to come down here and enjoy this and these residents voted for many of us and during citywide elections and trusted us with the care of the downtown area. [0:19:15, 0:19:16]: You're going, Ms. Barber. [0:19:17, 0:19:29]: Um, thank you. I appreciate that. And I hope that you all will keep the residents in the forefront of your minds while you're making decisions um in this particular area. [0:19:30, 0:19:32]: А вас електричто репрезентні інтерсфатю. [0:19:33, 0:19:35]: Not just my interest. [0:19:35, 0:19:39]: Of course, I support revitalizing the downtown area. [0:19:40, 0:19:42]: But I also know that there is an impact. [0:19:43, 0:19:45]: To the stakeholders in the area. [0:19:45, 0:19:46]: Have to consider that. [0:19:47, 0:19:49]: I have the unique responsibility. [0:19:49, 0:19:56]: Of caring for the interests, the needs, the desires of those who are farthest east and farthest north. [0:19:56, 0:19:58]: And everything in between. [0:19:59, 0:20:06]: Absolutely. I am going to vote their interests, not mine. Now I do have a question though, Mr. Gardner. [0:20:07, 0:20:11]: Some of these areas are shaded yellow. Mm-hmm. Some of them are [0:20:11, 0:20:12]: There are three. [0:20:13, 0:20:16]: different shades of yellow. So I need to understand um [0:20:17, 0:20:21]: Bryant street and some of the other side streets here. [0:20:21, 0:20:38]: All right, so y can you see you can see the cursor? Yes, sir. Alright, so that's Lee Street. Mm-hmm. That's North Lee Street. Um, that's Chris Away right there. As it comes through the amphitheater and connects to East Atlanta Road. [0:20:40, 0:20:50]: That's North Henry Boulevard. That's Norfolk Southerns Railroad right there. That is Lee Street. This is Brooke. [0:20:51, 0:21:11]: Oh Love, Love Street. Love. Love Street. I'm sorry. Love Street here. Right. This is Burke. This is MLK in here. And w what this is this is showing you guys is expanding some of the parking, which is another project that's coming up. But this is Burke Street. That's MLK. And we [0:21:11, 0:21:31]: Where you see the number renderings is where new buildings will be, where you see number renderings. So the numbers denote new buildings being added over time because s some of this is still in pup in private hands. So this is not something that's gonna happen overnight, but some of it where we own property can happen fairly quickly. [0:21:31, 0:21:51]: Um three acres, the already existing site for um the amphitheater. Um behind us, there's a potential for a parking deck there. Um they're making those improvements. But those the number buildings are the buildings that'll be brand new to the area. So in essence, rather than having a downtown of [0:21:51, 0:21:56]: Roughly twelve buildings will have a complete somewhat downtown. [0:21:57, 0:22:00]: So what impact though to Bryant Street? [0:22:01, 0:22:21]: I see some of the areas are shaded in yellow. So what does that mean? So th yeah, this is a bad photo, unfortunate. When you photo when you copy a copy, that's what happens. Um so Bryant Street is right here. Mm-hmm. That's Bryant. So there's nothing happening. Those are the existing houses on Bryant. [0:22:22, 0:22:26]: But they're shaded. Why d yes, they're denoted because their structures [0:22:27, 0:22:36]: So all structures have a color. The more intense yellow is what you see with a number are new. Everything else is existing. Gotcha. Thank you, sir. I appreciate that. [0:22:37, 0:22:41]: Mayor Ford. Yes, sir. Go ahead, please. Thank you, Mr. Garner. Um [0:22:43, 0:23:01]: The only concern I really have is toward the council. I just wanna make sure that we are in agreement, that we do understand, even when I look at the legend and strategically putting [0:23:01, 0:23:04]: This here, putting this there, putting this here. [0:23:04, 0:23:06]: I just wanna make sure [0:23:06, 0:23:10]: That we're all in agreement and we understand strategically. [0:23:11, 0:23:14]: Um, where everything sort of like a puzzle, if you will. [0:23:15, 0:23:20]: where everything is gonna be placed and we're okay with that because once you [0:23:20, 0:23:24]: put the shovel in the ground and the bulldozers are running. [0:23:24, 0:23:33]: It's it's sort of too late. And I and I say that from a a reference of experience, and I won't get too deep into the the the construction. [0:23:33, 0:23:34]: Of the amphitheater. [0:23:34, 0:23:38]: But in hindsight, and we didn't know, but in hindsight [0:23:39, 0:23:41]: I think we probably could have. [0:23:42, 0:24:02]: put something somewhere else or something somewhere else and those kind of thing. So I just want to make sure uh from the council standpoint that we all are in agreement with the legend and where everything is located uh strategically, traffic control with parking decks and other parks. [0:24:02, 0:24:03]: Yeah. [0:24:03, 0:24:06]: Uh the residential development is that the [0:24:06, 0:24:26]: place where it needs to go, those kind of thing. And I think then once we as a council say, okay, we okay, then I think then we go to the next step. And I know the purpose tonight. And I think this is the first time we really sort of going into this, and which is okay. But I just wanna make sure we as a council are in agreement [0:24:26, 0:24:46]: with how we how it's laid out and we think this is a great legend, this is a great plan. And then we sort of go forward. So and I've heard from some council members. And I know there are some some questions, but that just sort of where I am. I think we're all in favor of developing our downtown. And for me and my perspective. [0:24:46, 0:25:00]: even though we have district, but you know, I represent everybody. And because when we vote, so it's not one council person does not dictate what happens. [0:25:00, 0:25:07]: It takes all of us to vote. So I that's my perspective. I look at everything. It doesn't matter what district it's in. [0:25:07, 0:25:27]: uh we all are accountable to this whole set of stock bridge. And we have to just make sure that whatever we do in the City of Stockbridge, it is pleasing to everybody and we all feel comfortable in raising our hand and voting in favor or against something. And I understand, you know, the whole district concept, but [0:25:27, 0:25:34]: Um, citizens hold all of us accountable for everything that we do. And that's that's how I look at it. I just want to make sure. [0:25:35, 0:25:48]: 'Cause this is a very, very important step we're getting ready to take. And you talking about changing uh a new look for our downtown, this is gonna be it here. Now I know sometimes you don't always get it right. [0:25:49, 0:26:00]: But as closest to right that we can get it, this is sort of where I am. So I just wanna make sure that we understand this layout. We all are in agreement with this layout. [0:26:00, 0:26:01]: Or [0:26:01, 0:26:15]: Is there something else that we make it shift here, a shift there? So I just want to make sure that we're okay with that and we understand the legend and where everything is strategically placed right now. Are we okay with this legend? [0:26:16, 0:26:26]: And so I'm studying this now and I don't know what we need to do today. I don't know, I'm not sure what you're asking us to do today. [0:26:27, 0:26:36]: Um, but I wanna get a uh better understanding and I'm looking and I'm reading and I'm studying, but I don't know what other counsel, so I don't know. So what are you asking us to do today? [0:26:37, 0:26:38]: This was w [0:26:38, 0:26:58]: Uh Councilmember uh Thomas, yes. This was uh for us to present kind of what we've been working at as tied of the tad. Um uh if you have some questions or concerns, obviously you let me know what those are uh and we move'em. Uh understanding that everything that you see that's numberized except [0:26:58, 0:27:18]: For a few parcels, uh already vacant tracts of land. And based on the developers' urban, and they did this, they did this in consideration of looking at development, development types, right? So as we look to shift certain things around, yes, there's some things we can shift around. [0:27:18, 0:27:32]: Um but uh I would say that yes. This is open for discussion. If you you have any questions, please just let me know what they are. I'll answer them as best I can. If I can't I'll get our consultants to look at it as well. [0:27:32, 0:27:34]: But as I'm right now [0:27:34, 0:27:54]: But yeah, what you this is the plan. This this is the A this is the A plan right here. This this is this is what we're taking. This is what we're taking to the party. Okay. Yes, sir. Good. Okay. Go ahead, sir. I just want to say that there's an understanding that just because this is the initial plan, it it's bound to be [0:27:54, 0:28:04]: change. Most most times when there's a plan like this, there is no way that we can say today that we m marked off every building and every example and every plot on the legend and say [0:28:05, 0:28:14]: As of today, this is what it's going to be two, three, four, five years from now. This is just a rough draft. Is that correct? Is that the best way to describe it? [0:28:15, 0:28:35]: Yes, sir. This is your this is your draft almost final, right? We we understand that the architecture might be a little different, but in terms of making the development work in terms of scale, it's gonna have to be X amount of stories. So that's that's where that's where the heightened the building. [0:28:35, 0:28:55]: Come in to make sure that from a from the perspective of a developer, you know, they can actually do this project and make money. Because that's obviously what it's about. They're not in business to give away charity, but at the same time, an opportunity to grow. And all of this, when we get down to it, is going to be controlled through a development agreement. [0:28:54, 0:29:11]: agreement with that developer to make sure that hey yes we are getting what we say we're getting and any of the infrastructure improvements that needs to come will come and how that will come based on that development agreement. So yeah, we're we're still a mile away from the from the finish line. [0:29:13, 0:29:16]: Mr. Azan, go ahead. [0:29:17, 0:29:37]: What I wanted to say is, I think we need to understand something, and I certainly understand Mayor Pro Timberry, you're right on point, these programs more. But let's understand this council voted on LCI Plan B, which is what the Atlanta Regional Commission came up with, the general idea. [0:29:37, 0:29:57]: That's kind of the scale at where we are where we are placing these buildings with the uh multifamily over here and with the amphitheater being where it is. That's LCI plan B that was approved by the Atlanta Regional Commission. You know, when we reached out to them as a city to ask them to do the the livable [0:29:57, 0:30:17]: Centers initiative, and that's how we qualify for some type of grants and that type of thing that we do for our short-term work program and our capital program. So when we go to them and we ask for assistance, like we did with the trail plan downtown and other assistance that we would be able to get. [0:30:17, 0:30:37]: They look to see whether or not we're adhering to some of their recommendations, not all of them, but certainly we've been following that framework in order to do that. Because if you look at that picture in Miss Holliday's office that I often refer to, you will see that this was a mixed common right over there. [0:30:37, 0:30:57]: There across the street, uh, in that area, right here by City Hall. So that concept uh was uh was is a beautiful rendition. I know many of y'all have seen that when you go into our office, and that kind of captures this. That was a concept, whereas this is a concept too. So understanding that there is a something that the plan is. [0:30:57, 0:31:03]: grounded in for us to what what was determined with a lot of study went into it. [0:31:04, 0:31:04]: Yeah. [0:31:05, 0:31:21]: Okay. Mr. Uh Mr. Thomas, please. Right. Um Mr. Garden, is it appropriate for me to ask you to speak in detail? At this point, is it appropriate? Uh for you to speak in detail. Um [0:31:22, 0:31:26]: about in legend five, six [0:31:28, 0:31:29]: And eight. [0:31:30, 0:31:40]: um the thought that went behind that and could you just sort of speak to to some of that. I mean, uh, if it's not appropriate to speak today [0:31:40, 0:32:00]: I'm I'm okay if you take So five six? Right, five, six and eight. So five, six and eight is a multi story, not as tall as number five itself, but it's gonna be somewhere around three, maybe three to four stories because right there the grade elevation actually from the street is much lower. [0:32:00, 0:32:09]: Mm-hmm. Um so you're looking at potential for retail as well as some residential uses, and that's where you see the amenity, the pool. [0:32:09, 0:32:13]: It's associated with a with a structure of that size. Yes. [0:32:15, 0:32:22]: So that's what that building is. That's also a mixed use building as well. It will house some retail uses as well as residential above. [0:32:24, 0:32:44]: Well, w one of my concerns and I'm pretty sure the study has been done um with the um vibration from the trains, uh the blasting at the quarry,'cause I know where we sit here and where I live when [0:32:44, 0:32:50]: when the week those blastings. I mean, it rattles, it [0:32:50, 0:33:10]: Works with your foundation. Uh is any of that has any of that been considered in this construction of anything in this particular area? So so no. Uh as of right now, you know, we're not in the development review stage of this project. So that'll have [0:33:10, 0:33:13]: Obviously once we consummate the deal with the developer. [0:33:14, 0:33:34]: They're going to do their environmental assessment on the property. So they'll take into account either phase one or phase phase one or phase two environmental. They'll talk about those issues that are out there. Um and obviously making sure that like this building, yes, you're in an area where there's blasting, but they you can build a building to withstand [0:33:33, 0:33:53]: That obviously, because we do build buildings to extend to withstand uh earthquakes to a certain degree. So obviously, um if you looked at on the Richter scale, I would assume that one of our blasts is probably a one or point five for the most part, even though we feel them. But the folks in California that have [0:33:53, 0:34:13]: Has a two or three knows that it's more of this rather than that. Right? Um the worst one I think I felt was last week. I was actually over it it um at the tear stricklin and yeah, I felt that one real clear. And and that's obviously because we have the rock that sits on [0:34:13, 0:34:29]: on this side of um it's funny that you can live on the other side of of Eagles Landing and forty two and you don't feel it. Same distance away, but you don't feel it. Um so there's a difference between what's what this area's made of versus [0:34:29, 0:34:37]: Just over the ridge what that area is made of in terms of rock versus And I and I and I would thinking in terms of um especially the the pool. [0:34:37, 0:34:57]: Yeah. Uh for us'cause if a poo gonna crack in it. So yeah, so they they're they're obviously w once you once we get everything down pack and there's a there's a deal on the table, those guys that developer's gonna do their due diligence through their environmental, through landscape, and they will obviously know that they're blasting times and when they structure those. [0:34:57, 0:35:05]: buildings what they have to be done in order for them to do what this does. You feel the vibration, but right. Yeah. Thanks, sir. Yes sir. [0:35:06, 0:35:13]: Ms. Barber, go ahead, please. Mr. Gardner. Yes, ma'am. So what's the difference between um four? [0:35:13, 0:35:16]: And ten. I know TN is a parking deck. [0:35:17, 0:35:26]: So the ledger that you have is kind of cut off on the side. So I can't see the full Yeah. So four, ten, and seven are parking decks. [0:35:30, 0:35:31]: The parking decks. [0:35:32, 0:35:33]: But what's the difference? [0:35:33, 0:35:34]: The difference is [0:35:37, 0:35:57]: Size. So number ten will be a little bigger than number seven and number four. But for the amount of retail that you're gonna put and the amount of residence you're gonna put, you wanna have uh parking necessary to accommodate those the residential and retail components. Okay. Would you mind expanding your [0:35:57, 0:36:01]: keynote ledger just so I can read those descriptions. [0:36:08, 0:36:10]: It's still kind of cut off. [0:36:11, 0:36:12]: Whereas numbered [0:36:12, 0:36:13]: Yes. [0:36:16, 0:36:19]: So ten is a parking deck. Um [0:36:19, 0:36:20]: With [0:36:21, 0:36:23]: What is the R E team? [0:36:24, 0:36:26]: I'm sorry. Uh [0:36:28, 0:36:40]: I won't be able to look at it because I don't I have the same copy you have that when they copied it it didn't come all the way through. But it it is a parking deck. Um and that's gonna be [0:36:40, 0:36:54]: existing parking. So it's it's taking over. So tan will be replacing some of the parking that's already there. The only difference is you're going vertical um with that parking to give you ex excess parking. [0:36:55, 0:36:57]: So rather than spreading this, you're going this way. [0:36:58, 0:37:06]: So that that up should be able to accommodate obviously what's existing, but given additional parking spaces to deal with the retail and residential area. [0:37:08, 0:37:17]: And then number seven is the same. Um, it's that parking associated with the retail and the residential use for for number five. [0:37:20, 0:37:28]: Now looking at this really quick, um, some of these areas, are those properties all owned by the city? [0:37:29, 0:37:35]: As I mentioned, there are a few that are not for the most part. Um one is in private ownership. [0:37:36, 0:37:46]: Um one here is in private ownership and then right here is private ownership. Everything else, uh these are all private. Those are not impacted, those existing. [0:37:46, 0:37:57]: But when you talk about future development, obviously, you see the the more intense uh yellow reflects uh proposed structures versus the existing structures. [0:37:59, 0:38:01]: Thank you, sir. You're welcome, ma'am. [0:38:02, 0:38:16]: Any other questions? It it I would my assumption is a development agreement would be similar to the development agreement that was agreed to and signed upon, like the British of Jotaco's would put this development agreement will probably consist of once it's down comes down to nuts and bolts there. [0:38:16, 0:38:36]: The development agreement that that you mentioned earlier would be similar to what we signed, agreed to assign for the Bridges of Jodico. That type of development agreement. It'll be an agreement that specifies what the developers shall do, what the city shall do, and how those those TAD funds will be expended for what specific uses. Okay. So for us it's gonna be [0:38:36, 0:38:40]: So if you look at those parking structures, [0:38:40, 0:38:47]: If you do the math, one parking space is about one structured parking space is about fi twenty five thousand. [0:38:47, 0:39:07]: So if you're looking at 300, that's roughly seven point something million dollars. Um so if you're doing three of them, do the math, that's twenty-one, almost twenty-one million dollars um for parking. And then you obviously you're gonna have to do some restructuring with some water lines, some sewer lines, making sure some new road uh roadway improvements as you. [0:39:07, 0:39:16]: You do the development. So we factored about seven and a half million for that. So roughly about 30 million of investment. But the overall project. [0:39:17, 0:39:22]: And when we did the math we did not include anything over at Burke or [0:39:22, 0:39:42]: Um MLK, so most of it would be on the three-acre side here and the existing areas that we own here as part of the amphitheater. Uh the developer I met with said I was actually using a more conservative 150. He said nope. This is gonna be in the area of 225. So I helped my conservative. [0:39:42, 0:40:02]: Conservative estimate to about 175 to 225 is what this project all in will be once constructed. Um to do your easy calculation on that, you would say 40% of$175 million to the math when that comes out. That's what's taxable value. [0:40:02, 0:40:05]: Yeah. [0:40:05, 0:40:20]: Then you times that number by the city, county, school board, millage, and that's the overall of what this project would pay, um, be in the area of roughly two point seven to two point nine million. [0:40:21, 0:40:41]: Then you can go to the bond market and you can use those funds to borrow for the parking structures. So that takes that off. But the development is paying its first year for the improvements. So that's how the TAD works. Okay. And realize that your house that you bid that you might have bought for$200,000. [0:40:41, 0:40:45]: two thousand today, tomorrow is gonna probably be worth a little bit more. [0:40:45, 0:40:50]: So that additional money's above that is where we negotiate with the school board. [0:40:50, 0:40:59]: And the county commissioners that they can get that money, we can s give them that money. Anything in excess thereof, we give back to them. [0:41:00, 0:41:03]: So right now recognize that none of this property is paying them [0:41:04, 0:41:08]: Zero property tax because it's owned by the city for the most part. So they're not getting anything. [0:41:09, 0:41:12]: So in essence to build this and to get the increment [0:41:13, 0:41:17]: Gives us an opportunity to build something, the other part that they don't get is sales tax. [0:41:17, 0:41:25]: So for all the transactions that happen as part of the retail use of this, right now that vacant track of property over there is paying the city and the county. [0:41:25, 0:41:27]: And the school board zero sales tax. [0:41:28, 0:41:29]: But if you build it [0:41:29, 0:41:44]: That sales tax gets splits up sixty-six to the county and to us and the different cities cause we all share in the sales tax revenues. Right? And that one penny sales tax goes for the schools, school board tax goes to the school board. [0:41:45, 0:41:49]: So everybody wins. Right now, the land that you see around you is paying [0:41:50, 0:41:53]: The city, the county, the school board, nothing zero dollars. [0:41:54, 0:42:00]: Absolutely nothing. And if you factor in for me who've been here too almost twenty five years. [0:42:01, 0:42:08]: It's the same downtown it's the same downtown from twenty five years ago that you see here today. So the likelihood that twenty five years from now anything will change? [0:42:09, 0:42:13]: is high unless we do something different. And that's my discussion with the school board. [0:42:14, 0:42:16]: Right? Einstein theory of insanity. [0:42:16, 0:42:19]: Doing the same thing over and over again, expecting a different result. [0:42:20, 0:42:23]: Right, we dare to do something different and expect a different outcome. [0:42:25, 0:42:45]: There no other questions and uh on that note. Thank you for the pres well wait a minute. I'm sorry, you don't need a vote on this tonight now, do you? No sir. I'm gonna wait to hear any com other comments you guys have and then um talk to me sh talk to my sherry Matthews. Okay. Um if so if you have any other questions, please just shoot me. Um I will answer those and I'm gonna get a clearer picture because it is actually [0:42:45, 0:43:05]: Clara. It's just photocopy of a photocopy. Does this. Um, I will email those over to you guys. Um and uh talk to Sherry, get a date. Once she gives me the date, uh, I will then share that with the council because obviously we all want to be there to support our downtown. Right. Right? So when we go, if we can't [0:43:05, 0:43:25]: Can please come to that meeting because it's important. And then when you get a date, otherwise you know backtrack and try to forget a some type of town hall or depending on that date, I'm gonna try to squeeze in a town hall meeting and have uh I'll print some of this stuff out so we'll have more renderings. Okay. For folks to be able to see. Yes. All right, thank you. On that note, no other questions, we'll move on. All right, thank you, sir. Uh [0:43:25, 0:43:36]: Uh let's see here. Council consideration to approve a resolution to increase the number of members on the citywide development authority from seven members to nine members. Mr. Washington, please. [0:43:43, 0:43:45]: Come to the mic could you come to mic please, sir? [0:43:58, 0:44:10]: Yes, as this would be to the Citywide Development Authority, we would change the we would change the legislation documents to be an ordinance for it to increase from seven to nine members, if that be the will of the council. [0:44:13, 0:44:13]: Okay. [0:44:14, 0:44:20]: So you said that that's an ordinance that we have to uh We would we would do an ordinance setting the number from seven to nine, yes. Okay. [0:44:22, 0:44:42]: Alrighty. Yes, sir. Go right ahead. You got a question, sir. Yeah, I I did receive and I think the council did receive a notice from uh the citywide development authority chair uh in asking for the number to be increased and and basically in agreement with that. So that being said, I think we should go. [0:44:41, 0:44:45]: Go ahead and move forward with it. [0:44:45, 0:44:46]: I do. So [0:44:49, 0:44:50]: What was the purpose given? [0:44:51, 0:44:53]: to increasing the number of board members. [0:44:55, 0:45:01]: Not aware. I was just asked to draft if that be you all's will from seven to nine. [0:45:01, 0:45:21]: Yeah. Okay, if you want to explain that I think I understand it. The reason where we had some exemplary candidates and that di we did not want to exclude because we got some people really that would add something to the board uh on both sides, and that was the what it was expressed to me from uh the the [0:45:21, 0:45:23]: board and Ms. Gantt. [0:45:25, 0:45:28]: Okay, any any other you good? Gentlemen on the side, any other questions, you good? [0:45:29, 0:45:31]: All right, so uh uh to do that I just need a motion. [0:45:32, 0:45:43]: Go ahead. I got one more quick, I'm sorry. So will this be the board with the largest amount of members? [0:45:45, 0:45:45]: I'm not sure. [0:45:46, 0:45:58]: I don't know, nine members, uh that's something probably asked as a clerk, yeah. Uh I'll respond to that uh mayor. No, the youth council advisory committee has twelve members. Okay, there you go. [0:45:58, 0:46:08]: Thank you. All right. I need a motion, ladies and gentlemen. So moved. Okay, is there a second? Second. Okay, Mr. Barrett, second that all in favor please indicate. She now she says, thank you very much. Appreciate it. Thank you. [0:46:10, 0:46:14]: Uh okay. Council consideration approved the contract with the lease [0:46:14, 0:46:20]: If I saw how we pronounce it, companies incorporated for one million nine hundred sixty dollars and three hundred and seventy [0:46:21, 0:46:32]: $1,960,$371.90. Request for qualification number$2023 0012 Civic Wayfinding Project. [0:46:34, 0:46:36]: Mr. Gardner, please. [0:46:36, 0:46:46]: Good night again, man council. Um as you know that we're here to present the uh the winner, the winning bid for the uh [0:46:46, 0:46:50]: Were you finding sign a program that that we approved uh [0:46:50, 0:46:51]: A year or two ago. [0:46:51, 0:46:56]: Uh we're now at that point where we've gone through we've hired Sky Design. Sky Design is [0:46:57, 0:46:59]: Laid out some wonderful designs for us. [0:47:00, 0:47:05]: Um that I think everybody's approved and now we're getting to the point where we need to have a fabricator. [0:47:06, 0:47:26]: Correct, Dominic, a fabricator that's gonna come on and and fabricate the signs and put the signs out for us. Um so that process, we went through the RFP process and D nice, I think is what it's called, the uh winner of the bid. Um and we work with them to get the bid down to what we see is uh one point nine. [0:47:26, 0:47:46]: million. We we are looking at programming this in phases. So we've budgeted as part of our APA funds are at roughly a hundred five hundred and seventy three thousand plus dollars um to get the project started. That'll get us through phase one and phase two, I think it is. [0:47:48, 0:48:08]: And in the meantime, whilst we're doing phase one and phase two, um we'll be working with Sky Design to get uh phase three permitted because as you know, some of this requires us to have way s wayfinding signs at uh interstate exits. So we need to get the we need to get GDOT approval on those. So they'll be working. [0:48:08, 0:48:11]: So everything will happen in phases, but those phases will be going. [0:48:12, 0:48:14]: concur to some degree with each other on the permitting side of it. [0:48:15, 0:48:35]: Um but the development side, phase one, phase two, and as it relates to completing the project, um obviously I I'll talk to you guys a little bit about this at our next meeting, but um we we'll probably have to use some of our SPLUS funds in the upcoming SPLUS, which uh numbers that we use originally was considered. [0:48:35, 0:48:55]: So I got some new numbers from Tim um at Locust Grove that reflects us getting a higher percentage. So we'll be able to do additional projects. So this would hopefully be one of those that we could continue to make sure we get the wayfinding sign program from start to finish. But Opera will start it and hopefully a year and a half from now. [0:48:55, 0:48:58]: Uh we can continue it with Splash Dollars. [0:48:58, 0:49:18]: You know, when when we first started this, obviously the um sixty seven hundred folks weren't annexed into the city at this point. So my assumption is and maybe I might have missed it, that now with going down this road, we've taken into account those those additional residents that we've now had for roughly a year and a half on where these signs would go on those thoroughfares to make sure that we [0:49:18, 0:49:35]: we we make sure we accomplish uh accomplishing those right amount of folks that are in the city and we have we don't cut them short in this aspect So yeah so the the s the wayfinding sign is in keeping with our news with our new districts, with our new city boundaries. Okay. Not the old one. [0:49:36, 0:49:51]: All right. And Dominic with Sky Design is here to kind of go through presentation. Yeah, yeah. Go ahead please. We don't have any pictures of this up. Uh surely we have some and again we could put that on the uh for folks to see it's exciting. [0:49:59, 0:50:19]: Thank you, Councilmember, for your time today. To Mr. Gardner's point, yes, we've completed the bid process and you've tentatively awarded the job to Denise Companies. They're one of uh the fabricators that we've partnered with multiple times on many different projects, including civic wayfinding projects. We're at a point now, and again to Mr. Gardner's point, we've [0:50:19, 0:50:34]: worked on this for just of just over a year at this point. We have a full program going uh to give you an idea of some of the sign types you can see here. Everything from massive gateway signs, which would welcome guests into the city of Stockbridge, down to more um [0:50:36, 0:50:45]: More of the minutiae of individual vehicular wayfinding signs, getting people throughout the city, directing them to city hall, some of your amenities, etc. Um [0:50:45, 0:50:51]: Dennis has been tentatively awarded the job. So the purpose that I am here today is to get your approval on [0:50:52, 0:51:12]: Their budgetary numbers. When they first submitted their bid, they were, and I'm gonna just fast forward real quick to this page, they were about$2.3 million. And we had been asked and tasked to find any sort of cost savings. So you see VE option one and two, essentially what we've done is taken some designs and changed how they would function. [0:51:12, 0:51:32]: Function to find cost savings. It's anything from going with real brick to a faux brick, or if we want to find additional costs, we can just do painted aluminum, changing how your logos might look. Where when we initially came into this, we had very beefy dimensional logos. We've simplified the process. It's why we usually partner. [0:51:32, 0:51:38]: With vendors like this, they can come in and say, your designs are great, but here's a better way to do it, and here's where you can find cost savings. [0:51:38, 0:51:48]: So we've broken this down into three categories, just showing you the original proposal, VE option one, and VE option two. [0:51:49, 0:51:59]: I'll just quickly go through the different options of VE. So here you see the bulk of your sign types. There are some smaller things missing like street signs, but [0:52:00, 0:52:20]: Up here is your primary gateway, secondary gateways, vehicular directional, and these two, while looking identical, are slightly different in appearance for parks versus buildings. Pedestrian kiosks, which would be maps from a pedestrian viewpoint, getting them throughout the streets to different eateries, regions. [0:52:20, 0:52:21]: Detail, etc. [0:52:22, 0:52:24]: Um some of the things we've looked at [0:52:24, 0:52:43]: A lot of our designs initially had a recessed accent, any of your green stripes. We've since looked at that where VE option one is a buildup of material rather than an elimination of material. VE option two simplifies it further with them just being masked and painted. [0:52:43, 0:53:03]: Other things we've looked at, as I just touched on, was going from real brick to faux brick. So what you see in this photo where my cursor is, is in fact foam that's carved and painted to look just like brick. And it's um Danais in particular is a really skilled at this. So additional way of finding that cost savings. If we wanted to reduce things further, [0:53:03, 0:53:10]: we can just do aluminum that's painted and that is an example here where this is just fabricated aluminum painted a certain color. [0:53:11, 0:53:20]: Um one of the biggest cost savings we found is just how we were creating your vehicular directional, um, just simplifying the process. So [0:53:21, 0:53:40]: All that to be said is we're looking to hit that budgetary number that you all feel comfortable with. I know with a lot of these things and just looking at what was being presented today, there's development going on. So we are by no means confined to what has been programmed and the messaging. Obviously you want this to function for the city as it grows. [0:53:40, 0:53:41]: So [0:53:41, 0:53:52]: The goal here today is just get a denice contracted, because then we can really get into the meat and bones of things, figuring out how we're gonna mount these things, how we're gonna fabricate them, and [0:53:53, 0:54:13]: we can reduce or add to the sign family as we go on as the city grows. So this is not gonna be a short process. I'm just gonna fast forward to the timeline to give you an understanding of Get let me let me stop you for a second. Oh sure. What's the most durable uh I I would assume I know the answer, but I'm gonna ask you, what's the most durable product to use for this? [0:54:13, 0:54:22]: Aluminum, absolutely. Any kind of aluminum aluminum, yeah. So just because these are all gonna be outside. They're gonna be dealing with any c weathering and you want also want this to be [0:54:24, 0:54:29]: You don't want to invest in this a year or two down the road. You want this to be ten plus years, so [0:54:29, 0:54:31]: Fabricated aluminum. [0:54:31, 0:54:32]: That's painted. [0:54:33, 0:54:37]: Coded in um usually the paint that we use is automotive grade, so it's [0:54:37, 0:54:40]: It's gonna give you the longevity you need. [0:54:40, 0:54:43]: Any kind of plastics, they're gonna yellow in the sun. [0:54:44, 0:54:47]: Extreme heats can actually cause degradation and warping. [0:54:48, 0:55:03]: metal's what's gonna hold up the strongest. Because I thought I thought the brick would be more durable, but you're you're you're So ah, for the bases, so this brick is i what we've initially proposed, and this is also going into G DOT regulations, is [0:55:04, 0:55:20]: The base of these, especially if they're off of the thoroughfare, couldn't be solid concrete brick bases. They want them to have some level of breakaway ability in case of a collision. If it was to be solid brick with CMU cores. [0:55:20, 0:55:24]: That's gonna cause some heavy damage to someone that c crashes into them. So that [0:55:25, 0:55:28]: What would if we were to go with a brick, it would be a brick veneer. [0:55:28, 0:55:33]: atta attached to an aluminum body and in within that aluminum body is some level of [0:55:34, 0:55:39]: breakaway where if it's a collision that happens, the bolts break away and it it tips over so it's not just [0:55:40, 0:55:41]: A hard hit. [0:55:41, 0:55:47]: And that's G dot regulations across the board. No matter any civic project we do, we have to have that regulation or that requirement. [0:55:48, 0:55:51]: It's so it's really more of from a decorative aesthetic. [0:55:51, 0:55:59]: Um, do you want it to be true brick? Do you want it to be faux brick? Where you can see here in this photo where my cursor is. [0:56:00, 0:56:01]: We can make it look like real brick. [0:56:02, 0:56:04]: Especially as you're driving by. [0:56:04, 0:56:11]: Uh for some of these heavy gateway signs, these are gonna be in areas where no one's really gonna be able to walk right up to them. [0:56:11, 0:56:31]: So can I interject for this? Let me just say this. Sell me on quantity on quality, not not the cheapest price. So no I I want to the the overall goal here, we like what we saw, which is we liked it with the what we were presented was the real brick. Now if you can make the [0:56:31, 0:56:51]: Faux brick, but I certainly wouldn't want to just go the cheap route and paint something aluminum, and that's not what we're trying to do. We're trying to send out that symbol of quality and excellence, and that's what brick represents. I certainly understand that it wouldn't be solid brick. Yeah. Because we have regulation against building a brick. [0:56:51, 0:57:11]: Brick mailbox along a roadway as well. But certainly, I certainly, speaking for myself, would certainly want to see the appearance of brick. And the reasoning that we talked about selecting that is that that brick base matched City Hall. It kind of spread it that same look that we've had here in the general downtown. [0:57:11, 0:57:26]: downtown area throughout the city. So safety certainly in terms of it being collapsible, but the appearance uh of speaking for me, I would want to see uh the brick appearance, uh certainly not not just the painted aluminum. [0:57:27, 0:57:46]: See break appearance also if the amphitheater, the same stuff with the amphitheater, that's how the amphitheater looks like City Hall. We wanted that the same concept. Uh gentlemen, you got some you good down here? Good uh down Miss Barber, you got any questions right now? I do. Um I don't necessarily object to the break, but [0:57:47, 0:57:53]: All these signs won't be positioned near the amphitheater. So I'm not [0:57:54, 0:58:04]: opposed to aluminum either. My concern is maintenance and warranty of these. Um would that be under the contract for [0:58:04, 0:58:24]: This particular vendor, Denise? Okay Denise would be the holder of that warranty. I apologize that I don't know off the top of my head the length of their warranty. Um, but with any job I've ever worked on them there is some level of warranty involved and they have always stood by their quality. So if there's any kind of issues that come up within the first couple of years they're [0:58:25, 0:58:29]: Вей, ви воді не верта ніво. [0:58:30, 0:58:33]: uh Stockbridge or any other uh of our clients with [0:58:34, 0:58:45]: a vendor without integrity. So uh I can tell you firsthand that I've been working with DNIS on a civic wayfinding project for the Cumberland area, and they have been an excellent partner. [0:58:45, 0:58:49]: Um they've held my hand in a lot of instances. So [0:58:50, 0:58:52]: What I can tell you is we'd never stick you with someone who isn't [0:58:53, 0:59:07]: gonna be the right person to do this with. As far as phobic versus real big brick, that's that's interesting because it's uh it's a point of contention. If my superior Tiffany Chen was here, she would tell you don't go with phobic. She's a big, she's not a fan of phobic. [0:59:07, 0:59:26]: But if it's in the right vendors' hands, they can make it look like real brick. So it really kind of comes down to like your desire for real brick versus the price associated with it. As you can see, um now this cost savings isn't entirely from moving from a brick veneer to faux brick, but [0:59:26, 0:59:27]: You're probably gonna find [0:59:28, 0:59:33]: Roughly a hundred and fifty thousand dollars worth of savings, give or take. I could get you the exact number. [0:59:34, 0:59:37]: Nothing is gonna replace real brick. It's got a good look. [0:59:38, 0:59:43]: Though we can be selective in what signs we do that for, because as I said earlier, some of these signs [0:59:43, 0:59:49]: You're not gonna be able to walk up close to it. You're gonna be driving by at high speeds if they're off of I seventy five. You're gonna be traveling. [0:59:49, 0:59:53]: Anywhere from sixty to seventy miles per hour. So you're gonna see it like that, but [0:59:54, 0:59:55]: You're not gonna have the time to really [0:59:56, 1:00:10]: study and absorb the the the finish. Now some of those wayfinding signs that might be adjacent to a red light, some of the pedestrian kiosks, those we might want to invest in the brick veneer because people are actually going to get up to it, potentially touch it, etc. So [1:00:11, 1:00:12]: Once we get [1:00:13, 1:00:18]: A vendor contracted, these are all explor explorations we can [1:00:18, 1:00:19]: delve into what the [1:00:21, 1:00:26]: right material is for the right location. Because this is a robust wayfinding project. You guys have [1:00:27, 1:00:35]: Thirty-four vehicular directionals, and that's just a single sign type. We have street signs, stop signs, park signs, building signs. [1:00:36, 1:00:39]: It's getting people throughout the entire city of Stockbridge. [1:00:39, 1:00:40]: Yeah. [1:00:40, 1:00:43]: Yeah, go Mr. Barrett, go ahead, please. [1:00:43, 1:00:44]: With the full grid. [1:00:44, 1:00:45]: Yes, sir. [1:00:45, 1:01:05]: And you're talking about putting it in places that's not readily accessible like the uh ones on the street. So I'm I'm guessing you're talking about like the overpass of the interstate. Yeah. How would weather and wind come into play with phobic in those particular settings? Like with with being elevated and and exposed to greater amounts of sun. [1:01:05, 1:01:10]: More wind, more trucks, more traffic, stuff like that. [1:01:10, 1:01:25]: What would phobic look like in a situation like that? If we were having this conversation ten years ago, I would say it's it's might not be the best, but technology's come quite far and a lot of the phobic is carved and then coated in very durable clear coats to give it a rigidity and [1:01:26, 1:01:26]: I mean [1:01:28, 1:01:36]: It's gonna hold up um just as long as phobic. There's gonna be different levels of degradation. You know, if someone picks that phobic, if they really get in there, [1:01:36, 1:01:40]: They're gonna be piercing into the foam. Same thing with brick though, if anyone [1:01:41, 1:01:45]: You know, that that can weather over time. Moisture gets in and expansion happens. [1:01:46, 1:01:48]: It's kind of six in one hand, half a dozen in another. [1:01:48, 1:01:49]: But [1:01:50, 1:01:55]: Neither of which are gonna be falling apart within the first couple of years. Like they're they're gonna be holding up it it [1:01:58, 1:02:00]: Vandalism and any kind of [1:02:01, 1:02:13]: Things like that are is gonna be the real problem child rather than weathering. Yeah, like the like the p so graffiti artists and stuff. So we put these really, really nice signs up over the interstate, they're phobic, and somebody comes and [1:02:14, 1:02:32]: Yep. Cancel. How do we get it back? So we could there are things we can go um and put into place. We can coat these things. And now it's it's not priced accordingly, but we can coat those things in like a a cr there's basically graffiti guards where it it's so you can power wash it right off. [1:02:33, 1:02:43]: It's none of them are gonna just like the paint's not gonna melt off. There'll still be some level of legwork required. Someone's gonna have to go out there and and hose things down, maybe do a little bit of scrubbing, but we can put [1:02:44, 1:02:45]: Um [1:02:47, 1:02:50]: Protection in place to mitigate. [1:02:50, 1:02:52]: That that. [1:02:52, 1:02:53]: Okay. [1:02:53, 1:03:09]: Okay. That and that you know, that's an interesting point, Council Melberry, because that might be an advocation for why you wanna go with this over here with painted aluminum. I know you're sacrificing the brick look, but it's a lot easier for someone to come in and just slap a coat of paint over it versus [1:03:09, 1:03:20]: Power washing brick or faux brick. So so there's it's a pro and con to everything. Yeah, it's not a black and white answer in this as far as like what's the right course. It's we kind of have to look at [1:03:20, 1:03:31]: many different things. And and these are all explorations we can do throughout the process. It's it's by no means we're awarding this to the genice and they're gonna start digging, you know, getting shovels into the ground. [1:03:32, 1:03:40]: They have to do their due diligence and make sure and f figure out a lot of how these things are going to be mounted and and installed. So um [1:03:41, 1:03:44]: And we have to go through permitting with GDOT. It's gonna be a lengthy process. [1:03:45, 1:03:57]: It's more to what what this conversation is about is to just get the next step going. We can't really make any moves until we have a vendor under contract. And no vendor's gonna make any moves until they have a contract. [1:03:59, 1:04:00]: Mr Thomas, go ahead, please. [1:04:00, 1:04:08]: Y you you sorta answered my question and you sort of alluded to as far as depending on the location [1:04:10, 1:04:20]: that may dictate the material that we may use. So and you just mentioned also um [1:04:20, 1:04:40]: When the contractor come on board, we can start to get into those kind of discussions. So you sort of already answered my question and I think this is where we may drill down a little deeper into the material depending on location of and that particular signage. So I guess we just have to just wait till we get to that point for that discussion. [1:04:40, 1:04:43]: and get into I guess material that would be used, I guess. [1:04:44, 1:04:45]: Yeah, I think that's [1:04:46, 1:04:53]: Really the best course of action is even just seeing what was presented here today with the possible development going on uh adjacent to City Hall. [1:04:54, 1:05:01]: That is gonna impact possibly the amount of wayfinding signs we have proposed already. It's certainly gonna impact the copy, so [1:05:02, 1:05:12]: nothing's quite concrete simply because we wanna shift this and mold it to be right for the city before we actually start building things. [1:05:12, 1:05:15]: Follow up question, Mayor. [1:05:15, 1:05:20]: With this discussion today, what is it that you need from us today? [1:05:21, 1:05:27]: Um we are looking for you to approve Denise as your selected vendor. [1:05:27, 1:05:47]: approve their proposed number. So that's where we came in. We were tasked with coming up with some VE solutions. Their initial budget while was more preferential to the other vendors and their proposal in general, we were still asked to find additional cost savings. So [1:05:49, 1:05:58]: Denise isn't officially contracted. We're basically looking to show you, like, here's what we can do with the numbers. Do you feel comfortable with these? Do you want to move forward? And then [1:05:59, 1:06:18]: What budgetary number do you want to contact them at? So so the number really could change depending on the material that will be used as we go forward, the numbers could change. The number can change from material. The number can also change once we actually start digging in the ground, especially for those things off uh for the major gateway signs, that being um [1:06:20, 1:06:40]: This big honker here, you could see it's thirty feet tall. It's by no means a small sign. It's gonna be right in the middle of the two different directions on an I seventy-five. We don't know truly what's underground until someone starts digging in there. I'll give you just a quick antidote with Cumberland. Um we're working through some issues where location [1:06:40, 1:06:56]: Location was great, design's great, we start digging and it is nothing but rock underneath. So we have to bore into it. We've had to change how the foundation goes. I'm not alluding to that being a possibility here. The ground which with we've proposed this location is much more planar. [1:06:57, 1:06:58]: Little m more straightforward, but [1:06:59, 1:07:04]: I also don't know what's going on from a subterranean level until someone is in there with an excavator. So [1:07:05, 1:07:10]: I want to set the expectations that while we have budgetary numbers. [1:07:11, 1:07:22]: That meter could tip one way or another. It could be in your favor where, hey, things are going great, or we've omitted some signs, or we've simplified the process and you find cost savings. There could be change orders on the other end where [1:07:22, 1:07:34]: Hey, we're trying to install this and we're dealing with some issues or there's nothing but power lines and water lines underneath here. What do we do? Uh we've had to re reroute some things. It's [1:07:35, 1:07:40]: It's unfortunately the nature of the beast for a signed proposal this large. Right. Thank you. [1:07:40, 1:07:44]: Okay. Any other questions on this side? Anybody else? Ms. Barber Goy, please. [1:07:45, 1:07:48]: I'd ask Mr. Gardner if he could um [1:07:49, 1:08:09]: See if he find information on the maintenance or warranty of the contract that denies I see that they are a small business, women own business. I see their certificate from the city of Atlanta in here. That's a good thing. They are and they're also a multi generational um [1:08:09, 1:08:29]: Company, I believe. I don't know if it's onto the second or third generation, but Mark Danice is the son of. I apologize, I forget the original owner's name, but it's been in the family for I think 50 plus years. They are a small business in comparison to some of the larger corporations that are here in the city of Georgia, the state of Georgia. [1:08:29, 1:08:30]: Georgia but [1:08:30, 1:08:38]: As far as sign fabricators go, they're probably top three in the state of capabilities and quality and reputation. [1:08:39, 1:08:47]: Um so yeah, we will have to dig up the exact warranty scope for you. Um but what I can vouch for is the level of [1:08:48, 1:08:50]: The reputation. It [1:08:50, 1:08:55]: I I've never had an issue working with them and I'm on project probably nine or ten working with them. [1:08:55, 1:09:01]: Now the um the third option um with I guess that's the aluminum. [1:09:02, 1:09:07]: Yeah, so it's it's a kind of a mix of things. The the third option with the the one point nine million dollars is uh [1:09:08, 1:09:12]: Taking these accents, making them just painted stripes. [1:09:12, 1:09:15]: Taking your brick, making it painted aluminum. [1:09:15, 1:09:20]: Taking your dimensional logo where it's kind of like big beefy pieces that are overlapping each other. [1:09:21, 1:09:35]: to more standoffs, flatter pieces, but you still get a dimensional look. And that would be that would come into play for any instances where my cursor is where you have that stock bridge logo mark. We've just tweaked how that is built. And then [1:09:35, 1:09:38]: This is the side view of your [1:09:39, 1:09:43]: uh directional wayfinding sign, vehicular wayfinding sign. [1:09:43, 1:09:48]: So we have this kind of curved accent that used to be much thicker, about a little over an inch. [1:09:48, 1:10:08]: We've reduced that to just flat material, and that has actually ended up being one of the largest cost savings. So whether we're looking at VE option one or two, that is in both of them because it's just been such a substantial cost savings. And that that is really where we looked at the cost savings. Anything else. [1:10:08, 1:10:20]: Um Councilmember Barber, we can find other ways of saving money, but it's going to be far less impactful than the options we're presenting here. Or we might be able to save$5,000 from [1:10:22, 1:10:23]: Taking your [1:10:23, 1:10:33]: i if it says um memorial park, instead of the letters being dimensional and thick, we can mask and paint them. Like we can find cost savings there, but it's going to be [1:10:35, 1:10:36]: Pennies compared to [1:10:37, 1:10:38]: Dollars that we've found. [1:10:39, 1:10:47]: Well I know that um staff has recommended the one point nine million dollar offer option, this option three. Correct. [1:10:47, 1:10:48]: Okay. [1:10:49, 1:10:51]: I prefer to stay within [1:10:51, 1:10:54]: Staff's recommendation, um, just so that we're [1:10:55, 1:10:56]: Within budget. [1:10:56, 1:10:57]: Sure. [1:10:58, 1:11:01]: Thank you. Mr Gardner, were you able to find anything? [1:11:05, 1:11:25]: Mr. Please. Let me just say this. I I don't want to go with the cheapest options. We've spent a long time working on this program to get it right. Now, I've gone to different developments. You know, yeah, we can say that the painted signs look good, but those individual letters stand out. [1:11:24, 1:11:44]: They are there for a reason. They represent quality and what they are. Now, certainly I think what we could just do today is approve a number up to. And then as Councilman Thomas indicated, uh, when we got in with the the actual developer, we could tweak it to when um [1:11:44, 1:12:04]: uh the specific locations and that kind of thing. Cause trying to solve that right now, I don't think that's gonna be any of our capabilities. So I think we could probably approve a number up to not to exceed that could include some brick and faux brick and then we would adjust it uh once we got to working with uh the actual vendor. [1:12:05, 1:12:10]: Okay. Any other questions, thoughts? On that note then, sir, did you want to make a motion? [1:12:10, 1:12:30]: Okay, so uh give me a give me a motion uh certainly give me a number where I can have s some of the uh that you think there would be a combination of the brick and the faux brick uh combinations that we would be able to use and of course we that would give us an opportunity to do that. It doesn't exclude going down. [1:12:30, 1:12:48]: I wanna have a number that can get me the the very best, but at the same time it offers a options for some cost savings with some phobic and possibly s even some aluminum. But uh give me that number that we can go up to. We know that we're not gonna exceed that number. Uh well there's a option B, I guess you said. [1:12:49, 1:12:52]: Yeah, option B is a little over l a little over two million dollars, I think it is. [1:12:53, 1:13:01]: Option B is a little more than two million if I see that right. Option B two th two million three hundred and twenty five thousand. That's full brick everything. [1:13:01, 1:13:21]: That's full brick everything, correct. Okay, so if I got full brick everything, I mean full brick, I got I got a lot of brick. I added some full brick and I saved a little room for uh possibly some aluminum. What where would that put me at? That'll probably put me between those two numbers. Yeah, I was I was gonna say maybe like two point one four. [1:13:21, 1:13:41]: five if I was kind of split the difference. And again this is gonna be um not really a hard line so we can it's as we get into the nitty gritty things. Um another consideration too is how we phase this. I know when Mr. Garden we're not doing it all at one time. So we we're doing the initial phase right you said five hundred thousand so is that [1:13:41, 1:14:01]: That's what we're really going up to. We'll uh the program uh over time will be funded by SPLOS, T SPLOS, several other providers, grants that we come through. But right now we're saying that we want to move through with this project. So I think that will probably be the best thing to do. You said two point one five? Yes, sir. Okay. So I'll make the [1:14:01, 1:14:13]: motion for two po up to two point one five understanding that we will get into greater detail when we have the f uh the um provider uh provide us with the information. So second emotion. [1:14:14, 1:14:17]: Mr. Berry Secondan, any further discussion? [1:14:17, 1:14:19]: If not all in favor of motion please indicate. [1:14:20, 1:14:21]: Couples. [1:14:22, 1:14:29]: Okay, so it passes three one zero. May I add a comment? Um I think it's important that we stay within the budget. [1:14:29, 1:14:30]: Um [1:14:30, 1:14:33]: This particular project is being funded through ARPA. [1:14:34, 1:14:45]: We all received a account balance for our ARPA funding. Um we have not with this vote um given staff a directive on [1:14:45, 1:14:52]: The overage, everything beyond the one point nine that was originally recommended from ARPA. [1:14:53, 1:14:57]: didn't designate which account they would pull the excess from. [1:14:59, 1:15:00]: I'm concerned about the overspending. [1:15:02, 1:15:09]: But nonetheless, I oppose for that reason. Thank you, sir, for your presentation. Appreciate it. Thank you all. Have a great evening. [1:15:12, 1:15:32]: What we have next are upcoming events and uh committee events things here. Council meeting will be held in the city council chamber noting some of the board and committee meetings will continue to take place via Zoom. Meeting dates and times are subject to change. Please visit the city's website at WWW, City of Stockbridge.com for the meeting invitation link, Facebook. [1:15:32, 1:15:52]: Page or contact City Hall offices 770-389-7900 for updates. Start Bridge Citizens Police Advisory Council meeting is the first Thursday of each month at 6 p.m. at the Startbridge Police Community Room, 4545 North Henry Boulevard, which is June 6th. City Council meeting is second Monday of each. [1:15:52, 1:16:03]: month at six p.m. city hall council chambers june tenth. Use uh council meeting second Monday of each month at six thirty p.m. City Hall Levi Meeting Room June tenth. Says it's been canceled. [1:16:04, 1:16:24]: Okay, Citywide Development Authority meeting, second Tuesday of each month, 6 p.m. City Hall Levi Meeting Room, June 11th. The Main Street Advisory Board meeting, second Friday of each month at 9 a.m. location with the Downtown Connection Center, 130 ML King Senior Heritage Trail, which is June 14th. Downtown Development Authority meeting is [1:16:24, 1:16:44]: Third Tuesday of each month. Welcome Center 130 ML King Senior Heritage Trail June 18th. Youth Council Advisory Community Meeting, 6:30 p.m. Third Tuesday of each month. Levi meeting room at City Hall, June 18th. Planning Commission meeting is third Thursday of each month at 6:30 p.m. in City Hall Council. [1:16:44, 1:17:04]: Council Chambers of June, June 20th. City Council Work Session Meeting Special Meeting Date Wednesday, June 26th at 6 p.m. City Hall Council Chambers, which is on once again June 26th. Upcoming city events and initiatives, Food Truck Tasty Tuesday, which is going on right now. Join us at Clark Park at the one in one one David's [1:17:04, 1:17:24]: Road, Stockbridge, on Tuesdays from 5:30 p.m. to 8 p.m. for live music, great food, and a host of free games and activities for the kids. Join Councilwoman Yolanda Barber for the inaugural Final Art of this Day brunch, honoring the manifestation manifestation of greatness. This event will take place on Sunday, June 2nd from 2 p.m. to 5 p.m. at Merrima. [1:17:24, 1:17:44]: Conference Center at Stockbridge. Join Councilman Alfonso Thomas for the monthly senior bingo bash on Wednesday, June 12th, 10 a.m. to 12 uh noon at Mermanus Conference Center, 111 Davis Road for Raffles, Prizes, Games, Snacks, and F. Bring Kid's out for the annual Main Street movie night, uh, which is at Clark Park. [1:17:43, 1:18:03]: Friday, June 14th. Free games and uh activities starting at 6 p.m. Featured movies starting at uh sundown. Join Councilman Elton Alzena for District Five Town Hall Meeting on Saturday, June 15th. Location to be announced on that. Yes, sir. The location has been confirmed. It'll be at Argento. [1:18:03, 1:18:09]: Uh we'll have it there at the uh at the Argento Bridges at uh at Jodico. [1:18:09, 1:18:29]: Outstanding. Uh join the city of Stockbridge for the annual Juneteenth celebration on Wednesday, June 19th from 5 to 9 p.m. at the Stockbridge Amphitheater. There will be unique food and art vendors, food uh fun activities for the kids and DJ and live performances. Joins Councilmember Lakeisha Gantt for in partnership with Atlanta Food Truck Park. [1:18:29, 1:18:49]: For the night market at Stockbridge Ampathy parking lot from 6 p.m. to 9 30 p.m. is on on the third Thursday of each month or for the next event. And then uh that's what's happening on June 20th. There will be vendors, food trucks, activities, games, music, and vibes. Contact Tan Bowers at Tan at Atlanta.com. [1:18:49, 1:19:09]: of foodtruckpark.com for registration and additional information. Join Mayor Anthony Ford for the monthly Meet the Mayor on Wednesday, June 26th at 10 a.m. to 12 noon at Stockbridge City Hall. Save the date for the city of Stockbridge 4th of July Extravaganza with fireworks and live music. Gates open at 3 p.m. The concert featured soul cartel [1:19:09, 1:19:09]: Yeah. [1:19:09, 1:19:29]: Uh Algebra Blessette, Bobby V, and a Michael Jackson live tribute will take place from 5 p.m. to nine p.m. at Stockbridge Amphitheater. Save the days for the councilman, uh Councilmember Yelana Barber. Once again is partnering with Kick for Kids to collect shoes on Saturday, July 6th and Sunday, July 7th at the Stockbridge First United Methodist Church. [1:19:29, 1:19:49]: Please plan to donate what you can for this life-changing initiative. Join Council Member Thomas for the Don't Trash Stockbridge Initiative centered around education highlighting the causes and effects of littering and illegal dumping. More information to follow on that. And once again join Council Member Member Thomas and honoring veterans. [1:19:49, 1:20:09]: All year long, please send your pictures of veterans and their names, branch, rank, and years of service. Contact Roslyn Rawls to schedule an appointment with the meeting mayor for more information on Council Nift's and events. Uh call Roslin at six seven eight-eight three three-three three four eight or by way of email ralls at stopbridgega.org. [1:20:09, 1:20:29]: The 2024 Star Braze Amphithe Amphitheater Council series and uh actually we had a great uh Memorial Day series uh that just occurred with Zap, uh Brig James, Stone City Band, Evelyn Champaign King, and Rolls Royce. Fantastic concert. This next concert [1:20:29, 1:20:49]: Is uh Saturday, June 8th, uh with TLC's uh TLC celebrating the 30th anniversary of a crazy sexy cool album with special grants to Brownstone. And Brownstone was with us last year, the Gracious Days last year with us. Saturday, July 6th, Karen Briggs Contemple Orchestra featuring Phil Perry, Olita J. Adams. [1:20:49, 1:20:58]: Regina Bell, okay, Shechilla Montessucki, Jasmine Gyat, Brian Bloomberg, and Tommy Davison. [1:20:59, 1:21:19]: Okay, that's Sunday, July 7th, the end of the Fourth of July weekend featuring Charlie Wilson and uh and and this gentleman named uh Robin Thick. Uh Robin Thick's gonna join Charlie uh on Sunday, July 7th. Saturday, July 13th and Sunday, July 14th, the night with Kim and uh special guest Lisa James. [1:21:19, 1:21:23]: And Saturday, July 20th, Ladies Night Out, featuring Jodice, Johnny Gill, and Silk. [1:21:25, 1:21:45]: Saturday, July 27th, the 70 Soul Jam featuring Shine Lights, Manhattan's Legendary Blue Notes, Bloodstone, and Peach and the Herb. And then Saturday, August 3rd, uh will be Babyface with special guests, Avery Sunshine, and the four and four casts. On that note, uh my comments once again deal with [1:21:45, 1:22:05]: Well that actually we had a great Memorial Day uh weekend and uh our Memorial Day walk was uh changed because of thunderstorm and rain. So we had everything at Murray Manos Conference Center and it worked well for the amount of folks that showed up on the on this dreary, rainy, sunshiney type of day. And so uh once again for Memorial Day weekend, we have to remember that's really honoring the people that we're gonna do. [1:22:05, 1:22:25]: Gave the ultimate sacrifice, their lives for the freedom, the freedoms that we have in our country. So continue to keep those individuals all year long in your in your minds and support those families that lost those loved ones protecting our country. And that is all my uh notes at this point. And as far as I know, we have no executive session. So if that's the case, uh council I [1:22:25, 1:22:28]: So moved. Is there a second? [1:22:29, 1:22:32]: Uh Mr Berry, second from Alexander, Mr Berry, all in favor please indicate. [1:22:33, 1:22:35]: We are now adjourned. God bless ya.
  • 2024-05-16 · City Council · Transcript · Planning Commission

    2024-05-16 · City Council · Transcript · source: 10yr-transcripts · sha256 3e6be1f3 · pages – · method: official

    Full text — searchable
    --- title: Planning Commission date: 2024-05-16 source: 2024-05-16_Planning_Commission.wav --- [0:02:37, 0:02:43]: And um stick one. [0:02:54, 0:02:58]: Hey, how you doing? Good. How you doing? [0:03:28, 0:03:33]: It is now six thirty. The planning commission meeting would now come to order. [0:03:37, 0:03:40]: We'll have invocation by Mr Matthew Thomas. [0:03:41, 0:04:01]: Third is the Lord's and the forteness thereof. And dear Father, we thank you for this wonderful day you have given us. We thank you for this great privilege to come and make decisions on behalf of our city. We thank you for all the leaders of our city. And God, we are praying that you will bless us. We go forth, bless each and every individual here and their families respectively. [0:04:01, 0:04:05]: Give you all the honor and praise in Jesus' name. Amen. [0:04:06, 0:04:08]: That's stand for the pledge. [0:04:14, 0:04:26]: Pledge allegiance to the United States in America and to the Republic which is one nation, indivisible with liberty and justice all. [0:04:33, 0:04:35]: Madam Secretary, I roll call, please. [0:04:40, 0:04:41]: Anthony Mitten. [0:04:41, 0:04:42]: Present. [0:04:45, 0:04:46]: Jaden Williams. [0:04:49, 0:04:56]: Stanley Doomis. Present. Harold Dibotho. Present. David Planchin. Present. [0:05:03, 0:05:05]: Matthew Thomas. President. [0:05:06, 0:05:07]: Thank you. [0:05:22, 0:05:28]: Thank you, Madam Secretary. I presume we have a quorum. So we shall continue. [0:05:30, 0:05:33]: I need a motion please to adopt the agenda. [0:05:35, 0:05:36]: You like [0:05:38, 0:05:41]: Mrs. Harrow, I'd like to present a motion that we adopt the agenda. [0:05:41, 0:05:42]: I'll talk about it. [0:05:43, 0:05:50]: been m moved by Mr. Thibodeau and second by Mr. Planchon that we adopt the agenda. [0:05:50, 0:05:58]: All in favor, let it be known by the sound of aye. Aye. Any opposed? I have it. The agenda is adopted. [0:06:02, 0:06:07]: You have before you the minutes from the april eighteenth meeting. [0:06:09, 0:06:13]: If you haven't already done so, I d ask that you peruse the minutes. [0:06:14, 0:06:20]: For any necessary corrections, if if you have any, would you make those now, please? [0:06:38, 0:06:42]: I need a motion to approve the minutes from the April eighteenth meeting, please. [0:06:43, 0:06:47]: Chairman, I make the motion to approve the minutes. [0:06:47, 0:06:55]: It's been moved and properly second that we approve the minutes on the April eighteenth meeting. All in favor, let it be known by the sound of I. [0:06:55, 0:06:56]: [416.6, 418.2]: In your polls. [0:06:58, 0:07:00]: Does have it. The minutes are approved. [0:07:05, 0:07:15]: Next item on the agenda is a text amendment case, TX 2024-04 for housing shelters citywide. [0:07:16, 0:07:36]: The City of Stockbridge Mayor and City Council will hold a public hearing on Monday, June 10th, 2024, at 6 p.m. in the Stockbridge City Hall, located at 4640 North Henry Boulevard, Stockbridge, Georgia, to consider a proposed text amendment. [0:07:36, 0:07:40]: through the Stockbridge Unified Development Code, UDC. [0:07:41, 0:08:01]: To allow for the location of various types of housing shelters within the C two General Commercial, C three heavy commercial, and OI Office Industri Institutional and Lied Light Industrial Zoning Districts at special uses. [0:08:01, 0:08:07]: Requiring the approval of a special use permit through the public hearing process. [0:08:12, 0:08:15]: The case is to be presented by staff. Thank you. [0:08:16, 0:08:17]: Greetings board. [0:08:19, 0:08:37]: So before you, as read in the record, we are presenting a test amendment for specialized housing facility. And what this test amendment will do is allow for housing for um those that are homeless or looking for a um [0:08:38, 0:08:55]: that are going through an economic hardship in uh finding housing. And what we designed this test amendment to do is allow for this type of facility in certain zoning districts, such as C two, C three, O I, and L I. [0:08:56, 0:09:16]: So if you turn to the third page, exhibit A, um, that goes into the definition of specialized housing facility, I'm going to read in the record the definition of such facility. So it is a shelter, home, a refuge for those in urgent need or in times of [0:09:16, 0:09:36]: Of emergency. It is designed to provide temporary living accommodations to individuals or families who are experiencing homelessness in general. The facility may provide for overnight safe and secure environment for persons who may be experiencing financial difficulties, domestic, [0:09:36, 0:09:49]: Abuse or other challenges. This does not include substance abuse centers, personal care homes, boarding homes, and group homes. There are different types of housing shelters. [0:09:49, 0:09:53]: So there's a type tier one, tier two, and tier three. [0:09:53, 0:10:04]: So tier one states a shelter providing homelessness services whose primary purpose is to provide temporary shelter for no more than thirty days. [0:10:05, 0:10:25]: Tier two states a shelter providing homelessness services whose primary purpose is to provide temporary shelter for no more than six months. And the last tier three states a shelter providing homelessness services whose primary purpose is to provide temporary shelter for no more than a year. [0:10:24, 0:10:32]: So this language will be placed in the section 5.2 of our UDC. And um as you [0:10:33, 0:10:37]: Listen to me read that into the record. That's how it will read into our code. [0:10:38, 0:10:58]: If you go to letter B that states housing shelter as a permitted use, this will affect sections 2.4.6, 2.4.9, and 2.4.10 of the UDC. So it will be amended to add specialized housing facilities. [0:10:58, 0:11:12]: It's a permitted use under OI, which is official institutional, C2, General Commercial, C three heavy commercial districts, respectfully. And I failed to mention L I. [0:11:13, 0:11:30]: W which is light industrial. Um, the use table 3.1, section 3.1 will also be amended to add specialized housing facility in the list of specialized housing facilities as a special use permit, um, requiring a special use permit. [0:11:31, 0:11:51]: And for those that are not aware what a special use permit, um, that is a zoning request um to have a a special type of use. It requires a public hearing, so they will have to go before uh community zoning meetings as well as planning commission and the [0:11:51, 0:11:56]: last stop will be city council. So city council will have the final vote. [0:11:57, 0:12:17]: Now, if you look at section D, supplemental regulations that will affect section 3.2.17. So that section speaks to nursing homes, assisted living, hospice care facilities. We're planning to modify that section to include [0:12:17, 0:12:28]: special specialized housing facilities in the caption and in the table. And that additional row will be added to the table to require a 50-foot buffer. [0:12:29, 0:12:33]: When when specialized housing facilities are located adjacent to [0:12:34, 0:12:42]: uh rural residential, suburban residential, CCR, MFR, and RMH zoning districts. [0:12:44, 0:12:47]: Number two states the section for [0:12:47, 0:13:07]: 3.2.26 under supplemental use regulations will also be modified, and there will be um supplemental regulations that one will have to follow in order to be a specialized housing facility. And they read one in addition to required setbacks, a minimum. [0:13:07, 0:13:27]: A 50-foot-wide buffer shall be required along all property lines, which abut a residential district or use to provide a visual screen. B The specialized housing facility is not located within one mile of another homeless shelter. C One must meet [0:13:27, 0:13:38]: meet all regulations as identified and ad um adopted by our building code and adopted by the fire code. So they will have to meet those regulations. [0:13:42, 0:13:49]: D um all facility must apply for and receive a business license. [0:13:51, 0:14:11]: No more than 40 beds are um are to be maintained within the shelter. So they cannot have no more than 40 beds. F no alcoholic beverages or controlled substances are stored, served, sold, consumed, or in the possession of any person in the shelter. [0:14:11, 0:14:27]: G, the homeless shelter provides on-site parking and or a drop off space to adequ adequate to meet the needs as adequate to meet the needs of proposed facility, provided, however, that any modifications to the existing parking are [0:14:27, 0:14:33]: or drop off area will not increase the overall square footage of the existing area. [0:14:34, 0:14:35]: H. [0:14:35, 0:14:53]: The agency or organization must be registered through the Georgia Department of Community Affairs in the HUD Continuum of Care Program, Permanent Supportive Housing Program, or related State of Georgia Homelessness Services Program. [0:14:53, 0:15:02]: The facility, I the facility must maintain adequate trash service to prevent the accumulation of waste on the premises. [0:15:02, 0:15:14]: J. An operable telephone is maintained and readily available in the shelter, provided that in the event of an emergency or physical altercation, the city shall be immediately contacted. [0:15:15, 0:15:28]: And the last, which is K, is laudering, camping, sleeping, et cetera, on the sidewalks is prohibited and such shelter shall ensure compliance with the City of Stockbridge ordinance regulations. [0:15:28, 0:15:33]: So that completes my presentation on specialized housing facilities. [0:15:36, 0:15:37]: Thank you, Miss Jackson. [0:15:39, 0:15:42]: Are there questions there from the commission? [0:15:42, 0:15:44]: Yes, I do. A couple of questions, please. [0:15:46, 0:15:56]: So um just out of curiosity, is this being driven by a homeless prop problem in the city and how many potential shelters could be built? [0:15:56, 0:15:57]: Or do we have a number? [0:15:58, 0:16:06]: So there's not a specific number. They have to be at least a mile apart. So depending on that um [0:16:07, 0:16:16]: The distance will pretty much determine um but again they have to come before the board to get uh the approval to operate. [0:16:17, 0:16:37]: Also um there there isn't much available land in those districts, so uh we don't envision there being um more than three or four at the max. Uh and yes, it it is to deal with the problem of housing encampments in the city of Stockbridge. [0:16:37, 0:16:39]: That's w that is what precipitated this ordinance. [0:16:40, 0:16:41]: Well, this text amendment. [0:16:42, 0:16:43]: That's what's behind it. [0:16:44, 0:16:45]: Thank you. [0:16:48, 0:17:00]: Any of the questions? Uh may I speak, Mr. Chairman? Go right ahead, sir. Uh I notice uh you didn't mention anything about weapons. Uh no restriction as far as weapons are concerned in here. [0:17:01, 0:17:05]: Uh you did everything uh as far as laundering and [0:17:05, 0:17:25]: And different things, camping, but there was nothing mentioned about weapons. We have a issue with weapons right now. This should have been included in the in the in the document, but we will add it to make sure that it that it is in the final version. This is just the draft. So any recommendations that um that the planning commission makes tonight, we will we will include it in [0:17:25, 0:17:29]: in the final draft. So if you recommend we add that, we will add it. [0:17:30, 0:17:31]: Correct. Thank you. [0:17:34, 0:17:38]: Mr Anderson, does this uh text amendment require a public hearing? [0:17:39, 0:17:55]: Yes, it will be subjected to the public hearing process because it it will require a special use permit. They will have to come before the planning commission and then go before city council. My question is w with respect to tonight, do we need to open the floor for a public hearing? Yes, sir. Okay. Thank you. [0:17:58, 0:18:00]: This is David Planchon. I have a couple of questions. [0:18:02, 0:18:08]: Um, is this going to be an actual hard facility or are you just gonna open up ground to allow tent cities? [0:18:10, 0:18:27]: Um tomorrow, I'm sorry. No, we won't be opening up ten cities ten cities. This will have to be a facility. And and do you anticipate this is going to draw people from outside the city of Stockbridge area, or are you gonna keep it to this homeless we have here in Stockbridge now? [0:18:27, 0:18:47]: I mean we don't know exactly where the homeless I mean, you know p homeless people can travel to Stockbridge. Move well move to Stockbridge. So I'm not sure if we will limit or restrict restrict it to citizens of Stockbridge. Um primarily um homel the homeless community, they travel from communities [0:18:47, 0:18:53]: to the community. So I don't know if we'll have those type of limitations, but hopefully um [0:18:54, 0:18:55]: And our intent [0:18:55, 0:19:05]: is for it to be for uh residents of the city of Stockbridge, but we can't um dictate whether or not a homeless person will will um be from the city of Stockbridge. [0:19:06, 0:19:10]: As long as it's not used as an attractant to bring in more homeless than we already have. [0:19:11, 0:19:15]: No, that's not the intent behind the work. Yeah, but it it's gonna happen. [0:19:18, 0:19:25]: We're just trying we we're just trying to deal with the um the current homeless problem we have in the city right now and um also to help [0:19:26, 0:19:29]: The veterans and other groups affected by homelessness. [0:19:33, 0:19:35]: Other any more questions, please. [0:19:37, 0:19:38]: Thank you, Ms. Jackson. [0:19:41, 0:19:48]: As you heard, we'll require public hearing, so I wanna go over a few housekeeping chores. [0:19:50, 0:19:56]: With regard to the public hearing, number one, please mute all cell phones and electronic devices. [0:19:57, 0:20:08]: If anyone wishes to speak tonight on a public hearing item, please fill out a form available on the table at the right, at the hand hand it to the city clerk before approaching the podium. [0:20:10, 0:20:19]: After each case is called the council will hear from the city staff, followed by the applicant or their representatives regarding the proposed plans. [0:20:21, 0:20:25]: The council will be free to ask questions any time before the vote. [0:20:27, 0:20:35]: Following the applicant, anyone who wishes to speak in favor or opposed to the case will have the opportun opportunity to do so. [0:20:36, 0:20:38]: Each side will be allotted ten minutes total. [0:20:39, 0:20:45]: Additional time may be extended at the discretion of council or the commission. [0:20:46, 0:20:53]: Please keep comments and presentations professional, referring only to the facts that are pertinent to the case. [0:20:56, 0:21:01]: We will not allow comments or personal attacks toward any individual or group. [0:21:02, 0:21:10]: Please refrain from any applause or comments during the audience from the audience during the public hearing. [0:21:11, 0:21:18]: After the presiding officer recognizes the speaker, he or she shall direct all comments to the presiding officer. [0:21:18, 0:21:20]: And never to the members of the commission. [0:21:21, 0:21:22]: Stay off [0:21:22, 0:21:24]: All the audience [0:21:24, 0:21:29]: All comments will be made from the podium where you will be required to state your name. [0:21:29, 0:21:31]: An address for the record. [0:21:32, 0:21:36]: Please note please note that these hearings are not a debate. [0:21:38, 0:21:47]: Failure to comply would cause you to be removed from the chamber and the building by law enforcement if you if you de deviate from these proceedings. [0:21:49, 0:21:53]: Other than the applicant, no person may speak more than once. [0:21:54, 0:21:57]: The applicant may reserve part of his or her speaking time. [0:21:58, 0:21:58]: As a rebuttal. [0:21:59, 0:22:07]: And may speak next and last, may use the entire ten minutes allowed for the pro side of the application. [0:22:08, 0:22:13]: If questions are raised, the counselor may ask the applicant to address questions or concern. [0:22:15, 0:22:22]: The presiding officer will call for a motion and second to the motion and have any necessary discussions. [0:22:22, 0:22:26]: If the matter is not tabled, the presiding officer will call for a vote. [0:22:27, 0:22:31]: To recommend approval or denial of of the request. [0:22:34, 0:22:34]: Thank you. [0:22:36, 0:22:46]: Mr Chair, if we could, um before we get to the next case, can we read them into the record together, discuss it together, but vote separately? [0:22:47, 0:22:48]: We can do that. [0:22:49, 0:22:57]: But first you you need to open up for those in a approved or those not in approved. Not in appr not in favor. [0:23:00, 0:23:08]: Okay. With respect to the text amendment case T X twenty twenty four dash zero four for housing shelters. [0:23:10, 0:23:18]: I'd like to know if there's anyone in the building who opposes this text amendment. [0:23:20, 0:23:22]: And wishes to speak. [0:23:26, 0:23:29]: If you wish to speak, please line up in that owl. [0:23:30, 0:23:33]: And proceed to the podium. [0:23:34, 0:23:36]: Give your name and address. [0:23:40, 0:23:54]: My name's Connie Snow, 426, Chase, Mary and Way, McDonough, Georgia, 30253. My question more likely is uh what areas of town in Stockbridge would this be located? [0:23:54, 0:24:00]: So for example, I know we're saying it's gonna be in areas that were designated C two, C three, is that correct? [0:24:03, 0:24:07]: Yeah, G that's correct. That is correct. Yes. [0:24:07, 0:24:27]: So I'm pretty sure, like I if I'm not mistaken, and maybe you guys might need to look back in their records, but in recent annexations and rezonings for Patrick Henry, I do believe some of those developments were classified as C2, maybe possibly C three. Would any of those facilities be close or [0:24:27, 0:24:33]: be placed on the Patrick Henry Parkway area or Holloway or any cl anywhere close to the schools. [0:24:34, 0:24:47]: I can answer that. Um no, the intent is to ins to exclude exclude those type of facilities from the parkway mixed use overlay district and that area is is is within the parkway mixed use overlay district. [0:24:48, 0:24:49]: What area? [0:24:49, 0:24:50]: Patrick Henry Parkway. [0:24:51, 0:25:08]: So we're we're saying those that this won't wouldn't be placed on Patrick Henry, correct? They will be excluded from the PMU and and park Patrick Henry Parkway is is inside the PMU, the Parkway mixed use overlay district. They will not be allowed in the overlay district. Okay. So do we know where they would exactly be placed? [0:25:09, 0:25:29]: I mean not exactly, but uh uh the PMU uh covers about sixty to seven between sixty and seventy percent of of the entire city. It mostly covers areas where there are large arterials or collector streets, uh like um Rock Quarry, um how [0:25:28, 0:25:35]: 138, Patrick Henry Parkway, East Atlanta Road, uh, Eagles Landing Parkway. So they will be excluded from areas like that. [0:25:37, 0:25:45]: But am I right in saying that this is going to be held for a public hearing on June tenth, correct? Yes, ma'am, before city council. [0:25:45, 0:25:53]: So shouldn't those areas be defined before that even makes it to a public hearing so the community has a right to offer their input? [0:25:53, 0:26:09]: Yes, ma'am. I mean it it's defined now if they look at the um the land use map or the um or the city or the map of the city or the zoning map. So I'm asking the f definition, what street areas are we looking at this impact for? [0:26:11, 0:26:13]: Is it Hudson Bridge? Is it? [0:26:13, 0:26:15]: Ellen Wood is it? [0:26:15, 0:26:33]: Jodaco, is it Pate's Creek? I mean that's what the question we're asking. So then what areas? It would be areas mostly off major art that are not included in on major arterials or collector streets. [0:26:34, 0:26:37]: Would it be possible to get an actual [0:26:37, 0:26:46]: 'Cause I mean, on the site, there's no map or anything that's outlaying anything that's being heard today. There's no applications, nothing that's really being [0:26:47, 0:27:07]: Entered of substance where the community can actually look at what's going on. So that's the point I'm trying to make. Uh we have my point is, let me finish, is if we could please get a full detailed report of where we can anticipate where this housing will be or what we're proposing, so that the citizens of the community. [0:27:07, 0:27:25]: can be aware of what's gonna happen to them. That's all I'm asking. Well your point is is is well taken ma'am. However uh those areas uh are designated um well basically what we have done we've ex we've we've uh identified the areas areas where they will be excluded. [0:27:26, 0:27:32]: So So when do we identify the areas where it's gonna be included? [0:27:32, 0:27:39]: Well, I would hope that you guys would have that available way before the hearing so that we have time to review it. [0:27:40, 0:27:41]: Oh [0:27:43, 0:27:56]: Uh Mr Mr Chair, may I speak? Yes, sir. Um I'm I'm listening to the young lady and everything she's saying is correct. And what's happening is she's basically saying [0:27:56, 0:28:02]: that we're making decisions and move without really presenting the whole package to the community. [0:28:02, 0:28:22]: Uh this is what I'm getting from her. That's not the case. Um Well what is the case, but I'm listening to this young lady speak and you're not exactly telling everything she needs to know. We we're identifying the areas where they will not be allowed. And that's all we really have to do. I mean if if they're they're excluded from certain dish zoning. [0:28:22, 0:28:31]: zoning districts and the overlay district, then anywhere else in the city that has the specific zoning district that is mentioned, they can go there. [0:28:32, 0:28:52]: I I understand that th but I I also understand the question that she's trying to ask. She's basically saying, Hey, you're putting information out there and they don't think that they're getting all the information they need to understand what we're doing about this particular situation. [0:28:52, 0:28:55]: being very transparent and um the information is available. [0:28:56, 0:28:59]: Um you just have to look at a zoning map. [0:29:01, 0:29:21]: When Patrick Henry Parkway was annexed into the city, it was annexed with the anticipation of being a commercial slash high density housing zone because it's uh adjacent to the interstate, which is required for all high density housing, plus commercial, you know what's going on down at Jodigo Road and it's it's [0:29:21, 0:29:41]: Amazing for the county. I can't imagine this is my personal opinion. I can't imagine throwing in the middle of all of that this kind of facility. And the parkway mixed use overlay district will exclude their use. Yep. I know what it is now, but it there aren't many areas where they [0:29:41, 0:30:01]: They can go in the city, but we will try to do that. This this is a public hearing. We have people w waiting to speak. We can discuss those issues after the public has weighed in. Any other questions that need to be clarified, we'll be happy to do that at that time. [0:30:01, 0:30:06]: Ma'am, would you please state your name and your g give us your address and proceed? [0:30:06, 0:30:26]: Tasha Kempel, 410, Chase Marion Way, McDonough, Georgia, 30253. Um, this is the first I've heard about this meeting tonight, um, along with some other items that are on the agenda. Um, I feel like City of Stockbridge, the councilman, and slash lady, um, lady. [0:30:26, 0:30:40]: They don't address most of the issues to the public, the citizens that live here in the city of Stockbridge. So I feel like a lot of these items are getting passed without the you know proper posting on the [0:30:40, 0:31:00]: pages where people can read or something like that if they want to attend. So I would like to state um as far as the homelessness, um you've got homeless people that are criminals that you're gonna be housing. Um that's really dangerous. Um ex like what if there's someone [0:31:00, 0:31:17]: That's homeless, that doesn't have a record, their life might be in danger. So there's one point. Then you got the other point. What about the security about the surrounding people? Like, I don't know. So, anyways, I don't agree with any of this and that's all I gotta say. Thank you. [0:31:21, 0:31:22]: Next, please. [0:31:27, 0:31:43]: Uh good afternoon. Uh thank you everyone on the council. My name is Jocelyn Williams. I live at one ninety Banks Drive, uh Stockbridge, Georgia, three oh two, eight one. I'm in uh opposition to the uh homeless buildings being built. I think they s mentioned we could have up to four. [0:31:44, 0:32:04]: Uh if I'm correct when they were discussing it, the maximum could be four. Was that the number that I heard? That was just an um I was just d guessing, really. I'm not sure uh exactly how many it will be, but we always can place a limit in the uh in the text amendment based on the comments we get tonight. [0:32:04, 0:32:15]: This is a draft that we're presenting tonight and we'll take the comments that we received tonight and we'll we will rework the text amendment to include a specific limit if that's what the public will want. [0:32:15, 0:32:35]: Okay. I also want to uh thank you for this opportunity for us to speak. Um piggybacking on if if we could get uh tonight where we could go and get information. I'm new I was just annexed into um um Stockbridge. I'm excited about it. I came from Henry County and it's done differently. So whatever procedures and guidelines that [0:32:35, 0:32:55]: Stockbridge has for us to find this information. I'd be so grateful if uh so I can make an informed decision. But my rec record is showing that I'm in opposition but would like to move forward where we could get exact information. I don't I'm elderly, I don't know how to read the zoning maps. So I want to thank you, Mr. Anderson, if somebody could break it down so that I could have [0:32:55, 0:33:07]: Yes, ma'am. Okay, I appreciate you. And you can speak to one of our staff members off the record and they'll they'll give you additional. Okay, I thank you. Thank you, Counselman. Thank you. Next, please. [0:33:13, 0:33:29]: Uh good afternoon, good evening, gentlemen and ladies. Um my name is Christina Lovett and um I just recently purchased my home in Stockbridge. I live at uh 180 Oakwood Circle in Stockbridge, Georgia, 30281. [0:33:30, 0:33:32]: And I wanna apologize for coming in a little late. [0:33:32, 0:33:52]: But I I kind of came in on the tail end of the um comments that were being made in the discussion for homelessness. Um I wanna say that um I don't know exactly what uh areas you're talking about, but I got a letter in the mail at this [0:33:52, 0:34:12]: This address stating that there was going to be a hearing today about re um zoning, possibly rezoning, right around the street that I live. And I wasn't sure exactly what that meant, but I do want to say that I am in favor with the limited [0:34:12, 0:34:32]: information I have of for trying to help the homeless population as long as like the one lady commented, as long as it's safe for the public. But we do need to do something for homelessness. I'm the CEO of [0:34:32, 0:34:36]: Um somewhere to go. [0:34:38, 0:34:53]: somewhere to go. It's a a non profit uh to help people who are homeless or underhoused, um, generally for no fault of their own. I'm also a disabled veteran and so um it's very important to me [0:34:53, 0:35:13]: uh that somebody does something about the homelessness uh in our communities across the board. Um I lived in Clayton County and then I per purchased a home here in Henry County. So my my question would be [0:35:13, 0:35:15]: The um [0:35:16, 0:35:23]: What the lady uh this woman here had said earlier, it would be very important for us to have. [0:35:24, 0:35:24]: Um [0:35:25, 0:35:35]: knowledge of exactly where uh the homeless shelters were going to be. And can I ask how many homeless shelters? [0:35:35, 0:35:50]: We're not as Mr. Dunwell's gonna answer that or you want me to go right ahead, sir. We can't uh say for sure, but we will add to the text amendment, we will probably limit it to two or three until the city population grows. We'll we'll put in a statement to that effect. [0:35:50, 0:35:57]: Yes, sir. What we're presenting tonight is basically a draft. So we want to get the s the the community's input on it. It's not a final draft. [0:35:57, 0:36:02]: So after this meeting we will go back and work on it based on the comments and feedback we received tonight. [0:36:03, 0:36:05]: Thank you. And um [0:36:06, 0:36:17]: Is is that going to be in the part of the area that you were saying for the maps, is that going to be around Oakwood Manor, um, close to the Walmart here? [0:36:18, 0:36:26]: Ma'am, uh we can't we can't say for sure, but uh we know the areas that they will be excluded from. So uh um exactly where [0:36:27, 0:36:31]: They will be they would have to go to those specific zoning [0:36:31, 0:36:35]: uh districts that have been mentioned. They won't be in residential neighborhoods. So [0:36:35, 0:36:37]: We realized that it could um [0:36:38, 0:36:56]: possibly have a negative impact on residential uh zoning districts. So it it will not be allowed in residential districts. So we're trying to reduce the impact on our citizens. But however, um there is a big problem in the city that we want to address as far as housing encampments. So we feel like this is the most fair way to do it. [0:36:57, 0:37:17]: Okay, I would I would love to be able to work with um this program, you know, to be of assistance. My uh um nonprofit is hoping to try and house people with the home voucher programs uh to put them into hotel areas and things like that. So I would love to be able [0:37:17, 0:37:21]: able to be a a part of it. I'm I'm finished, but thank you all. Thank you. [0:37:23, 0:37:43]: Miss No, because you're an exceptional lady, we're gonna make an exception and allow you to speak one more time. I just have one more question. I just have one more question. Is this gonna impact any of the TAD districts, specifically those in the downtown district where there are elderly people where the city's already approved a couple of property attacks creases? [0:37:43, 0:37:55]: I just want to make sure we're not gonna hit those elderly people anymore with any other tax increases that we've already done. [0:37:55, 0:38:05]: Ma'am, it will be ex like I mentioned earlier, it w the overlay districts will be excluded. Okay, cool. The downtown overlay district, they will not be allowed in that area. [0:38:05, 0:38:11]: Will you let us know when you know what's gonna be included? How about Mr. Chairman, I have a question. [0:38:12, 0:38:23]: Like all ordinances and and r request to change what we have, where did this request come from? Who requested this ordinance change? [0:38:25, 0:38:35]: Uh Mr. Plans and uh it it was just uh a request so we can try to d deal with the um the housing encampments and and homelessness problem in the city. [0:38:36, 0:38:43]: That's that's what's spuriating. Just out of the blue or does somebody some body get together and it's the ongoing problem. The city wishes to address it. [0:38:44, 0:39:04]: So no one specifically recommended it, but there's a need for it within the city. Well, there's a need worldwide for it, but Stockbridge is kind of a small creature on the That's that's true, but we have a significant uh homeless population and okay I'll just address that issue uh before it gets out. [0:39:04, 0:39:12]: Okay. I was just curious if somebody actually requested it. Can we hear from the next individual, please? [0:39:15, 0:39:21]: Hi, I'm Cyrinthia Evans at one forty six Could you speak into the microphone please became I'm Cyrinthia Evans? [0:39:23, 0:39:24]: Go right ahead. [0:39:24, 0:39:35]: 146 St. Margaret Circle, Stockbridge, Georgia, in reference to your proposal. And I am a veteran. [0:39:35, 0:39:40]: I take exception to throwing it out as a [0:39:41, 0:39:43]: that title veteran. [0:39:43, 0:39:47]: To encourage this development. [0:39:47, 0:39:53]: Do you have any figures on the number of homeless people that are in camping in Stockbridge? [0:39:54, 0:39:55]: Not an exact figure, man. [0:39:56, 0:39:58]: Okay. You say that you have [0:39:58, 0:40:01]: Excluded certain places. [0:40:03, 0:40:07]: from being possible sites for the zoning district. [0:40:08, 0:40:17]: Okay, so for and in the same sense I feel that you've also taken a look at places that would accept this facility. [0:40:18, 0:40:21]: So at what point do you think that you'll reach that? [0:40:22, 0:40:24]: Say accept, what do you mean? [0:40:24, 0:40:31]: As far as the placement of this facility, you're saying that you have ruled out certain areas, right? [0:40:33, 0:40:35]: Based on the compatibility. [0:40:36, 0:40:37]: Based on what? [0:40:37, 0:40:39]: compatibility. [0:40:39, 0:40:42]: Compatibility for the facility? [0:40:43, 0:40:44]: The land use. [0:40:44, 0:40:46]: Oh, for the land use. Okay. [0:40:47, 0:41:02]: All right, I'll make it. I oppose until I have more information about what and where this will go. I like where I live and I do not want to see more changes. There are different things that are around my [0:41:03, 0:41:08]: home that I am concerned about. So for add anything else, no. [0:41:09, 0:41:10]: Thank you. [0:41:12, 0:41:13]: Thank you very much. [0:41:15, 0:41:20]: Is there anyone present who wishes to speak in favor of this text amendment? [0:41:27, 0:41:34]: Hearing none, the public hearing aspect is now closed. Thank you very much for your comments. [0:41:37, 0:41:42]: Are there any more questions or comments from staff? I'm sorry, from the commission. [0:41:43, 0:41:50]: One question regarding you say this is a draft. So will we have the opportunity as a commission to see a final [0:41:50, 0:42:06]: Yes, you'll you'll be able to see a final, yes. And um and the purpose of this meeting tonight is basically to get input from the Planning Commission and from residents. So that will give us a chance to improve the document prior to us sending it to city council. So this will come back to this commission. [0:42:07, 0:42:27]: No, it won't come back to this commission, no sir. So it will go final package will go straight to the city council for public debate. Unless you vote to uh defer and and then if you vote to defer, um then the city council will have to will have a choice to make whether or not they agree with your um recommendation, but they still will have the choice to make a mic. [0:42:27, 0:42:31]: us to proceed with the with the legislation if they d if they desire. [0:42:33, 0:42:36]: But we will take in all comments that we have received tonight. [0:42:37, 0:42:39]: and uh incorporate them into the document. [0:42:41, 0:42:55]: Okay, I just wanna make sure that this is not go to the city council next month and is voted. I just wanna make sure this does not go to the city council next month and is voted on as a final package and I think there's still a lot of questions here on this commission. [0:42:56, 0:43:01]: Yes, yes, sir, I understand that, but we will uh incorporate all the comments and feedback. [0:43:02, 0:43:06]: That's applicable that we've heard tonight into the draft. [0:43:07, 0:43:08]: Thank you. [0:43:09, 0:43:11]: Mr. Chairman, may I speak? [0:43:12, 0:43:12]: Um [0:43:14, 0:43:26]: I I kinda understand the dilemma here and and it seems to be that we are lacking information in terms of what the city council wants to do. [0:43:26, 0:43:28]: But I will say this, uh [0:43:30, 0:43:31]: This planning zoning. [0:43:32, 0:43:36]: does not make the last decision. We we can say yes [0:43:37, 0:43:43]: And the city council I mean we can say no and the city council can say yes at the end of the day. So you need to understand that. [0:43:43, 0:43:48]: That we don't have the last say so no matter what comes up. [0:43:49, 0:44:09]: At this planning zoning meeting. So just keep that in mind when you come up here and address issues with us. The city council has the final say-so, no matter what decision we make. And for all those veterans, I'm also a veteran. I'm one of your Vietnam veterans. So you do have some. [0:44:08, 0:44:12]: Thank you. [0:44:15, 0:44:35]: Any more comments, please. Mr. Uh Chairman, I would just like to say those of you who oppose, I understand uh the seriousness of your concerns, and uh it is my heart desire that uh information would be given to you um concerning the defined areas because I can definitely [0:44:35, 0:44:38]: and at least uh understand cut circles. [0:44:44, 0:44:46]: The areas have been defined, sir. [0:44:47, 0:44:52]: The the areas have been defined. We we w we mentioned four specific districts. [0:44:53, 0:44:58]: So just you just have to look at the zoning map and look for those zoning districts. [0:45:03, 0:45:23]: I think it may be important, uh, Madam Secretary, if you would read back to us the amendments that have been articulated that Mr. Anderson has informed us would be [0:45:22, 0:45:27]: add it to this m text amendment for the record before we vote. [0:45:30, 0:45:31]: What did you capture? [0:45:31, 0:45:51]: Sure. One of the items I captured is to include weapons as a prohibited use or um one of the prohibited uses. Um the other is to define more of where in the city these facilities will be located. [0:45:51, 0:46:11]: And um I understand that there's a question on do we know the population of our homelessness in the city of Stockbridge? So we would definitely um look into or research that information and provide it at our next meeting. Um [0:46:11, 0:46:20]: take into consideration to place a limitation based on the population of the city of Stockbridge on the number of those type of facilities that can be in the city. [0:46:22, 0:46:23]: Anything else? [0:46:24, 0:46:26]: That's the gist of what I have. [0:46:28, 0:46:31]: Okay. Thank you very much. Thank you. [0:46:33, 0:46:53]: Mr. Chairman, I just want to make a comment. You said the areas are defined. Yes, sir. The areas are defined. But she used the word they're where. I guess that's what I'm saying about. I'm not sure which her intent was, but we listed four specific districts in which they are allowed. Zoning districts in which they are allowed. [0:46:53, 0:47:00]: Allowed and they cannot go in and it cannot be included within the Parkway Mixed Use Overlay District and the Downtown Overlay District. [0:47:01, 0:47:02]: So it's really [0:47:02, 0:47:07]: Just four areas that are excluded of those two overlay districts. That's not much land. [0:47:11, 0:47:27]: And we we will w when we go back into the office tomorrow, we will update the the document to um we will come up with a exact number that we feel would be appropriate before we move forward to the city council. Uh I'm thinking maybe two or three at the max. [0:47:31, 0:47:32]: Thank you. [0:47:32, 0:47:43]: Uh I need a motion please uh with respect to text amendment case uh for housing shelters incorporating the uh [0:47:45, 0:47:52]: Amendments that Ms. Jackson just articulated. Could I get a motion from the commission, please? [0:48:03, 0:48:09]: Let me be more specific him, but can I get a motion to approve from the commission? [0:48:12, 0:48:15]: Can I get a motion to deny from the commission? [0:48:16, 0:48:25]: Mr. Chairman Dave Planchon, I'd like to make a motion to deny this uh proposed change to our city ordinance. [0:48:26, 0:48:42]: Is there a second? I second it, Harold. It's been moved by Mr. Planchon and seconded by Mr. Thibodeau that we deny the text amendment case TX twenty four twenty twenty four-zero four for housing shelters. All in favor, let it be known by the sound of I. [0:48:43, 0:48:44]: Okay. [0:48:45, 0:48:45]: In your polls. [0:48:48, 0:48:54]: The eyes have it. The text amendment case is denied. Thank you, Ms. Jackson. [0:48:55, 0:48:56]: You're welcome. [0:48:58, 0:49:06]: Next case, comprehensive plan amendment case p twenty twenty-four-zero one, council district five. [0:49:07, 0:49:18]: The City of Stockbridge Planning Commission will hold a public hearing on Thursday, May 16th, which is today at 630. The City Council, Mayor and the City of Stockbridge. [0:49:19, 0:49:39]: Located at 4640 North Henry Boulevard in Stopridge, Georgia, to consider a comprehensive plan amendment request to change the future land use designation of property on the north side of Hudson Bridge Drive comprising Parcel 032-0. [0:49:39, 0:49:51]: Sero one zero two six thousand from medium density mixed use to medium density residential to allow for the construction of a town home development. [0:49:52, 0:49:56]: The applicant is Lenar, Georgia, LLC. [0:49:57, 0:49:59]: Agent is battle law PC. [0:50:00, 0:50:10]: Property is located in land lot twenty-one of district six and it contains twenty p point three point three point three six seven acres more or less. [0:50:13, 0:50:15]: To present about there, please. Go ahead. [0:50:16, 0:50:23]: If I can, Mr. Chair, um, can we also read the rezoning component to this comprehensive plan? [0:50:23, 0:50:27]: Resulting case RZ dash twenty twenty four dash zero one. [0:50:29, 0:50:39]: Council District 5, the city of Stockbridge Planning Commission will hold a public meeting on Thursday, May 16, 2024 at 6:30 p.m. [0:50:40, 0:50:49]: And the city of Stockbridge mayor and city council will hold a public hearing on Monday, june tenth, twenty twenty four at six PM. [0:50:50, 0:51:10]: in the Stockbridge City Hall located at forty six forty North Henry Boulevard in Stockbridge, Georgia, to consider a request to rezone property on the north side of Hudson Bridge Drive comprising parcel zero zero thirty-two-one zero two six thousand. [0:51:10, 0:51:10]: Yeah. [0:51:11, 0:51:20]: from the C two General Commercial Zoning District to the multif MFR multifamily residential zoning district. [0:51:21, 0:51:25]: to allow for the construction of a town home development. [0:51:26, 0:51:27]: The property [0:51:28, 0:51:33]: also lies within the PMU, the Parkway Mixed Use Overlay District. [0:51:34, 0:51:48]: Applicant is Lenard Georgia LLC agent. It's Battle of Law PC. The property is located in land 21 of District 6, and it contains 20.367 acres, more or less. [0:51:49, 0:51:50]: Two presenter was air. [0:51:51, 0:52:11]: Thank you, Mr. Chair. The subject property before us tonight, um, the applicant is proposing a development of a townhome community that will consist of 140 fee simple units at the parcel number that was read into the record. The entire acreage of this parcel is [0:52:11, 0:52:25]: 20.367 acres of district six, landlock 21. And as mentioned, the applicant is Lenar Georgia, Cara of Better Law PC. So the property is currently zoned C2. [0:52:27, 0:52:41]: And what the applicant is seeking is to rezone that property to MFR, which is multifamily residential, and also to change the land use to misuse. [0:52:41, 0:52:50]: Medium density misuse uh to allow, I'm sorry, medium density residential uh to allow for this townhome development. [0:52:51, 0:53:11]: Now this has been before you a few times, and I'm just going to go over the background for those that are not aware of this um zoning request. So previously it came to you um in multiple facets of the zoning request. [0:53:11, 0:53:31]: This was originally a part of the Walmart master plan development plan and this property also went through a DRI process. The Sudra property um was a part of the again Walmart Supercenter as a misuse development for a total of 70.16 acres. And [0:53:31, 0:53:51]: And what happened was at that time, that entire property was annexed into the city of Stockbridge. When that property was annexed into the city, it was zone C2. And it was then split. So you had track one and track two. What we're currently speaking of, this side is on track one. [0:53:51, 0:53:55]: one and the Walmart Super Center is on track two. [0:53:56, 0:54:16]: Now the original track two um became a standalone parcel for future development. Um there was a covenant on the property that basically restricted retail uses. That covenant has now expired, so therefore this applicant now has the autonomy to come before you and ask for. [0:54:16, 0:54:18]: for this type of rezoning. [0:54:19, 0:54:39]: Um as I mentioned before there was a DRI um plan that was um put in place to um look at the traffic, look at uh environmental concerns, etc. Um after the review the site shall be used a [0:54:39, 0:54:59]: Shall be misused and contain a minimum of 200 residential units and a mass of 343,500 square feet. Um that DRI conditions have now expired. So it has been 10 years since that DRI. So we're looking at, let's go to the zone. [0:54:59, 0:55:12]: activity that was first first came to you in 2019. And that was RZ 2019-04. And at that time the applicant requested a 118 home [0:55:12, 0:55:32]: townhome development on 18.23 acres. It was eventually approved by both Planning Commission and City Council on October 14, 2019. However, the applicant at that time redrew the application and there was no further action. [0:55:32, 0:55:33]: Yeah. [0:55:36, 0:55:56]: In 2020, an another application came before you, also a rezoning. And in this case, the applicant sought a rezoning of 147 townhome development. Now the Planning Commission did hear the case on June 25th, 2020. [0:55:56, 0:55:56]: [3357.0, 3365.1]: Uh both the staff and planning commission recommended approval with conditions. It did go to city council. City council denied it. [0:56:07, 0:56:23]: In 2022, another applicant, which is battle law and uh representing Carter acquisitions came before us and the change or the zoning request changed somewhat. [0:56:24, 0:56:32]: They requested to rezone the property from C two to MFR to allow for the development of a townhome community. [0:56:32, 0:56:48]: Um however they wanted 330 units. The proposed development was over the allowable density of sixteen units per the high density residential future land use designation. Uh therefore [0:56:48, 0:56:50]: Um after [0:56:50, 0:57:08]: talks with the applicant, the applicant redrew their application along with their comprehensive plan amendment, which was CP-2022-07. So here we are today in 2024. Again, speaking of trap one is where they want to build this development. [0:57:08, 0:57:28]: Um, although this development will consist of 140 townhomes, which is far less than um what was previously brought to you, um they will need a comprehensive plan, comprehensive plan change to proceed with this development. Now before you um you have the parcel, it is planned. [0:57:28, 0:57:33]: pointing at the subject property where they're tending to build the townhomes. [0:57:35, 0:57:36]: This [0:57:37, 0:57:57]: shows the surrounding land use designation. So you have to the north St. Ives apartments. Um there's a subdivision. The land use for those are high density residential. To the south you have commercial uses on Hudson Bridge as well as JJ Liquor and [0:57:57, 0:58:17]: In Western Union, that is deemed as high density mixed use, high density residential. To the east, you have a shopping center that is deemed medium density mixed use. And to the west, you have Oakwood Village Subdivision as well as Oakwood Mainor Subdivision. [0:58:17, 0:58:24]: Vision. Again, those have a Henry County future land use of medium density residential. [0:58:25, 0:58:27]: Um we both do have a [0:58:28, 0:58:30]: A land use of medium density residential. [0:58:32, 0:58:51]: Now, here is just a breakdown of the subdivisions, the number of units that are in those subdivisions. Um I won't read those into the record as you can see. Um so let's get into the project itself. So as I mentioned before, um the future land use change here will allow [0:58:51, 0:59:11]: the developer to be able to construct townhomes on this property after if the rezoning is approved from multifamily residential to be able to do this. Now if you look at the consistency with the comprehensive plan as found [0:59:11, 0:59:31]: On pages 36, 38, and 44, what they're proposing does align with the goals of our comprehensive plan. And those goals are before you to provide a mixture of housing for to attract young professionals, to maintain a family-friendly environment, and a sense of [0:59:31, 0:59:34]: [3575.5, 3592.3]: So with staff analysis, we have um looked at the land use designation as well as the rezoning, and we do feel that the surrounding properties and the f surrounding land use designations does fit in what what is being requested. [0:59:52, 0:59:54]: Um staff has [0:59:54, 0:59:57]: recommended approval. [0:59:57, 1:00:01]: And that concludes our presentation before you tonight. [1:00:03, 1:00:04]: Thank you, Ms. Jackson. [1:00:07, 1:00:11]: Are there any questions or comments from the commission, please? [1:00:12, 1:00:14]: Uh Mr. Chairman. [1:00:14, 1:00:34]: Mr. Mitten had raised the info. Yes, ma'am. So um that corridor between the quick trip and JJ Lickers is pretty much controlled chaos. So is I see that the entrance into the complex is basically going to use that. Is there any has there [1:00:34, 1:00:54]: There been any traffic study, anything done? Great question. We did ask the applicant for traffic study. We did not receive a reply. And if I can take this moment to mention that the front edge of the property, the setback, the front setback is not in compliance with the MF. [1:00:54, 1:01:07]: our zoning district. So the applicant will need a variance um to move forward. So um to answer your question, no, we have not received a traffic study. [1:01:08, 1:01:08]: Thank you. [1:01:10, 1:01:11]: Mr. Turbado, please. [1:01:12, 1:01:22]: I think we would need that traffic study because I I think it already has been done before. Now you said that this has come be before us three times, right? [1:01:22, 1:01:24]: Correct. [1:01:24, 1:01:29]: I I remember this property and uh we had issues with homeliness. [1:01:30, 1:01:41]: people over there and incidents in that area. Uh we also made a lot of recommendations that that area uh would be uh gated. [1:01:41, 1:01:49]: when that time came that we did other things over there, uh there was a lot of recommendations made for this property so that way [1:01:49, 1:01:51]: We wouldn't have issues. [1:01:52, 1:01:56]: Um from my understanding, if you made it commercial [1:01:57, 1:02:11]: it would actually be more traffic. If you made it uh multifamily use, it'll be less traffic from my understanding. Of the years of looking at this property, go back and forth to people that wanna develop it. [1:02:14, 1:02:15]: Anyone else? [1:02:21, 1:02:22]: Thank you, Ms. Jackson. [1:02:26, 1:02:28]: As stated earlier, this is a [1:02:29, 1:02:31]: Public hearing item. [1:02:33, 1:02:40]: We will now open the floor for public hearing. If there is anyone present tonight, [1:02:41, 1:02:43]: Who is in favor of this? [1:02:45, 1:02:49]: Comprehensive plan and rezoning case. [1:02:53, 1:02:55]: You may come to the podium and speak. [1:02:57, 1:03:00]: Hearing none, a seeing none, oh [1:03:01, 1:03:05]: I'm opening it up now for anyone that's opposed to it. [1:03:06, 1:03:08]: Could you please light up in this owl? [1:03:13, 1:03:18]: Is the applicant the applicant needs to speak? Is the applic is the applicant present? [1:03:19, 1:03:21]: I'm sorry, just a moment. [1:03:22, 1:03:23]: Is the applicant present? [1:03:25, 1:03:26]: Apparently not, sir. [1:03:31, 1:03:32]: Okay, you may proceed now. [1:03:37, 1:03:42]: Good evening. Um my name is Barber Floshman. I live at ten twenty six Brandon Road, McDonough, Georgia. [1:03:43, 1:03:45]: I am in unincorporated Henry County and [1:03:46, 1:03:48]: And I'm a landowner and a lot of the stuff [1:03:48, 1:03:51]: Affects me and doesn't affect me. [1:03:51, 1:04:04]: But um I my one question is why do we have a planning and zoning commission if everything y'all say or do gets overridden? I don't know if the city council takes in de into consideration any of your comments or not. [1:04:04, 1:04:05]: But it just [1:04:06, 1:04:07]: It seems like a waste of time. [1:04:08, 1:04:17]: But also we're not supposed to comp complain about traffic. Have y'all dri ridden down Eagle Sandy Parkway lately? And it's like dodged the hole. [1:04:17, 1:04:22]: I mean literally dodge the hole and you're talking about more building. [1:04:24, 1:04:26]: What what about the roads and what about the traffic? [1:04:26, 1:04:29]: My husband and I went to a closing in Locust Grove about [1:04:30, 1:04:31]: Mm, three o'clock. [1:04:31, 1:04:35]: And we were back on the road, where I was gonna come up to Eagle Standing Parkway and get off and get some gas. [1:04:36, 1:04:37]: And um [1:04:38, 1:04:40]: It took me an hour and a half. [1:04:40, 1:04:41]: To get [1:04:42, 1:04:45]: At Bill Gardner Parkway, up Dagles Landing. [1:04:46, 1:05:06]: to get off to get gas and I'm thinking, okay, if y'all don't care about the traffic, I sure do. I'm retired, but I spend most of my time sitting in traffic now. And like I said, all these things that y'all are doing affects all of us. And I don't understand why everybody wants to be all of a sudden unincorporated, wants to be annexed in the city. [1:05:05, 1:05:25]: And what's the benefit of being annexed in the city? I mean what what are our benefits and what's the detriment? So I pay Henry County taxes. If I get annexed into the city, do I then pay city taxes? Okay, so why would I want to be annexed into the city? And so what is the city's budget? Are y'all Mr Dumas, this is [1:05:25, 1:05:26]: Is out the scope. [1:05:27, 1:05:27]: Huh? [1:05:28, 1:05:30]: This is not pertaining to the case. [1:05:30, 1:05:37]: You're right. Well anyway, I just think would y'all please consider the traffic? Thank you. [1:05:39, 1:05:43]: I believe that the lady in the blue was next. [1:05:44, 1:05:50]: It no, no, no, no, no. No, you cut line behind you. These two lateral Yeah. [1:05:54, 1:05:55]: Good catch. [1:05:57, 1:06:17]: Okay, so um again I'm Christina Lovett at 180 Oakwood Circle and that's the property I was talking about earlier. Uh so my question is the town homes that are uh they're trying to put up um as multifamily use, um would they be for sale or [1:06:17, 1:06:37]: rent. Does anybody know the answer to that? They're for sale. So okay. And um what happens with the homes that we currently live in are uh they're just regular residential, not multifamily use, like with just regular houses. [1:06:37, 1:06:44]: Um so what happens with that property? I mean, are they trying to like buy our property out or [1:06:47, 1:07:00]: Okay. And um would there be something like a HOA then? I I know someone was talking about maybe a gated community, I think they had mentioned uh is this [1:07:00, 1:07:01]: Pardon me? [1:07:03, 1:07:11]: Okay, I currently am not in a HOA, so would that change for me under this proposal? Your property won't be affected at all. [1:07:11, 1:07:15]: 'Cause I live right on Oakwood here. Okay. [1:07:15, 1:07:33]: Okay, and um would anybody be able to answer this question? Would our taxes increase? You know, I mean I I know the property taxes are really going up. I mean, we already have people being taxed out of their homes. Okay, thank you. Next question. Tax police. [1:07:37, 1:07:57]: Uh good evening again. Thanking the council so much for uh working with me this evening. My name is Jocelyn Williams. I live at one ninety Banks Drive, Stockbridge. The reason I'm in opposition um of this um development is beautiful and I know it will bring in a lot of people. I'm just concerned I've been here since nineteen ninety-two and Mike concerned. [1:07:57, 1:08:17]: Is the flipping road corridor? Um, there's no infrastructure, there's no widening. Uh, went to uh online, there's nothing for the 2024-2030 um that's gonna be built uh for that area, unless I didn't see is anything being built for the um flipping road corridor to widen or to [1:08:17, 1:08:24]: [4105.4, 4108.1]: But is it anything that you know of concrete? [1:08:30, 1:08:40]: Okay. That's the only reason. Uh we already have a beautiful uh broader farm. They just built that. They just built their um Popeye's chicken and they're building a beautiful um [1:08:40, 1:08:55]: um car wash and I just was in opposition only because I didn't know is there a different frontage to this um gated community? Will there be only one near the Taco Bell? Will they be able to get in and out? Is that only one access? [1:08:57, 1:08:58]: [4138.9, 4146.0]: Okay, I know the frontage would be near the Taco Bell. Is another way that they could get into um their subdivision? [1:09:06, 1:09:08]: There will be an em emergency access. [1:09:09, 1:09:15]: Emergency access but n nothing that the regular residents could use on a regular basis? [1:09:16, 1:09:23]: Okay. I just want to thank the council again and I appreciate you. Thank you so much. Thank you. Next please. [1:09:28, 1:09:38]: Good evening, gentlemen. My name's Cheryl Whitnell and I live in Saint Marguerite. I want to talk to you about three subjects regarding motor vehicle safety. [1:09:38, 1:09:39]: Um [1:09:40, 1:09:46]: We are in the St. Ives flipping road right across from the golf course. [1:09:47, 1:09:55]: When Broto Farms was built and the increase in traffic and population of Henry County. [1:09:55, 1:09:58]: The roads are not able to accommodate. [1:09:59, 1:10:09]: We cannot get out of our subdivisions. I do not believe a thorough investigation regarding traffic was ever done. [1:10:10, 1:10:13]: when this was done because there is no room for expansion. [1:10:13, 1:10:24]: Not only that, um there are trees, bushes that we cannot get out of the subdivision because we can't see and we're halfway in the middle of the road. [1:10:25, 1:10:30]: The other thing is there's nothing to contain traffic between banks and Hudson Bridge. [1:10:31, 1:10:32]: And it's a free for all. [1:10:33, 1:10:37]: We cannot get out, okay? And [1:10:37, 1:10:43]: I you've added Broder, you've added the you've added that um you've got [1:10:44, 1:11:04]: Increased traffic between 138 and Hudson Bridge. So my and there are no traffic, no street lights between Stay Knives and Hudson Bridge. So my request would be a comprehensive study of where uh stay knives and flippin' meet to try to either get some kind of caution sign. [1:11:04, 1:11:08]: stop sign, um anything because somebody's gonna get killed. [1:11:08, 1:11:12]: If they don't cut back those branches, somebody's gonna get killed. [1:11:12, 1:11:14]: Um if they don't install [1:11:15, 1:11:22]: Streetlights, somebody's gonna get killed. These are simple things that should have been thought of when we increased. [1:11:22, 1:11:24]: The population in that area. [1:11:26, 1:11:32]: So I would hope that you would take this tonight and first and foremost have those bushes cut back. [1:11:32, 1:11:34]: Because otherwise [1:11:34, 1:11:37]: We're in the middle of the road trying to make a turn. [1:11:37, 1:11:40]: And I'm sure none of you want that on your conscience. [1:11:42, 1:11:43]: Thank you, ma'am. [1:11:44, 1:11:50]: I'd like to remind the planning commission you can't take transportation issues into consideration when you make your decision. [1:11:53, 1:11:59]: Ma'am, you may take your seat. Is I mean, is there any way you guys can do a traffic study? You may take your seat, ma'am. [1:11:59, 1:12:00]: Okay. [1:12:00, 1:12:01]: Oh, is it weird? [1:12:04, 1:12:09]: But the tank was fine. [1:12:16, 1:12:17]: The public hearing [1:12:18, 1:12:20]: It's not closed. [1:12:24, 1:12:42]: I would need a motion from the commission with regard to comprehensive plan amendment K C P twenty twenty-four-zero one. Mr. Chairman, before we do that, I have a couple of statements to make because the requester is not here. I want to turn my questions into just statements if I'm allowed. Go right ahead, sir. [1:12:43, 1:12:46]: We have the number of units that they're planning on building in this. [1:12:47, 1:12:56]: development, but they don't say how many anticipated residents they're looking to to put in these units. That's one statement. [1:12:58, 1:13:00]: Um course the big issue is [1:13:01, 1:13:04]: egress into the property in and out and [1:13:04, 1:13:08]: Um I wanted to ask the developer if he is prepared to [1:13:09, 1:13:15]: purchase additional properties around this entrance because right now they do not own property to the street. [1:13:15, 1:13:27]: Um the Taco Bell and the bottle shop and I think Walmart owns the property there. Are they prepared to purchase property to put in appropriate uh traffic control devices? [1:13:28, 1:13:45]: you know, at that intersection in the middle of the curve. Um that's kind of what squashed it in the last couple of plans they've had for it. So I was just w gonna I was gonna ask them that, but since they're not here I'm just making a statement that they will have to purchase additional property. [1:13:47, 1:13:50]: No, Mr. Chair, may I speak also? Go right ahead, sir. [1:13:51, 1:14:01]: I I think it's unfair to make any decisions if you if you don't have the client here to answer all the questions pertaining to developing the property. [1:14:11, 1:14:31]: My name is Alex McCart. I'm with Moor Bass Consulting. We have worked some on this project, um, and I was letting the applicant know for some reason they didn't know it was on the agenda tonight. I can't explain all that, but they wanted me to ask for a deferral. So if that's possible. [1:14:32, 1:14:33]: Sure. [1:14:33, 1:14:33]: Thank you. [1:14:40, 1:14:43]: Mr. Chairman, I have a question. Go ready, sir. Um this gentleman here. [1:14:45, 1:15:01]: Just curious if the uh if the developer has held any kind of a community forum to discuss with any of the residents. So that's what kind of the messages I'm receiving. They've hoped to do that before this meeting tonight. [1:15:02, 1:15:22]: Again, I can't explain all the scheduling mishaps, but that's their intent, yes. Okay. I would suggest if possible that they try to schedule a forum, be it a Zoom call, uh something prior to coming here to kind of tamper the emotions, get a lot of the questions out. Uh it's very helpful. [1:15:22, 1:15:23]: I find yes, I agree. [1:15:23, 1:15:25]: Okay, thank you. You got anything else from me? [1:15:27, 1:15:27]: Thank you sir. [1:15:29, 1:15:36]: So I just heard from the uh attorney representing the client on this project. They wish to defer this matter. [1:15:37, 1:15:40]: All right, sir. That's what he just said. Yeah. [1:15:41, 1:15:43]: So having heard [1:15:44, 1:15:49]: I need a motion to defer it. The comprehensive plan amendment case and the resulting case. [1:15:50, 1:15:53]: I would like to present a motion that we defer. [1:15:54, 1:15:55]: Is there a second? [1:15:56, 1:16:16]: It's been moved by Mr. Thibodeau and second by Mr. Mitten that we defer the comprehensive plan amendment case CP twenty twenty-four-zero one and the rezoning case, RZ2024-01. All in favor, let it be known by the sound of aye. Aye. Any opposed? As I have it. [1:16:16, 1:16:18]: These cases have been deferred. Thank you. [1:16:22, 1:16:36]: Next is an annexation case AX twenty twenty four-zero one. Council District Five, the City of Stockbridge Planning Commission will hold a public meeting on Thursday, May sixteenth, twenty twenty four, at six thirty PM. [1:16:37, 1:16:38]: And the city council. [1:16:39, 1:16:55]: The City of Stockbridge, Mayor and City Council will hold a public hearing on Monday, July 8th, 2024, at 6 PM in the Stockbridge City Hall, located at 4640 North Henry Boulevard in Stockbridge, Georgia. [1:16:56, 1:17:03]: To consider a request to annex property on the southeastern corner of Patrick Henry Boulevard, Patrick Henry Parkway. [1:17:04, 1:17:05]: And Holloway Road. [1:17:07, 1:17:15]: The parcels uh subject to this is zero seven one A zero one zero eight eight zero zero three. [1:17:15, 1:17:20]: zero seven one eight zero one zero eight nine zero zero zero [1:17:21, 1:17:32]: zero seven one eight zero one zero nine zero zero zero zero and zero seven one eight zero one zero nine one zero zero zero [1:17:33, 1:17:35]: From Henry County. [1:17:35, 1:17:40]: R three and C three to the city of Stockbridge [1:17:43, 1:17:45]: Uh C three. [1:17:45, 1:18:03]: The applicant is Nathan McGuerty. The property is located in landlot fifty seventy-nine of District Six and unincorporated Henry County and it contains two point six three acres of land more or less. [1:18:04, 1:18:05]: Mm-hmm. [1:18:05, 1:18:08]: Mr Gordon Linton, please. [1:18:08, 1:18:09]: Thank you, Mr. Chairman. [1:18:11, 1:18:25]: Uh my name is Gordon Linton, Planner One for the City of Stockbridge. I'm here to present the annexation twenty four twenty-four-zero one, the CP twenty twenty-four-four, and RC twenty-four-zero four. [1:18:29, 1:18:49]: As he mentioned, the applicant is Mr. Nathan McGerty, and the owner is Holloway Jodico Property Partners. The number of acres is 2.6 acres, and the address of the property is located at Project County Parkway at Holloway Road. The project characteristics, the properties are vacant, and the county land use that [1:18:49, 1:18:55]: Designation is low density, any land land use zoning is C three along with R three. [1:18:59, 1:19:03]: So these are the four parcels parcels that are located here. [1:19:08, 1:19:18]: And this is the joint joint zoning map. The parcels are right here and as you can see it is contiguous with seventy seven and eighty seven Highway Road. [1:19:19, 1:19:30]: twenty five Holloway Road and the two other parcels zero five two dash zero one zero thirty one hundred and zero five two zero one zero twenty three zero zero two. [1:19:34, 1:19:37]: And this is the joint future land use um zoning. [1:19:43, 1:19:46]: And staff recommends approval for the annexation. Mm-hmm. [1:19:48, 1:19:53]: Uh the next one is on the comprehensive plan, C P twenty twenty four dash zero four. [1:19:55, 1:20:03]: Um, the applicant's request is to assign the future Latin use designation of high high density mixed use once the properties have been annexed into the city limits. [1:20:05, 1:20:11]: This is the comprehensive plan amendment for twenty twenty four and this is a definition of high density mixed use. [1:20:14, 1:20:34]: And as you can see, the surrounding land use designations, which with property to the north, which is high density residential, Harring County, high density residential, Stockbridge, properties to the south, mixed use, which is Harring County, properties to the east, low density residential, Harring County, and properties to the west, mixed use, Henry County, and high density mixed use. [1:20:38, 1:20:39]: And staff recommends approval. [1:20:41, 1:20:50]: And last but not least, the uh RZ 2024-04. It is important to note that some of the properties there are surrounded by [1:20:51, 1:21:10]: C three, which is down here in this area by Herring County. And it's also surrounded by PUD. So therefore we recommend that we assign the C three heavy commercial once we annex it to the city. And it also will be consistent with the policy and goals of the EDC. It does meet those requirements. And therefore our staff recommends approval. [1:21:11, 1:21:17]: Thank you. Thank you, Gordon. Any comments, questions from the commission? [1:21:21, 1:21:26]: Uh it is important to note that the uh pro property owner is not proposing any development at this time. [1:21:28, 1:21:29]: Thank you. [1:21:33, 1:21:34]: No questions, no comments. [1:21:34, 1:21:40]: Mr Chairman, since this is the same piece of property we just deferred, would we like to defer this as well? [1:21:41, 1:21:42]: Come again, sir? [1:21:43, 1:21:47]: So since this is the same piece of property we just deferred it's not. [1:21:48, 1:21:52]: It's not the same page. You sure? No. [1:21:54, 1:21:58]: Yeah, Mr. Planchin, this I think this property's over in the overlay district. [1:21:59, 1:21:59]: Probably say. [1:22:04, 1:22:07]: No. No. [1:22:08, 1:22:10]: Okay. I stand corrected. [1:22:12, 1:22:13]: You good? [1:22:14, 1:22:17]: You clear? Yes, sir. Okay, good. Thank you. [1:22:19, 1:22:20]: Thank you, Gordon. [1:22:20, 1:22:21]: Sorry. [1:22:21, 1:22:30]: We will now open this the floor for public hearing regarding the annexation, the comprehensive plan, and the rezoning. [1:22:31, 1:22:38]: Of those these four parcels of Patrick Henry, are they anyone in the building whose [1:22:39, 1:22:40]: In favour of [1:22:43, 1:22:45]: Come right up, sir. State your name. [1:22:50, 1:23:03]: My name is Alex McCart with Moorbass Consulting. I'm uh the agent representing Nathan McGarrity. Uh I'm just really here to answer any questions. We just uh using this to clean clean up some of the split zoning that's here. [1:23:04, 1:23:04]: Thank you. [1:23:10, 1:23:15]: The before you sit down, sir, does any or the commission have any questions for [1:23:17, 1:23:18]: The consultant. [1:23:19, 1:23:21]: No questions? Thank you, sir. [1:23:24, 1:23:26]: Are there anyone in the building who's [1:23:26, 1:23:28]: Opposed to this annexation. [1:23:31, 1:23:33]: Please come forward, state your name and address, please. [1:23:35, 1:23:40]: Connie Snow, four twenty six Chase, Marion Way, McDonough, Georgia. [1:23:40, 1:24:00]: I de I disagree with this request for annexation or any other act annexation that has been proposed for any property on Patrick Henry Parkway. We have currently gone through about two or three right now. These annexations are setting up my community in the Eagles Crest subdivision to be island off. And if you're from [1:24:00, 1:24:20]: Familiar with SB 612, that caveat. So you do have the thing where you could ask to be annexed off if you're a landowner, if you're in a neighborhood that's maybe surrounded differently, you vote for it. But if you're where I'm living right now, you're forcing us into an island, which means if we're forced into an [1:24:20, 1:24:27]: on an island, we get no vote on annexation. And there is not one person in my neighborhood that is a homeowner. [1:24:27, 1:24:47]: That wants to be a part of Stockbridge. And by doing this annexation, we will be forced to become an island. And then we will be forcefully annexed off and a city that we want no part in. And that is our choice. Additionally, I do have a question that I would like everybody to answer tonight in regards to SBC. [1:24:47, 1:25:07]: 612. In 2022, it appeared on a ballot asking if Stockbridge, you wanted to be a part of Stockbridge. A lot of us in unincorporated Henry County believe that that did not appear on our ballot, and therefore we were not allowed to vote on it, but yet we are suffering the consequences of that vote. Can anybody compare? [1:25:07, 1:25:16]: Confirm here today, or can they provide me further research where that appeared on every ballot for Henry County? This is off-scope. [1:25:17, 1:25:19]: You need to let me finish. [1:25:20, 1:25:40]: We are against this. Additionally, we have documented that the city of Stockbridge has constantly changed their comprehensive plan on multiple occasions to fit the needs of developers. At what point does this stop, and at what point do we take care of our citizens? Because where I'm standing and where I'm living, I [1:25:40, 1:25:52]: I am getting pushed into a situation I do not want to be. And I can promise you this, if I become a part of the city of Thoughtbridge, I will not make life easy. [1:25:53, 1:25:57]: Mr. Dilmers, we need to stay on scope. Thank you, Ms. Null. Next please. [1:26:04, 1:26:10]: Tasha Kempel, 410 Chase, Marion Way, McDonough, Georgia, 30253. I do not agree with this. Um [1:26:10, 1:26:24]: I do think that property owners have the right to sell to who they want to sell to, yes. But if it's gonna be a multifamily unit again or a used car lot or a new car lot, whatever it is. [1:26:25, 1:26:34]: I don't think I'm fond of that. But I do know that the traffic getting off of Holloway Road, there's no light there. There's no roundabout. [1:26:35, 1:26:51]: Not even a four-way stop sign. So it's so hard to get out right there. And I'm not driving to Tunis to go to a red light when you got school getting out of and then having all these school buses. So anyways, just looking at this, it's just gonna be more congested. My neighborhood. [1:26:52, 1:26:55]: More people, more crime, gas station. [1:26:55, 1:26:58]: Across the street from the racetracker already had a shooting over there. [1:26:59, 1:27:03]: So I don't know how much more crime that this area is gonna be getting, but [1:27:04, 1:27:09]: I don't feel good about it. Um, that's all I gotta say. Thank you. Mm-hmm. [1:27:11, 1:27:12]: Anyone else, please? [1:27:13, 1:27:16]: The public hearing is now closed. Thank you. [1:27:16, 1:27:17]: Yeah. [1:27:20, 1:27:21]: Any comments from commission? [1:27:31, 1:27:35]: No comments? No questions? [1:27:40, 1:27:41]: I see. [1:27:44, 1:27:45]: Go ahead, Miss Jackson. [1:27:49, 1:28:00]: I just want to remind everyone there is no proposed development. They're only pr um planning to and it's four parcels into the city. No proposed development. [1:28:00, 1:28:01]: That one. [1:28:02, 1:28:04]: Thank you, Ms. Jackson. [1:28:06, 1:28:18]: No further questions, no further comments. I need a motion from the c commission respect to annexation case AX twenty twenty four-zero one. [1:28:26, 1:28:27]: Chairman. [1:28:27, 1:28:38]: Well I sympathize with the uh with the citizens. Um I'll just note before I cast uh before I make my motion that this is C three to C three from county to city. So I'm gonna make the motion to approve. [1:28:39, 1:28:44]: Is there a second? Second. It's been moved improperly second. [1:28:44, 1:28:51]: That annexation case AX twenty twenty four dash zero one be approved. All in favor, let it be known by the sound of I. [1:28:52, 1:28:53]: Uh. [1:28:54, 1:28:55]: In a pulse. [1:28:56, 1:29:05]: I opposed. Harold. We have three in favor, Mr. Plashawn, Mr. Mitten, Mr. Thomas. [1:29:06, 1:29:10]: W one Mr. Thibodeau was in opposition, so they uh [1:29:12, 1:29:15]: The f affirmative vote is to approve the annexation case. [1:29:18, 1:29:25]: Next, I need a motion on the comprehensive land use amendment KCP 2024-04. [1:29:28, 1:29:30]: I need a motion from the commission, please. [1:29:32, 1:29:34]: Mr. Chairman, I make the motion to approve. [1:29:36, 1:29:36]: One second. [1:29:37, 1:29:51]: It's been moved by Mr. Minton and second by Mr. Thomas. The comprehensive land use amendment KCP twenty twenty four-04 be approved. All in favor, let it be known by the sound of I. [1:29:51, 1:29:52]: Hi. [1:29:53, 1:29:55]: Any opposed? No opposed. [1:29:56, 1:30:02]: The eyes have it. The comprehensive plan amendment case is approved. [1:30:04, 1:30:09]: With regard to the rezoning case R Z twenty twenty four dash zero four. [1:30:11, 1:30:14]: I need a motion from the commission, please. [1:30:17, 1:30:19]: Mr. Chairman, again I make the motion to approve. [1:30:21, 1:30:21]: Not second. [1:30:22, 1:30:26]: Mr. Mitten has moved approval, Mr. Thomas will move to second it. [1:30:28, 1:30:30]: All in fail let be no Marsanova. [1:30:30, 1:30:31]: Okay. [1:30:32, 1:30:34]: Any opposed? Opposed. [1:30:35, 1:30:38]: There has habit the rezoning cases. [1:30:39, 1:30:46]: Approved. Mr. Plashon, Mr. Mitten, Mr. Thomas voted yay. Mr. Thibodeau voted nay. [1:30:48, 1:30:49]: Thank you very much. [1:30:51, 1:30:58]: Project updates from the staff. Staff has none. No project updates. Any comments from staff? [1:31:00, 1:31:03]: No comments? Any comments from the board? [1:31:04, 1:31:04]: Sure. [1:31:07, 1:31:15]: Got no comments, meeting stands adjourned. Thank you. Have a great evening, everyone. [1:31:31, 1:31:35]: Yeah, getting a small one short. [1:31:39, 1:31:43]: They don't even live in the city of Stocks Raven, they come in here.
  • 2024-05-14 · City Council · Transcript · Citywide Development Authority

    2024-05-14 · City Council · Transcript · source: 10yr-transcripts · sha256 ff98f6e9 · pages – · method: official

    Full text — searchable
    --- title: Citywide Development Authority date: 2024-05-14 source: 2024-05-14_Citywide_Development_Authority.wav --- [0:00:14, 0:00:17]: It says I have to reload it, it said it can't be reached. [0:00:30, 0:00:34]: I keep hit reloading and it keeps giving me the same message. [0:00:35, 0:00:39]: The site can't be reached. Check if there is a typo in the RTMP. [0:00:53, 0:00:57]: Can you make me the admin and see if I can do it from here? Okay. [0:01:23, 0:01:24]: It's joining it. [0:01:25, 0:01:26]: It's streaming. [0:01:27, 0:01:32]: I turned on the um civic thing. I didn't know if we were gonna be on civic or Facebook. [0:01:33, 0:01:34]: It should be all surface. [0:01:34, 0:01:35]: Oh yeah, say you now. [0:01:36, 0:01:37]: But I only see you. Let me see my [0:01:39, 0:01:44]: I want to see you. I didn't change my screen. Woo, you can't. Yeah, your camera probably. [0:01:46, 0:01:48]: Um, can you put it on gallery? [0:01:49, 0:01:52]: Here I'm gonna give you control back. [0:01:53, 0:01:54]: It says gallery. [0:01:54, 0:01:56]: I guess it's just waiting for [0:01:57, 0:02:01]: But wait a minute, you're on my screen that I'ma need to be showing the agenda. [0:02:04, 0:02:05]: It's doing them. [0:02:06, 0:02:07]: You're all live. [0:02:08, 0:02:10]: I turned on the um [0:02:10, 0:02:18]: Civic thing. I didn't know if we were gonna be on civic or Facebook. It should be on civic. Oh, yeah, I see you now. But I only see you. Let me see my. [0:02:20, 0:02:25]: Oh see, you I didn't change my screen. Oh, you know, [0:02:26, 0:02:29]: Um, can you put it on gallery? [0:02:30, 0:02:33]: Here I'm gonna give you control back. [0:02:34, 0:02:35]: It says gallery. [0:02:35, 0:02:43]: My screen too has you on my screen that I'm gonna need to be showing. I'm not seeing my [0:02:43, 0:02:48]: Screen two as my civic. [0:02:49, 0:02:50]: I turned on [0:02:56, 0:02:57]: I'll see you now. [0:02:57, 0:03:00]: Well now it's an going. [0:03:00, 0:03:11]: Yes, echo and it's got a um so somebody is is uh somebody's um civic clerk or something is on. [0:03:12, 0:03:24]: Yeah, I got civic, hold on. Let me that's probably why it's echoing because it's got a like a a delay. Right. [0:03:24, 0:03:31]: Screen two as my okay, okay. Now I d I took this the sound off civic. [0:03:33, 0:03:35]: But why is my civic showing? [0:03:36, 0:03:37]: You [0:03:39, 0:03:41]: Instead of my agenda screen. [0:03:42, 0:03:43]: It's just you. [0:04:02, 0:04:03]: I can't hear you. [0:04:07, 0:04:08]: You know what me? [0:04:08, 0:04:15]: We hear you. I don't guess I need well, no, it's only showing you. That's what's gonna be showing on the um [0:04:15, 0:04:17]: Streaming, Demetrius, it's just you. [0:04:19, 0:04:20]: And you shouldn't. [0:04:21, 0:04:23]: Well, that's what's on there. You got control, right? [0:04:23, 0:04:24]: You got control? [0:04:25, 0:04:28]: Uh, what you want me to do? Do it. [0:04:31, 0:04:34]: Because now I see Fred. Hey everyone just pop in. [0:04:38, 0:04:45]: Oh, can you hear me? Let me see. Good afternoon. Good afternoon. Hi, Fred. Hey, I do now. Um [0:04:47, 0:04:48]: Demetrius. [0:04:48, 0:04:51]: I just got off the phone with Angie Angie. [0:04:52, 0:04:52]: Mm-hmm. [0:04:53, 0:04:57]: So uh we were just talking about how to fix this little [0:04:57, 0:04:59]: issue is going on. [0:04:59, 0:05:02]: Yeah, I I Quentin talked to me. He said that [0:05:03, 0:05:10]: The title companies thing was incorrect, but the one that that they had was correct, and that's the one we should go by. [0:05:10, 0:05:14]: I think I told Andrew that the buyer um the the [0:05:16, 0:05:25]: We did both. We did a title report on both of those, but the parcel identification number, I think, in one y'all did is incorrect. I think the partial identification number in in the [0:05:26, 0:05:28]: Updated title report is the actual property. [0:05:29, 0:05:29]: Uh [0:05:30, 0:05:32]: That's what it's looking like of a [0:05:33, 0:05:37]: Andy's gonna help. We're gonna figure this thing out. So [0:05:37, 0:05:40]: She's gonna look at it again and [0:05:40, 0:05:44]: So I think the the issue is the um [0:05:48, 0:05:50]: The resolution conveying the property. [0:05:50, 0:05:51]: Mm-hmm. [0:05:51, 0:06:01]: The D the the s the this parcel identification number referenced in that resolution is correct for that parcel, but I don't believe that that's the parcel. [0:06:03, 0:06:04]: That the [0:06:05, 0:06:07]: That the property that the hotel is supposed to be built on. [0:06:08, 0:06:10]: I think the p I think the reference is incorrect. [0:06:13, 0:06:19]: Anyway, that's what the the buyers we we have been looking at um a few weeks. So if we [0:06:20, 0:06:21]: Should should we? [0:06:21, 0:06:25]: If it's subject, I sent I'm gonna send Angie's information to the title company. [0:06:26, 0:06:26]: Okay. [0:06:27, 0:06:29]: to and also to the buyer's attorney. [0:06:29, 0:06:33]: And we're gonna work it all out. If we have to just switch it over, if the city needs us to [0:06:34, 0:06:41]: give the property back and do a switch or if this is one other but you know we'll we'll we'll do what tell us to do. [0:06:41, 0:06:44]: I I go down that rabbit hole again. [0:06:46, 0:06:56]: But um Andrew said it can be fixed and so I just uh so we'll I'm I'm confident that we can get it done. I'm just glad we still have time because there's a May 28th city council meeting. [0:06:57, 0:07:01]: Um quick question. Uh this this meeting is being streamed live. [0:07:02, 0:07:07]: Mm-hmm. Yep. We're we're just talking ahead of the meeting. It's just the two of us. So it's not the board comp [0:07:08, 0:07:09]: Participating, but we'll wait. [0:07:10, 0:07:13]: No, no, no. I'm I'm saying this is being streamed. [0:07:15, 0:07:26]: Yes, I didn't know wait until we had a a quorum. But are y'all gonna stream it once we have a quorum or is it stream? What I'm saying to you is it is live. She's saying it's live. Okay. Okay. [0:07:26, 0:07:26]: Yeah. [0:07:27, 0:07:30]: Okay. How can I give him that information? [0:07:30, 0:07:37]: So if he goes to the secretary, I'm sorry, the um city of Stockbridge, um [0:07:37, 0:07:38]: Page? [0:07:39, 0:07:43]: Um he can go into the live meeting. Um [0:07:45, 0:07:48]: It is under our um [0:07:49, 0:07:53]: Is there a way we can drop it in the chat? Is there an opportunity to put this in the chat? [0:07:54, 0:07:57]: I don't even see a chat option. [0:08:01, 0:08:08]: Where don't we see a chat option? Vanessa, are we able to drop that link inside of a chat? Do we not have that option here? [0:08:10, 0:08:17]: I don't believe that was part of the setup. There are certain things you have to select when you s set up the meeting. [0:08:18, 0:08:23]: Okay. Okay. I think it's appropriate to start the meeting since we're live streaming, Mount Chair. [0:08:23, 0:08:33]: Okay. Yeah. Um I'll just say this, uh, Mark, if you can uh go to the link where um Vanessa sent the [0:08:33, 0:08:35]: The agenda [0:08:35, 0:08:40]: It will go directly to the page where he can join. [0:08:41, 0:08:45]: That's correct. Right. So we uh we're it's still saying we're in practice session, Vanessa. [0:08:48, 0:08:51]: Can we come out of it? Hold on. [0:09:15, 0:09:35]: I mean, if it's no big thing to if if it's still being able to be streamed, I know we're still in practice mode. Um, we'll we'll move forward. So we're gonna call this meeting to order at 6.09 p.m. It is Tuesday, May 14th. Um, can we move forward and do a roll call, Secretary? Can [0:09:35, 0:09:38]: Can you do the roll call for the board, please? [0:09:42, 0:09:43]: Yes, just one moment. [0:09:57, 0:09:58]: Mm-hmm. [0:10:00, 0:10:02]: Бор Чай Арил Ша. [0:10:02, 0:10:03]: Present. [0:10:05, 0:10:05]: Um [0:10:10, 0:10:10]: Yeah. [0:10:11, 0:10:13]: Sorry, I'm trying to bring up the [0:10:14, 0:10:19]: agenda so I can I can do it if if you can that that's fine. I can jump in. [0:10:20, 0:10:24]: Um so Samantha Samuels, vice chair. [0:10:24, 0:10:25]: Here. [0:10:28, 0:10:31]: Lakeisha Gantt, uh Councilwoman Lakeisha Gantt. [0:10:35, 0:10:36]: Mark Glenn? [0:10:37, 0:10:37]: Here. [0:10:40, 0:10:41]: Gats and woodall. [0:10:42, 0:10:42]: Present. [0:10:46, 0:10:47]: Terry Gleaton. [0:10:48, 0:10:48]: Present. [0:10:51, 0:10:53]: And uh Latonya White. [0:10:55, 0:10:56]: Which yeah. [0:10:57, 0:10:58]: Or council present. [0:10:59, 0:11:01]: All right. Thank you. [0:11:06, 0:11:09]: I would like to make a motion to approve. [0:11:09, 0:11:13]: the agenda as presented. Hopefully everyone has had an opportunity. [0:11:14, 0:11:15]: to um [0:11:15, 0:11:23]: See the agenda. Um, do I have a motion? Uh I I want to put it down a motion to approve the agenda. Do I have a second? [0:11:25, 0:11:25]: I second. [0:11:26, 0:11:29]: All right, seconded by Vice Chair Samuels. [0:11:30, 0:11:32]: Do I have any discussion? [0:11:33, 0:11:35]: All right, so all in favor? [0:11:35, 0:11:36]: Uh I think. [0:11:37, 0:11:38]: Uh [0:11:38, 0:11:41]: Okay. Awesome. [0:11:41, 0:11:45]: We have um we have to approve the [0:11:45, 0:11:55]: minutes from we had two meetings in April, one being uh our regularly call meeting, which was on April 9th. [0:11:55, 0:12:01]: And then our special call emergency meeting, which was on April sixteenth. [0:12:01, 0:12:09]: If we can um take a moment, if you have not to review those meeting minutes. [0:12:09, 0:12:14]: Um if there are any changes, um please let us know. [0:12:15, 0:12:17]: Um or let the clerk know. Um [0:12:19, 0:12:20]: And we'll just [0:12:21, 0:12:23]: We'll give about a minute to review guys. [0:12:23, 0:12:27]: If you haven't had a chance, but we'll give everybody another minute or so. [0:12:45, 0:12:46]: What [0:12:50, 0:12:51]: Hmm. [0:13:29, 0:13:40]: Right. Does anybody have any changes, recommendations, um, additions to the April 9th? Do we need to approve these separately, Attorney Wiley? [0:13:42, 0:13:43]: Yes. [0:13:43, 0:13:48]: Okay. So does anyone have any changes to the April 9th? [0:13:48, 0:13:52]: Meeting minutes. Any additions? Any changes? [0:13:54, 0:13:56]: Okay. [0:13:57, 0:13:58]: Okay. [0:13:59, 0:14:00]: Uh [0:14:01, 0:14:02]: The paint. [0:14:02, 0:14:03]: Page two. [0:14:04, 0:14:06]: Uh vote to [0:14:06, 0:14:07]: Um [0:14:08, 0:14:09]: approved the [0:14:11, 0:14:12]: Paims to the um [0:14:14, 0:14:15]: I like it. [0:14:16, 0:14:17]: Use that. [0:14:18, 0:14:19]: Або [0:14:19, 0:14:19]: Mm. [0:14:20, 0:14:22]: We can folks in here that's going to use this office. [0:14:23, 0:14:24]: Um [0:14:26, 0:14:27]: Basically. [0:14:28, 0:14:31]: Mr. Secretary, I can't understand what you're saying. [0:14:36, 0:14:40]: There's some some folks in here. Um and I'm exiting the the office. [0:14:42, 0:14:43]: Excuse me, just for a moment. [0:14:56, 0:14:57]: Please proceed. [0:14:59, 0:15:05]: Okay. All right. So if if there are no uh no changes, I know um [0:15:05, 0:15:13]: Secretary Glenn stated he had some changes. I don't think he's able to communicate that right now. But if we don't have any additional changes, [0:15:13, 0:15:20]: Um, I would like to make a motion to approve the April 9th minutes as it is. Um, do I have a second? [0:15:21, 0:15:22]: I have a second. [0:15:23, 0:15:24]: All right. Thank you, Terry. [0:15:24, 0:15:26]: Um, are is there any discussion? [0:15:27, 0:15:30]: All in favor of approving April 9th minutes. [0:15:32, 0:15:32]: Fine. [0:15:34, 0:15:41]: All right. We've heard from all we've heard from Mark. We've uh We did not he's muted. [0:15:41, 0:15:45]: So we don't have a vote from um board member Glenn. [0:15:45, 0:15:49]: Okay. Um is that an ab is that a is he abstaining from [0:15:52, 0:15:56]: We ha we have a majority vote, so we the motion does pass. [0:15:57, 0:16:01]: So we can move on to the April 16th emergency meeting. [0:16:02, 0:16:04]: Were there any changes? [0:16:04, 0:16:06]: Is that okay? Um [0:16:08, 0:16:10]: Clerk and attorney Wiley, are we good? [0:16:11, 0:16:12]: With the April ninth. [0:16:13, 0:16:14]: motion to um [0:16:15, 0:16:19]: in a in in uh to move forward with this these minutes. [0:16:21, 0:16:23]: I recorded it as four. [0:16:24, 0:16:27]: Votes and an affirmative and no vote from Mr. Planned. [0:16:28, 0:16:29]: Okay, thank you. [0:16:29, 0:16:34]: All right, so April sixteenth, if there are no changes to the minutes. [0:16:35, 0:16:40]: I would like to make a motion to approve the April sixteenth minutes. [0:16:43, 0:16:45]: I like to file a um [0:16:47, 0:16:51]: Please second Yes, second, I'm sorry. [0:16:52, 0:16:59]: Okay. Uh seconded by uh Terry. Um, is there any discussion? [0:17:00, 0:17:06]: Hello, this is Secretary Glenn. Sorry for uh the delay there. Sorry for interruption. Um [0:17:07, 0:17:10]: There was a a change that I did see. [0:17:10, 0:17:18]: to uh uh to have me abstain from the uh vote to change the bylaws. [0:17:19, 0:17:21]: Uh that was actually an uh [0:17:21, 0:17:25]: Uh I opposed that vote. I did not abstain. [0:17:29, 0:17:37]: Okay. Um attorney Wiley. Can you let us know what re what pace that was because that that discussion happened a few times during that meeting. [0:17:39, 0:17:40]: Yes, I believe that was page two. [0:17:42, 0:17:45]: Okay, so page two. [0:17:45, 0:17:48]: On the ninth doesn't have a vote. [0:17:48, 0:17:49]: It was on the sixteenth. [0:17:50, 0:17:54]: Oh on sixteenth meeting. Okay. Yes. All right. [0:17:57, 0:18:05]: So what was your vote for the meeting for the ninth? I'm I'm sorry, the sixteenth, he was not present for that meeting. You mean the ninth? [0:18:07, 0:18:08]: Um [0:18:09, 0:18:11]: Yes, I'm sorry, the sixteenth. [0:18:20, 0:18:24]: Okay. On the ninth he was present by teleconference. So what is your vote? [0:18:25, 0:18:28]: For the minutes to be approved on the ninth. [0:18:30, 0:18:34]: Just to uh add that correction. Uh and um [0:18:35, 0:18:37]: I vote two. Approve the minutes. [0:18:49, 0:18:54]: Do you have that um Vanessa? Are we able to move forward with April ninth? I mean April sixteenth. [0:18:57, 0:19:05]: I'll note that I just need to find it in the minutes it didn't so that I can reference the page because it's not page two. [0:19:05, 0:19:06]: Okay. [0:19:06, 0:19:08]: Okay. So I'll make the correction when [0:19:09, 0:19:10]: O of what page it is. [0:19:11, 0:19:18]: Okay. All right. Madam Chair, I'm sorry. Uh Councilwoman Gantt, I I couldn't get on. [0:19:18, 0:19:32]: I've done everything. I text you as well as I sent an email to Miss Holiday. It wouldn't let me get on. I called in, but it had me as an attendant to the meeting. So I just hung up from that. [0:19:32, 0:19:36]: 'Cause I couldn't talk, but I've I've had the hardest time getting on today. [0:19:38, 0:19:50]: Okay, no problem. Thank you for joining in, Councilwoman Gantt. We're just um approving minutes from April's meetings, so we haven't gotten into really anything yet. [0:19:50, 0:19:51]: Okay, great. [0:19:51, 0:19:53]: We will make a [0:19:53, 0:19:56]: Um be sure to make an adjustment. [0:19:57, 0:20:00]: to count Councilwoman Gantt present. [0:20:01, 0:20:03]: For the roll call, if we can do that, um [0:20:04, 0:20:05]: Madam Clerk, I have it. [0:20:06, 0:20:07]: All right, awesome. [0:20:08, 0:20:24]: Okay, so moving on to the April again April 16th minutes. I want to make a motion to approve those minutes as presented. Um, if there are no changes. So um I believe Terry seconded. Um all in favor. [0:20:27, 0:20:28]: Hi. Hi. [0:20:29, 0:20:32]: I didn't have any discussion on that. Okay. Awesome. Thank you. [0:20:33, 0:20:35]: So that that motion has been approved. [0:20:36, 0:20:43]: Um, we actually can move directly into I would like a motion to go into executive session. [0:20:43, 0:20:46]: For uh real estate matters. [0:20:46, 0:20:53]: So if we can go ahead and do that, um, I'm not sure it what we need to do and [0:20:53, 0:20:59]: Um Vanessa, what we need to do, but we definitely would have to come off live stream. [0:21:00, 0:21:06]: So that we can discuss real estate matters. You'll receive a second you'll receive an email, which is a separate meeting. [0:21:07, 0:21:08]: Oh. [0:21:08, 0:21:09]: Okay. [0:21:09, 0:21:14]: You need you need to have a motion to go into this. We do need to motion to go in, yes. [0:21:14, 0:21:15]: All right. [0:21:17, 0:21:20]: And who who who was that? Uh councilwoman? [0:21:20, 0:21:21]: Yeah. [0:21:21, 0:21:28]: All right. Thank you. And all uh no discussion. Is there any discussion on that? Who seconded? I'm sorry. [0:21:28, 0:21:29]: Uh Councilwoman Gann. [0:21:30, 0:21:31]: Who motioned? [0:21:32, 0:21:33]: I made a motion. Oh, you shall okay. [0:21:34, 0:21:39]: And all in favor of going into executive session for real estate matters. [0:21:39, 0:21:41]: Uh [0:21:41, 0:21:48]: All right, the board approves. Um, and so we will reconvene in the public space and everyone please mute. [0:21:51, 0:21:52]: Mute. [0:21:54, 0:21:55]: To do [0:22:04, 0:22:07]: Including you, Matt, or I mean you